The Impact of Biopsy Tool Choice and Rapid On-Site Evaluation on Diagnostic Accuracy for Malignant Lesions in the Prospective: Multicenter NAVIGATE Study

Impact of Pulmonary and Critical Care Fellow Participation during Advanced Diagnostic Bronchoscopy

Background: Pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) fellows frequently participate in advanced diagnostic bronchoscopy (ADB) procedures. Objective: To investigate the impact of PCCM fellow involvement during ADB on various procedural outcomes in a real-world setting. Methods: This was a retrospective observational cohort study analyzing prospectively collected registry data of consecutive ADB procedures performed between February 2018 and December 2021. Procedure duration, safety, breadth, and diagnostic performance of ADBs performed by PCCM fellows supervised by interventional pulmonologists (IPs) were compared with those completed solely by IP faculty. Results: Among 628 ADBs, fellows participated in 379 (60.3%). With unadjusted analysis, fellow-involved cases were a median 11.5 minutes longer for convex-probe endobronchial ultrasound bronchoscopy (95% confidence interval [CI], 6.0-14.0; P < 0.001) and 10.5 minutes longer for peripheral bronchoscopy (95% CI, 2.0-18.0; P = 0.016). Compared with ADBs performed by IP faculty alone, procedures with second-year (post-graduate year 5) fellows had the largest duration differences. These included convex-probe endobronchial ultrasound bronchoscopy (+14.5 min; 95% CI, 7.0-18.0 min; P < 0.001), cases not using rapid on-site evaluation (+14.0 min; 95% CI, 8.0-21.0 min; P < 0.001) and those performed with moderate sedation (+12.0 min; 95% CI, 7.0-18.0 min; P < 0.001). After multivariate adjustment, fellow-involved procedures overall were 7.2 minutes longer in duration (95% CI, 3.8-10.5; P < 0.001), and 8.8 minutes longer when performed by post-graduate year 5 fellows-an approximate 16% decrease in efficiency. Bronchoscopies performed with fellows were also more likely to experience complications (38.7% compared with 25.8% with faculty procedures; adjusted odds ratio [OR], 2.0; 95% CI, 1.3-3.0; P < 0.001) and be prematurely terminated (adjusted OR, 4.95; 95% CI, 1.44-17.02; P = 0.011). Diagnostic performance and occurrence of major complications were similar between fellow and no-fellow bronchoscopies. Conclusion: Participation of PCCM fellows during ADB increases procedure duration and the risk for minor complications compared with cases completed solely by IPs. Procedures performed with fellows on the steepest portion of the ADB learning curve are the least efficient. Fellowship directors and faculty bronchoscopists should acknowledge these potential impacts on ABD practice while optimizing the approach to bronchoscopy training.

Cryoprobe biopsy versus mechanical biopsies in pulmonary diagnostics

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Biopsy tools have been essential in improving the diagnostic accuracy of bronchoscopic procedures. Of these tools, cryobiopsy has emerged as a promising technique for diagnosing thoracic diseases. This review summarizes the existing data comparing cryobiopsies to other mechanical biopsy methods for sampling endobronchial, parenchymal, and mediastinal targets.

RECENT FINDINGS

Initially adopted for managing airway stenoses, the use of cryoprobes has expanded to diagnosing endobronchial lesions, parenchymal opacities, and mediastinal lymph node pathologies. Studies have demonstrated that cryobiopsy offers a higher diagnostic yield than forceps biopsy alone. By leveraging the Joule-Thomson effect to freeze and collect larger tissue samples compared to traditional methods, cryobiopsy improves diagnostic accuracy and helps in better characterizing the nature of the lesions. While the risk of complications, such as pneumothorax and hemorrhage are comparable to, or higher than traditional biopsy methods, cryobiopsy's enhanced diagnostic capabilities make it a valuable tool in the assessment of pulmonary disease.

SUMMARY

Compared with other mechanical biopsy techniques, cryoprobe biopsies significantly enhance the diagnostic yield for endobronchial lesions, interstitial lung disease, pulmonary nodules, and mediastinal lymph nodes.

State of the art: peripheral diagnostic bronchoscopy

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer related death worldwide and in the United States according to the World Health Organization and National Cancer Institute. Improvements in the diagnosis and treatment of lung cancer are of the utmost importance. A prompt diagnosis is a crucial factor to improve outcomes in the treatment of lung cancer. Although the implementation of lung cancer screening guidelines and the overall steady growth in the use of computed tomography have improved the likelihood of detecting lung cancer at an earlier stage, the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions (PPLs) has remained a challenge. The bronchoscopic techniques for PPL sampling have historically offered modest diagnostic yields at best in comparison to computed tomography guided transthoracic needle aspiration (TTNA). Fortunately, recent advances in technology have ushered in a new era of diagnostic peripheral bronchoscopy. In this review, we discuss the introduction of advanced intraprocedural imaging included digital tomosynthesis (DT), augmented fluoroscopy (AF), and cone beam computed tomography. We discuss robotic assisted bronchoscopy with a review of the currently available platforms, and we discuss the implementation of novel biopsy tools. These technologic advances in the bronchoscopic approach to PPLs offer greater diagnostic certainty and pave the way toward peripheral therapeutics in bronchoscopy.

