The rapid evolution of flagellar ion selectivity in experimental populations of E. coli

Determining which cellular processes facilitate adaptation requires a tractable experimental model where an environmental cue can generate variants that rescue function. The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is an excellent candidate-an ancient and highly conserved molecular complex for bacterial propulsion toward favorable environments. Motor rotation is often powered by H⁺ or Na⁺ ion transit through the torque-generating stator subunit of the motor complex, and ion selectivity has adapted over evolutionary time scales. Here, we used CRISPR engineering to replace the native Escherichia coli H⁺-powered stator with Na⁺-powered stator genes and report the spontaneous reversion of our edit in a low-sodium environment. We followed the evolution of the stators during their reversion to H⁺-powered motility and used both whole-genome and RNA sequencing to identify genes involved in the cell's adaptation. Our transplant of an unfit protein and the cells' rapid response to this edit demonstrate the adaptability of the stator subunit and highlight the hierarchical modularity of the flagellar motor.

Structural basis of torque generation in the bi-directional bacterial flagellar motor

The flagellar stator unit is an oligomeric complex of two membrane proteins (MotA₅B₂) that powers bi-directional rotation of the bacterial flagellum. Harnessing the ion motive force across the cytoplasmic membrane, the stator unit operates as a miniature rotary motor itself to provide torque for rotation of the flagellum. Recent cryo-electron microscopic (cryo-EM) structures of the stator unit provided novel insights into its assembly, function, and subunit stoichiometry, revealing the ion flux pathway and the torque generation mechanism. Furthermore, in situ cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) studies revealed unprecedented details of the interactions between stator unit and rotor. In this review, we summarize recent advances in our understanding of the structure and function of the flagellar stator unit, torque generation, and directional switching of the motor.

Expansion of Necrosis Depending on Hybrid Motor-Driven Motility of Aeromonas hydrophila in a Murine Wound Infection Model

The gram-negative bacterium Aeromonas hydrophila is a cause of fulminant and lethal necrotizing soft tissue infections (NSTIs). Suppressing the rapid proliferation of the pathogen and expansion of the necrosis caused in the host is an important issue in clinical practice, but the pathogenic mechanism for the rapid aggravation has not been clarified. In this study, we characterized the function of two types of motor stators in A. hydrophila and explored the role of motility during wound infection. In vitro analysis showed that the motility was reliably maintained while being complemented by the stators. We created a non-motile strain that lacked genes encoding two types of motor stators and analyzed the role of motility in a murine wound infection model. Examination of the bacterial burden in the local infection site and systemic circulation revealed that motility was not essential for the proliferation of A. hydrophila in the host. However, the extent of necrosis at the lesions was lower, and survival times were prolonged in mice infected with the non-motile strain compared with mice infected with the parent strain. These results provide evidence that the rapid expansion of necrosis and the progression to death within a short time period is dependent on the motility of A. hydrophila.

Characterization of PomA periplasmic loop and sodium ion entering in stator complex of sodium-driven flagellar motor

The bacterial flagellar motor is a rotary nanomachine driven by ion flow. The flagellar stator complex, which is composed of two proteins, PomA and PomB, performs energy transduction in marine Vibrio. PomA is a four transmembrane (TM) protein and the cytoplasmic region between TM2 and TM3 (loop2–3) interacts with the rotor protein FliG to generate torque. The periplasmic regions between TM1 and TM2 (loop1–2) and TM3 and TM4 (loop3–4) are candidates to be at the entrance to the transmembrane ion channel of the stator. In this study, we purified the stator complex with cysteine replacements in the periplasmic loops and assessed the reactivity of the protein with biotin maleimide (BM). BM easily modified Cys residues in loop3–4 but hardly labelled Cys residues in loop1–2. We could not purify the plug deletion stator (ΔL stator) composed of PomBΔ41–120 and WT-PomA but could do the ΔL stator with PomA-D31C of loop1–2 or with PomB-D24N of TM. When the ion channel is closed, PomA and PomB interact strongly. When the ion channel opens, PomA interacts less tightly with PomB. The plug and loop1–2 region regulate this activation of the stator, which depends on the binding of sodium ion to the D24 residue of PomB.

