Short-Term Clinical Outcomes of a Novel Corneal Prosthetic Device in a Rabbit Model

Prognostic Significance of Biointegration at the Optic-Cornea Joint in Keratoprosthesis Implantation

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to characterize the morphological and immunological aspects of biointegration at the optic-cornea joint of a second-generation synthetic corneal device.

METHODS

The initial prototype, single-piece optic-skirt configuration, is constructed from compact and flexible perfluoroalkoxy alkane with porous expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) overlying the skirt to allow skirt-cornea biointegration. The second-generation version was modified to add ePTFE around the optic wall to allow optic-cornea biointegration. Initial and amended second-generation devices were implanted into healthy rabbit eyes. Clinical examination, anterior segment optical coherence tomography, light microscopy, and immunofluorescence studies were performed to assess structural integrity and determine molecular signatures indicative of inflammation and tissue remodeling between the 2 prototypes.

RESULTS

Recipient eyes with both device versions showed no epithelial defects or tissue retraction at 3 months postoperatively. Optical coherence tomography images demonstrated no appreciable perioptic space with either prototype. Histopathology of the initial device demonstrated lack of stromal adhesion at the optic-cornea joint with epithelium filling the perioptic space. Second-generation devices demonstrated full sealing of the recipient stroma along the optic stem. Although the routine histopathology did not demonstrate inflammatory cells in the recipient cornea with either device, immunohistochemistry stains demonstrated quiescent phenotype of stromal and epithelial cells only in the second-generation devices.

CONCLUSIONS

Biointegration between the synthetic corneal device and recipient tissue at the optic-cornea joint seems to avert inflammation and may help prevent sterile tissue lysis and prolong retention.

Design and Biocompatibility of a Novel, Flexible Artificial Cornea

Purpose

We sought to introduce the materials, design, and biocompatibility of a flexible and suturable artificial corneal device.

Methods

Single-piece, fully synthetic, optic-skirt design devices were made from compact perfluoroalkoxy alkane. The skirt and the optic wall surfaces were lined with a porous tissue ingrowth material using expanded polytetrafluoroethylene. Full-thickness macroapertures around the skirt perimeter were placed to facilitate nutrition of the recipient cornea. Material properties including the skirt's modulus of elasticity and bending stiffness, optic light transmission, wetting behavior, topical drug penetrance, and degradation profile were evaluated.

Results

The final prototype suitable for human use has a transparent optic with a diameter of 4.60 mm anteriorly, 4.28 mm posteriorly, and a skirt outer diameter of 6.8 mm. The biomechanical and optical properties of the device closely align with the native human cornea with an average normalized device skirt-bending stiffness of 4.7 kPa·mm4 and light transmission in the visible spectrum ranging between 92% and 96%. No optical damage was seen in the 36 devices tested in fouling experiments. No significant difference was observed in topical drug penetrance into the anterior chamber of the device implanted eye compared with the naïve rabbit eye.

Conclusions

The flexibility and biocompatibility of our artificial cornea device may offer enhanced tissue integration and decreased inflammation, leading to improved retention compared with rigid keratoprosthesis designs.

Translational Relevance

We have developed a fully synthetic, flexible, suturable, optic-skirt design prototype artificial cornea that is ready to be tested in early human feasibility studies.

Mechanical, optical, chemical, and biological evaluations of fish scale-derived scaffold for corneal replacements: A systematic review

Corneal blindness is commonly treated through corneal replacement with allogeneic corneal donors, which may face shortage. Regarding this issue, xenogeneic alternatives are explored. Fish scale-derived scaffolds (FSSs) are among the alternatives due to the lower risk of infection and abundant sources of raw materials. Unfortunately, the information about mechanical, optical, chemical, and biological performances of FSSs for corneal replacements is still scattered, as well as about the fabrication techniques. This study aims to gather scattered pieces of information about the mentioned performances and fabrication techniques of FSSs for corneal replacements. Sorted from four scientific databases and using the PRISMA checklist, eleven relevant articles are collected. FSSs are commonly fabricated using decellularization and decalcification processes, generating FSSs with parallel multilayers or crossed fibers with topographic microchannels. In the collected studies, similar mechanical properties of FSSs to native tissues are discovered, as well as good transparency, light remittance, but poorer refractive indexes than native tissues. Biological evaluations mostly discuss histology, cell proliferations, and immune responses on FSSs, while only a few studies examine the vascularization. No studies completed comprehensive evaluations on the four properties. The current progress of FSS developments demonstrates the potential of FSS use for corneal replacements.

Twelve-Month Clinical and Histopathological Performance of a Novel Synthetic Cornea Device in Rabbit Model

Purpose

To report the biological stability and postoperative outcomes of a second-generation, single-piece, flexible synthetic cornea in a rabbit model.

