Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease in 2 siblings with adult-onset type II citrullinemia

Metabolic profiles and prediction of failure to thrive of citrin deficiency with normal liver function based on metabolomics and machine learning

PURPOSE

This study aimed to explore metabolite pathways and identify residual metabolites during the post-neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency (post-NICCD) phase, while developing a predictive model for failure to thrive (FTT) using selected metabolites.

METHOD

A case-control study was conducted from October 2020 to July 2024, including 16 NICCD patients, 31 NICCD-matched controls, 34 post-NICCD patients, and 70 post-NICCD-matched controls. Post-NICCD patients were further stratified into two groups based on growth outcomes. Biomarkers for FTT were identified using Lasso regression and random forest analysis. A non-invasive predictive model was developed, visualized as a nomogram, and internally validated using the enhanced bootstrap method. The model's performance was evaluated with receiver operating characteristic curves and calibration curves. Metabolite concentrations (amino acids, acylcarnitines, organic acids, and free fatty acids) were measured using liquid chromatography or ultra-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry.

RESULTS

The biosynthesis of unsaturated fatty acids was identified as the most significantly altered pathway in post-NICCD patients. Twelve residual metabolites altered during both NICCD and post-NICCD phases were identified, including: 2-hydroxyisovaleric acid, alpha-ketoisovaleric acid, C5:1, 3-methyl-2-oxovaleric acid, C18:1OH, C20:4, myristic acid, eicosapentaenoic acid, carnosine, hydroxylysine, phenylpyruvic acid, and 2-methylcitric acid. Lasso regression and random forest analysis identified kynurenine, arginine, alanine, and aspartate as the optimal biomarkers for predicting FTT in post-NICCD patients. The predictive model constructed with these four biomarkers demonstrated an AUC of 0.947.

CONCLUSION

While post-NICCD patients recover clinically and biochemically, their metabolic profiles remain incompletely restored. The predictive model based on kynurenine, arginine, alanine, and aspartate provides robust diagnostic performance for detecting FTT in post-NICCD patients.

Analysis of daily energy, protein, fat, and carbohydrate intake in citrin-deficient patients: Towards prevention of adult-onset type II citrullinemia

Patients with citrin deficiency during the adaptation/compensation period exhibit diverse clinical features and have characteristic diet of high protein, high fat, and low carbohydrate. Japanese cuisine typically contains high carbohydrate but evaluation of diet of citrin-deficient patients in 2008 showed a low energy intake and a protein:fat:carbohydrate (PFC) ratio of 19:44:37, which indicates low carbohydrate consumption rate. These findings prompted the need for diet intervention to prevent the adult onset of type II citrullinemia (CTLN2). Since the publication of the report about 10 years ago, patients are generally advised to eat what they wish under active dietary consultation and intervention. In this study, citrin-deficient patients and control subjects living in the same household provided answers to a questionnaire, filled-up a maximum 6-day food diary, and supplied physical data and information on medications if any. To study the effects of the current diet, the survey collected data from 62 patients and 45 controls comparing daily intakes of energy, protein, fat, and carbohydrate. Food analysis showed that patient's energy intake was 115% compared to the Japanese standard. The confidence interval of the PFC ratio of patients was 20-22:47-51:28-32, indicating higher protein, higher fat and lower carbohydrate relative to previous reports. The mean PFC ratio of female patients (22:53:25) was significantly different from that of male patients (20:46:34), which may explain the lower frequency of CTLN2 in females. Comparison of the present data to those published 10 years ago, energy, protein, and fat intakes were significantly higher but the amount of carbohydrate consumption remained the same. Regardless of age, most patients (except for adolescents) consumed 100-200 g/day of carbohydrates, which met the estimated average requirement of 100 g/day for healthy individuals. Finally, patients were generally not overweight and some CTLN2 patients were underweight although their energy intake was higher compared with the control subjects. We speculate that high-energy of a low carbohydrate diet under dietary intervention may help citrin-deficient patients attain normal growth and prevent the onset of CTLN2.

AGC2 (Citrin) Deficiency-From Recognition of the Disease till Construction of Therapeutic Procedures

Can you imagine a disease in which intake of an excess amount of sugars or carbohydrates causes hyperammonemia? It is hard to imagine the intake causing hyperammonemia. AGC2 or citrin deficiency shows their symptoms following sugar/carbohydrates intake excess and this disease is now known as a pan-ethnic disease. AGC2 (aspartate glutamate carrier 2) or citrin is a mitochondrial transporter which transports aspartate (Asp) from mitochondria to cytosol in exchange with glutamate (Glu) and H⁺. Asp is originally supplied from mitochondria to cytosol where it is necessary for synthesis of proteins, nucleotides, and urea. In cytosol, Asp can be synthesized from oxaloacetate and Glu by cytosolic Asp aminotransferase, but oxaloacetate formation is limited by the amount of NAD⁺. This means an increase in NADH causes suppression of Asp formation in the cytosol. Metabolism of carbohydrates and other substances which produce cytosolic NADH such as alcohol and glycerol suppress oxaloacetate formation. It is forced under citrin deficiency since citrin is a member of malate/Asp shuttle. In this review, we will describe history of identification of the SLC25A13 gene as the causative gene for adult-onset type II citrullinemia (CTLN2), a type of citrin deficiency, pathophysiology of citrin deficiency together with animal models and possible treatments for citrin deficiency newly developing.

