Immediate reconstruction of a nonreplantable thumb amputation by great toe transfer

The first dorsal metacarpal artery flaps versus reverse homodigital dorsal flaps for thumb reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

This review was performed to systematically compare the effectiveness and safety of the first dorsal metacarpal artery flaps (FDMAF) and reverse homodigital dorsal flaps (RHDF) for thumb reconstruction.

METHODS

All literatures, which compared FDMAF versus RHDF for thumb reconstruction, were acquired through a comprehensive search in multiple databases from inception until 31st August 2022. A meta-analysis was performed using the Cochrane Collaboration's RevMan 5.4 software.

RESULTS

A total of 19 articles were retrieved, comprising 396 patients in the FDMAF group and 423 patients in the RHDF group. The pooled estimates suggested that there were no significant differences in venous congestion, complications about flap necrosis and reduced range of motion (ROM) of thumb, static 2-point discrimination (S-2PD) between the two groups. On the other hand, patients in the RHDF group had less vascular crisis (odds ratio [OR] = 3.15, 95%CI, 1.31-7.56), complications about poor cortical reorientation (OR = 440.02, 95%CI, 91.97-2105.27) and higher satisfaction rate (OR = 0.56, 95% CI, 0.33-0.96) than those in the FDMAF group.

CONCLUSIONS

The two surgical procedures were both safe and reliable since no significant differences were found in flap necrosis between the two groups. However, the patients in the RHDF group had less complications about vascular crisis, poor cortical reorientation and higher satisfaction rate. Accordingly, we thought RHDF may be more superior for thumb reconstruction than FDMAF.

Foot Plantar Pressure Profile Alteration after Microsurgical Great Toe-to-thumb Transfer

Background

Microsurgical great toe-to-thumb transfer (mGTT) is a widely used procedure when immediate replantation of thumb is not feasible. The aim of this study was to investigate the alteration of plantar pressure profile of the donor foot after mGTT.

Methods

Twenty patients receiving microsurgical great toe-to-hand transfer between 1985 to 2014, and 16 healthy subjects were recruited. Group 1 consisted of 20 feet receiving mGTT, whereas group 2 consisted of 32 normal feet as control. The flap design in this study was to preserve 1 cm of the proximal phalanx to maintain the attachment of the plantar aponeurosis and intrinsic muscles. The Taiwan Chinese version of the Foot Function Index was used for patient-reported outcome measurement. A novel Emed-X system was used for dynamic plantar pressure measurement. A total of four parameters were collected, including peak pressure, contact area, contact time, and pressure-time integral.

Results

In group 1, the peak pressure redistributed under the first metatarsal bone and was significantly higher than group 2 (P < 0.05). There was no significant change of the contact area between the midfoot region of group 1 and group 2 (P > 0.05). Furthermore, similar foot clearance efficiency was demonstrated in group 1 and group 2 (P > 0.05).

Conclusions

The windlass effect of the foot will not be affected when performing mGTT with preservation of 1 cm of the proximal phalanx. Therefore, this surgical procedure is highly recommended for clinical application.

A new method for second toe flap revascularization in plantar dominant artery pattern - dorsal metatarsal artery interpositional graf

BACKGROUND

Toe transfer to hand is a viable option for patients, which can provide functionally useful digits. Harvesting of the second toe is still accepted as a demanding surgical procedure. The major questions before this transfer are the location and the dominance of the arterial anatomy of the second toe. The authors present the incidence of patients with a dominant plantar artery system and a description of a versatile technique that can be used for toe transfers in these patients.

METHODS

The study was designed retrospectively. Toe to hand transfers performed between 2010 and 2018 were reviewed. The patients with a dominant plantar arterial system were included in this study. The dorsalis pedis arterial graft technique described by the authors was used in all cases with a dominant plantar system. All of transfers were done by the senior author. All cases followed up at least one year post-operatively. The survival of the transferred finger was examined in the follow-ups.

RESULTS

Eleven toe to hand transplantation cases in nine traumatic patients were included in this series. The reason for the operation was trauma in all patients. Second toe transfer was performed in all of the cases. Plantar dominant arterial system was seen in 3 of the 9 patients. Dorsal arterial system was dominant in the remaining six patients. Dorsalis pedis arterial graft technique was used in these four cases. All of the toes survived, and reexploration was needed in 2 cases because of venous insufficiency. Mean follow-up time was 16.4 months.

