Nucleolar dominance and maternal control of 45S rDNA expression

Uniparental expression of ribosomal RNA in ×Festulolium grasses: a link between the genome and nucleolar dominance

Genome or genomic dominance (GD) is a phenomenon observed in hybrids when one parental genome becomes dominant over the other. It is manifested by the replacement of chromatin of the submissive genome by that of the dominant genome and by biased gene expression. Nucleolar dominance (ND) - the functional expression of only one parental set of ribosomal genes in hybrids - is another example of an intragenomic competitive process which, however, concerns ribosomal DNA only. Although GD and ND are relatively well understood, the nature and extent of their potential interdependence is mostly unknown. Here, we ask whether hybrids showing GD also exhibit ND and, if so, whether the dominant genome is the same. To test this, we used hybrids between Festuca and Lolium grasses (Festulolium), and between two Festuca species in which GD has been observed (with Lolium as the dominant genome in Festulolium and F. pratensis in interspecific Festuca hybrids). Using amplicon sequencing of ITS1 and ITS2 of the 45S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) cluster and molecular cytogenetics, we studied the organization and expression of rDNA in leaf tissue in five hybrid combinations, four generations and 31 genotypes [F. pratensis × L. multiflorum (F1, F2, F3, BC1), L. multiflorum × F. pratensis (F1), L. multiflorum × F. glaucescens (F2), L. perenne × F. pratensis (F1), F. glaucescens × F. pratensis (F1)]. We have found that instant ND occurs in Festulolium, where expression of Lolium-type rDNA reached nearly 100% in all F1 hybrids and was maintained through subsequent generations. Therefore, ND and GD in Festulolium are manifested by the same dominant genome (Lolium). We also confirmed the concordance between GD and ND in an interspecific cross between two Festuca species.

Structure and Methylation of 35S rDNA in Allopolyploids Anemone multifida (2n = 4x = 32, BBDD) and Anemone baldensis (2n = 6x = 48, AABBDD) and Their Parental Species Show Evidence of Nucleolar Dominance

Transcriptional silencing of 35S rDNA loci inherited from one parental species is occurring relatively frequently in allopolyploids. However, molecular mechanisms by which it is selected for transcriptional silencing remain unclear. We applied NGS, silver staining and bisulfite sequencing to study the structure, expression and methylation landscape of 35S rDNA in two allopolyploids of common origin, allotetraploid Anemone multifida (2n = 4x = 32, genome composition BBDD) and allohexaploid A. baldensis (2n = 6x = 48, AABBDD), and their genome donors, A. sylvestris (2n = 16, AA), A. cylindrica (2n = 16, BB) and A. parviflora (2n = 16, DD). The size of the recovered 35S rDNA units varied from 10,489 bp in A. cylindrica to 12,084 bp in A. sylvestris. Anemone showed an organization typical of most ribosomal 35S rDNA composed of NTS, ETS, rRNA genes, TTS and TIS with structural features of plant IGS sequences and all functional elements needed for rRNA gene activity. The NTS was more variable than the ETS and consisted of SRs which are highly variable among Anemone. Five to six CpG-rich islands were found within the ETS. CpG island located adjacent to the transcription initiation site (TIS) was highly variable regarding the sequence size and methylation level and exhibited in most of the species lower levels of methylation than CpG islands located adjacent to the 18S rRNA gene. Our results uncover hypomethylation of A. sylvestris- and A. parviflora-derived 35S rDNA units in allopolyploids A. multifida and A. baldensis. Hypomethylation of A. parviflora-derived 35S rDNA was more prominent in A. baldensis than in A. multifida. We showed that A. baldensis underwent coupled A. sylvestris-derived 35S rDNA array expansion and A. parviflora-derived 35S rDNA copy number decrease that was accompanied by lower methylation level of A. sylvestris-derived 35S rDNA units in comparison to A. parviflora-derived 35S rDNA units. These observations suggest that in A. baldensis nucleolar dominance is directed toward A. sylvestris-derived chromosomes. This work broadens our current knowledge of the 35S rDNA organization in Anemone and provides evidence of the progenitor-specific 35S rDNA methylation in nucleolar dominance.

