Open total talus dislocation: clinical and functional outcomes: a case series

Retrospective analysis of treatment strategies and clinical outcome of isolated talar dislocations

Talar dislocations are rare injuries of the foot and ankle and require quick and decisive diagnostic and therapeutic decisions. Evidence concerning the treatment and outcome of these injuries is sparse. The aim of this study was to analyze all talar dislocations of the last ten years treated in a large German level I trauma center in an effort to add to the experience on these injuries.

METHODS

All patients with a talar dislocation injury were retrospectively included. Medical reports, x-ray and computertomography scans were analyzed for the sex, age, trauma mechanism, and injury classifications as well as for the clinical outcome as measured by the Foot Function Index (FFI).

RESULTS

A total of 18 patients were included in this study: Luxatio pedis cum talo (n = 1), Luxatio tali totalis (n = 3), Luxatio pedis sub talo (n = 14). Analysis of the therapeutic algorithms revealed that only one patient was treated conservatively, the other 17 patients underwent operation. In most cases, stabilization was achieved using an external fixator and if necessary, the subtalar and talonavicular joints were temporarily stabilized using K-wires. The mean follow-up time was 4.25 years (2.05 SD) and the mean FFI-sum score 45.00 (42.26 SD). Two patients required subtalar fusion two years after the injury.

CONCLUSION

Isolated talar dislocations can have a good outcome and be effectively treated in the emergency setting by basic techniqes if neurovasular structures are not injured. Often, these injuries are associated with fractures of adjacent bones which then need complex reconstruction.

Complete Extrusion of Talar Body Associated With Ipsilateral Floating Knee

Talar injuries represent serious medico-surgical conditions because of the involvement of the talus in multiple articulations, such as the subtalar, the transverse talar, and the ankle joint complex. Its complete detachment from the surrounding ligaments and bone is known as talar extrusion, a very rare injury with a complicated treatment course.

We report a case of a 43-year-old female patient presenting with a non-retrieved complete left talar body extrusion associated with a floating knee, manifested by left tibial shaft fracture and left supracondylar femoral fracture. The patient was treated with open reduction and internal fixation for the floating knee and a manually shaped talar cement spacer with staged tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis for the ankle. The patient was monitored over a six-year period.

This case is reported for the extreme rarity of lost open talar body extrusion, and its problematic treatment in the absence of clear guidelines, especially with the presence of multiple concomitant ipsilateral fractures of the limb, such as floating knee, as in this case.

A Case Report of an Open Pan-Talar Dislocation

Total talar extrusion is a rare injury that most commonly occurs secondary to high-energy trauma. There are few reported cases of open dislocations in literature and still, there is no consensus regarding the appropriate treatment of the extruded talus. In this case report, we present a 12-month follow-up of a patient with an open talar dislocation with extrusion treated with immediate surgical debridement, reduction and temporary fixation with one Steinmann pin. No infection was reported, although the patient developed avascular necrosis.

Primary Triple Arthrodesis Equivalent for Complete Extruded Missing Talus with Associated Midfoot Instability: A Case Report

CASE

Complete extrusion of the talus is rare and associated with high rates of complications including infection, osteonecrosis, persistent pain and stiffness, and post-traumatic arthritis. Less well described is associated midfoot instability. We report a case of a complete extruded missing talus that resulted in significant midfoot instability treated with a modified triple arthrodesis of the tibiocalcaneal, tibionavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints.

CONCLUSIONS

This approach resulted in a radiographic fusion at 3 months without complication, acceptable subjective and Patient-Reported Outcome Measurement System (PROMIS) scores at the 18-month follow-up, and presents a viable treatment strategy in the case of a complete extruded missing talus.

Fractures of the Talus: Current Concepts

Talus fractures continue to represent a challenging and commonly encountered group of injuries. Its near-complete articular cartilage surface, and its role in force transmission between the leg and foot, makes successful treatment of such injuries a mandatory prerequisite to regained function. Familiarity with the complex bony, vascular, and neurologic anatomy is crucial for understanding diagnostic findings, treatment indications, and surgical techniques to maximize the likelihood of anatomic bony union. This review details the structure and function of the talus, a proper diagnostic workup, the treatment algorithm, and post-treatment course in the management of talus fractures.

Complications and Functional Outcomes After Pantalar Dislocation

BACKGROUND

Pantalar dislocations without associated talar fracture are rare and have high risks of complications, including infection, osteonecrosis, and posttraumatic osteoarthrosis. Limited information on later function exists. This study evaluated complications and outcomes following pantalar dislocation without talar fracture.