DISCUSSION

This is the first study to recommend the use of dorsalis pedis as an arterial graft instead of vein grafts. This surgical method described will make these rarely performed transfers easier and affect the success rates positively.

Thumb Reconstruction Using Transfer of the Ring Finger Without Vascular Anastomosis

PURPOSE

This study describes the results of the ring finger transfer technique for thumb reconstruction.

METHODS

Five fingers of 4 patients aged 23-57 years who presented to our clinic with an amputated thumb between 2017 and 2019 were included in this study. The results were assessed using Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder, Hand (DASH) scoring. Active range of motion, grip and pinch strengths, Kapandji scores, and static 2-point discrimination were measured.

RESULTS

The mean age of the patients (3 men, 1 woman) was 37 years (23-57 years). The level of amputation was the proximal phalanx in 3 digits and metacarpal in 2 digits. The average procedure time of was 89 ± 12 minutes. The average follow-up duration was 13 months (12-16 months). There was no total or partial digit necrosis in any patient. The mean preoperative shortened DASH score was 52.5 ± 6.7, and the mean postoperative score was 5.3 ± 6.5. The mean preoperative DASH Work Module score was 81.2 ± 18.8 and the mean postoperative score was 13.8 ± 7.5. Two-point discrimination was normal.

CONCLUSIONS

Transfer of the ring finger to reconstruct the amputated thumb is an alternative reconstruction method for patients who do not accept toe-to-thumb and pollicization techniques.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Superficial Peroneal Neurocutaneous Flap for Coverage of Donor Site Defect After the Combined Transfer of Toe and Dorsal Foot Flap

BACKGROUND

Reconstruction of digital loss with soft tissue defects remains a tough challenge. Although a combined flap of toe and dorsal foot skin provides a good option for "like-for-like" hand reconstruction, the disappointed donor site morbidity prevents it from popularity. In this study, we presented experiences of the superficial peroneal neurocutaneous (SPNC) flap for donor site closure after the combined toe and dorsal foot flap transfer.

METHODS

Superficial peroneal neurocutaneous flaps were used to cover foot donor site defects in 9 patients. The flaps harvested from feet including 3 cases of wrap-around flap with dorsal foot flap, 4 cases of 2nd toe flap with dorsal foot flap, 2 cases of 2nd and 3rd toe flap with dorsal foot flap. The flap size, operation time, and complications were documented, and the donor sites were evaluated by the subjective outcome measure, the foot evaluation questionnaire, and the Vancouver Scar Scale.

RESULTS

All flaps but one survived completely without complications. Marginal necrosis occurred in the distal part of the flap in one case, which was treated by daily dressings. The skin grafts on the lower leg healed uneventfully. The average operation time of flap transfer was 40 minutes. Follow-up ranged from 9 to 16 months, and patients were content with the results of the foot donor site according to the outcome measures. All the patients were able to wear normal shoes walking and running with a normal gait, and none sustained complications of skin erosion or ulceration. Protective sensibility was obtained in all the flaps. Two patients complained of cold intolerance and 2 could not wear a thong sandal. The donor site scars on the lower leg were measured 3.2 on average on the Vancouver Scar Scale.

CONCLUSIONS

The SPNC flap is a practical procedure for donor site closure on the foot, especially when extra dorsal foot skin is elevated with a toe flap for hand reconstruction.

Current indications for abdominal-based flaps in hand and forearm reconstruction

Extensive soft tissue loss or injury of the hand and upper extremity is a challenging reconstructive problem traditionally treated with abdominal-based pedicled flaps. Options for coverage included the groin flap based on the superficial circumflex iliac artery, the Scarpa's fascia flap based on the superficial inferior epigastric artery, and the paraumbilical perforator flap from the deep inferior epigastric artery perforators. Despite the ability to provide consistent and pliable soft tissue coverage with ease of elevation, these flaps have several disadvantages including restriction of mobility, requirement for multiple procedures, bulkiness and patient discomfort. With the advent of microsurgery, pedicled regional flaps, and off-the-shelf skin substitutes, the applications for these flaps have narrowed. However several indications still remain. These include: patient and facility factors which deter microsurgery, the absence of recipient vessels after injury, prior surgical use of recipient vessels, the need to preserve major vessels for future reconstruction, and large multi-surface wounds requiring coverage. In this review we detail these indications and provide case examples for each.