Rapid On-Site Evaluation Performed by an Interventional Pulmonologist: A Single-Center Experience

BACKGROUND

Rapid On-Site Evaluation (ROSE) during bronchoscopy allows us to assess sample adequacy for diagnosis and molecular analyses in the context of precision oncology. While extemporaneous smears are typically evaluated by pathologists, their presence during bronchoscopy is not always possible. Our aim is to assess the concordance between ROSE performed by interventional pulmonologists and cytopathologists.

METHODS

We performed ROSE on 133 samples collected from 108 patients who underwent bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of suspect thoracic findings or for mediastinal lymph node staging (May 2023-October 2023). Randomly selected smears (one for each collection site) were independently evaluated for adequacy by a pulmonologist and a pathologist to assess the concordance of their evaluation.

RESULTS

Among 133 selected smears evaluated by a pulmonologist and pathologist, 100 were adequate for both, 10 were inadequate for both and 23 were discordant; hence, global concordance was 82.7%; Cohen's Kappa was 0.385, defining fair agreement. Concordance was similar irrespective of sample collection site (lymph nodes vs. pulmonary lesions; p = 0.999) and among samples which were considered adequate or inadequate by the pulmonologist (p = 0.608).

CONCLUSIONS

Trained pulmonologists can evaluate the appropriateness of sampling with good concordance with cytopathologists. Our work supports autonomous ROSE by pulmonologists where pathologists are not immediately available.

ERJ Advances: interventional bronchoscopy

The field of interventional bronchoscopy is rapidly growing, with the development of minimally invasive approaches and innovative devices to diagnose and treat a spectrum of respiratory diseases (figure 1 ), often as outpatient procedures, and supported by high quality collaborative research. This short review covers aspects related to COPD, peripheral pulmonary nodules, interstitial lung disease, and airway stenosis and malacia.

This ERJ Advances article summarises the latest developments in the rapidly advancing field of interventional bronchoscopy https://bit.ly/44Qvgrm

[Clinical Application of Robotic Assisted Bronchoscopy in Peripheral Pulmonary Nodule Biopsy]

With the popularization of chest computed tomography (CT) lung cancer screening, the detection rate of peripheral pulmonary nodules is increasing day by day. Some patients could make clear diagnoses and receive early treatment by obtaining biopsy specimens. Transbronchial lung biopsy (TBLB) is one of the non-surgical biopsy methods for peripheral pulmonary nodules, which has less trauma and lower incidence of complications compared to percutaneous thoracic needle biopsy (PTNB). However, the diagnostic rate of TBLB is about 70%, which is still inferior to that of PTNB, which is about 90%. Since 2018, robot assisted bronchoscopy systems have been applied in clinical practice. This article reviews their application in further improving the diagnostic rate of peripheral pulmonary nodules by TBLB.
.

Rapid on-site evaluation of touch imprint cytology in navigation bronchoscopy for small peripheral pulmonary nodules

BACKGROUND

Rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE) of cytopathology plays an important role in determining whether representative samples have been taken during navigation bronchoscopy. With touch imprint cytology (TIC), histologic samples can be assessed using ROSE. Although advised by guidelines, there have been almost no studies on the performance of TIC during navigation bronchoscopy. The objective of this study was to evaluate the value of TIC-ROSE (forceps/cryobiopsy) in combination with conventional ROSE (cytology needle/brush).

METHODS

In this single-center, prospective cohort study, patients who had pulmonary nodules with an indication for navigation bronchoscopy were consecutively included. The primary outcome of the study was the concordance of ROSE and the procedural outcome. The concordance rates of TIC-ROSE and the combination of TIC-ROSE plus conventional ROSE were compared.

RESULTS

Fifty-eight patients with 66 nodules were included. Conventional ROSE and TIC-ROSE were assessable in 61 nodules (90.9%) each. By combining both ROSE techniques, all sampled lesions were assessable. Combining conventional ROSE with TIC-ROSE showed concordant results in 51 of 66 cases (77.3%) versus 44 of 66 (66.7%) and 48 of 66 (72.8%) concordant results for conventional ROSE and TIC-ROSE alone, respectively, compared with the procedural outcome. There was no indication of tissue depletion as a result of TIC. The combined ROSE approach had a statistically significant higher concordance rate compared with conventional ROSE alone.

CONCLUSIONS

TIC-ROSE is a cheap, easily implementable technique that can result in higher concordant ROSE outcomes. This could lead to more efficient procedures and possibly higher diagnostic results. In a monomodality sampling setting with only histologic samples, TIC can provide ROSE.

A Cone Beam CT Bronchoscopy Study of the Ultrathin Cryoprobe for Biopsy of Peripheral Lung Lesions

BACKGROUND

Compared with the standard cryoprobe, the novel ultrathin 1.1 mm cryoprobe (UTCP) has improved ergonomics, shape memory, and flexibility. The performance of UTCP has demonstrated promising results in several small trials.

METHODS

In this single-center, retrospective review, we examine 200 (N=200) consecutive patients referred for cone beam CT bronchoscopic biopsy of peripheral lung lesions. We utilized an extended multimodality approach, including transbronchial needle aspirate, brush, traditional forces biopsies, UTCP biopsies, and BAL. We analyzed tool in lesion, tool touch lesion, center strike rates, and diagnostic yield. We assessed for molecular adequacy and analyzed safety.

