Noninvasive diagnostics for extremity compartment syndrome following traumatic injury: A state-of-the-art review

Comparison of intracompartment pressure changes in tibial plateau fractures and controlled people: A pilot study

OBJECTIVE

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is a serious medical condition that can be encountered in tibial plateau fractures. However, no studies of compartment pressure changes in patients with tibial plateau fractures compared to patient without fractures have been reported. To obtain a comprehensive understanding of the pressure changes in patients with fractures, we monitored and recorded the compartment pressure and attempted to reveal the potential pressure release function of the human fascia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Cohorts of 43 normal individuals and 23 patients (initial 33, 10 were excluded due to inclusion criteria) and include the number of patients who completed the study with closed tibial fractures (the fracture group, FG, which comprised 6 men and 17 women) were included in this retrospective research. Compartment pressures were measured with Icare, a device that is traditionally used to measure intraocular pressure. Results of measurements at 6 different locations in the lower limb were recorded and compared for three days (days 2, 3, and 4 post fracture) between normal cohort (CG) and fracture cohort (FG) patients.

RESULTS

The compartment pressures were comparable at each pressure measurement site (upper, middle and lower) in patients of the CG and the FG. Compared with the CG patients, there was a significant increase in compartment pressure at the upper lateral location in 18-45-year-old patients in the FG (P = 0.013) and at the upper lateral (P = 0.004) and medial locations (P = 0.005) in 46-69-year-old patients, and the values tended to normalize over time. Compared with the contralateral normal limb of patients in the FG, there was a significant increase in compartment pressure at the upper lateral location in 18-45-year-old patients (P = 0.009) and at the upper lateral (P = 0.015) and medial locations (P = 0.016) in 46-69-year-old patients on the fractured side. Based on different fracture classifications, there were no significant differences in compartment pressure at the medial (upper, middle and lower) locations when compared with pressures at the corresponding lateral sites of measurement.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study revealed that the fascial compartment as a whole can release the increased intracompartment pressure after fracture to prevent complications such as acute compartment syndrome caused by a continued increase in pressure. The Icare as a portable device, is potentially useful in compartmental pressure measurement especially in emergency room.

In Vivo Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography Assessment of Acute Compartment Syndrome in a Turkey Model

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the work described here was to evaluate the objectivity and reproducibility of non-invasive intra-compartment pressure (ICP) measurement using ultrasound shear wave elastography (SWE) in a turkey model in vivo and to determine the biological and histologic changes in acute compartment syndrome (ACS).

METHODS

Twenty-four turkeys were randomly divided into four groups based on the duration and fasciotomy of ACS created by infusion of up to 50 mm Hg in the tibialis muscle: group 1, ACS 2 h; group 2, ACS 4 h; group 3, ACS 2 h + fasciotomy 2 h; group 4, ACS 4 h + fasciotomy 2 h. For each turkey, the contralateral limb was considered the control. Time-synchronized measures of SWE and ICP from each leg were collected. Then turkeys were euthanized for histology and quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) examination.

RESULTS

All models created reproducible increases in ICP and SWE, which had a strong linear relationship (r = 0.802, p < 0.0001) during phase 1. SWE remained stable (50.86 ± 9.64 kPa) when ICP remained at 50.28 ± 2.17 mm Hg in phase 2. After fasciotomy, SWE declined stepwise and then normalized (r = 0.737, p < 0.0001). Histologically, the myofiber diameter of group 2 (82.31 ± 22.92 μm) and group 4 (90.90 ± 20.48 μm) decreased significantly (p < 0.01) compared with that of the control group (103.1 ± 20.39 μm); the interstitial space of all groups increased significantly (p < 0.01). Multifocal muscle damage revealed neutrophilic infiltration, degeneration, hemorrhage and necrosis, especially in group 4. Quantitative RT-PCR verified that interleukin-6 and heparin-binding EGF-like growth factor were significantly increased in group 4.

CONCLUSION

SWE provided sensitive measurements correlating to ICP in a clinically relevant ACS animal model. Once ACS time was exceeded, progression to irreversible necrosis continued spontaneously, even after fasciotomy. SWE may help surgeons in the early detection, monitoring, prognosis and decision making on fasciotomy for ACS.

Practical Review on the Contemporary Diagnosis and Management of Compartment Syndrome

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is a limb-threatening pathology that necessitates early detection and management. The diagnosis of ACS is often made by physical examination alone; however, supplemental methods such as compartment pressure measurement, infrared spectroscopy, and ultrasound can provide additional information that support decision-making. This practical review aims to incorporate and summarize recent studies to provide evidence-based approaches to compartment syndrome for both resource-rich and -poor settings among several patient populations.