Chromosomal inheritance of parental rDNAs distribution pattern detected by FISH in diploid F1 hybrid progeny of Cobitis (Teleostei, Cobitidae) species has non-Mendelian character

This study was conducted to describe the major and the minor rDNA chromosome distribution in the spined loach Cobitis taenia (2n = 48) and the Danubian loach Cobitis elongatoides (2n = 50), and their laboratory-produced diploid reciprocal F₁ hybrid progeny. It was tested by fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) whether the number of 28s and 5s rDNA sites in the karyotypes of diploid hybrids corresponds to the expectations resulting from Mendelian ratio and if nucleolar organiser regions (NOR)were inherited from both parents or nucleolar dominance can be observed in the induced F₁ hybrid progeny. Ten (females) or twelve (males) 28s rDNA loci were located in nine uniarm chromosomes of C. taenia. Two of such loci terminally bounded on one acrocentric chromosome were unique and indicated as specific for this species. Large 5s rDNA clusters were located on two acrocentric chromosomes. In C. elongatoides of both sexes, six NOR sites in terminal regions on six meta-submetacentric chromosomes and two 5s rDNA sites on large submetacentrics were detected. The F₁ hybrid progeny (2n = 49) was characterised by the intermediate karyotype with the sites of ribosome synthesis on chromosomes inherited from both parents without showing nucleolar dominance. 5s rDNA sites were detected on large submetacentric and two acrocentric chromosomes. The observed number of both 28s and 5s rDNAs signals in F₁ diploid Cobitis hybrids was disproportionally inherited from the two parental species, showing inconsistency with the Mendelian ratios. The presented rDNA patterns indicate some marker chromosomes that allow the species of the parental male and female to be recognised in hybrid progeny. The 5s rDNA was found to be a particularly effective diagnostic marker of C. elongatoides to partially discern genomic composition of diploid Cobitis hybrids and presumably allopolyploids resulting from their backcrossing with one of the parental species. Thus, the current study provides insight into the extent of rDNA heredity in Cobitis chromosomes and their cytotaxonomic character.

Ribosome Biogenesis in Plants: From Functional 45S Ribosomal DNA Organization to Ribosome Assembly Factors

The transcription of 18S, 5.8S, and 18S rRNA genes (45S rDNA), cotranscriptional processing of pre-rRNA, and assembly of mature rRNA with ribosomal proteins are the linchpins of ribosome biogenesis. In yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and animal cells, hundreds of pre-rRNA processing factors have been identified and their involvement in ribosome assembly determined. These studies, together with structural analyses, have yielded comprehensive models of the pre-40S and pre-60S ribosome subunits as well as the largest cotranscriptionally assembled preribosome particle: the 90S/small subunit processome. Here, we present the current knowledge of the functional organization of 45S rDNA, pre-rRNA transcription, rRNA processing activities, and ribosome assembly factors in plants, focusing on data from Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). Based on yeast and mammalian cell studies, we describe the ribonucleoprotein complexes and RNA-associated activities and discuss how they might specifically affect the production of 40S and 60S subunits. Finally, we review recent findings concerning pre-rRNA processing pathways and a novel mechanism involved in a ribosome stress response in plants.

Integrative rDNAomics-Importance of the Oldest Repetitive Fraction of the Eukaryote Genome

Nuclear ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes represent the oldest repetitive fraction universal to all eukaryotic genomes. Their deeply anchored universality and omnipresence during eukaryotic evolution reflects in multiple roles and functions reaching far beyond ribosomal synthesis. Merely the copy number of non-transcribed rRNA genes is involved in mechanisms governing e.g., maintenance of genome integrity and control of cellular aging. Their copy number can vary in response to environmental cues, in cellular stress sensing, in development of cancer and other diseases. While reaching hundreds of copies in humans, there are records of up to 20,000 copies in fish and frogs and even 400,000 copies in ciliates forming thus a literal subgenome or an rDNAome within the genome. From the compositional and evolutionary dynamics viewpoint, the precursor 45S rDNA represents universally GC-enriched, highly recombining and homogenized regions. Hence, it is not accidental that both rDNA sequence and the corresponding rRNA secondary structure belong to established phylogenetic markers broadly used to infer phylogeny on multiple taxonomical levels including species delimitation. However, these multiple roles of rDNAs have been treated and discussed as being separate and independent from each other. Here, I aim to address nuclear rDNAs in an integrative approach to better assess the complexity of rDNA importance in the evolutionary context.

Nucleolar Dominance in a Tetraploidy Hybrid Lineage Derived From Carassius auratus red var. () × Megalobrama amblycephala ()

Nucleolar dominance is related to the expression of 45S rRNA genes inherited from one progenitor due to the silencing of the other progenitor’s rRNA genes. To investigate nucleolar dominance associated with tetraploidization, we analyzed the changes regarding the genetic traits and expression of 45S rRNA genes in tetraploidy hybrid lineage including F₁ allotetraploids (4n = 148) and F₂ autotetraploids (4n = 200) derived from the distant hybridization of Carassius auratus red var. (2n = 100) () ×Megalobrama amblycephala (2n = 48) (). Results showed that nucleolar dominance from the females was established in F₁ hybrids and it was inherited in F₂ hybrids, suggesting that tetraploidization can lead to rapid establishment of nucleolar dominance in the hybrid origin’s tetraploid lineage. These results extend the knowledge of nucleolar dominance in polyploidy hybrid animals, which are of significance for the evolution of hybrids in vertebrates.