RESULTS

A total of 222 lesions were biopsied. We achieved a tool in lesion or tool touch lesion confirmation for all biopsy attempts (100%) and a center strike rate of 68%. AQuIRE diagnostic yield was 90%, with 60% malignant, 30% benign lung nodules, and 10% nondiagnostic. UTCP was diagnostic in 3.6 % of peripheral lung lesions biopsies when all other modalities were nondiagnostic; thus, raising our overall diagnostic yield from 86.4% to 90.1%. Our analysis demonstrates superior adequacy for molecular analysis for histologic samples (TBBX or UTCP) versus cytologic samples (FNA) ( P <0.001). Three patients (1.5%) had a pneumothorax, and 1 patient (0.5%) had moderate bleeding.

CONCLUSION

UTCP was diagnostic in 3.6% of peripheral lung lesions when all other modalities were nondiagnostic. In the setting of CBCT guidance, UTCP has a similar safety profile to standard biopsy tools. Future trials are warranted to assess UTCP and its impact on peripheral lung lesion biopsies.

Imaging modalities during navigational bronchoscopy

INTRODUCTION

Lung nodules are commonly encountered in clinical practice. Technological advances in navigational bronchoscopy and imaging modalities have led to paradigm shift from nodule screening or follow-up to early lung cancer detection. This is due to improved nodule localization and biopsy confirmation with combined modalities of navigational platforms and imaging tools. To conduct this article, relevant literature was reviewed via PubMed from January 2014 until January 2024.

AREAS COVERED

This article highlights the literature on different imaging modalities combined with commonly used navigational platforms for diagnosis of peripheral lung nodules. Current limitations and future perspectives of imaging modalities will be discussed.

EXPERT OPINION

The development of navigational platforms improved localization of targets. However, published diagnostic yield remains lower compared to percutaneous-guided biopsy. The discordance between the actual location of lung nodule during the procedure and preprocedural CT chest is the main factor impacting accurate biopsies. The utilization of advanced imaging tools with navigation-based bronchoscopy has been shown to assist with localizing targets in real-time and improving biopsy success. However, it is important for interventional bronchoscopists to understand the strengths and limitations of these advanced imaging technologies.

Novel electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy system for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary nodules: a prospective, multicentre study

BACKGROUND

Traditional electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy (ENB) is a real-time image-guided system and used with thick bronchoscopes for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary nodules (PPNs). A novel ENB that could be used with thin bronchoscopes was developed. This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic yield and the experience of using this ENB system in a real clinical scenario.

METHODS

This multicentre study enrolled consecutive patients with PPNs adopting ENB from March 2019 to August 2021. ENB was performed with different bronchoscopes, ancillary techniques and sampling instruments according to the characteristics of the nodule and the judgement of the operator. The primary endpoint was the diagnostic yield. The secondary endpoints included the diagnostic yield of subgroups, procedural details and complication rate.

RESULTS

In total, 479 patients with 479 nodules were enrolled in this study. The median lesion size was 20.9 (IQR, 15.9-25.9) mm. The overall diagnostic yield was 74.9% (359/479). A thin bronchoscope was used in 96.2% (461/479) nodules. ENB in combination with radial endobronchial ultrasound (rEBUS), a guide sheath (GS) and a thin bronchoscope was the most widely used guided method, producing a diagnostic yield of 74.1% (254/343). The median total procedural time was 1325.0 (IQR, 1014.0-1676.0) s. No severe complications occurred.

CONCLUSION

This novel ENB system can be used in combination with different bronchoscopes, ancillary techniques and sampling instruments with a high diagnostic yield and safety profile for the diagnosis of PPNs, of which the combination of thin bronchoscope, rEBUS and GS was the most common method in clinical practice.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT03716284.

Accuracy of Preliminary Pathology for Robotic Bronchoscopic Biopsy

BACKGROUND

Diagnosis and treatment of peripheral pulmonary lesions (PPLs) currently require at least 2 procedures. An all-in-1 approach would require diagnosing malignancy with preliminary cytology results. This study investigated the concordance between preliminary cytology and final pathology results in biopsies of PPLs obtained by shape-sensing robotic-assisted bronchoscopy (ssRAB).

METHODS

This study was a retrospective, consecutive, single-arm, single-center study of 110 ssRABs for PPLs. Concordance was defined as agreement between preliminary cytology and final pathology results. Accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and safety outcomes were examined.

RESULTS

The concordance was 89% for needle biopsies, 85% for forceps biopsies, and 92% overall, with substantial agreement. There was no significant association of concordance with patients' demographics or lesion characteristics. Preliminary cytology resulted in a malignant diagnosis in 70%, a nonmalignant diagnosis in 4%, and a nondiagnostic result in 26%, with accuracy of 86% and sensitivity of 84%. The total complication rate was 3.6%, with a pneumothorax rate of 1.8%.

CONCLUSIONS

This study compared the concordance of preliminary pathology results with final pathology results for ssRAB biopsies in PPLs. The results showed that preliminary samples have a high concordance with final pathology results and may enable management of PPLs with a single anesthetic procedure including biopsy, staging, and treatment.

Utility of multimodal sampling and testing during advanced bronchoscopy for diagnosing atypical respiratory infections in a Coccidioides-endemic region

Background

The role of advanced diagnostic bronchoscopy (ADB) for assessing atypical respiratory infections is unclear. The purpose of this study was to ascertain: (I) the diagnostic utility of ADB-tissue sampling in patients with focal thoracic lesions due to atypical respiratory infections; (II) how multimodal bronchoscopic sampling and testing enhance diagnosis in a Coccidioides-endemic region.