Effect of sodium ions on conformations of the cytoplasmic loop of the PomA stator protein of Vibrio alginolyticus

The sodium driven flagellar stator of Vibrio alginolyticus is a hetero-hexamer membrane complex composed of PomA and PomB, and acts as a sodium ion channel. The conformational change in the cytoplasmic region of PomA for the flagellar torque generation, which interacts directly with a rotor protein, FliG, remains a mystery. In this study, we introduced cysteine mutations into cytoplasmic charged residues of PomA, which are highly conserved and interact with FliG, to detect the conformational change by the reactivity of biotin maleimide. In vivo labelling experiments of the PomA mutants revealed that the accessibility of biotin maleimide at position of E96 was reduced with sodium ions. Such a reduction was also seen in the D24N and the plug deletion mutants of PomB, and the phenomenon was independent in the presence of FliG. This sodium ions specific reduction was also detected in Escherichia coli that produced PomA and PomB from a plasmid, but not in the purified stator complex. These results demonstrated that sodium ions cause a conformational change around the E96 residue of loop2-3 in the biological membrane.

Essential ion binding residues for Na+ flow in stator complex of the Vibrio flagellar motor

The bacterial flagellar motor is a unique supramolecular complex which converts ion flow into rotational force. Many biological devices mainly use two types of ions, proton and sodium ion. This is probably because of the fact that life originated in seawater, which is rich in protons and sodium ions. The polar flagellar motor in Vibrio is coupled with sodium ion and the energy converting unit of the motor is composed of two membrane proteins, PomA and PomB. It has been shown that the ion binding residue essential for ion transduction is the conserved aspartic acid residue (PomB-D24) in the PomB transmembrane region. To reveal the mechanism of ion selectivity, we identified essential residues, PomA-T158 and PomA-T186, other than PomB-D24, in the Na⁺-driven flagellar motor. It has been shown that the side chain of threonine contacts Na⁺ in Na⁺-coupled transporters. We monitored the Na⁺-binding specific structural changes using ATR-FTIR spectroscopy. The signals were abolished in PomA-T158A and -T186A, as well as in PomB-D24N. Molecular dynamics simulations further confirmed the strong binding of Na⁺ to D24 and showed that T158A and T186A hindered the Na⁺ binding and transportation. The data indicate that two threonine residues (PomA-T158 and PomA-T186), together with PomB-D24, are important for Na⁺ conduction in the Vibrio flagellar motor. The results contribute to clarify the mechanism of ion recognition and conversion of ion flow into mechanical force.

Analysis of the GTPase motif of FlhF in the control of the number and location of polar flagella in Vibrio alginolyticus

Vibrio alginolyticus normally has a single polar flagellum whose number and placement are regulated positively by FlhF. FlhF is a GTPase and homolog of a signal recognition particle (SRP) protein called Ffh and SRP receptor FtsY. FlhF is located at the cell pole and directs formation of the flagellum. To study the mechanism of FlhF localization, we introduced random mutations into flhF by means of hydroxylamine and isolated mutants that could not generate the flagellum at the cell pole. The novel mutations were only mapped to the GTPase motif of FlhF. The mutant FlhF proteins showed reduced polar localization as compared to the wild type and still could associate with the membrane. These results support the assumption that the GTPase motif of FlhF plays a critical role in the polar localization of this protein during formation of the flagellum.

Mechanism of Stator Assembly and Incorporation into the Flagellar Motor

In many cases, conformational changes in proteins are related to their functions, and thereby inhibiting those changes causes functional defects. One way to perturb such conformational changes is to covalently link the regions where the changes are induced. Here, I introduce an example in which an intramolecular disulfide crosslink in the stator protein of PomB, introduced based on its crystal structure, reversibly inhibits the rotation of the flagellar motor, and I detail how we analyzed that phenotype. In this Chapter, first I describe how we monitor the motility inhibition and restoration by controlling disulfide bridge formation, and secondly how we detect intramolecular disulfide crosslinks, which are sometimes difficult to monitor by mobility shifts on SDS-PAGE gels.

