Strong anisotropy in two-dimensional surfaces with generic scale invariance: Gaussian and related models

Non-KPZ fluctuations in the derivative of the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation or noisy Burgers equation

The Kardar-Parisi-Zhang (KPZ) equation is a paradigmatic model of nonequilibrium low-dimensional systems with spatiotemporal scale invariance, recently highlighting universal behavior in fluctuation statistics. Its space derivative, namely the noisy Burgers equation, has played a very important role in its study, predating the formulation of the KPZ equation proper, and being frequently held as an equivalent system. We show that, while differences in the scaling exponents for the two equations are indeed due to a mere space derivative, the field statistics behave in a remarkably different way: while the KPZ equation follows the Tracy-Widom distribution, its derivative displays Gaussian behavior, hence being in a different universality class. We reach this conclusion via direct numerical simulations of the equations, supported by a dynamic renormalization group study of field statistics.

Gaussian statistics as an emergent symmetry of the stochastic scalar Burgers equation

Symmetries play a conspicuous role in the large-scale behavior of critical systems. In equilibrium they allow us to classify asymptotics into different universality classes, and out of equilibrium, they sometimes emerge as collective properties which are not explicit in the "bare" interactions. Here we elucidate the emergence of an up-down symmetry in the asymptotic behavior of the stochastic scalar Burgers equation in one and two dimensions, manifested by the occurrence of Gaussian fluctuations even within the time regime controlled by nonlinearities. This robustness of Gaussian behavior contradicts naive expectations due to the detailed relation-including the lack of up-down symmetry-between the Burgers equation and the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation, which paradigmatically displays non-Gaussian fluctuations described by Tracy-Widom distributions. We reach our conclusions via a dynamic renormalization group study of the field statistics, confirmed by direct evaluation of the field probability distribution function from numerical simulations of the dynamical equation.

Strong anisotropy in two-dimensional surfaces with generic scale invariance: nonlinear effects

We expand a previous study [Phys. Rev. E 86, 051611 (2012)] on the conditions for occurrence of strong anisotropy in the scaling properties of two-dimensional surfaces displaying generic scale invariance. In that study, a natural scaling ansatz was proposed for strongly anisotropic systems, which arises naturally when analyzing data from, e.g., thin-film production experiments. The ansatz was tested in Gaussian (linear) models of surface dynamics and in nonlinear models, like the Hwa-Kardar (HK) equation [Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 1813 (1989)], which are susceptible of accurate approximations through the former. In contrast, here we analyze nonlinear equations for which such approximations fail. Working within generically scale-invariant situations, and as representative case studies, we formulate and study a generalization of the HK equation for conserved dynamics and reconsider well-known systems, such as the conserved and the nonconserved anisotropic Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equations. Through the combined use of dynamic renormalization group analysis and direct numerical simulations, we conclude that the occurrence of strong anisotropy in two-dimensional surfaces requires dynamics to be conserved. We find that, moreover, strong anisotropy is not generic in parameter space but requires, rather, specific forms of the terms appearing in the equation of motion, whose justification needs detailed information on the dynamical process that is being modeled in each particular case.