Breakdown of nonlinear elasticity in stress-controlled thermal amorphous solids

Elastic to plastic transition in amorphous solids

The response of amorphous solids to mechanical loads is accompanied by plasticity that is generically associated with "non-affine" quadrupolar events seen in the resulting displacement field. To develop a continuum theory, one needs to assess when these quadrupolar events have a finite density, allowing the development of a field theory. Is there a transition, as a function of the material parameters and the nature of the loads, from isolated plastic events whose density is zero to a regime governed by a finite density? And if so, what is the nature of this transition? The aim of the paper is to explore this issue. The motivation for the present study stems from recent research in which it was shown that gradients of the quadrupolar fields act as dipole charges that can screen elasticity. Analytically soluble examples of mechanical loading that lead to screening and emergent length scales (that are absent in classical elasticity) have been analyzed and tested. However, "gradients of quadrupolar fields" make sense only when the density of quadrupoles is finite, and hence, the issue is central to this article. The article introduces a notion of polarizability under the strain of Eshelby quadrupoles and concludes that the onset of a density of such quadrupoles with random orientations can only appear when the polarizability is finite.

Anomalous elasticity and emergent dipole screening in three-dimensional amorphous solids

In recent work, we developed a screening theory for describing the effect of plastic events in amorphous solids on its emergent mechanics. The suggested theory uncovered an anomalous mechanical response of amorphous solids where plastic events collectively induce distributed dipoles that are analogous to dislocations in crystalline solids. The theory was tested against various models of amorphous solids in two dimensions, including frictional and frictionless granular media and numerical models of amorphous glass. Here we extend our theory to screening in three-dimensional amorphous solids and predict the existence of anomalous mechanics similar to the one observed in two-dimensional systems. We conclude by interpreting the mechanical response as the formation of nontopological distributed dipoles that have no analog in the crystalline defects literature. Having in mind that the onset of dipole screening is reminiscent of Kosterlitz-Thouless and hexatic transitions, the finding of dipole screening in three dimensions is surprising.

Anomalous elasticity and plastic screening in amorphous solids

Amorphous solids appear to react elastically to small external strains, but in contrast to ideal elastic media, plastic responses abound immediately at any value of the strain. Such plastic responses are quasilocalized in nature, with the "cheapest" one being a quadrupolar source. The existence of such plastic responses results in screened elasticity in which strains and stresses can either quantitatively or qualitatively differ from the unscreened theory, depending on the specific screening mechanism. Here we offer a theory of such screening effects by plastic quadrupoles, dipoles, and monopoles, explain their natural appearance, and point out the analogy to electrostatic screening by electric charges and dipoles. For low density of quadrupoles the effect is to normalize the elastic moduli without a qualitative change compared to pure elasticity theory; for higher density of quadrupoles the screening effects result in qualitative changes. Predictions for the spatial dependence of displacement fields caused by local sources of strains are provided and compared to numerical simulations. We find that anomalous elasticity is richer than electrostatics in having a screening mode that does not appear in the electrostatic analog.

Noise amplification in frictional systems: Oscillatory instabilities

It was discovered recently that frictional granular materials can exhibit an important mechanism for instabilities, i.e., the appearance of pairs of complex eigenvalues in their stability matrix. The consequence is an oscillatory exponential growth of small perturbations which are tamed by dynamical nonlinearities. The amplification can be giant, many orders of magnitude, and it ends with a catastrophic system-spanning plastic event. Here we follow up on this discovery, explore the scaling laws characterizing the onset of the instability, the scenarios of the development of the instability with and without damping, and the nature of the eventual system-spanning events. The possible relevance to earthquake physics and to the transition from static to dynamic friction is discussed.

Oscillatory Instabilities in Frictional Granular Matter

Frictional granular matter is shown to be fundamentally different in its plastic responses to external strains from generic glasses and amorphous solids without friction. While regular glasses exhibit plastic instabilities due to the vanishing of a real eigenvalue of the Hessian matrix, frictional granular materials can exhibit a previously unnoticed additional mechanism for instabilities, i.e., the appearance of a pair of complex eigenvalues leading to oscillatory exponential growth of perturbations that are tamed by dynamical nonlinearities. This fundamental difference appears crucial for the understanding of plasticity and failure in frictional granular materials. The possible relevance to earthquake physics is discussed.

Anomalous nonlinear damping in metallic glasses: Signature of elasticity breakdown

Solid materials, whether crystalline or glasses, are characterized by their elasticity. Generally, elasticity is independent of the probing strain if it is not exceeding the yielding point. Here, by contrast, we experimentally capture a pronounced strain-dependent elasticity in metallic glasses, as manifested by nonlinear mechanical damping in the apparent elastic deformation regime (∼1/100 of the yielding strain). Normal damping behaviors recover at higher temperatures but still below the glass transition. Atomistic simulations reproduce these features and reveal that they could be related to avalanche-like local structural instabilities. Our findings demonstrate that the standard elasticity is not held for metallic glasses at low temperatures and plastic events can be triggered at small perturbations. These results are consistent with previous simulations of model glasses and a scenario of hierarchical free-energy landscape of mean-field theory.

Universal scaling of the stress-strain curve in amorphous solids

The yielding transition of amorphous solids is a phase transition with a special type of universality. Critical exponents and scaling relations have been defined and proposed near the yield stress. We show here that, even in the initial stage of shear far below the yield stress, the stress-strain curve of amorphous solids also shows critical scaling with universal exponents. The key point is to remove the elastic part of the strain, and the shear stress exhibits a sublinear scaling with the plastic strain. We show how this critical scaling is related to the finite size effect of the minimum strain to trigger the first plastic avalanche after a quench. We point out that this sublinear scaling between the stress and the plastic strain implies the divergence of a high-order shear modulus. A scaling relation is derived between two exponents characterizing the stress-strain curve and the density distribution of the local stabilities, respectively. We test the critical scaling of the stress-strain curve using both mesoscopic and atomistic simulations and get satisfying agreement in two and three dimensions.