METHODS

Nineteen patients were identified with open (n = 14) or closed (n = 5) pantalar dislocations without talar fracture. Ten male and 9 female patients with a mean age of 39.6 years (range, 19 to 68 years) were included. Open injuries underwent surgical debridement. Sixteen patients had open reduction, and 2 had closed reduction. Fixation was achieved with Kirschner wires (n = 4), external fixation (n = 9), or both (n = 3). Two patients did not have fixation. Another patient had primary transtibial amputation due to nonreconstructible foot trauma. Charts and radiographs were reviewed to identify infection, osteonecrosis, and posttraumatic arthrosis. Data on pain, medications, range of motion, and secondary procedures were collected. After a minimum of 1 year, Foot Function Index (FFI) and Musculoskeletal Function Assessment (MFA) surveys were administered.

RESULTS

The mean clinical follow-up was 45.1 months. Two patients had superficial wound-healing problems with prolonged drainage, which healed with dressing changes and oral antibiotics, and 1 patient developed cellulitis 4 months after injury, which resolved with intravenous antibiotics. No deep wound infections occurred. Fourteen (88%) of the 16 patients with a minimum of 11 months of radiographic follow-up developed osteonecrosis, 2 with collapse of the talar dome, and 7 (44%) developed arthrosis of ≥1 peritalar articulation. Outcome surveys were obtained for 11 (58%) of the 19 patients, at a mean of 5.2 years after injury. The mean MFA score was 30.3, and the mean FFI score was 25.3. Six of 10 survey respondents had returned to employment, but 88% (14 of 16) of the patients with radiographic and clinical follow-up reported at least mild pain and 75% (12 of 16) were taking analgesics.

CONCLUSIONS

Urgent surgical debridement of open injuries and reimplantation of the talus after pantalar dislocation was not associated with deep infection. Osteonecrosis occurred in the majority of patients, but collapse was uncommon. Persistent pain and functional limitations are frequent after pantalar dislocation, as reflected in extremity-specific and generalized functional outcome scores.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Extruded talus treated with reimplantation and primary tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis

Extruded talus is a rare serious result from a high-energy injury to a supinated and plantar flexed foot. Treatment remains controversial with a lack of congruent evidence for talar reimplantation. A 34-year-old woman was involved in a road traffic accident at 40 mph. Imaging revealed a left talus extruded anterolaterally with a talar neck fracture. Additional injuries included right acetabular fracture, transverse process fractures and rib fractures, which were treated conservatively. The talus was reimplanted and the talar neck fixed with a cortical screw. A hindfoot nail was used to fuse the calcaneus, talus and tibia. Follow-up at two years showed solid tibiotalocalcaneal fusion, with no evidence of avascular development, and the patient was fully weight bearing without pain. We believe this is the first published case of successful primary tibiotalocalcaneal fusion for extruded talus injuries.

A systematic review of total dislocation of the talus

This review summarizes the treatment and resulting outcomes for total talar dislocation. The PubMed database was searched for articles about humans with total talar dislocation published in the English language in the last twenty years. The following data were entered into a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet: type of dislocation, nature of associated fractures (if any), type of reduction/fixation utilized, immobilization, weight-bearing status, outcome, complications and average follow-up time. Thirty-nine articles reporting a total of 86 cases of total talar dislocation are included in this review. Seventy-three of these were open injuries and 13 closed. Forty-three cases had an associated foot or ankle fracture, 32 of those cases specifically having a fracture of the talus. The talus was preserved in the initial management of 74 cases, whereas the remaining 12 cases were managed by primary talectomy. The mean duration of follow-up was 32 months. Twenty-two cases required a secondary arthrodesis or another additional procedure. A good outcome was achieved in 35% of cases, a fair outcome in 37% and a poor outcome in 27%. The complication of avascular necrosis (AVN) occurred in 22 cases and 14 subjects developed clinically significant osteoarthritis. Generally, the outcome of current treatments associated with total talar dislocation is not ideal, only 1/3 of cases achieving good outcomes. So far, preservation of the talus is the best treatment option. AVN is still a relatively common complication even in the absence of fracture or postoperative infection.

Early reimplantation for open total talar extrusion

PURPOSE

To review outcome of early reimplantation for open total talar extrusion in 7 patients.

METHODS

Medical records of 5 men and 2 women aged 19 to 53 years who underwent reimplantation for open total talar extrusion within 6 hours after road traffic accident (n= 6) or industrial injury (n=1) were reviewed. The talus was first irrigated with 9 to 10 litres of saline solution, followed by 10% povidone iodine. It was then reduced after thorough debridement and fixed with tension band wiring or external fixation. Ankle mobilisation exercises were started at week 6 and full weight bearing at week 14. Outcome was assessed using the American Foot And Ankle Society score.

RESULTS

After a mean follow-up of 31.9 (range, 24-46) months, the mean American Foot and Ankle Society score was 81, and the mean dorsiflexion-plantar flexion arc was 36.9º (range, 25º-45º). All patients were able to walk with a balanced, unaided gait with mild-to-moderate pain (n=3) or pain-free (n=4). No patient developed deep infection or instability. Three patients developed avascular necrosis of the talus; restriction of motion was moderate at the ankle joint and severe at the subtalar joint. None of these 3 patients opted for revision surgery, as the pain was tolerable and did not limit their daily activities, but their condition was expected to deteriorate with time.