Serine 26 in the PomB subunit of the flagellar motor is essential for hypermotility of Vibrio cholerae

Vibrio cholerae is motile by means of its single polar flagellum which is driven by the sodium-motive force. In the motor driving rotation of the flagellar filament, a stator complex consisting of subunits PomA and PomB converts the electrochemical sodium ion gradient into torque. Charged or polar residues within the membrane part of PomB could act as ligands for Na⁺, or stabilize a hydrogen bond network by interacting with water within the putative channel between PomA and PomB. By analyzing a large data set of individual tracks of swimming cells, we show that S26 located within the transmembrane helix of PomB is required to promote very fast swimming of V. cholerae. Loss of hypermotility was observed with the S26T variant of PomB at pH 7.0, but fast swimming was restored by decreasing the H⁺ concentration of the external medium. Our study identifies S26 as a second important residue besides D23 in the PomB channel. It is proposed that S26, together with D23 located in close proximity, is important to perturb the hydration shell of Na⁺ before its passage through a constriction within the stator channel.

Functional chimeras of flagellar stator proteins between E. coli MotB and Vibrio PomB at the periplasmic region in Vibrio or E. coli

The bacterial flagellar motor has a stator and a rotor. The stator is composed of two membrane proteins, MotA and MotB in Escherichia coli and PomA and PomB in Vibrio alginolyticus. The Vibrio motor has a unique structure, the T ring, which is composed of MotX and MotY. Based on the structural information of PomB and MotB, we constructed three chimeric proteins between PomB and MotB, named PotB₉₁ , PotB_129, and PotB₁₃₈ , with various chimeric junctions. When those chimeric proteins were produced with PomA in a ΔmotAB strain of E. coli or in ΔpomAB and ΔpomAB ΔmotX strains of Vibrio, all chimeras were functional in E. coli or Vibrio, either with or without the T ring, although the motilities were very weak in E. coli. Furthermore, we could isolate some suppressors in E. coli and identified the mutation sites on PomA or the chimeric B subunit. The weak function of chimeric PotBs in E. coli is derived mainly from the defect in the rotational switching of the flagellar motor. In addition, comparing the motilities of chimera strains in ΔpomAB, PotB₁₃₈ had the highest motility. The difference between the origin of the α1 and α2 helices, E. coli MotB or Vibro PomB, seems to be important for motility in E. coli and especially in Vibrio.

The function of the Na+-driven flagellum of Vibrio cholerae is determined by osmolality and pH

Vibrio cholerae is motile by its polar flagellum, which is driven by a Na(+)-conducting motor. The stators of the motor, composed of four PomA and two PomB subunits, provide access for Na(+) to the torque-generating unit of the motor. To characterize the Na(+) pathway formed by the PomAB complex, we studied the influence of chloride salts (chaotropic, Na(+), and K(+)) and pH on the motility of V. cholerae. Motility decreased at elevated pH but increased if a chaotropic chloride salt was added, which rules out a direct Na(+) and H(+) competition in the process of binding to the conserved PomB D23 residue. Cells expressing the PomB S26A/T or D42N variants lost motility at low Na(+) concentrations but regained motility in the presence of 170 mM chloride. Both PomA and PomB were modified by N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD), indicating the presence of protonated carboxyl groups in the hydrophobic regions of the two proteins. Na(+) did not protect PomA and PomB from this modification. Our study shows that both osmolality and pH have an influence on the function of the flagellum from V. cholerae. We propose that D23, S26, and D42 of PomB are part of an ion-conducting pathway formed by the PomAB stator complex.

Mutation in the a-subunit of F(1)F(O)-ATPase causes an increased motility phenotype through the sodium-driven flagella of Vibrio

Bacterial flagellar motors exploit the electrochemical potential gradient of a coupling ion as energy source and are composed of stator and rotor proteins. Vibrio alginolyticus has a Na(+)-driven motor and its stator is composed of PomA and PomB. Recently, we isolated increased motility strains (sp1-sp4) from the PomA-N194D/PomB-D24N mutant whose motility was quite weak. To detect the responsible mutation, we have used a next-generation sequencer and determined the entire genome sequences of the sp1 and sp2 strains. Candidate mutations were identified in the gene encoding the a-subunit of F1Fo-ATPase (uncB). To confirm this, we constructed a deletion strain, which gave the increased motility phenotype. The amount of membrane-bound ATPase was reduced in the sp2 and ΔuncB mutants. From these results, we conclude that a mutation in the uncB gene causes the increased motility phenotype in V. alginolyticus. They confer faster motility in low concentrations of sodium than in the parental strain and this phenotype is suppressed in the presence of KCN. Those results may suggest that the proton gradient generated by the respiratory chain is increased by the uncB mutation, consequently the sodium motive force is increased and causes the increased motility phenotype.

