Kelly Punch Punctoplasty and Simple Punctal Dilatation Are Equally Effective for Punctal Stenosis: A Prospective Study

Evaluation of anatomical and functional success in canalicular laceration repair using anterior segment optical coherence tomography and dacryoscintigraphy

PURPOSE

To assess the anatomical and functional outcomes in patients who underwent surgery for canalicular laceration and did not experience significant epiphora, and to compare these outcomes with contralateral uninjured eye.

METHOD

Dacryoscintigraphy, anterior segment optical coherence tomography (OCT), MUNK scores, and a satisfaction questionnaire were administered to 24 patients who had canalicular laceration repair without significant epiphora and had a minimum of 6 months of follow-up. Tear meniscus height (TMH), depth (TMD), and area (TMA) were measured using anterior segment OCT and compared with the values in the uninjured eye.

RESULTS

Sixteen patients (67 %) had lower, 7 (29 %) had upper canaliculus, and one (4 %) had lacerations in both canaliculi. Five patients (20.83 %) had concomitant orbital fractures, and three patients (12.5 %) underwent additional repair for corneoscleral laceration. Bicanalicular silicone tube intubation was performed in one patient, while Mini-Monoka stent intubation was used for all other patients. The mean follow-up period was 41 ± 22.3 months, and the mean interval between trauma and surgery was 30.2 ± 29 h. The mean duration until tube removal was 3 ± 2.54 months. The MUNK score was 1 in eight patients (33 %) and 0 in sixteen patients (67 %). Canalicular lacerations occurred due to home accidents in 8 patients, work accidents in 4, assaults in 5, and traffic accidents in 7. Dacryoscintigraphy showed drainage of tracer into the nasal cavity in dynamic imaging for 12 patients. Five patients had retention in the sac, four had prolonged and reduced drainage, one had reduced drainage, and two showed no drainage in the first and second hour images. In the operated eye, the mean tear meniscus height (TMH) was 279.6 µm, depth (TMD) was 215 µm, and area (TMA) was 28.9 µm². In the healthy eye, the mean TMH was 221.5 µm, TMD was 152.5 µm, and TMA was 15.3 µm². The anterior segment OCT values for the affected eye were statistically significantly higher than those for the healthy eye (p = 0.044 for TMH, p = 0.003 for TMD, p = 0.006 for TMA). TMD and TMA were statistically significantly higher in patients with a MUNK score of 1 (p = 0.019 for TMD, p = 0.05 for TMA). Abnormal dacryoscintigraphy results were more common in patients with globe injuries requiring additional surgery.

CONCLUSION

Although patients did not report epiphora after canalicular laceration repair, our observations indicated potential functional and anatomical differences in dacryoscintigraphy and anterior segment OCT compared to their healthy eyes. We believe that close follow-up is crucial to identify and address any issues that may arise in the future following surgery.

A major review on punctal stenosis: Part II: Updated therapeutic interventions, complications, and outcomes

We continue our review of on punctal stenosis by providing a detailed discussion of management modalities, their complications, and outcomes. There is a significant change in the understanding of punctal and peripunctal anatomy, puncto-canalicular junction, and the lacrimal pump mechanisms. While the snip punctoplasty procedures are still practiced, there is an increasing trend toward nonincisional procedures. The nonincisional procedures in select cases appear to be equally effective as the incisional ones. Although simple to use, punctal plugs never became the mainstay of treatment because of design issues and the inability to address the coexisting canalicular stenosis. Placing stents only in the lower punctum in cases of upper and lower punctal stenosis should be discouraged, and management needs to address punctal stenosis and not which punctum is involved. Several types of stents are used in the management of punctal stenosis, mostly based on surgeon's preference. The benefits of adjuvant mitomycin C are uncertain. In view of literature on how stent biofilms can themselves cause chronic inflammation, placing them for prolonged periods should be reviewed and debated. Enhanced understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of punctal stenosis and addressing the current controversies in management would help standardize the therapeutic interventions available in the lacrimal armamentarium.

A major review of punctal stenosis: Updated anatomy, epidemiology, etiology, and clinical presentation

We aim to provide a detailed and updated literature review on the epidemiology, etiology, clinical presentations, histopathology, and ultrastructural features of punctal stenosis. There are inconsistencies in the definition and staging of punctal stenosis. While advanced optical coherence tomography imaging techniques have revolutionized the way the punctum and vertical canaliculi are assessed or monitored following treatment, the planes of measurement to characterize punctum anatomy need to evolve further. The current criteria for diagnosing and grading punctal stenosis are inadequate and based on empirical clinical findings. There is increasing evidence of the role of lymphocytes and myofibroblasts in the pathogenesis of punctal stenosis. There is a need for a uniform assessment of punctal stenosis and a uniform reporting of severity that would help standardize the several management options available in the lacrimal armamentarium.

Imaging of the lower punctum with anterior segment OCT in patients with dacryocystorhinostomy who underwent bicanalicular silicone tube implantation

Spectral domain OCT imaging of the lower punctum in cases with silicone tube implantation OBJECTIVE: To record the structural changes in the lower punctum by performing spectral domain anterior segment OCT imaging of dacryocystorhinostomy cases who underwent bicanalicular silicone tube implantation.

METHODS

Thirty eyes of 30 patients who underwent bicanalicular Crawford silicone tube implantation with dacryocystorhinostomy were included in the study. The mean age of the cases was 53 ± 13.96 (24-72). Of the cases, 19 were female and 11 were male, 18 of them were operated on the right eye and 12 on the left eye. The lower punctum images of the cases were recorded with spectral domain anterior segment OCT preoperatively and at the 1st day, 1st month and 6th month after explantation of the silicone tube. In the lower punctum, external punctal width(EPW) and canaliculi depth (CD) were measured.

RESULTS

The mean EPW and CD measurements of the cases in the preoperative period, respectively; 544.90±144.11 µm and 451.70±197.45 µm. First day after silicone tube explantation, EPW was 818.00±186.83 µm and CD was 735.35±337.15 µm, at 1st month EPW was 665.95±142.12 µm and CD was 619.30±212.11 µm and at 6th months EPW was 530±150.29 µm and CD was 558.45±254.37 µm, respectively. Mean EPW values were found to be higher on the first day after extubation than before surgery (p = 0.001). There was no significant difference in the mean EPW values at the first and sixth months after extubation compared to pre-implantation (p>0.05). The mean CD values were higher at the 1st day, 1st month and 6th month after tube explantation than preoperative CD values, they were not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

According to the lower punctum OCT imaging data, silicone tube implantations applied to the canalicular system do not create a structurally significant difference in the lower punctum. The punctal opening gradually decreases after extubation. The decrease in EPW values is more pronounced than the decrease in CD values. Silicone tube implantation was more effective in maintaining canaliculi depth compared to external punctal diameter.