Acute compartment syndrome of the thigh complicated with a pseudoaneurysm of the arteria profunda femoris

Compartment syndrome of the thigh and a pseudoaneurysm of the arteria profunda femoris are rare entities that usually occur independently. Untreated, both can lead to life-threatening complications making prompt diagnosis and management mandatory. The diagnosis of an acute compartment syndrome can be suspected clinically, and subsequently needs to be confirmed by intra-compartmental pressure measurement. Treatment should be done by urgent fasciotomy within 6 hours. A pseudoaneurysm can also be suspected clinically. Various imaging modalities exist to confirm the diagnosis, with duplex ultrasound being the diagnostic test of choice. Treatment is depending on the importance of clinical symptoms and on the size of the pseudoaneurysm. We present the first case in which an acute compartment syndrome of the thigh was complicated by a pseudoaneurysm of the arteria profunda femoris. The pseudoaneurysm was subsequently complicated by hemorrhage and infection.

Non-invasive assessment of muscle compartment elasticity by pressure-related ultrasound in pediatric trauma: a prospective clinical study in 25 cases of forearm shaft fractures

BACKGROUND

Soft-tissue swelling after limb fractures in pediatric patients is well known to be a risk factor for developing acute compartment syndrome (ACS). Clinical assessment alone is uncertain in specific cases. Recently, we proposed a non-invasive ultrasound-based method to objectify muscle compartment elasticity for monitoring. We hypothesize a strong correlation between the soft-tissue swelling after stabilization of upper limb fractures and the compartment elasticity objectified with a novel ultrasound-based approach in pediatric trauma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a prospective clinical study, children suffering forearm fractures but not developing an ACS were included. The muscle compartment elasticity of the m. flexor carpi ulnaris was assessed after surgical intervention by a non-invasive, ultrasound-based method resulting in a relative elasticity (RE in %) in both the control (healthy limb) and study group (fractured limb). Soft-tissue swelling was categorized in four different levels (0-3) and correlated with the resulting RE (%).

RESULTS

The RE in the study group (15.67%, SD ± 3.06) showed a significantly decreased level (p < 0.001) compared with the control (22.77%, SD ± 5.4). The categorized grade of soft-tissue swelling resulted in a moderate correlation with the RE (rs = 0.474).

CONCLUSIONS

The presented study appears to represent a novel approach to assess the posttraumatic pressure changes in a muscle compartment after fracture stabilization non-invasively. In this first clinical study in pediatric cases, our measurement method represents a low-cost, easy, and secure approach that has the potential to substitute invasive measurement of suspected ACS in muscle compartment conditions. Further investigations in lager cohorts are required to prove its daily clinical practicability and to confirm the expected reliability.

Porcine Model of Acute Compartment Syndrome

OBJECTIVES

Acute compartment syndrome is a devastating condition associated with lasting consequences or even death if not treated in a timely fashion. Current preclinical modeling is inadequate. Ideally a model should mimic human disease. There should be a trauma-induced reperfusion or direct muscle event that causes gradual increased pressure and is amenable to release with fasciotomy. We have attempted to reproduce this mechanism and outcome in a porcine model.

METHODS

Anterior tibial musculature was injured with vascular occlusion plus exterior tourniquet crush or direct intracompartmental crush through balloon inflation. The injury was maintained for over 5 hours. At that time, the tourniquet or balloon was removed. The injuries were continuously monitored with an intramuscular continuous pressure sensor. Pressure changes were recorded and after 2 hours of postinjury observation, a fasciotomy was performed for the muscle compartment.

RESULTS

Pressures were brought to 100 mm Hg during the injury phase. During the two-hour observation period, the balloon catheter technique achieved an average pressure of 25.1 ± SD 8.8 mm Hg with a maximum reading of 38.2 mm Hg and minimum reading of 14.1 mm Hg. During this same period, the ischemia-reperfusion + direct crush technique achieved an average pressure of 33.7 ± SD 7.3 mm Hg, with a maximum reading of 43.5 mm Hg and minimum reading of 23.5 mm Hg. Average pressure postfasciotomy for the balloon catheter technique was 2.4 ± SD 2.5 mm Hg; and for the crush technique, average value postfasciotomy was 4.9 ± SD 3.7 mm Hg-both representing a return to physiologic levels.

CONCLUSION

This is the first preclinical model that shows the same response to injury and treatment as is observed in human physiology. Surgical and nonsurgical therapies for compartment syndrome can now be tested reliably.

Review of Reliable and Valid Noninvasive Tools for the Diagnosis of Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome

Background

Currently, invasive dynamic intracompartmental pressure (ICP) measurements are considered the gold standard for diagnosis of chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS). During recent years, different noninvasive imaging modalities have been presented as a possible replacement for ICP measurement.