Methods

Device materials and design were amended to enhance biointegration. Optic skirt design devices were made from compact perfluoroalkoxy alkane with porous expanded polytetrafluoroethylene ingrowth surface overlying the skirt and optic wall. Sixteen devices were implanted into intrastromal pocket in rabbit eyes. Rabbits were randomly assigned to 6- and 12-month follow-up cohorts (n = 8 in each) postoperatively. Monthly examinations and optical coherence tomography assessed cornea-device integration, iridocorneal angle, optic nerve, and retina.

Results

There were no intraoperative complications. All devices were in situ at exit, with clear optics. No retroprosthetic membrane, glaucoma, cataract formation, or retinal detachment was observed. Two rabbits in the 6-month group had mild, focal anterior lamella thinning without retraction adjacent to the optic near tight sutures. Three postoperative complications occurred in the 12-month group. One rabbit diagnosed with endophthalmitis was euthanized on day 228. Mild sterile focal retraction of anterior lamella occurred in two rabbits, which were terminated on days 225 and 315. Light microscopic examination of enucleated globes demonstrated fibroplasia with new collagen deposition into the porous scaffold without significant inflammation, encapsulation, or granuloma formation.

Conclusions

Clinical evaluations, imaging, and histopathological findings indicate favorable outcomes of this synthetic corneal device in a rabbit model. Early feasibility studies in humans are being planned.

Translational Relevance

Favorable 12-month results of the device in rabbits demonstrate vision-restoring potential in corneally blind individuals at high risk of failure with donor keratoplasty.

Probing mechanisms and improving management of glaucoma following Boston keratoprosthesis surgery