Repair of distal thumb degloving injury using combination of reverse dorsoradial flap of the thumb and middle finger proper digital arterial island flap

BACKGROUND

To examine the efficacy of combination of the reverse dorsoradial flap of the thumb and middle finger proper digital arterial island flap for repair of distal thumb degloving injury.

METHODS

Twelve patients with mechanical distal thumb degloving injuries were treated between February 2017 and August 2019. A combination of the reverse dorsoradial flap of the thumb and the middle finger proper digital arterial island flap were used. Semmes-Weinstein (SW) monofilament and static two-point discrimination (S-2PD) tests, active range-of-motion (ROM) of the joints, cold intolerance, visual analog scale (VAS) score patient complications, and patient satisfaction were sequentially evaluated.

RESULTS

Two cases with postoperative flap blisters were treated at time of dressing changes up to successful scab formation. One case with postoperative arterial crisis of finger arterial dorsal branch vessel was successfully released in the pedicle. Ten cases healed by first intention and 2 cases by secondary intention. Twelve patients received follow-up examinations between 3 and 20 months (average 13 months) post-treatment, and all exhibited full, soft flaps with no fingertip pain.

CONCLUSION

The combined use of the reverse dorsoradial flap of the thumb and the middle finger proper digital arterial island flap is a practical and effective approach to surgical repair of distal thumb degloving injuries.

Thumb reconstruction with combination of the wrap-around flap prefabricated by medialis pedis perforator flap with nail bed and phalanx banked from the amputated thumb: A case report

Thumb reconstruction has been a very challenging issue for hand surgeons. In this report, we present a case of thumb reconstruction with combination of the wrap-around flap prefabricated by the medialis pedis perforator flap with phalanx and nail bed banked from the amputated thumb. A 22-year-old man suffered from the left thumb amputation as well as large soft tissue defect of hand and comminuted fracture in wrist due to a crush accident. The distal phalanx and nail bed of left thumb were exposed and no suitable vessels for microsurgical anastomosis could be found, resulting in the great difficulty of replantation. After debridement, nail bed of the amputated thumb was dissected and banked on the medial side of foot, while the distal phalanx was buried in the abdominal subcutaneous tissue. The fracture was fixed with an external fixation and the soft tissue defect was covered with a free anterolateral flap. Wound and bone healing was achieved 6 months after the initial treatment. Thumb was reconstructed with combination of the banked phalanx and a wrap-around flap prefabricated by the medialis pedis perforator flap and the banked nail bed. The postoperative course was uneventful with complications from both reconstruction and donor sites. The nail of the reconstructed thumb grew normally. Thumb oppositional function was rebuilt. The patient was satisfied with the aesthetic and functional outcome at 5-year postoperative follow-up. We propose that tissue banked from the nonreplantable amputated thumb could be used for secondary reconstruction with the technique of flap prefabrication.

Microsurgical thumb repair and reconstruction

In this article, we review microsurgical reconstructive techniques available to treat thumb amputation at different levels based on our experience. We reference techniques used by other surgeons and identify the most suitable technique for different clinical situations. Indications and techniques for microsurgical partial or composite transfer of the great or second toe for thumb reconstruction are summarized. Different microsurgical transfer techniques suggest a great freedom of surgical choices. However, the choices are considerably restricted if all functional and cosmetic requirements are to be met. We recommend individualized surgical design and reconstruction because each case of thumb amputation is unique.

Functional salvage of a hand after unsuccessfull attempt of replantation

Amputation by crush injuries generally represents a contraindication for replantation, and especially when the lesion is caused by the summation of multiple concomitant traumatic mechanisms.

We present the case of a 22 year- old female who arrived in our service with a crush/torsion amputation of all long fingers at the metacarpo-phalangeal level of the right hand. After the unsuccessful attempt of replantation, the functional reconstruction of the hand was achieved by using a double free flap transfer: anterolateral thigh perforator flap (ALT) and digital block transfer of second and third toes.