Current treatment for citrin deficiency during NICCD and adaptation/compensation stages: Strategy to prevent CTLN2

Identification of the genes responsible for adult-onset type II citrullinemia (CTLN2) and citrin protein function have enhanced our understanding of citrin deficiency. Citrin deficiency is characterized by 1) neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency (NICCD); 2) adaptation/compensation stage with unique food preference from childhood to adulthood; and 3) CTLN2. The treatment of NICCD aims to prevent the progression of cholestasis, and it includes medium chain triglycerides (MCT) milk and lactose-free milk, in addition to medications (e.g., vitamin K₂, lipid-soluble vitamins and ursodeoxycholic acid). Spontaneous remission around the age of one is common in NICCD, though prolonged cholestasis can lead to irreversible liver failure and may require liver transplantation. The adaptation/compensation stage (after one year of age) is characterized by the various signs and symptoms such as hypoglycemia, fatty liver, easy fatigability, weight loss, and neuropsychiatric symptoms. Some poorly-controlled patients show failure to thrive and dyslipidemia caused by citrin deficiency (FTTDCD). Diet therapy is the key in the adaptation/compensation stage. Protein- and fat-rich diet with a protein: fat: carbohydrate ratio being 15-25%: 40-50%: 30-40% along with the appropriate energy intake is recommended. The use of MCT oil and sodium pyruvate is also effective. The toxicity of carbohydrate is well known in the progression to CTLN2 if the consumption is over a long term or intense. Alcohol can also trigger CTLN2. Continuous intravenous hyperalimentation with high glucose concentration needs to be avoided. Administration of Glyceol® (an osmotic agent containing glycerol and fructose) is contraindicated. Because the intense treatment such as liver transplantation may become necessary to cure CTLN2, the effective preventative treatment during the adaptation/compensation stage is very important. At present, there is no report of a case with patients reported having the onset of CTLN2 who are on the diet therapy and under the appropriate medical support during the adaptation/compensation stage.

A 6-Year-Old Child With Citrin Deficiency and Advanced Hepatocellular Carcinoma

We report the case of a 6-year-old boy with citrin deficiency and advanced hepatocellular carcinoma diagnosed by using imaging. He exhibited intrahepatic cholestasis 2 days after his birth and was misdiagnosed with inspissated bile syndrome at that time. The symptoms of jaundice spontaneously resolved when he was 5 months old. However, his transaminase levels remained elevated for ∼6 years, for which he received no treatment. He preferred a high-protein, high-fat, low-carbohydrate diet, which has been observed in many patients with citrin deficiency, but no clinical features of adult-onset type II citrullinemia were observed. At the age of 6 years, he was admitted to our hospital with a nonviral infection and high α-fetoprotein level; results from an abdominal MRI and computed tomography revealed multiple tumors in the liver. Because of his history of intrahepatic cholestasis in the neonatal period, he was suspected to have citrin deficiency. A genetic analysis of solute carrier family 25, member 13 revealed the presence of a homozygous 851del4 mutation, and a diagnosis of citrin deficiency was made. The patient did not qualify for liver transplantation and died 2 months later, after discharge from our hospital. Thus, this case reveals that not all patients with neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis spontaneously and totally improve, and this case is used to emphasize that patients with neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis should be managed carefully, especially in the stage of failure to thrive and dyslipidemia caused by citrin deficiency, which may lead to advanced hepatocellular carcinoma.

SLC25A13 cDNA cloning analysis using peripheral blood lymphocytes facilitates the identification of a large deletion mutation: Molecular diagnosis of an infant with neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency

Neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency (NICCD) is an autosomal recessive disorder resulting from biallelic mutations of the SLC25A13 gene. Due to the lack of well‑recognized clinical or biochemical diagnostic criteria, the definitive diagnosis of this disease relies on the genetic analysis of SLC25A13 at present. As novel large deletion/insertion mutations of the SLC25A13 gene are difficult to detect using routine DNA analytic approaches, the timely diagnosis of patients with these types of mutations remains a challenge. The present study aimed to examine SLC25A13 mutations in an infant with a suspected diagnosis of NICCD. DNA was extracted from blood samples, and SLC25A13 mutations were examined by screening for high‑frequency mutations and Sanger sequencing. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction and cDNA cloning analyses were then performed using peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) to identify the obscure mutation. The results demonstrated that the infant was heterozygous for a paternally‑inherited mutation, c.851_854del4, and a maternally‑inherited large deletion, c.1019_1177+893del, which has not been reported previously. A positive diagnosis of NICCD was made, and the infant responded favorably to a galactose‑free and medium‑chain triglyceride‑enriched formula. The present study confirmed the effectiveness of this formula in NICCD therapy, enriched the SLC25A13 mutational spectrum and supported the feasibility of cDNA cloning analysis using PBLs as a molecular tool for facilitating the identification of large SLC25A13 deletions.

Identification of a Large SLC25A13 Deletion via Sophisticated Molecular Analyses Using Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes in an Infant with Neonatal Intrahepatic Cholestasis Caused by Citrin Deficiency (NICCD): A Clinical and Molecular Study

Background. Neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency (NICCD) is a Mendelian disorder arising from biallelic SLC25A13 mutations, and SLC25A13 genetic analysis was indispensable for its definite diagnosis. However, conventional SLC25A13 analysis could not detect all mutations, especially obscure large insertions/deletions. This paper aimed to explore the obscure SLC25A13 mutation in an NICCD infant. Methods. Genomic DNA was extracted to screen for 4 high-frequency SLC25A13 mutations, and then all 18 exons and their flanking sequences were analyzed by Sanger sequencing. Subsequently, cDNA cloning, SNP analyses, and semiquantitative PCR were performed to identify the obscure mutation. Results. A maternally inherited mutation IVS16ins3kb was screened out, and then cDNA cloning unveiled paternally inherited alternative splicing variants (ASVs) featuring exon 5 skipping. Ultimately, a large deletion c.329-1687_c.468+3865del5692bp, which has never been described in any other references, was identified via intensive study on the genomic DNA around exon 5 of SLC25A13 gene. Conclusions. An NICCD patient was definitely diagnosed as a compound heterozygote of IVS16ins3kb and c.329-1687_c.468+3865del5692bp. The large deletion enriched the SLC25A13 mutation spectrum, and its identification supported the concept that cDNA cloning analysis, along with other molecular tools such as semiquantitative PCR, could provide valuable clues, facilitating the identification of obscure SLC25A13 deletions.

Chronic hepatitis without hepatic steatosis caused by citrin deficiency in a child

Citrin deficiency manifests as both neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis (NICCD) during early infancy and adult-onset type II citrullinemia during adulthood. Hepatic steatosis is most frequently observed in patients with citrin deficiency. Thus, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease that is unrelated to being overweight is considered one of the clinical features of citrin deficiency in children and adults. However, it remains unknown whether citrin deficiency is a cause of chronic hepatitis in the absence of fatty changes to the liver that occur during childhood. We encountered an 8-year-old girl who showed no clinical features of NICCD during infancy and had persistently elevated transaminase levels for several years. Liver biopsy showed widening of the portal tracts with intense mononuclear cell infiltration and mild fibrosis but no fatty changes. However, she had peculiar dietary habits similar to those that have been observed in many patients with citrin deficiency. In addition, a slightly elevated plasma citrulline level and a high pancreatic secretory trypsin inhibitor level were detected by blood examination, and she was diagnosed with citrin deficiency. Analysis of the SLC25A13 gene revealed the presence of the compound heterozygous mutations 851del4 and IVS13 + 1G > A. Thus, citrin deficiency should be included in the differential diagnosis of chronic hepatitis in children, even in the absence of hepatic steatosis.

An Adolescent Case of Citrin Deficiency With Severe Anorexia Mimicking Anorexia Nervosa

We report a 12-year-old female citrin-deficient patient presenting with severe anorexia and body weight loss, mimicking the restricting type of anorexia nervosa (AN). She showed normal development until age 10 years when she started to play volleyball at school. She then became gradually anorexic, and her growth was stunted. At age 12, she was admitted to hospital because of severe anorexia and thinness. She was first thought to have AN, and drip infusion of glucose solution and high-calorie drinks were given, but her condition deteriorated further. She had a history of neonatal hepatitis and was therefore suspected to have citrin deficiency (CD). Genetic analysis of SLC25A13 revealed that she was compound heterozygous for 851del4 and IVS16ins3kb, and a diagnosis of CD was made. A low-carbohydrate diet with oral intake of arginine and ursodeoxycholic acid was started, and her condition gradually improved. The clinical features in our patient were similar to those of AN, and therefore AN may also be an important clinical sign in adolescent patients with CD.

