Pickering emulsions stabilized by oppositely charged colloids: Stability and pattern formation

Electrostatic Heteroaggregation: Fundamentals and Applications in Interfacial Engineering

The aggregation of oppositely charged soft materials (particles, surfactants, polyelectrolytes, etc.) that differ in one or more physical or chemical attributes, broadly referred to as electrostatic heteroaggregation, has been an active area of research for several decades now. While electrostatic heteroaggregation (EHA) is relevant to diverse fields such as environmental engineering, food technology, and pharmaceutical formulations, more recently there has been a resurgence to explore various aspects of this phenomenon in the context of interface stabilization and the development of functional materials. In this Feature Article, we provide an overview of the recent contributions of our group to this exciting field with particular emphasis on fundamental studies of electrostatic heteroaggregation between oppositely charged systems in the bulk, at interfaces, and across the bulk/interface. The influence of the size and shape of particles and the surface charge of heteroaggregates on the formation of Pickering emulsions and their utilization in the development of porous ceramics is discussed.

Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by Binary Mixtures of Colloidal Particles: Synergies between Contrasting Properties

Pickering emulsions that are stabilized by colloidal particles have attracted substantial research attention because of their potential applications in various industries. Previously, single colloidal particles have usually been used to fabricate Pickering emulsions and to investigate the stabilization mechanism. However, surface modification of the colloidal stabilizer is normally required to adjust the particle wettability, which often involves chemical modification, the adsorption of a surfactant or polymer, and the addition of an electrolyte. Such a modification is expensive, time-consuming, and thus only partially effective. In this Perspective, we describe an alternative approach that uses binary mixtures of particles as stabilizers and could be an effective solution to the above-described problems with Pickering emulsions. We introduce various types of Pickering emulsions stabilized by binary mixtures of particles with different functional groups, opposite charges, or opposite wettabilities (i.e., they are hydrophilic or hydrophobic). Examples of stabilizing mechanisms are discussed, showing that compared with emulsions stabilized by single colloidal particles, emulsions stabilized by binary mixtures of particles are generated via simpler particle-pretreatment processes and have higher stability and customizable properties and thus can enable the exploration of the next generation of Pickering emulsions.

Investigation of the Contact Angle and Packing Density of Silica Nanoparticles at a Pickering Emulsion Interface Fixed by UV Polymerization

The contact angle of colloidal particles at an oil-water interface plays a crucial role in determining Pickering emulsion stability and emulsion type, but the contact angle cannot be directly determined using conventional methods. In this work, a Pickering emulsion was prepared with photocurable resin as the internal phase containing silica nanoparticle stabilizers. Particles adsorbed at the oil-water interface were then fixed through UV curing, allowing for the investigation of various parameters that influence the contact angle of colloidal particles at the interface. After curing, the contact angle can then be observed using scanning electron microscopy and subsequently measured. The contact angle of interfacial adsorbed silica nanoparticles gradually decreases as the size increases due to the line tension at the three-phase contact line, but, more importantly, we found that the surface chemistry of the silica nanoparticles plays the most important role in determining the contact angle. The fast fixation of solid nanoparticles at emulsion interfaces facilitates accurate measurements of the partition of particles between oil and water, providing a new method for studying the factors that affect Pickering emulsion stability.

Pickering Emulsions Simultaneously Stabilized by Starch Nanocrystals and Zein Nanoparticles: Fabrication, Characterization, and Application

Using two types of colloidal particles having natural origins to synergistically stabilize Pickering emulsions is essential for food, cosmetics, and pharmaceutics, especially when neither particle can stabilize the Pickering emulsions alone. The use of two natural stabilizers avoids the complicated surface treatments of particles and the introduction of poisonous or harmful chemicals. In this work, we report an all-natural Pickering emulsion stabilized synergistically by starch nanocrystals and zein protein nanoparticles. Our result shows that the electrostatic interaction between the two types of particles greatly affects their assembled structure at the oil/water interface, which is closely related to the emulsion stability. Specifically, particle bilayers could form with oppositely charged particles at the interface to endow the emulsion with improved stability. As a demonstration, the resultant Pickering emulsions effectively carry β-carotene and have high stability against high temperatures and ultraviolet radiation. This type of all-natural Pickering emulsion is a promising tool to protect and deliver liposoluble bioactive components.