Purpose

To provide an overview of the current state of evidence and possibilities regarding noninvasive diagnostic methods for CECS.

Study Design

Scoping review; Level of evidence, 4.

Methods

The PubMed (MEDLINE) and Embase databases were searched using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. Full-text articles were included if they reported on noninvasive diagnostic methods for CECS, included ≥5 patients with CECS, and were published between 1994 and 2022. Articles not written in English were excluded. Systematic reviews, letters to the editor, and case reports were not eligible for inclusion. Out of 961 articles identified in the initial search, 25 studies (N = 1257 participants) were included. Risk of bias was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-Comparative (QUADAS-C) tool for comparative studies and the QUADAS-2 tool for noncomparative studies. Narrative synthesis was used to present results.

Results

The level of evidence for the 25 studies ranged from 2 to 4. Four studies were classified as having a low risk of bias, 21 studies were classified as being at risk of bias. The following noninvasive diagnostic tools for CECS were reported: magnetic resonance imaging/diffusion tensor imaging (n = 8), near-infrared spectroscopy (n = 6), electromyography (n = 4), single-photon emission computed tomography (n = 5), ultrasound (n = 2), myotonometry (n=1) and predictive clinical model (n = 1). There was insufficient evidence in the literature to support the use of any of these noninvasive diagnostic tools as a gold standard for CECS.

Conclusion

Despite the need to replace the controversial use of ICP for the diagnosis of CECS, our review indicated a lack of validity on all discussed noninvasive diagnostic tools as a replacement.

Spontaneous acute forearm compartment syndrome: Case report of a clinical diagnosis with limited imaging options

Diagnostic radiology is essential for providing targeted management of different diseases. Thus, there has been a dramatic increase in the demand for medical imaging. However, acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is one of the clinical scenarios in which radiology has limited value. The authors report a nontraumatic spontaneous ACS in the forearm of a 56-year-old female. The roles of Ultrasound and MRI, if available, are also illustrated. Limited reports of spontaneous ACS are published in the literature; we hope this case adds to the limited data. Our goal in reporting this case is to improve clinical practice with favorable outcomes for the patients involved globally by alert to the onset of ACS to promote early detection and timely fasciotomy. Also, we aim to increase awareness among physicians and radiologists of the limitations of radiology in specific clinical scenarios. Finally, it may aid in illuminating a possible link between malignant hypertension, spontaneous bleeding/hematoma, and ACS.

Extremity compartment syndrome: A review with a focus on non-invasive methods of diagnosis

The article deals with an overview of acute extremity compartment syndrome with a focus on the option of non-invasive detection of the syndrome. Acute extremity compartment syndrome (ECS) is an urgent complication that occurs most often in fractures or high-energy injuries. There is still no reliable method for detecting ECS. The only objective measurement method used in clinical practice is an invasive measurement of intramuscular pressure (IMP). The purpose of this paper is to summarize the current state of research into non-invasive measurement methods that could allow simple and reliable continuous monitoring of patients at risk of developing ECS. Clinical trials are currently underway to verify the suitability of the most studied method, near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS), which is a method for measuring the local oxygenation of muscle compartments. Less explored methods include the use of ultrasound, ultrasound elastography, bioimpedance measurements, and quantitative tissue hardness measurements. Finding a suitable method for continuous non-invasive monitoring of the syndrome would greatly improve the quality of care for patients at risk. ECS must be diagnosed quickly and accurately to prevent irreversible tissue damage that can occur within hours of syndrome onset and may even warrant amputation if neglected.

Is the Presence of a Psychiatric Disorder Associated With More Aggressive Management of Compartment Syndrome?

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether pre-existing psychiatric disorder is associated with potentially unnecessary fasciotomy.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Academic Level-1 trauma center.

PATIENTS

All the patients with orthopaedic trauma undergoing leg fasciotomy at an academic Level I trauma center from 2006 to 2020.

INTERVENTION

Pre-existing diagnosis of psychiatric disorder.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Early primary wound closure and delayed primary wound closure.

RESULTS

In total, 116 patients were included. Twenty-seven patients (23%) had a pre-existing diagnosis of psychiatric disorder with 13 having anxiety, 14 depression, 5 bipolar disorder, and 2 ADHD. Several patients had multiple diagnoses. Fifty-one patients (44%) had early primary closure (EPC), and 65 patients (56%) had delayed primary closure. Of patients with a psychiatric disorder, 52% received EPC compared with 42% of patients without a disorder, P = 0.38. This lack of a strong association did not seem to vary across specific psychiatric conditions. After adjusting for sex, age, injury type, and substance abuse, there was still no significant association between a psychiatric disorder and EPC with an odds ratio of 1.08 (95% CI, 0.43-2.75).