CONCLUSION

Early reimplantation is recommended for open total talar extrusion, as it restores (to some extent) hind foot mechanics, heel height, and bone stock for activities of daily living and future reconstructive options.

An uncommon treatment of totally extruded and lost talus: a case report

Introduction

Total extrusion and loss of the talus is a rare injury with a wide choice of appropriate treatment, but rarely resulting in a fully functional recovery. We report on an uncommon case, both for the severity of the injury and for the uncommon treatment due to the patient’s rejection of secondary surgery.

Case presentation

We treated a 16-year-old Caucasian man with the most extreme variant of a totally extruded and lost talus, accompanied with complex injury of the soft tissues of the ankle and foot. The treatment included urgent microvascular foot reimplantation, microvascular muscle free flap transfer, and temporary fixation. This kind of injury should typically be treated by tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis. However, this was not performed, as after the successful early stages of the treatment he strongly objected to another surgery due to his fully functional status and the successful therapeutic results of our early treatment.

Conclusions

The injury described in this case study would ordinarily be treated by amputation, but due to the well-executed treatment in the early stages after the injury, the outcome was satisfying. Surprisingly and against our expectations, the late results of the treatment were successful even without arthrodesis. He is now 37 years old and has a functional foot 21 years after the injury.

Nonoperative treatment of closed total talus dislocation without fracture: A case report and literature review

Complete dislocation of the talus not accompanied by a fracture is a very rare injury. Most cases reported are open talus dislocations; closed dislocations are rarely seen. The functional prognosis is poor due to osteonecrosis of the talus which develops in the majority of cases. We present a case of lateral dislocation of the left talus in a 29-year-old road accident victim, but no fracture could be detected in the talus and any of malleolus. Reduction of dislocation had been performed in emergency by external manipulation. At 1-year follow-up, the right ankle was pain free and stable. Motion was satisfactory: 15° dorsal flexion, 30° plantar flexion; the talus didn't show subluxation and avascular necrosis could not be detected.

Delayed debridement of an open total talar dislocation reimplanted in the emergency room

Open total talar dislocation is a rare but well known injury. Its management is controversial and fraught with complications such as infection, avascular necrosis, and post-traumatic osteoarthritis. We report the case of a woman sustaining a pure open talar dislocation reduced in the emergency room. Debridement was done three days after the injury in the operating room. There was no infection. One year after surgery she complained of occasional pain. Ambulation was normal. She wore regular shoes. The overall alignment of the ankle, hindfoot, and midfoot was normal. Movements of the tibiotalar and subtalar joints were not impaired. She has resumed her regular activities. Radiographs showed no signs of avascular necrosis. All components of the treatment strategy of open total dislocation should be carried out in emergency. This results in environment close to the original biological state. Good results can be achieved if infection is avoided.

Treatment of an open medial tibiotalar dislocation with no associated fracture

Tibiotalar dislocations without associated fractures are very uncommon in adults, and only a few studies have been published regarding this injury. More than 50% of these dislocations will be posteromedial, with a high incidence of open injuries, and 25% are pure posterior dislocations. In the present report, we discuss our experience and management of a medial tibiotalar dislocation with no associated fracture. In the present case, the patient was brought to the operating room on presentation to our facility and underwent irrigation and debridement with primary closure of his wound. He was immobilized postoperatively. The patient tolerated the operation well and did not sustain any postoperative complications. He was able to regain function of the injured extremity until he was lost to follow-up. Regarding treatment, the surgery should be speedy, gentle to the soft tissue, and with as little implanted material as possible. Although we do not advocate that our management and treatment of this injury become the standard, the present case provides a good example of some of the challenges often encountered when treating these injuries.

Treatment and outcome of open dislocation of the ankle with complete talar extrusion: a case report

BACKGROUND

Open total talar extrusion is a severe, disabling ankle injuries. The most appropriate treatment (reimplantation versus talar body removal and tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis) is still a controversial challenge; outcomes and fearful potential complications are not predictable.

OBJECTIVE

To report the case of an open ankle dislocation with talar extrusion, focusing on treatment modality and outcomes.

METHOD

Immediate reduction, surgical debridement and external fixation were performed under antibiotic coverage. Wound closure was achieved with accurate debridement, postoperative strict clinical surveillance and meticulous handling of medications. The patient maintained external fixator for three weeks, then kept non-weight bearing with a cast for an additional four weeks.

RESULTS

The patient's wound healed with no complications. Full weight-bearing was gained at 12 weeks postoperation. At 18 months postoperatively, the patient did not develop any infection or a vascular necrosis, which are the major complications associated to talar extrusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Good treatment procedure for a such severe open trauma, based on accurate debridement, wound care and stable temporary immobilization with external fixation allow reduction of infection risk and made preservation of extruded talus a successful option to preserve function and normal hindfoot anatomy at first instance. Talectomy should be considered as a salvage procedure.