Controlling the microstructure of emulsions by exploiting particle-polyelectrolyte association

HYPOTHESIS

Albeit solid stabilized emulsions are studied for several decades, the surface of the emulsion drops most often are coated with densely packed and jammed monolayer of particles. However, a control over the area that the particles occupy on the drop surface is necessary, especially in applications involving controlled release of active compounds from emulsions. We hypothesize that it is possible to achieve precise control over the concentration of particles on the surface of emulsions by tailoring the adsorption of different species in a multi-component dispersion used for emulsification.

EXPERIMENTS

To this end, we carry out emulsification of oil and aqueous dispersions consisting of a combination of oppositely charged colloidal particles and polyelectrolyte. The droplet size distribution and storage stability of the oil-in-water emulsions, the microstructure, the percentage area of the drop surface occupied by the particles and the adsorption behavior of particle-polyelectrolyte binary dispersions are investigated.

FINDINGS

Our results demonstrate that the association between oppositely charged colloidal particles and polyelectrolyte can be exploited to obtain surface active species that aid in the formation of emulsions. Moreover, we found that the concentration of particle-polyelectrolyte complexes and polyelectrolyte in the dispersions used in emulsification greatly influence the mean diameter of the emulsions and their microstructure. Our findings provide a strategy to achieve control over surface coverage of particles on the emulsion droplets across a wide range - from a theoretically possible maximum, ≈90%, to as low as ≈5%. Interestingly, the emulsions formulated are found to possess excellent storage stability irrespective of the particle coverage on the drop surface.

Pickering emulsions stabilized by luteolin micro-nano particles to improve the oxidative stability of pine nut oil

BACKGROUND

Pine oil contains a high percentage of polyunsaturated fatty acids, which make it prone to oxidation. Luteolin (LUT) micro-nano particles with antioxidant properties can be used as stabilizers to form an edible oil-in-water Pickering emulsion to improve the oxidative stability of pine nut oil.

RESULTS

Under optimal preparation conditions, the LUT micro-nano particles and pine nut oil account for about 0.44 and 90.9 g·kg^-1 of the total mass of the emulsion, respectively. The LUT particles in the suspension have a mean particle size of about 479 nm, present a sheet-like structure with a cut surface of 30-50 nm, and can reduce the surface tension of deionized water. In the optimized Pickering emulsion, the emulsion droplets are approximately spherical and have a mean diameter of about 125.6 nm and uniform distribution. The optimized Pickering emulsion droplets can remain stable for up to 2 h in an environment where the pH levels are 7-8.5, ultraviolet B radiation (UVB) irradiation, of less than 5.0 g·kg^-1 , and at a temperature of 80 °C. The stability of the emulsion in simulated digestive fluid changed minimally. In the first 7 days of the accelerated oxidation experiment, LUT micro-nano particles not only successfully protected the integrity of emulsion droplets but also fully inhibited the peroxidation of pine oil.

CONCLUSION

The strong antioxidant properties of LUT micro-nano particles, and the dense protective layer they formed, stabilized the Pickering emulsion successfully. The particles also improved the oxidation stability of pine nut oil. © 2020 Society of Chemical Industry.

Coadsorption of Counterionic Colloids at Fluid Interfaces: A Coarse-Grained Simulation Study of Gibbs Monolayers

Monolayers of oppositely charged colloids form versatile self-organizing substrates, with a recognized potential to tailor functional interfaces. In this study, a coarse-grained Monte Carlo simulation approach is laid out to assess the structural properties of Gibbs monolayers, in which one of the counterionic species is partially soluble. It is shown that the composition of this type of monolayer varies in a nontrivial way with surface coverage, as a result of a subtle competition between steric and attractive forces. In the regime of weak electrostatic interactions, the monolayer is depleted of soluble colloids as the surface coverage is increased. At sufficiently strong interactions, the incorporation of soluble colloids is favored at high surface coverage, leading to a re-entrant-type behavior in the expansion/compression isotherms. Strong electrostatic interactions also favor the clustering of the colloids, leading to a range of aggregated configurations, qualitatively resembling those obtained in previous experimental studies. At sufficiently high surface coverage, the clusters collapse into a gel-like percolated mesoscopic structure and eventually into a square crystal lattice configuration. Such interfacial structures are in good agreement with the ones observed in the few experimental investigations available for these systems, showing that the simple methodology introduced in this study provides a valuable predictive framework to anticipate the landscape of interfacial structures that may be produced with oppositely charged colloids, through the modulation of pair interactions and thermodynamical conditions.