A quinazoline-2,4-diamino analog suppresses Vibrio cholerae flagellar motility by interacting with motor protein PomB and induces envelope stress

Vibrio cholerae strains of serogroups O1 and O139, the causative agents of the diarrheal illness cholera, express a single polar flagellum powered by sodium motive force and require motility to colonize and spread along the small intestine. In a previous study, we described a high-throughput assay for screening for small molecules that selectively inhibit bacterial motility and identified a family of quinazoline-2,4-diamino analogs (Q24DAs) that (i) paralyzed the sodium-driven polar flagellum of Vibrios and (ii) diminished cholera toxin secreted by El Tor biotype V. cholerae. In this study, we provide evidence that a Q24DA paralyzes the polar flagellum by interacting with the motor protein PomB. Inhibition of motility with the Q24DA enhanced the transcription of the cholera toxin genes in both biotypes. We also show that the Q24DA interacts with outer membrane protein OmpU and other porins to induce envelope stress and expression of the extracellular RNA polymerase sigma factor σ(E). We suggest that Q24DA-induced envelope stress could affect the correct folding, assembly, and secretion of pentameric cholera toxin in El Tor biotype V. cholerae independently of its effect on motility.

Na+ conductivity of the Na+-driven flagellar motor complex composed of unplugged wild-type or mutant PomB with PomA

PomA and PomB form the stator complex, which functions as a Na(+) channel, in the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus. The plug region of PomB is thought to regulate the Na(+) flow and to suppress massive ion influx through the stator channel. In this study, in order to measure the Na(+) conductivity of the unplugged stator, we over-produced a plug-deleted stator of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor in Escherichia coli. The over-production of the plug-deleted stator in E. coli cells caused more severe growth inhibition than in Vibrio cells and that growth inhibition depended on the Na(+) concentration in the growth medium. Measurement of intracellular Na(+) concentration by flame photometry and fluorescent analysis with a Na(+) indicator, Sodium Green, revealed that over-production of the plug-deleted stator increased the Na(+) concentration in cell. Some mutations in the channel region of PomB or in the cytoplasmic region of PomA suppressed both the growth inhibition and the increase in intracellular Na(+) concentration. These results suggest that the level of growth inhibition correlates with the intracellular Na(+) concentration, probably due to the Na(+) conductivity through the stator due to the mutations.

Intragenic suppressor of a plug deletion nonmotility mutation in PotB, a chimeric stator protein of sodium-driven flagella

The torque of bacterial flagellar motors is generated by interactions between the rotor and the stator and is coupled to the influx of H(+) or Na(+) through the stator. A chimeric protein, PotB, in which the N-terminal region of Vibrio alginolyticus PomB was fused to the C-terminal region of Escherichia coli MotB, can function with PomA as a Na(+)-driven stator in E. coli. Here, we constructed a deletion variant of PotB (with a deletion of residues 41 to 91 [Δ41-91], called PotBΔL), which lacks the periplasmic linker region including the segment that works as a "plug" to inhibit premature ion influx. This variant did not confer motile ability, but we isolated a Na(+)-driven, spontaneous suppressor mutant, which has a point mutation (R109P) in the MotB/PomB-specific α-helix that connects the transmembrane and peptidoglycan binding domains of PotBΔL in the region of MotB. Overproduction of the PomA/PotBΔL(R109P) stator inhibited the growth of E. coli cells, suggesting that this stator has high Na(+)-conducting activity. Mutational analyses of Arg109 and nearby residues suggest that the structural alteration in this α-helix optimizes PotBΔL conformation and restores the proper arrangement of transmembrane helices to form a functional channel pore. We speculate that this α-helix plays a key role in assembly-coupled stator activation.