Adult liver disorders caused by inborn errors of metabolism: review and update

Inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) are a group of genetic diseases that have protean clinical manifestations and can involve several organ systems. The age of onset is highly variable but IEMs afflict mostly the pediatric population. However, in the past decades, the advancement in management and new therapeutic approaches have led to the improvement in IEM patient care. As a result, many patients with IEMs are surviving into adulthood and developing their own set of complications. In addition, some IEMs will present in adulthood. It is important for internists to have the knowledge and be familiar with these conditions because it is predicted that more and more adult patients with IEMs will need continuity of care in the near future. The review will focus on Wilson disease, alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency, citrin deficiency, and HFE-associated hemochromatosis which are typically found in the adult population. Clinical manifestations and pathophysiology, particularly those that relate to hepatic disease as well as diagnosis and management will be discussed in detail.

Inspissated bile syndrome in an infant with citrin deficiency and congenital anomalies of the biliary tract and esophagus: identification and pathogenicity analysis of a novel SLC25A13 mutation with incomplete penetrance

Biallelic mutations of the SLC25A13 gene result in citrin deficiency (CD) in humans. Neonatal intrahepatic cholestasis caused by citrin deficiency (NICCD) is the major CD phenotype in pediatrics; however, knowledge on its genotypic and phenotypic characteristics remains limited. The present study aimed to explore novel molecular and clinical characteristics of CD. An infant suspected to have NICCD as well as her parents were enrolled as the research subjects. SLC25A13 mutations were investigated using various methods, including cDNA cloning and sequencing. The pathogenicity of a novel mutation was analyzed bioinformatically and functionally with a yeast model. Both the infant and her father were heterozygous for c.2T>C and c.790G>A, while the mother was only a c.2T>C carrier. The novel c.790G>A mutation proved bioinformatically and functionally pathogenic. The infant had esophageal atresia and an accessory hepatic duct, along with bile plug formation confirmed by laparoscopic surgery. However, the father seemed to be healthy thus far. The findings of the present study enrich the genotypic and phenotypic characteristics of CD patients, and provided clinical and molecular evidence suggesting the possible non-penetrance of SLC25A13 mutations and the likely involvement of this gene in primitive foregut development during early embryonic life.

Three cases of adult-onset type II citrullinemia treated with different therapies: Efficacy of sodium pyruvate and low-carbohydrate diet

We report three cases of adult-onset type II citrullinemia (CTLN2) treated with different therapies including one case successfully treated with p.o. administration of sodium pyruvate and low-carbohydrate diet. Although recent advances in liver transplantation have enabled successful treatment of patients with CTLN2, several issues concerning liver transplantation remain. Further, there is still an urgent need for therapies that do not rely on liver transplantation. The first case was a 41-year-old man who developed impaired consciousness in 1992. The patient was treated with conventional therapy for hepatic encephalopathy and died of severe brain edema. The second case was a 31-year-old man who suddenly presented a syncope-like attack with hyperammonemia. He was treated with carbohydrate-restricted diet but the encephalopathy could not be controlled, and he received emergency living donor liver transplantation. The third patient was a 67-year-old man who developed abnormal behavior with hyperammonemia. He has remained well with oral sodium pyruvate and a low-carbohydrate diet without receiving liver transplantation.

SLC25A13 gene analysis in citrin deficiency: sixteen novel mutations in East Asian patients, and the mutation distribution in a large pediatric cohort in China

Background

The human SLC25A13 gene encodes citrin, the liver-type mitochondrial aspartate/glutamate carrier isoform 2 (AGC2), and SLC25A13 mutations cause citrin deficiency (CD), a disease entity that encompasses different age-dependant clinical phenotypes such as Adult-onset Citrullinemia Type II (CTLN2) and Neonatal Intrahepatic Cholestasis caused by Citrin Deficiency (NICCD). The analyses of SLC25A13 gene and its protein/mRNA products remain reliable tools for the definitive diagnoses of CD patients, and so far, the SLC25A13 mutation spectrum in Chinese CD patients has not been well-characterized yet.

Methods and Results

By means of direct DNA sequencing, cDNA cloning and SNP analyses, 16 novel pathogenic mutations, including 9 missense, 4 nonsense, 1 splice-site, 1 deletion and 1 large transposal insertion IVS4ins6kb (GenBank accession number KF425758), were identified in CTLN2 or NICCD patients from China, Japan and Malaysia, respectively, making the SLC25A13 variations worldwide reach the total number of 81. A large NICCD cohort of 116 Chinese cases was also established, and the 4 high-frequency mutations contributed a much larger proportion of the mutated alleles in the patients from south China than in those from the north (χ² = 14.93, P<0.01), with the latitude of 30°N as the geographic dividing line in mainland China.

Conclusions

This paper further enriched the SLC25A13 variation spectrum worldwide, and formed a substantial contribution to the in-depth understanding of the genotypic feature of Chinese CD patients.