Combined two foot flaps with iliac bone graft for reconstruction of the thumb

The purpose of this report was to retrospectively review the results of reconstruction of the thumb by use of combined two foot flaps with an iliac bone graft. From 2009 to 2014, nine patients with traumatic amputation of the thumb had their thumbs reconstructed. The two flaps were based on one pedicle. All flaps survived completely. Patients were followed for a mean of 15.6 months (range, 6-35 months). The appearance of the reconstructed thumb was comparable to a normal one, except for one thumb which required debulking. The appearance of the nail was satisfactory without deformity. The range of joint motion was satisfactory. The two point discrimination of the pulp ranged from 6 mm to >15 mm. The Michigan Hand Questionnaire outcome score was a mean of 76.2 ± 11.3 points and the Maryland foot rating score a mean of 94.8 ± 3.4 points. The combined two foot flaps with iliac bone graft might provide an option for the reconstruction of the thumb.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Immediate Great Toe Transfer for Thumb Reconstruction After Tumor Resection: Report of 3 Cases

BACKGROUND

Modern oncologic surgery aims not only to obtain tumor-free margins but also to spare or reconstruct limb function and preserve quality of life. A negative tumor margin in the digit generally requires amputation; therefore, function is preserved with reconstruction. We report results of simultaneous ablative tumor resection and reconstruction with a great toe transfer in patients requiring surgery for aggressive benign and malignant thumb tumors.

METHODS

Between 2000 and 2009, three patients with extensive soft tissue tumors of the distal thumb underwent amputation to obtain wide negative surgical margins. In each case, an immediate trimmed toe-to-thumb transfer was performed. Results, evaluated retrospectively, included a review of perioperative complications, donor-site morbidity, oncologic status, objective functional outcomes, and subjective patient satisfaction.

RESULTS

Three patients were found with either locally aggressive benign (n = 1) or malignant (n = 2) tumors of the thumb. All patients underwent immediate reconstruction after amputation through the base of the proximal phalanx for tumor eradication. No perioperative complications were encountered, and all toes survived. Full thumb opposition and protective sensation were achieved in all patients. All patients returned to their previous occupation without functional limitations. There is no local or distant tumor recurrence. Delayed wound healing at the ipsilateral foot donor site occurred in all 3 patients. Wet-to-dry dressing changes were successful in 2 patients, whereas the third patient required full-thickness skin grafting. All patients were satisfied with their reconstruction.

CONCLUSIONS

An immediate great toe-to-thumb transfer should be considered when thumb amputation is required to satisfy adequate oncologic margins. Such a transfer provides simultaneous restoration of digit length, position, sensation, and acceptable esthetics. This procedure is technically demanding and requires an experienced microsurgical team as well as appropriate patient counseling and consent before surgery.

Risk factors for reexploration in toe-to-hand transfer: a multivariate analysis of 363 cases

BACKGROUND

Reexploration after toe-to-hand transfer increases the risk of failure. In this study, the authors aimed to identify risk factors for reexploration after toe-to-hand transfer.

METHODS

The medical records of 363 patients who underwent single toe-to-hand transfer between 2000 and 2010 were reviewed retrospectively. Patient demographics, clinical data, and operative data were collected, and multivariate analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Of these 363 patients, 299 toes (82.4 percent) had primary success in transplantation. Sixty-four toes required reexploration, of which seven toes failed. The overall success rate was 98.1 percent. Of the 64 toes that required reexploration, arterial spasm was found in 39 (60.9 percent), arterial thrombosis was found in 27 (42.2 percent), and venous thrombosis was found in 16 (25.0 percent). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that postoperative wound infection, metacarpal hand injuries, and preceding flap coverage were independently associated with reexploration.

CONCLUSIONS

Reducing reexploration in toe-to-hand transfer may be facilitated by managing or avoiding these risk factors. Particular attention must be paid to avoid postoperative wound infection, which was the single greatest factor contributing to reexploration (adjusted OR, 12.6).

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Risk, III.