Methods

A retrospective observational cohort study analyzing all ADBs performed over a 10-year period in patients with focal thoracic lesions diagnosed with a non-malignant disorder. Only cases which procured lower respiratory tract secretion and tissue samples by ADB, and had both cytohistology and culture results available were included.

Results

Among 403 subjects with non-malignant disease, 136 (33.7%) were diagnosed with atypical respiratory infections, with ADB contributing a diagnosis in 119 (87.5%) of these. Coccidioidal disease was independently associated with a cytohistologic diagnosis [odds ratio =7.64, 95% confidence interval (CI): 2.51-23.26; P<0.001]. Mycobacteria were more effectively identified by culture (overall yield of 8.4%, vs. 2.7% by cytohistology; P<0.001). Among subjects for which both respiratory secretion and tissue sampling were dual-tested with culture and cytology/cytohistology, adding ADB-guided transbronchial needle aspiration and/or forceps biopsy (TBNA/TBFB) to bronchoalveolar lavage and/or bronchial washings (BAL/BW) more than doubled the yield for dimorphic fungi, from 7.1% to 15.1% (increase of 8.0%, 95% CI: 5.2-11.9%). For lung lesions, adding tissue culture to dual TBNA/TBFB cytohistology-tested lung samples doubled the proportion diagnosed with atypical infection over using TBNA-cytohistology alone (increase of 15.8%, 95% CI: 10.4-23.1%). Adding lymph node to lung sampling increased the proportion diagnosed with coccidioidomycosis by 8.8% (95% CI: 4.8-15%). Among subjects with atypical respiratory infections, major ADB-related complications occurred in 1.5%.

Conclusions

ADB is useful for diagnosing atypical respiratory infections manifesting as focal thoracic lesions. A multimodal approach to both sampling and testing enhances yield, while maintaining a favorable procedure safety profile. Cytohistology testing and nodal sampling are beneficial for pulmonary coccidioidomycosis, and culture for mycobacterial disease. The approach to ADB-sampling should be adjusted according to clinical context and regional infection patterns.

Real-World Impact of Robotic-Assisted Bronchoscopy on the Staging and Diagnosis of Lung Cancer: The Shape of Current and Potential Opportunities

The approach to peripheral pulmonary lesions (PPL) has been evolving continuously. Advanced bronchoscopic navigational techniques have improved the airway-based approaches to these lesions. Robotic Assisted Bronchoscopy (RAB) can be considered the current pinnacle of this evolution; allowing for a safer approach to sampling lesions previously considered outside of bronchoscopic reach. We present a comprehensive review of the changing epidemiology of lung cancer and the importance of early tissue sampling, the evolution of sampling and navigational bronchoscopic techniques, technical considerations and evidence pertaining to the use of RAB, and adjunct techniques in the diagnosis of lung cancer. Complications and future applications of RAB are also discussed.

Robotic bronchoscopy in diagnosing lung cancer-the evidence, tips and tricks: a clinical practice review

The development of robotic-assisted bronchoscopy has empowered bronchoscopists to access the periphery of the lung with more confidence and promising accuracy. This is due in large to the superior maneuverability, further reach, and stability of these technologies. Despite the advantages of robotic bronchoscopy, there are some drawbacks to using these technologies, such as the loss of tactile feedback, the need to overcome computed tomography (CT)-to-body divergence, and the potential for overreliance on the navigation software. There are currently two robotic bronchoscopy platforms on the US market, the MonarchTM Platform by Auris Health© (Redwood City, CA, USA) and the IonTM endoluminal robotic bronchoscopy platform by Intuitive Surgical© (Sunnyvale, CA, USA). In this clinical practice review, we highlight the evidence and strategies for successful clinical use of both robotic bronchoscopy platforms for pulmonary lesion sampling. Specifically, we will review pre-procedural considerations, such as procedural mapping, room set-up and anesthesia considerations. We will also review the technical aspects of using the robotic bronchoscopy platforms, such as how to compensate for the loss of tactile feedback, optimize visualization, use of ancillary technology to accommodate for CT-to-body divergence, employ best practices for sampling techniques, and utilize information from rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE) to aid in improving diagnostic yield.

Cone-beam CT in lung biopsy: a clinical practice review on lessons learned and future perspectives