Interfacial Viscoelasticity of Self-Assembled Hydrophobic/Hydrophilic Particles at an Air/Water Interface

Hydrophobic/hydrophilic mixtures of latex particles at an air/water interface self-assemble, creating space filling, interconnected aggregates as the relative surface fractions of the dissimilar particles approach 0.5, which is reflected both in qualitative observation and fractal dimension of the microstructure. It is hypothesized that this change in microstructure occurs due to an asymmetry in the electrostatic interaction between similar and dissimilar particles caused by polarization of hydrophilic particles by hydrophobic particles. The changes in both microstructure and interparticle interactions significantly impact the interfacial viscoelasticity. As greater shape complexity is observed, interfacial complex moduli can increase by as much as 3 orders of magnitude and interfaces become more elastic.

Water-in-Oil Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by Synergistic Particle-Particle Interactions

Here, we report a novel "double Pickering stabilization" of water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions, where complex formation at the interface between Pickering polyphenol particles adsorbing from the oil side and whey protein microgel (WPM) particles coadsorbing from the aqueous side of the interface is investigated. The interfacial complex formation was strongly dependent on the concentration of WPM particles. At low WPM concentrations, both polyphenol crystals and WPM particles are present at the interface and the water droplets were stabilized through their synergistic action, while at higher concentrations, the WPM particles acted as "colloidal glue" between the water droplets and polyphenol crystals, enhancing the water droplet stability for more than 90 days and prevented coalescence. Via this mechanism, the addition of WPM up to 1 wt % gave a significant improvement in the stability of the W/O emulsions, allowing an increase to a 20 wt % water droplet fraction. The evidence suggests that the complex was probably formed due to electrostatic attraction between oppositely charged polyphenol Pickering particles on the oil side of the interface and WPM Pickering particles mainly on the aqueous side of the interface. Interfacial shear viscosity measurements and monolayer (Langmuir trough) experiments at the air-water interface provided further evidence of this strengthening of the film due to the synergistic particle-particle complex formation at the interface.

Controlling the stability of Pickering emulsions by pH-responsive nanoparticles

Electrostatic dissipative particle dynamics simulations were conducted to model the interactions between emulsion droplets stabilized by pH-sensitive polyelectrolyte-grafted nanoparticles. Using a steered molecular dynamics approach, a mechanistic study of forced coalescence was performed to probe the resistance between two particle-covered droplets. The degree of ionization of the grafted polyelectrolytes was adjusted to capture the pH responsiveness. The maximal resistance forces were measured to quantitatively discriminate the efficacy of particles in stabilizing emulsions at different degrees of ionization. Through analyzing droplet dynamics, resistance force variation, and electric field, we discovered that the resistance is attributed to direct electrostatic repulsion, the image charge effect near the water-oil interface, and steric hindrance among extended polymers. When the particle density on the droplet surface is relatively low, the increasing resistance forces at higher degrees of ionization can effectively prevent droplet coalescence. Oppositely, the ionization compromises emulsion stability when the particle surface coverage is high. Substantial desorption of particles from the interface was triggered as the degree of ionization increases. This in turn reduces resistance force and facilitates coalescence. Moreover, the nanoparticles prevent coalescence at high surface coverages by forming dense layers at individual interfaces, while the particle bridges straddling two interfaces were found at low surface coverages, which can also keep the droplets apart.

Colloidal tectonics for tandem synergistic Pickering interfacial catalysis: oxidative cleavage of cyclohexene oxide into adipic acid

Supramolecular preorganization and interfacial recognition can provide useful architectures for colloidal building. To this aim, a novel approach, based on colloidal tectonics involving two surface-active particles containing both recognition and catalytic sites, has been developed for controlling the formation and the properties of Pickering emulsions. This was illustrated by the combination of dodecyltrimethylammonium phosphotungstate nanoparticles, [C12]3[PW12O40], and silica particles functionalized with alkyl and sulfonic acid groups, [C n /SO3H]@SiO2. The interfacial self-assembly occurs by the penetration of the alkyl chains of [C n /SO3H]@SiO2 into the [C12]3[PW12O40] supramolecular porous structure constituted of polar and apolar regions. The emulsions were used as a non-nitric acid route for adipic acid synthesis from the one-pot oxidative cleavage of cyclohexene oxide with aqueous H2O2. The catalytic performance was significantly boosted due to the synergistic interactions between the particles.