Transfer of the Fifth Finger to Replace an Amputated Thumb: A Preliminary Study

Amputation of the thumb causes not only loss of significant functional use of the hand but also psychological and social problems. The procedures of toe-to-thumb transfer, pollicization, or metacarpal extension are recognized and well-documented options in thumb reconstruction. Although these techniques have been successfully applied, they have some disadvantages. This study aims to test the feasibility of the fifth finger for thumb reconstruction. The fifth finger was released following exploration of the digital artery, vein, nerve, and flexor and extensor tendons, including the flexor retinaculum. The digital vein and the extensor tendon of the fifth finger were separated at the level of the metacarpophalangeal joint. The proximal phalanx of the fifth finger was cut smoothly at the level of the metacarpophalangeal joint with a saw. The deep flexor tendons, digital arteries, and nerves were preserved. The proximal phalanx of the released fifth finger was fixed to the first metacarpal bone. The digital vein of the first finger was anastomosed to the digital vein of the fifth finger by microsurgery. Angiography was done after the transfer. Exploration till the flexor retinaculum enabled thumb transfer without any restriction of movement in all 10 cadaver fingers. The average total surgical time was 135 ± 12 minutes. Flow from both radial and ulnar arteries was demonstrated in the transferred fifth finger by angiography. The technique appears to be feasible for thumb reconstruction by preserving digital arteries and nerves in a relatively short time, but further important aspects have to be assessed in further clinical studies.

Toe-to-hand transfer: evolving indications and relevant outcomes

Toe-to-hand transfer is indicated for many types of congenital and traumatic thumb absences. This review will highlight the applications of toe-to-hand transfer and their functional, aesthetic, and psychosocial outcomes. Despite its technical complexity, toe to hand reconstruction techniques can provide an elegant option to restore function for patients with difficult hand disabilities.

Successful thumb reconstruction after tumor resection by immediate toe transfer in a 67-year-old patient: case report and literature review

Age is a limiting factor for microsurgery. We report the case of a 67-year-old patient with a malignant tumor on the right thumb, treated by amputation and immediate reconstruction by partial transfer of the hallux, with an excellent result, but venous swelling at the fourth day that required a controlled bleeding for 3 days. In the light of this observation, we think that there is no age limit for reconstruction of a thumb by toe transfer, either cosmetically or functionally.

A systematic review of outcomes of toe-to-thumb transfers for isolated traumatic thumb amputation

BACKGROUND

Toe-to-thumb transfer is an established procedure for reconstruction of traumatic thumb amputations. The four types of toe-to-thumb transfers are the second toe, the great toe, the wrap-around great toe and the trimmed great toe transfers. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic review of the literature to compare outcomes amongst different methods of toe-to-thumb transfers.

METHODS

A literature search using 'toe-to-thumb transfer' combined with 'thumb injury' and 'thumb reconstruction' as keywords and limited to humans and the English language identified 633 studies. Studies were included in the review if they: (1) present primary data, (2) report three or more toe-to-thumb transfers for isolated complete traumatic thumb amputation between the metacarpophalangeal joint and the interphalangeal joint (both excluded) and (3) present functional outcome data.

RESULTS

Twenty-five studies representing 450 toe-to-thumb transfers met the inclusion criteria. They included 101 second toe transfers, 196 great toe transfers, 122 wrap-around transfers and 31 trimmed toe transfers. The mean survival rate was 96.4%. No statistically significant differences could be detected between the four transfers with regards to survival, arc of motion, total active motion, grip and pinch strength and static two-point discrimination.

CONCLUSIONS

All four types of toe transfer procedures have predictably high survival rates and good patient satisfaction scores. The current data are inadequate to make any comments with regards to donor site morbidity. Till such data are available, an evidence-based recommendation for the superiority of a specific type of toe-to-thumb transfer cannot be made.

Recurrent calcifying aponeurotic fibroma of the thumb: case report

We present an unusual case report of an aggressive, recurrent calcifying aponeurotic fibroma of the thumb in an adult man with invasion into the distal and proximal phalanges, the skin, the radial and ulnar neurovascular bundles, and the tendons, treated with amputation and an immediate toe-to-thumb transfer.

Functional and aesthetic results of immediate reconstruction of traumatic thumb defects by toe-to-thumb transplantation

Traumatic thumb defects significantly affect the function and appearance of the hand; thus, thumb reconstruction is very important in clinical practice. In our report, three reconstruction strategies of toe-to-thumb transplantation, based on the amputation level of the thumb, were used for immediate thumb reconstruction in 27 patients with traumatic thumb defects. All procedures were performed successfully. Patients were satisfied with the function and appearance of the reconstructed thumb. These results indicate that if the reconstruction method is properly selected based on the amputation level of the thumb, toe-to-thumb transplantation is feasible for the immediate reconstruction of the thumb.