Pulmonary nodules with intermediate to high risk of malignancy should preferably be diagnosed with image guide minimally invasive diagnostics before treatment. Several technological innovations have been developed to endobronchially navigate to these lesions and obtain tissue for diagnosis. This review addresses these technological advancements in navigation bronchoscopy in three basic steps: navigation, position confirmation and acquisition, with a specific focus on cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT). For navigation purposes ultrathin bronchoscopy combined with virtual bronchoscopy navigation, electromagnetic navigation and robotic assisted bronchoscopy all achieve good results as a navigation guidance tool, but cannot confirm location or guide biopsy positioning. Diagnostic yield has seen improvement by combining these techniques with a secondary imaging tool like radial endobronchial ultrasound (rEBUS) and fluoroscopy. For confirmation of lesion access, rEBUS provides local detailed ultrasound-imaging and can be used to confirm lesion access in combination with fluoroscopy, measure nodule-contact area length and determine catheter position for sampling. CBCT is the only technology that can provide precise 3D positioning confirmation. When focusing on tissue acquisition, there is often more than 10% difference between reaching the target and getting a diagnosis. This discrepancy is multifactorial and caused by breathing movements, small samples sizes, instrument tip displacements by tool rigidity and tumour inhomogeneity. Yield can be improved by targeting fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG)-avid regions, immediate feedback of rapid onsite evaluation, choosing sampling tools with different passive stiffnesses, by increasing the number biopsies taken and (future) catheter modifications like (robotic assisted-) active steering. CBCT with augmented fluoroscopy (CBCT-AF) based navigation bronchoscopy combines navigation guidance with 3D-image confirmation of instrument-in-lesion positioning in one device. CBCT-AF allows for overlaying the lesion and navigation pathway and the possibility to outline trans-parenchymal pathways. It can help guide and verify sampling in 3D in near real-time. Disadvantages are the learning curve, the inherent use of radiation and limited availability/access to hybrid theatres. A mobile C-arm can provide 3D imaging, but lower image quality due to lower power and lower contrast-to-noise ratio is a limiting factor. In conclusion, a multi-modality approach in experienced hands seems the best option for achieving a diagnostic accuracy >85%. Either adequate case selection or detailed 3D imaging are essential to obtain high accuracy. For current and future transbronchial treatments, high-resolution (CBCT) 3D-imaging is essential.

Endobronchial Radiofrequency Ablation for pulmonary nodules with Radial-Ebus and Navigation: Pros and Cons

Introduction: Pulmonary nodules are common in the everyday clinical practice. There is always a diagnostic issue with this imaging finding. Based on the size we can use a variety of imaging and diagnostic techniques. Moreover; in the case of primary lung cancer or metastasis we can use radiofrequency ablation endobronchially. Patients and Methods: We used the radial-endobronchial ultrasound with C-arm and Archemedes, Bronchus electromagnetic navigation in order to acquire biopsy sample and we also used rapid on-site evaluation as a rapid diagnosis for pulmonary nodules. After rapid diagnosis we used the radiofrequency ablation catheter in order to ablate central pulmonary nodules. Results: Both techniques provide efficient navigation, however, with the Bronchus system less time is needed. The new radiofrequency ablation catheter provides efficient results in central lesions with low watts ≤40. Conclusion: We provided in our research a protocol to diagnose and treat such lesions. Future larger studies will provide more data on this subject.

Diagnostic yield and safety of navigation bronchoscopy: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Navigation bronchoscopy has seen rapid development in the past decade in terms of new navigation techniques and multi-modality approaches utilizing different techniques and tools. This systematic review analyses the diagnostic yield and safety of navigation bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary nodules suspected of lung cancer.

METHODS

An extensive search was performed in Embase, Medline and Cochrane CENTRAL in May 2022. Eligible studies used cone-beam CT-guided navigation (CBCT), electromagnetic navigation (EMN), robotic navigation (RB) or virtual bronchoscopy (VB) as the primary navigation technique. Primary outcomes were diagnostic yield and adverse events. Quality of studies was assessed using QUADAS-2. Random effects meta-analysis was performed, with subgroup analyses for different navigation techniques, newer versus older techniques, nodule size, publication year, and strictness of diagnostic yield definition. Explorative analyses of subgroups reported by studies was performed for nodule size and bronchus sign.

RESULTS

A total of 95 studies (n = 10,381 patients; n = 10,682 nodules) were included. The majority (n = 63; 66.3%) had high risk of bias or applicability concerns in at least one QUADAS-2 domain. Summary diagnostic yield was 70.9% (95%-CI 68.4%-73.2%). Overall pneumothorax rate was 2.5%. Newer navigation techniques using advanced imaging and/or robotics(CBCT, RB, tomosynthesis guided EMN; n = 24 studies) had a statistically significant higher diagnostic yield compared to longer established techniques (EMN, VB; n = 82 studies): 77.5% (95%-CI 74.7%-80.1%) vs 68.8% (95%-CI 65.9%-71.6%) (p < 0.001).Explorative subgroup analyses showed that larger nodule size and bronchus sign presence were associated with a statistically significant higher diagnostic yield. Other subgroup analyses showed no significant differences.

CONCLUSION

Navigation bronchoscopy is a safe procedure, with the potential for high diagnostic yield, in particular using newer techniques such as RB, CBCT and tomosynthesis-guided EMN. Studies showed a large amount of heterogeneity, making comparisons difficult. Standardized definitions for outcomes with relevant clinical context will improve future comparability.

Advanced Imaging for Robotic Bronchoscopy: A Review

Recent advances in navigational platforms have led bronchoscopists to make major strides in diagnostic interventions for pulmonary parenchymal lesions. Over the last decade, multiple platforms including electromagnetic navigation and robotic bronchoscopy have allowed bronchoscopists to safely navigate farther into the lung parenchyma with increased stability and accuracy. Limitations persist, even with these newer technologies, in achieving a similar or higher diagnostic yield when compared to the transthoracic computed tomography (CT) guided needle approach. One of the major limitations to this effect is due to CT-to-body divergence. Real-time feedback that better defines the tool-lesion relationship is vital and can be obtained with additional imaging using radial endobronchial ultrasound, C-arm based tomosynthesis, cone-beam CT (fixed or mobile), and O-arm CT. Herein, we describe the role of this adjunct imaging with robotic bronchoscopy for diagnostic purposes, describe potential strategies to counteract the CT-to-body divergence phenomenon, and address the potential role of advanced imaging for lung tumor ablation.