Role of Electrostatic Interactions in Oil-in-Water Emulsions Stabilized by Heteroaggregation: An Experimental and Simulation Study

Oil-in-water emulsion stabilization by heteroaggregation of hydrophilic particles without a surfactant is of importance in a wide range of applications; however, the stabilization mechanism is little described. To shed light on the early stage of the stabilization mechanism, a model system composed of an oil wax phase dispersed in water with oppositely charged colloidal particles is studied experimentally and numerically. Experiments show that the colloids do not penetrate deeply in the oil phase, suggesting that adsorption of the colloidal particles on the wax droplets is mainly due to electrostatic interactions. Experiments and Brownian dynamics simulations show also that when oppositely charged colloidal particles are present in the emulsion, a multilayer coating of heteroaggregated colloidal particles is formed around the wax droplets. This protective coating is expected to prevent from the oil droplet coalescence and therefore to stabilize the emulsion.

Aggregation and Stabilization of Colloidal Spheroids by Oppositely Charged Spherical Nanoparticles

Heteroaggregation of colloids is an important yet complex physical process involving colloidal/nanosized particles and is relevant in river delta formation, paper-making, water treatment, blood flocculation, and so on. Despite the earlier studies on oppositely charged spherical colloids, heteroaggregation of colloids of different shapes is less explored. In this regard, we report an experimental study to investigate the colloidal stability of mixture of positively charged spheroidal hematite and negatively charged spherical silica nanoparticles. In this study, pH and surface area ratio (silica to hematite, S_S-H) are varied to tune the colloidal stability/instability of the suspension. At pH 6.5 and low S_S-H, the silica particles adsorb onto the hematite particles and reduce the effective charge of the latter, leading to aggregation and resulting in unstable dispersions. At higher S_S-H, adsorption of silica on hematite leads to overcharging and charge reversal, which leads to a stable dispersion. Similar experiments were performed at pH 2.4 and 3.5, and the crossover from unstable to stable dispersion is observed as a function of S_S-H. Calculation of Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey, and Overbeek (DLVO) interaction between particles in the binary mixture, as a function of pH and S_S-H, based on the aggregate size and zeta potential, explains the transition from unstable to stable dispersion. The size and zeta potential of heteroaggregates in the dispersion were analyzed by dynamic light scattering (DLS) technique. Adsorption of silica nanoparticles on hematite particles was visualized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The study provides a framework based on DLVO interactions to stabilize or destabilize a colloidal dispersion of nonspherical particles by controlled addition of oppositely charged spherical colloids, which is a feat that is not possible with simple salt. The stability ratio ( W) calculated from DLVO interactions demark the unstable-stable dispersion regions, which is found to be in agreement with the experimental results.

Structure and Dynamics of Stimuli-Responsive Nanoparticle Monolayers at Fluid Interfaces

Stimuli-responsive nanoparticles at fluid interfaces offer great potential for realizing on-demand and controllable self-assembly that can benefit various applications. Here, we conducted electrostatic dissipative particle dynamics simulations to provide a fundamental understanding of the microstructure and interfacial dynamics of responsive nanoparticle monolayers at a water-oil interface. The model nanoparticle is functionalized with polyelectrolytes to render the pH sensitivity, which permits further manipulation of the monolayer properties. The monolayer structure was analyzed in great detail through the density and electric field distributions, structure factor, and Voronoi tessellation. Even at a low surface coverage, a continuous disorder-to-order phase transition was observed when the particle's degree of ionization increases in response to pH changes. The six-neighbor particle fraction and bond orientation order parameter quantitatively characterize the structural transition induced by long-range electrostatic interactions. Adding salt can screen the electrostatic interactions and offer additional control on the monolayer structure. The detailed dynamics of the monolayer in different states was revealed by analyzing mean-squared displacements, in which different diffusion regimes were identified. The self-diffusion of individual particles and the collective dynamics of the whole monolayer were probed and correlated with the structural transition. Our results provide deeper insight into the dynamic behavior of responsive nanoparticle surfactants and lay the groundwork for bottom-up synthesis of novel nanomaterials, responsive emulsions, and microdroplet reactors.