Characterization of PomA mutants defective in the functional assembly of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor in Vibrio alginolyticus

The polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus rotates using Na(+) influx through the stator, which is composed of 2 subunits, PomA and PomB. About a dozen stators dynamically assemble around the rotor, depending on the Na(+) concentration in the surrounding environment. The motor torque is generated by the interaction between the cytoplasmic domain of PomA and the C-terminal region of FliG, a component of the rotor. We had shown previously that mutations of FliG affected the stator assembly around the rotor, which suggested that the PomA-FliG interaction is required for the assembly. In this study, we examined the effects of various mutations mainly in the cytoplasmic domain of PomA on that assembly. All mutant stators examined, which resulted in the loss of motor function, assembled at a lower level than did the wild-type PomA. A His tag pulldown assay showed that some mutations in PomA reduced the PomA-PomB interaction, but other mutations did not. Next, we examined the ion conductivity of the mutants using a mutant stator that lacks the plug domain, PomA/PomB(ΔL)(Δ41-120), which impairs cell growth by overproduction, presumably because a large amount of Na(+) is conducted into the cells. Some PomA mutations suppressed this growth inhibition, suggesting that such mutations reduce Na(+) conductivity, so that the stators could not assemble around the rotor. Only the mutation H136Y did not impair the stator formation and ion conductivity through the stator. We speculate that this particular mutation may affect the PomA-FliG interaction and prevent activation of the stator assembly around the rotor.

Mutations targeting the C-terminal domain of FliG can disrupt motor assembly in the Na(+)-driven flagella of Vibrio alginolyticus

The torque of the bacterial flagellar motor is generated by the rotor-stator interaction coupled with specific ion translocation through the stator channel. To produce a fully functional motor, multiple stator units must be properly incorporated around the rotor by an as yet unknown mechanism to engage the rotor-stator interactions. Here, we investigated stator assembly using a mutational approach of the Na(+)-driven polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus, whose stator is localized at the flagellated cell pole. We mutated a rotor protein, FliG, which is located at the C ring of the basal body and closely participates in torque generation, and found that point mutation L259Q, L270R or L271P completely abolishes both motility and polar localization of the stator without affecting flagellation. Likewise, mutations V274E and L279P severely affected motility and stator assembly. Those residues are localized at the core of the globular C-terminal domain of FliG when mapped onto the crystal structure of FliG from Thermotoga maritima, which suggests that those mutations induce quite large structural alterations at the interface responsible for the rotor-stator interaction. These results show that the C-terminal domain of FliG is critical for the proper assembly of PomA/PomB stator complexes around the rotor and probably functions as the target of the stator at the rotor side.

Sodium-driven motor of the polar flagellum in marine bacteria Vibrio

The Na(+) -driven bacterial flagellar motor is a molecular machine powered by an electrochemical potential gradient of sodium ions across the cytoplasmic membrane. The marine bacterium Vibrio alginolyticus has a single polar flagellum that enables it to swim in liquid. The flagellar motor contains a basal body and a stator complexes, which are composed of several proteins. PomA, PomB, MotX, and MotY are thought to be essential components of the stator that are required to generate the torque of the rotation. Several mutations have been investigated to understand the characteristics and function of the ion channel in the stator and the mechanism of its assembly around the rotor to complete the motor. In this review, we summarize recent results of the Na(+) -driven motor in the polar flagellum of Vibrio.

Characterization of the periplasmic region of PomB, a Na+-driven flagellar stator protein in Vibrio alginolyticus

The stator proteins PomA and PomB form a complex that couples Na(+) influx to torque generation in the polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus. This stator complex is anchored to an appropriate place around the rotor through a putative peptidoglycan-binding (PGB) domain in the periplasmic region of PomB (PomB(C)). To investigate the function of PomB(C), a series of N-terminally-truncated and in-frame mutants with deletions between the transmembrane (TM) segment and the PGB domain of PomB was constructed. A PomB(C) fragment consisting of residues 135 to 315 (PomB(C₅) formed a stable homodimer and significantly inhibited the motility of wild-type cells when overexpressed in the periplasm. A fragment with an in-frame deletion (PomB(ΔL)) of up to 80 residues retained function, and its overexpression with PomA impaired cell growth. This inhibitory effect was suppressed by a mutation at the functionally critical Asp (D24N) in the TM segment of PomB, suggesting that a high level of Na(+) influx through the mutant stator causes the growth impairment. The overproduction of functional PomA/PomB(ΔL) stators also reduced the motile fractions of the cells. That effect could be slightly relieved by a mutation (L168P) in the putative N-terminal α-helix that connects to the PGB domain without affecting the growth inhibition, suggesting that a conformational change of the region including the PGB domain affects stator assembly. Our results reveal common features of the periplasmic region of PomB/MotB and demonstrate that a flexible linker that contains a "plug" segment is important for the control of Na(+) influx through the stator complex as well as for stator assembly.