Electromagnetic Navigation Bronchoscopy Versus Radial Endobronchial Ultrasound for Diagnosing Lung Cancer: A Propensity Score-Matched Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy (ENB) and radial endobronchial ultrasound (R-EBUS) are advanced imaging-guided bronchoscopy techniques for diagnosing pulmonary lesions. This study aimed to determine the comparative diagnostic yield of sole ENB and R-EBUS under moderate sedation.

METHODS

We investigated 288 patients who underwent sole ENB (n=157) or sole R-EBUS (n=131) under moderate sedation for pulmonary lesion biopsy between January 2017 and April 2022. After a 1:1 propensity score-matching to control for pre-procedural factors, the diagnostic yield, sensitivity for malignancy, and procedure-related complications between both techniques were compared.

RESULTS

The matching resulted in 105 pairs/procedure for analyses with balanced clinical and radiological characteristics. The overall diagnostic yield was significantly higher for ENB than for R-EBUS (83.8% vs. 70.5%, p=0.021). ENB demonstrated a significantly higher diagnostic yield than R-EBUS among those with lesions>20mm in size (85.2% vs. 72.3%, p=0.034), radiologically solid lesions (86.7% vs. 72.7%, p=0.015), and lesions with a class 2 bronchus sign (91.2% vs. 72.3%, p=0.002), respectively. The sensitivity for malignancy was also higher for ENB than for R-EBUS (81.3% vs. 55.1%, p<0.001). After adjusting for clinical/radiological factors in the unmatched cohort, using ENB over R-EBUS was significantly associated with a higher diagnostic yield (odd ratio=3.45, 95% confidence interval=1.75-6.82). Complication rates for pneumothorax did not significantly differ between ENB and R-EBUS.

CONCLUSION

ENB demonstrated a higher diagnostic yield than R-EBUS under moderate sedation for diagnosing pulmonary lesions, with similar and generally low complication rates. Our data indicate the superiority of ENB over R-EBUS in a least-invasive setting.

Robotic Bronchoscopy for the Diagnosis of Pulmonary Lesions

Pulmonary nodules (lesions <3 cm in size) are commonly identified on computed tomographic scans, but radiographic features alone are inadequate to reliably differentiate between benign and malignant etiologies. Therefore, tissue biopsy remains the standard approach to determine the appropriate treatment course for many patients with pulmonary nodules. Although percutaneous biopsy is highly accurate, it poses substantial risks of procedural complications, including pneumothorax and bleeding. Robotic bronchoscopy has recently been developed to overcome many of the limitations of previous navigational platforms. Here, we explore the currently available systems for robotic bronchoscopy-in particular, electromagnetic-navigation robotic-assisted bronchoscopy and shape-sensing robotic-assisted bronchoscopy.

Suitability of transbronchial needle aspiration for genotyping peripheral pulmonary tumors

Background

Transbronchial needle aspiration (TBNA) is a sampling tool that has demonstrated a higher accuracy in the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions (PPL) compared to other techniques. However, there are no studies investigating the value of TBNA in defining the genotype of peripheral lung cancer.

Objective

To evaluate the accuracy of TBNA in defining the molecular characteristics of peripheral lung cancer.

Methods

Consecutive patients who underwent TBNA for the diagnosis of a PPL at the Pulmonary Unit of the Azienda Ospedali Riuniti of Ancona (Italy) between January 2020 and September 2022 were included in the study. TBNA was performed under fluoroscopic guidance and the additional support of an ultrasound miniprobe, with an ultrathin bronchoscope with a flexible 21G needle. Samples were smeared on glass slides for cytological evaluation and flushed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin for cell-blocks.

Results

154 patients were enrolled:55 were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma and 21 with squamous cell carcinoma. TBNA correctly diagnosed 43/55 (78.2%) patients with adenocarcinoma and 17/21 (81.0%) patients with squamous cell carcinoma, with a sensitivity of 77.5%. Complete genotyping for guiding targeted therapies was obtained in 52 patients (86.6%).

Conclusions

TBNA is a valid tool for the diagnosis of PPL, allowing a correct diagnosis and a complete genotyping of the tumors in a considerable proportion of patients.

Applications of cryobiopsy in airway, pleural, and parenchymal disease

INTRODUCTION

:Cryobiopsy is a novel diagnostic technique for thoracic diseases which has been extensively investigated over the past 20 years. It was originally proposed for the diagnosis of endobronchial lesions and diffuse parenchymal lung disease due to limitations of conventional sampling techniques including small size and presence of artifacts.

AREAS COVERED

:We will review recent evidence related to the expanding use of cryobiopsy in thoracic diseases. To identify references, the MEDLINE database was searched from database inception until May 2022 for case series, cohort studies, randomized controlled trials, systematic reviews and meta-analyses related to cryobiopsy.

EXPERT OPINION

Cryobiopsy has expanding applications in the field of thoracic diseases. Evidence to support transbronchial cryobiopsy as an alternative to surgical lung biopsy is increasing and was recently endorsed as a conditional recommendation by the latest American Thoracic Society guideline update for Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis. Developments in technology and technique, in particular the availability of a 1.1 mm flexible cryoprobe, have extended applications to pulmonary diseases, including diagnosis of interstitial lung diseases, peripheral pulmonary lesions, and lung transplant rejection.