ENGLISH SUMMARY

Corneal blindness is a leading cause of visual impairment worldwide. The most common treatment is to replace the diseased cornea by standard corneal transplantation. In eyes at high risk of graft failure, the Boston keratoprosthesis type 1 (KPro) can be used to restore vision and is currently the most frequently used artificial cornea in the world. However, glaucoma is a well-known complication of KPro surgery and is the most important threat to vision in KPro-implanted eyes (paper I). This chronic disease is influenced by elevated intraocular pressure (IOP) and damages the optic nerve, leading to progressive vision loss. In KPro patients, glaucoma is highly prevalent and extremely challenging to manage, yet its exact cause remains unknown. The overall purpose of this PhD Thesis (Geoffrion, 2021) was to better understand the mechanisms and how to improve management of glaucoma after KPro implantation. The approaches used in this thesis included investigating one of the largest KPro patient cohorts in North America, with a total of 157 operated patients at that time, as well as studying KPro surgery and outcomes in mice. The first objective was to identify risk factors for glaucoma development and progression after KPro implantation (paper II). Multivariate logistic regression revealed that high preoperative IOP signals a higher risk for both glaucoma development and progression. Stromal and endothelial corneal disorders were less associated with glaucoma progression, while autoimmune and ocular surface diseases precipitated glaucoma development. Second, there is no objective evidence that indicates the best order for glaucoma surgeries and KPro implantation. By comparing medical and surgical management in KPro eyes with either preexisting or de novo glaucoma (paper III), we showed that glaucoma surgery may be performed before or at the time of KPro in eyes with preexisting glaucoma to limit progression without increasing complications. In eyes with de novo glaucoma, glaucoma surgery did not increase complications compared with medications. Third, among glaucoma surgery interventions, the two most frequently implanted glaucoma drainage devices were compared in KPro patients (paper IV). Compared with the Ahmed glaucoma valve, the Baerveldt glaucoma implant was associated with lower failure rates, without increased postoperative complications. Fourth, even with aggressive management, many KPro patients suffer from progressive optic nerve damage, sometimes despite normal IOP. Inflammatory cytokines play an important role in glaucomatous optic neuropathy, but their role in KPro-associated glaucoma is still unknown. By analysing tear fluid of KPro patients by multiplex bead immunoassay (paper V), we identified that cytokines TNF-a, IL-1b, FGF-basic and IFN-g were elevated in KPro patients with glaucoma compared to those without. These cytokines correlated with optic nerve excavation and IOP. For the first time in humans, these results concorded with the elevations of TNF-a and IL-1b documented in the mouse KPro model. Ocular surface inflammation may thus reflect the inflammatory processes that perpetuate glaucoma damage years after KPro surgery. Fifth, we determined that miniaturized mouse KPro implantation requires extensive practice to be used as a reproducible model of glaucoma post-KPro (paper VI). KPro animal models with larger eyes and a full-thickness, 360-degree corneal excision should be prioritized to best validate human outcomes. In conclusion, glaucoma in KPro eyes is a long-lasting and multifactorial process. Most probable mechanisms combine IOP-independent inflammation mediated by TNF-a and IL-1b that prolong glaucoma damage, together with post-surgical angle closure elevating the IOP. Altogether, our results inform glaucoma risk profiling of transplant recipients, improvement of surgical management of KPro patients with glaucoma and development of targeted treatments to minimize glaucomatous damage after KPro. Ultimately, this work has the potential to preserve the vision of thousands of patients who undergo KPro surgery every year worldwide and to provide insight for the role of inflammation in other diseases involving neuronal damage. RÉSUMÉ (FRENCH SUMMARY): La cécité cornéenne est l'une des causes les plus importantes de déficience visuelle dans le monde. Le traitement usuel est de remplacer la cornée malade par une greffe de cornée traditionnelle. Dans les yeux à haut risque d'échec de greffe, la kératoprothèse de Boston de type 1 (KPro) peut rétablir la vision et est la cornée artificielle la plus utilisée au monde. Cependant, le glaucome est une complication importante de la KPro (papier I). Cette maladie chronique est influencée par une pression intraoculaire (PIO) élevée et endommage le nerf optique, menant à une perte de vision. Chez les patients avec KPro, le glaucome est fréquent et difficile à contrôler, mais sa cause exacte demeure inconnue. L'objectif principal de cette thèse est de découvrir les mécanismes et d'optimiser la prise en charge du glaucome après l'implantation de la KPro. Pour ce faire, nous avons investigué l'une des plus grandes cohortes de patients KPro en Amérique du Nord avec un total de 157 patients, ainsi qu'un groupe de souris ayant reçu une implantation de kératoprothèse. Le premier but était d'identifier les facteurs de risque pour le développement et la progression du glaucome après la KPro (papier II). Par régression logistique multivariée, nous avons démontré qu'une PIO préopératoire élevée mène à un plus grand risque de développement et de progression du glaucome. Les maladies cornéennes stromales ou endothéliales sont moins associées à une progression, alors que les maladies autoimmunes ou de la surface oculaire précipitent le développement du glaucome. Deuxièmement, il n'existe aucune donnée objective pour indiquer le meilleur ordre des chirurgies de glaucome et de KPro. En comparant les traitements médicaux et chirurgicaux des yeux KPro avec glaucome (papier III), nous avons démontré que les chirurgies de glaucome peuvent limiter la progression en étant effectuées avant ou pendant l'implantation de KPro dans les yeux avec glaucome préexistant, sans augmenter les complications. Dans le glaucome de novo, les chirurgies de glaucome n'augmentent pas les complications en comparaison aux médicaments. Troisièmement, les deux implants de glaucome les plus communs ont été étudiés chez les patients KPro (papier IV). Comparé à la valve Ahmed, l'implant Baerveldt est associé à des taux d'échec plus bas, sans augmentation des complications. Quatrièmement, même avec une prise en charge agressive, plusieurs patients KPro souffrent de glaucome qui progresse, parfois sans PIO élevée. Les cytokines inflammatoires jouent un rôle dans la pathophysiologie du glaucome, mais leur rôle dans le glaucome associé à la KPro est inconnu. En analysant les larmes de patients KPro (papier V), nous avons identifié que les cytokines TNF-a, IL-1b, FGF-basic et IFN-g sont élevées chez les patients KPro avec glaucome comparé à ceux sans glaucome. Ces cytokines corrèlent avec l'excavation du nerf optique et la PIO. Pour la première fois chez les humains, ces résultats concordent avec les niveaux élevés de TNF-a et IL-1b documentés dans le modèle murin de KPro. L'inflammation de la surface oculaire pourrait donc refléter les processus inflammatoires qui perpétuent le dommage glaucomateux. Cinquièmement, nous avons déterminé que l'implantation de la KPro miniature chez la souris requiert beaucoup de pratique pour être utilisé comme modèle de glaucome post-KPro (papier VI). Des modèles animaux avec des yeux plus larges et une excision cornéenne de pleine épaisseur sur 360 degrés devraient être priorisés pour valider les résultats chez l'humain. En conclusion, le glaucome associé à la KPro est un processus multifactoriel qui persiste à long terme. Les mécanismes probables combinent l'inflammation médiée par TNF-a et IL-1b et une fermeture de l'angle qui augmente la PIO. Nos résultats contribuent à établir les facteurs de risque de glaucome pour les receveurs de KPro, à améliorer leur prise en charge et à développer des thérapies ciblées. Ce travail a le potentiel de préserver la vision de milliers de patients recevant une KPro chaque année dans le monde et d'aider à mieux comprendre le rôle de l'inflammation dans d'autres maladies avec atteinte neuronale.