Dynamic nucleolar activity in wheat × Aegilops hybrids: evidence of C-genome dominance

NOR loci of C-subgenome are dominant in wheat × Aegilops interspecific hybrids, which may have evolutionary implications for wheat group genome dynamics and evolution. After interspecific hybridisation, some genes are often expressed from only one of the progenitor species, shaping subsequent allopolyploid genome evolution processes. A well-known example is nucleolar dominance, i.e. the formation of cell nucleoli from chromosomes of only one parental species. We studied nucleolar organizing regions (NORs) in diploid Aegilops markgrafii (syn: Ae. caudata; CC), Ae. umbellulata (UU), allotetraploids Aegilops cylindrica (C^cC^cD^cD^c) and Ae. triuncialis (C^tC^tU^tU^t), synthetic interspecific F₁ hybrids between these two allotetraploids and bread wheat (Triticum aestivum, AABBDD) and in F₃ generation hybrids with genome composition AABBDDC^tC^tU^tU^t using silver staining and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). In Ae. markgrafii (CC), NORs of both 1C and 5C or only 5C chromosome pairs were active in different individual cells, while only NORs on 1U chromosomes were active in Ae. umbellulata (UU). Although all 35S rDNA loci of the C^t subgenome (located on 1C^t and 5C^t) were active in Ae. triuncialis, only one pair (occupying either 1C^c or 5C^c) was active in Ae. cylindrica, depending on the genotype studied. These C-genome expression patterns were transmitted to the F₁ and F₃ generations. Wheat chromosome NOR activity was variable in Ae. triuncialis × T. aestivum F₁ seeds, but silenced by the F₃ generation. No effect of maternal or paternal cross direction was observed. These results indicate that C-subgenome NOR loci are dominant in wheat × Aegilops interspecific hybrids, which may have evolutionary implications for wheat group genome dynamics and allopolyploid evolution.

An Epigenetic Perspective on the Midwife Toad Experiments of Paul Kammerer (1880-1926)

Paul Kammerer was the most outstanding neo-Lamarckian experimentalist of the early 20th century. He reported spectacular results in the midwife toad, including crosses of environmentally modified toads with normal toads, where acquired traits were inherited in Mendelian fashion. Accusations of fraud generated a great scandal, ending with Kammerer's suicide. Controversy reignited in the 1970s, when journalist Arthur Koestler argued against these accusations. Since then, others have argued that Kammerer's results, even if real, were not groundbreaking and could be explained by somatic plasticity, inadvertent selection, or conventional genetics. More recently, epigenetics has uncovered mechanisms by which inheritance can respond directly to environmental change, inviting a reanalysis of Kammerer's descriptions. Previous arguments for mere somatic plasticity have ignored the description of experiments showing heritable germ line modification. Alleged inadvertent selection associated with egg mortality can be discarded, since mortality decreased in a single generation, upon repeated exposures. The challenging implications did not escape the attention of Kammerer's noted contemporary, William Bateson, but he reacted with disbelief, thus encouraging fraud accusations. Nowadays, formerly puzzling phenomena can be explained by epigenetic mechanisms. Importantly, Kammerer described parent-of-origin effects, an effect of parental sex on dominance. Epigenetic mechanisms underlie these effects in genomic imprinting and experiments of transgenerational epigenetic inheritance. In the early 20th century, researchers had no reason to link them with the inheritance of acquired traits. Thus, the parent-of-origin effects in Kammerer's experiments specifically suggest authenticity. Ultimate proof should come from renewed experimentation. To encourage further research, we present a model of possible epigenetic mechanisms.

Nucleolar Dominance and Repression of 45S Ribosomal RNA Genes in Hybrids between Xenopus borealis and X. muelleri (2n = 36)

Nucleolar dominance is a dramatic disruption in the formation of nucleoli and the expression of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes, characteristic of some plant and animal hybrids. Here, we report that F1 hybrids produced from reciprocal crosses between 2 sister species of Xenopus clawed frogs, X. muelleri and X. borealis, undergo nucleolar dominance somewhat distinct from a pattern previously reported in hybrids between phylogenetically more distant Xenopus species. Patterns of nucleolar development, 45S rRNA expression, and gene copy inheritance were investigated using a combination of immunostaining, pyrosequencing, droplet digital PCR, flow cytometry, and epigenetic inhibition. In X. muelleri × X. borealis hybrids, typically only 1 nucleolus is formed, and 45S rRNA genes are predominantly expressed from 1 progenitor's alleles, X. muelleri, regardless of the cross-direction. These changes are accompanied by an extensive (∼80%) loss of rRNA gene copies in the hybrids relative to their parents, with the transcriptionally underdominant variant (X. borealis) being preferentially lost. Chemical treatment of hybrid larvae with a histone deacetylase inhibitor resulted in a partial derepression of the underdominant variant. Together, these observations shed light on the genetic and epigenetic basis of nucleolar dominance as an underappreciated manifestation of genetic conflicts within a hybrid genome.