Electrostatic interaction between dissimilar colloids at fluid interfaces

The electrostatic interaction between two nonidentical, moderately charged colloids situated in close proximity of each other at a fluid interface is studied. By resorting to a well-justified model system, this problem is analytically solved within the framework of linearized Poisson-Boltzmann density functional theory. The resulting interaction comprises a surface and a line part, both of which, as functions of the interparticle separation, show a rich behavior including monotonic as well as nonmonotonic variations. In almost all cases, these variations cannot be captured correctly by using the superposition approximation. Moreover, expressions for the surface tensions, the line tensions and the fluid-fluid interfacial tension, which are all independent of the interparticle separation, are obtained. Our results are expected to be particularly useful for emulsions stabilized by oppositely charged particles.

Physical properties of mixed Langmuir monolayers of polystyrene particles with poly(N,N-dimethylaminoethylmethacrylate) hairs and a poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) polymer at an air/water interface

The effect of adding a poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) (PHEMA) polymer to a Langmuir monolayer of polystyrene particles carrying poly(N,N-dimethylaminoethylmethacrylate) hair (PDMA-PS particles) at air/water interfaces on the physical properties of the monolayer was studied. The addition of PHEMA to a PDMA-PS particle monolayer at an air/water interface gave a polymer-like monolayer at low surface pressures and a particle-like monolayer at high surface pressures. The PDMA-PS particles formed small aggregates that were dispersed throughout the PHEMA monolayer at low surface pressures, a result suggesting that the particles were trapped in the PHEMA network. Monolayers of closely packed particles were observed at higher surface pressures, suggesting that PHEMA was squeezed-out at higher surface pressures. The stiffness of the mixed monolayer was independent of the surface pressure, but increased as the ratio of PHEMA in the mixed monolayer increased. This increased stiffness was explained by the immobilization of the PDMA-PS particles by PHEMA.

Interaction of polymer-coated silicon nanocrystals with lipid bilayers and surfactant interfaces

We use photoluminescence (PL) microscopy to measure the interaction between polyethylene-glycol-coated (PEGylated) silicon nanocrystals (SiNCs) and two model surfaces: lipid bilayers and surfactant interfaces. By characterizing the photostability, transport, and size-dependent emission of the PEGylated nanocrystal clusters, we demonstrate the retention of red PL suitable for detection and tracking with minimal blueshift after a year in an aqueous environment. The predominant interaction measured for both interfaces is short-range repulsion, consistent with the ideal behavior anticipated for PEGylated phospholipid coatings. However, we also observe unanticipated attractive behavior in a small number of scenarios for both interfaces. We attribute this anomaly to defective PEG coverage on a subset of the clusters, suggesting a possible strategy for enhancing cellular uptake by controlling the homogeneity of the PEG corona. In both scenarios, the shape of the apparent potential is modeled through the free or bound diffusion of the clusters near the confining interface.

Role of electrostatic interactions in the adsorption kinetics of nanoparticles at fluid-fluid interfaces

The adsorption of particles to the fluid-fluid interface is a key factor for the stabilization of fluid-fluid interfaces such as those found in emulsions, foams and bijels. However, for the formation of stable particle-laden interfaces, the particles must migrate to the interface from the bulk. Recent studies show that the adsorption of particles to the interface formed during emulsification is influenced by the surface charge of the particles. To further investigate this phenomenon, we study the effect of the surface charge of the particle on the adsorption kinetics of particles to the oil-water interface. By suspending a drop of aqueous dispersion of charge stabilized nanoparticles in decane, the adsorption dynamics of particles to the decane-water interface is studied using the dynamic surface tension measurements. When the particles are highly charged (low salt), a negligible change in the interface tension is observed indicating that almost no particles are adsorbed. These results show that the charged particles experience an energy barrier when they approach the interface. But when the particle surface charge is screened by the addition of monovalent salt, a significant reduction in surface tension is observed indicating the migration and adsorption of particles to the decane-water interface. We estimate the effective diffusivity of particles to the interface by analyzing the initial decay in the measured surface tension by considering particle laden drops containing different amounts of salt using the modified Ward and Tordai theory. This effective diffusivity is used to calculate the energy barrier for the adsorption of particles to the interface. The energy barrier from the analysis of dynamic surface tension data agrees well with the concept of image charge repulsion which inhibits the adsorption of highly charged particles to the interface. By considering various types of relevant interactions, we derive an analytical expression that qualitatively captures the effect of the surface charge on the equilibrium surface coverage of particles at the drop surface.