Evaluation of the synergistic impact of needle and forceps biopsy with electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy: the CONFIDENT-ENB trial design

Background

Electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy (ENB) is an emerging advanced imaging-guided bronchoscopy technique for diagnosing peripheral lung lesions. However, the selection strategy for the optimal biopsy device and whether adopting a multi-tool strategy increases the diagnostic yield remains undetermined. The CONFIDENT-ENB trial (NCT05110131) is a prospective randomized study on ENB, performed in a least-invasive setting. The primary aim is to evaluate whether a combination of needle aspiration and forceps biopsy improves the diagnostic performance, and assess the comparative diagnostic value and discordance of the two devices.

Methods

The trial will recruit 142 participants with lung lesions suspected of malignancy who are eligible for an elective ENB procedure under moderate sedation. Participants will undergo ENB-guided needle aspiration and forceps biopsy in a randomized order without the use of any complementary techniques. All participants will be followed up subsequently for up to 12 months to conclude the final diagnosis of the biopsied lesions. Primary outcomes include the diagnostic yield and sensitivity of each biopsy modality and the diagnostic yield of the combined modalities.

Discussion

The CONFIDENT-ENB trial will prospectively evaluate the synergistic effectiveness and comparative accuracy of ENB-guided needle aspiration and forceps biopsy in a least-invasive setting. The results are expected to improve our understanding of the optimal tool-selection strategy for ENB.

Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT05110131). Prospectively registered on 5 November 2021.

Robotic bronchoscopy and future directions of interventional pulmonology

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To describe the emerging field of robotic bronchoscopy within advanced diagnostic bronchoscopy. We review the literature available for these two novel platforms to highlight their differences and discuss the impact on future directions.

RECENT FINDINGS

There are two distinct technologies both known as robotic bronchoscopy. The Monarch robotic-assisted bronchoscopy is based on electromagnetic guidance whereas the Ion robotic-assisted bronchoscopy is founded on shape sensing technology. Although there is ongoing work to explore the capabilities of these systems, studies have shown that both are safe modalities. Furthermore, both hold promise to improve diagnostic yield and may eventually pave the way for therapeutic bronchoscopic ablation in the future.

SUMMARY

Although both platforms fall under the umbrella term of robotic-assisted bronchoscopy, the Monarch and Ion systems are quite unique in their technology. Thus far, both have demonstrated safety, and early data shows promising results for improved diagnostic yield compared to previously advanced bronchoscopy modalities, especially when combined with advanced confirmatory imaging. Future directions may include bronchoscopic ablation of peripheral lesions given the stability and reach of these platforms.

NAVIGATE 24-Month Results: Electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy for pulmonary lesions at 37 centers in Europe and the United States

INTRODUCTION

Electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy (ENB) is a minimally invasive, image-guided approach to access lung lesions for biopsy or localization for treatment. However, no studies have reported prospective 24-month follow-up from a large, multinational, generalizable cohort. This study evaluated ENB safety, diagnostic yield, and usage patterns in an unrestricted, real-world observational design.

METHODS

The NAVIGATE single-arm, pragmatic cohort study (NCT02410837) enrolled subjects at 37 academic and community sites in 7 countries with prospective 24-month follow-up. Subjects underwent ENB using the superDimension navigation system versions 6.3 to 7.1. The prespecified primary endpoint was procedure-related pneumothorax requiring intervention or hospitalization.

RESULTS

A total of 1,388 subjects were enrolled for lung lesion biopsy (1,329; 95.7%), fiducial marker placement (272; 19.6%), dye marking (23; 1.7%), and/or lymph node biopsy (36; 2.6%). Concurrent endobronchial ultrasound-guided staging occurred in 456 subjects. General anesthesia (78.2% overall, 56.6% Europe, 81.4% US), radial endobronchial ultrasound (50.6%, 4.0%, 57.4%), fluoroscopy (85.0%, 41.7%, 91.0%), and rapid on-site evaluation use (61.7%, 17.3%, 68.5%) differed between regions. Pneumothorax and bronchopulmonary hemorrhage occurred in 4.7% and 2.7% of subjects, respectively (3.2% [primary endpoint] and 1.7% requiring intervention or hospitalization). Respiratory failure occurred in 0.6%. The diagnostic yield was 67.8% (range 61.9%-70.7%; 55.2% Europe, 69.8% US). Sensitivity for malignancy was 62.6%. Lung cancer clinical stage was I-II in 64.7% (55.3% Europe, 65.8% US).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite a heterogeneous cohort and regional differences in procedural techniques, ENB demonstrates low complications and a 67.8% diagnostic yield while allowing biopsy, staging, fiducial placement, and dye marking in a single procedure.

4D Electromagnetic Navigation Bronchoscopy for the Sampling of Pulmonary Lesions: First European Real-Life Experience

Purpose

The use of Electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy (ENB) for the diagnosis of pulmonary peripheral lesions is still debated due to its variable diagnostic yield; a new 4D ENB system, acquiring inspiratory and expiratory computed tomography (CT) scans, overcomes respiratory motion and uses tracked sampling instruments, reaching higher diagnostic yields. We aimed at evaluating diagnostic yield and accuracy of a 4D ENB system in sampling pulmonary lesions and at describing their influencing factors.