CONCLUSIONS

Among patients with orthopaedic trauma undergoing emergent fasciotomy for acute compartment syndrome, a psychiatric disorder was not associated with a significantly increased rate of possibly unnecessary fasciotomy. Given the potential for a psychiatric condition to complicate the diagnosis of acute compartment syndrome, this data is somewhat reassuring; however, there remains a need for continued vigilance in treating patients with psychiatric conditions and research in this area.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Non-invasive and reliable assessment of compartment elasticity by pressure related ultrasound: An in-vitro study

PURPOSE

The development of acute compartment syndrome is a serious threat to trauma patients. The clinical assessment alone is not reliable enough to determine the need for fasciotomy in many cases. The Physician´s assessment of the elasticity of the muscle compartment might be particularly important to objectively evaluate the pressure in this enclosed space. The purpose of this study was to determine the observer´s reproducibility, of compartment elasticity measurements by a novel ultrasonic approach.

METHODS

Increasing intra-compartmental pressures (ICP) were simulated in a water filled in-vitro model. Pressure related ultrasound was used to determine the relative elasticity (RE) of soft tissue compartments. A pressure transducing probe head was combined with the ultrasonic probe to obtain cross section views of the simulated compartment and to detect the amount of applied pressure by the observer. In this model, the compartment depth without compression (P₀) was set to be 100%. Changes of the compartment depth due to a probe pressure of 80 mmHg (P₈₀) were correlated to P₀ and an elasticity quotient as a value for RE (%) was calculated. Twelve blinded observers performed measurements for RE determination (%) under three pressure conditions. Reproducibility was calculated using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

Measurements (n = 432) revealed that the RE (%) in the control group was 17,06% (SD+/-2,13), whereas the RE of the group ICP₃₀ significantly decreased to 12,66% (SD+/- 1,19) (p<0,001). The ICP₅₀ group revealed a further significant decrease to 8,43% (SD+/- 0,67) (p<0,001). Repeated measurement of RE and ICP showed a high level of correlation (spearman correlation coefficient: roh=0,922). A RE <14% resulted in a sensitivity of 96% and a specificity of 90,3% for diagnosis of an ICP >30 mmHg. ICC_inter was 0,986; 95%, CI: 0,977-0,992 (p<0,001).

DISCUSSION

The presented ultrasound-based approach reliably assesses the elasticity in a simulated compartment model. In this pioneer study investigating the inter- and intra-observer reproducibility, this method of measurement appears to be of low cost in addition to being an easy and secure approach that may have the potential to substitute invasive measurement. Further investigations are required to improve its feasibility and to confirm the reliability under clinical conditions.

Virtual reality as a non-pharmacologic analgesic for fasciotomy wound infections in acute compartment syndrome: a case report

BACKGROUND

Fasciotomy is a life-saving procedure to treat acute compartment syndrome, a surgical emergency. As fasciotomy dramatically improves wound pain, it should be performed as soon as possible. Moreover, delays in the use of fasciotomy can increase the rate of wound infections. Once the fasciotomy wound is infected, pain control is achieved via the long-term use of opioids or anti-inflammatory analgesics. However, the administration of high doses of opioids may cause complications, such as respiratory depression, over-sedation, and constipation. Therefore, treatment methods other than narcotic administration should be established to better manage the pain caused by fasciotomy wound infections. Virtual reality has recently been introduced in analgesic therapy as a replacement, or complement, to conventional pharmacological treatments. Its use has been extensively studied in the pain management of patients with burns. An increasing number of painful conditions are being successfully treated with virtual reality. Here, we report a case of acute compartment syndrome complicated by fasciotomy wound infection.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 40-year-old Japanese man suffering from acute compartment syndrome of his leg due to a car accident trauma was treated with a fasciotomy to decompress intra-compartmental pressure and restore tissue perfusion, and admitted to an intensive care unit. Unfortunately, as the open fasciotomy wound was complicated by infection, he complained of hyperalgesia and severe pain during wound debridement. He was therefore given acetaminophen and high-dose intravenous patient-controlled analgesic fentanyl (35 μg/kg per day) to reduce the pain. Despite these efforts, the pain was poorly controlled and opioid-induced side effects such as respiratory depression were observed. An immersive virtual reality analgesic therapy aimed at distraction and relaxation was used and effectively alleviated the pain. Three sessions of virtual reality analgesic therapy over 2 days produced sustainable analgesic effects, which led to a 25-75% dose reduction in fentanyl administration and the concomitant alleviation of respiratory depression.

CONCLUSIONS

This case suggests the feasibility of virtual reality analgesic therapy for pain management of fasciotomy wound complications in acute compartment syndromes. Virtual reality represents a treatment option that would reduce analgesic consumption and eliminate opioid-induced respiratory depression to treat fasciotomy wound infection.