Time to update the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma pancreas injury grading lexicon?

American Association for the Surgery of Trauma pancreatic organ injury scale: 2024 revision

BACKGROUND

The American Association for the Surgery of Trauma Organ Injury Scale (OIS) Committee published the original pancreatic OIS in 1990 with the authors acknowledging at the time that the classification would need to undergo "continued refinement as clinical experience dictates." The current OIS overemphasizes injury location over ductal integrity; modifications are needed to improve concordance between OIS, therapy, and outcomes and promote accuracy in quality assessment and research.

METHODS

A subcommittee of the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma and invited experts in radiology and interventional gastroenterology were chosen. Contemporary literature was reviewed, and a standardized iterative and collegial process was used to arrive at consensus.

RESULTS

The pancreatic OIS is anatomically based on operative, radiographic, or pathologic findings. Major changes to the grading system include moving lacerations of the pancreatic head without ductal injury from Grade IV to Grade II. Injuries to the duct in the neck, body, or tail remain Grade III but are further subclassified to distinguish between deep parenchymal injuries without ductal interrogation, partial ductal injuries, and complete ductal transection. Grade IV injuries follow the same nomenclature but for injuries to the right of the portal vein or superior mesenteric vein. Grade V injuries are destructive injuries of the pancreatic head with nonviable parenchyma. These injuries are further subgraded based on ductal injuries.

CONCLUSION

The pancreatic OIS schema is revised based on contemporary experience informed by the current understanding of outcomes and treatment, including operative management and outcomes. Increasing grades now more closely reflect increasing severity.

Open or Not Open the Retroperitoneum: A Pandora's Box for Blunt High-Grade Pancreatic Trauma?

INTRODUCTION

The optimal management strategy for pancreatic trauma remains unclear. We aimed to determine whether the initial nonoperative management (NOM) strategy based on percutaneous drainage combined with endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography guided stent placement would improve outcomes for blunt high-grade pancreatic trauma.

METHODS

Patients with blunt abdominal trauma who were hemodynamically stable without signs of diffuse peritonitis were consecutively enrolled at a high-volume center. The primary outcome was the occurrence of severe complications (Clavien‒Dindo classification ≥ Ⅲb) for patients who underwent initial laparotomy (LAP) versus NOM. Modified Poisson regression was used to model the primary outcome. Propensity score matching and weighting models were included into a regression-based sensitivity analysis.

RESULTS

Of 119 patients with grade III/IV pancreatic trauma, 29 patients underwent initial NOM, and 90 underwent initial LAP. The incidence of severe complications in the LAP group was higher than that in the NOM group (65/90 [72.2%] versus 9/29 [31.0%], P < 0.001). In the multivariable modified Poisson regression model, the relative risk for severe complications was decreased in the NOM group (relative risk, 0.52; 95% confidence interval, 0.30-0.90; P = 0.020). The results of the sensitivity analysis were consistent with those of the multivariable analysis. The mean number of reinterventions per patient was 1.8 in the NOM group and 2.6 in the LAP group (P = 0.067).

CONCLUSIONS

For blunt high-grade pancreatic trauma patients with stable hemodynamics and no diffuse peritonitis, the NOM strategy was associated with a lower risk of severe complications (Clavien‒Dindo classification ≥ Ⅲb) and did not require more invasive reintervention procedures. In high-volume centers with sufficient expertise, percutaneous drainage combined with endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography guided stent placement may serve as an initial reasonable option for selected patients.