Methods

We conducted a three-year retrospective observational study including all patients with pulmonary lesions who underwent 4D ENB with diagnostic purposes; all the factors potentially influencing diagnosis were recorded.

Results

103 ENB procedures were included; diagnostic yield and accuracy were, respectively, 55.3% and 66.3%. We reported a navigation success rate of 80.6% and a diagnosis with ENB was achieved in 68.3% of cases; sensitivity for malignancy was 61.8%. The majority of lesions had a bronchus sign on CT, but only the size of lesions influenced ENB diagnosis (p < 0.05). Transbronchial needle aspiration biopsy was the most used tool (93.2% of times) with the higher diagnostic rate (70.2%). We reported only one case of pneumothorax.

Conclusion

The diagnostic performance of a 4D ENB system is lower than other previous navigation systems used in research settings. Several factors still influence the reachability of the lesion and therefore diagnostic yield. Patient selection, as well as the multimodality approach of the lesion, is strongly recommended to obtain higher diagnostic yield and accuracy, with a low rate of complications.

Multi-modal tissue sampling in cone beam CT guided navigation bronchoscopy: comparative accuracy of different sampling tools and rapid on-site evaluation of cytopathology

Background

Advanced technological aids are frequently used to improve outcome of transbronchial diagnostics for peripheral pulmonary lesions. Even when lesion access has been confirmed by 3D imaging, obtaining an accurate tissue sample however remains difficult. In this single institution study, we evaluate the comparative accuracy of different sampling methodologies and the accuracy of rapid on-site evaluation of cytopathology (ROSE) in navigation bronchoscopy cases where imaging has confirmed the catheter to have accurately accessed the lesion.

Methods

All consecutive navigation bronchoscopies in between December 2017– June 2020 performed in a room with a cone beam CT (CBCT) system where catheter position was intra-procedurally confirmed to be within or adjacent to the lesion by cone beam CT and augmented fluoroscopy were included. Individual tool outcomes were compared against one another and follow-up outcome.

Results

A mean of 11.39 samples using 2.93 tools were obtained in 225 lesions (median diameter 15 mm, 195 patients). A correct diagnosis was most often obtained by forceps (accuracy 70.6%), followed by 1.1 mm cryoprobe (68.4%), needle aspiration (46.7%), 1.9 mm cryoprobe (41.2%), brush (30.3%) and lavage (23.7%). Procedural outcome corresponded to follow-up outcome in 75.1% of lesions (80.5% of patients). Accurately diagnosed lesions were sampled significantly more often (11.91 vs. 9.72 samples, P=0.014). In cases where procedural outcome proved malignant, ROSE had also detected this in 47.5%.

Conclusions

Of all clinically available biopsy tools, the forceps showed most often accurate. However, extensive multi-modal sampling resulted in highest diagnostic accuracy. A hypothetical multi-modal approach of only using forceps and needle aspiration provided eventual diagnostic outcome in 91.7% of successfully diagnosed lesions. In the circumstances of our study, confirmation of malignancy on ROSE did not reduce number of biopsies taken nor biopsy time. Future research on how to improve the accuracy and effectivity of tissue sampling is needed.

Endovascular steerable and endobronchial precurved guiding sheaths for transbronchial needle delivery under augmented fluoroscopy and cone beam CT image guidance

BACKGROUND

Endobronchial navigation is performed in a variety of ways, none of which are meeting all the clinicians' needs required to reach diagnostic success in every patient. We sought to characterize precurved and steerable guiding sheaths (GS) in endobronchial targeting for lung biopsy using cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) based augmented fluoroscopy (AF) image guidance.

METHODS

Four precurved GS (EdgeTM 45, 90, 180, 180EW, Medtronic) and two steerable GS [6.5 F Destino Twist (DT), Oscor; 6 F Morph, BioCardia] were evaluated alone and in combination with an electromagnetic tracking (EM) guide and biopsy needles in three experimental phases: (I) bench model to assess GS deflection and perform biopsy simulations; (II) ex vivo swine lung comparing 2 steerable and 2 precurved GS; and (III) in vivo male swine lung to deliver a needle (n=2 swine) or to deliver a fiducial marker (n=2 swine) using 2 steerable GS. Ex vivo and in vivo image guidance was performed with either commercial or prototype AF image guidance software (Philips) based on either prior CT or procedural CBCT. Primary outcomes were GS delivery angle (θGS) and needle delivery angle (θN) in bench evaluation and needle delivery error (mm) (mean ± se) for ex vivo and in vivo studies.

RESULTS

The steerable DT had the largest range of GS delivery angles (θN: 0-114°) with either the 21 G or 19 G biopsy needle in the bench model. In ex vivo swine lung, needle delivery errors were 8.7±0.9 mm (precurved Edge 90), 5.4±1.9 mm (precurved Edge 180), 4.7±1.2 mm (steerable DT), and 5.6±2.4 mm (steerable Morph). In vivo, the needle delivery errors for the steerable GS were 6.0±1.0 mm (DT) and 15±7.0 mm (Morph). In vivo marker coil delivery was successful for both the steerable DT and morph GS. A case report demonstrated successful needle biopsy with the steerable DT.

CONCLUSIONS

Endobronchial needle delivery with AF guidance is feasible without a bronchoscope with steerable GS providing comparable or improved accuracy compared to precurved GS.