Partial inertia induces additional phase transition in the majority vote model

Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics of the Majority Vote Model

The majority vote model is one of the simplest opinion systems yielding distinct phase transitions and has garnered significant interest in recent years. This model, as well as many other stochastic lattice models, are formulated in terms of stochastic rules with no connection to thermodynamics, precluding the achievement of quantities such as power and heat, as well as their behaviors at phase transition regimes. Here, we circumvent this limitation by introducing the idea of a distinct and well-defined thermal reservoir associated to each local configuration. Thermodynamic properties are derived for a generic majority vote model, irrespective of its neighborhood and lattice topology. The behavior of energy/heat fluxes at phase transitions, whether continuous or discontinuous, in regular and complex topologies, is investigated in detail. Unraveling the contribution of each local configuration explains the nature of the phase diagram and reveals how dissipation arises from the dynamics.

Stochastic thermodynamics of opinion dynamics models

We show that models of opinion formation and dissemination in a community of individuals can be framed within stochastic thermodynamics from which we can build a nonequilibrium thermodynamics of opinion dynamics. This is accomplished by decomposing the original transition rate that defines an opinion model into two or more transition rates, each representing the contact with heat reservoirs at different temperatures, and postulating an energy function. As the temperatures are distinct, heat fluxes are present even at the stationary state and linked to the production of entropy, the fundamental quantity that characterizes nonequilibrium states. We apply the present framework to a generic-vote model including the majority-vote model in a square lattice and in a cubic lattice. The fluxes and the rate of entropy production are calculated by numerical simulation and by the use of a pair approximation.

Phase transition in the majority-vote model on time-varying networks

Social interactions may affect the update of individuals' opinions. The existing models such as the majority-vote (MV) model have been extensively studied in different static networks. However, in reality, social networks change over time and individuals interact dynamically. In this work, we study the behavior of the MV model on temporal networks to analyze the effects of temporality on opinion dynamics. In social networks, people are able to both actively send connections and passively receive connections, which leads to different effects on individuals' opinions. In order to compare the impact of different patterns of interactions on opinion dynamics, we simplify them into two processes, that is, the single directed (SD) process and the undirected (UD) process. The former only allows each individual to adopt an opinion by following the majority of actively interactive neighbors, while the latter allows each individual to flip opinion by following the majority of both actively interactive and passively interactive neighbors. By borrowing the activity-driven time-varying network with attractiveness (ADA model), the two opinion update processes, i.e., the SD and the UD processes, are related with the network evolution. With the mean-field approach, we derive the critical noise threshold for each process, which is also verified by numerical simulations. Compared with the SD process, the UD process reaches a larger consensus level below the same critical noise. Finally, we also verify the main results in real networks.

Influence of distinct kinds of temporal disorder in discontinuous phase transitions

Based on mean-field theory (MFT) arguments, a general description for discontinuous phase transitions in the presence of temporal disorder is considered. Our analysis extends the recent findings [C. E. Fiore et al., Phys. Rev. E 98, 032129 (2018)2470-004510.1103/PhysRevE.98.032129] by considering discontinuous phase transitions beyond those with a single absorbing state. The theory is exemplified in one of the simplest (nonequilibrium) order-disorder (discontinuous) phase transitions with "up-down" Z_{2} symmetry: the inertial majority vote model for two kinds of temporal disorder. As for absorbing phase transitions, the temporal disorder does not suppress the occurrence of discontinuous phase transitions, but remarkable differences emerge when compared with the pure (disorderless) case. A comparison between the distinct kinds of temporal disorder is also performed beyond the MFT for random-regular complex topologies. Our work paves the way for the study of a generic discontinuous phase transition under the influence of an arbitrary kind of temporal disorder.

Non-Markovian majority-vote model

Non-Markovian dynamics pervades human activity and social networks and it induces memory effects and burstiness in a wide range of processes including interevent time distributions, duration of interactions in temporal networks, and human mobility. Here, we propose a non-Markovian majority-vote model (NMMV) that introduces non-Markovian effects in the standard (Markovian) majority-vote model (SMV). The SMV model is one of the simplest two-state stochastic models for studying opinion dynamics, and displays a continuous order-disorder phase transition at a critical noise. In the NMMV model we assume that the probability that an agent changes state is not only dependent on the majority state of his neighbors but it also depends on his age, i.e., how long the agent has been in his current state. The NMMV model has two regimes: the aging regime implies that the probability that an agent changes state is decreasing with his age, while in the antiaging regime the probability that an agent changes state is increasing with his age. Interestingly, we find that the critical noise at which we observe the order-disorder phase transition is a nonmonotonic function of the rate β of the aging (antiaging) process. In particular the critical noise in the aging regime displays a maximum as a function of β while in the antiaging regime displays a minimum. This implies that the aging/antiaging dynamics can retard/anticipate the transition and that there is an optimal rate β for maximally perturbing the value of the critical noise. The analytical results obtained in the framework of the heterogeneous mean-field approach are validated by extensive numerical simulations on a large variety of network topologies.

Entropy production as a tool for characterizing nonequilibrium phase transitions

Nonequilibrium phase transitions can be typified in a similar way to equilibrium systems, for instance, by the use of the order parameter. However, this characterization hides the irreversible character of the dynamics as well as its influence on the phase transition properties. Entropy production has been revealed to be an important concept for filling this gap since it vanishes identically for equilibrium systems and is positive for the nonequilibrium case. Based on distinct and general arguments, the characterization of phase transitions in terms of the entropy production is presented. Analysis for discontinuous and continuous phase transitions has been undertaken by taking regular and complex topologies within the framework of mean-field theory (MFT) and beyond the MFT. A general description of entropy production portraits for Z_{2} ("up-down") symmetry systems under the MFT is presented. Our main result is that a given phase transition, whether continuous or discontinuous has a specific entropy production hallmark. Our predictions are exemplified by an icon system, perhaps the simplest nonequilibrium model presenting an order-disorder phase transition and spontaneous symmetry breaking: the majority vote model. Our work paves the way to a systematic description and classification of nonequilibrium phase transitions through a key indicator of system irreversibility.

Phase transitions in a multistate majority-vote model on complex networks

We generalize the original majority-vote (MV) model from two states to arbitrary p states and study the order-disorder phase transitions in such a p-state MV model on complex networks. By extensive Monte Carlo simulations and a mean-field theory, we show that for p≥3 the order of phase transition is essentially different from a continuous second-order phase transition in the original two-state MV model. Instead, for p≥3 the model displays a discontinuous first-order phase transition, which is manifested by the appearance of the hysteresis phenomenon near the phase transition. Within the hysteresis loop, the ordered phase and disordered phase are coexisting, and rare flips between the two phases can be observed due to the finite-size fluctuation. Moreover, we investigate the type of phase transition under a slightly modified dynamics [Melo et al., J. Stat. Mech. (2010) P110321742-546810.1088/1742-5468/2010/11/P11032]. We find that the order of phase transition in the three-state MV model depends on the degree heterogeneity of networks. For p≥4, both dynamics produce the first-order phase transitions.

Fundamental ingredients for discontinuous phase transitions in the inertial majority vote model

Discontinuous transitions have received considerable interest due to the uncovering that many phenomena such as catastrophic changes, epidemic outbreaks and synchronization present a behavior signed by abrupt (macroscopic) changes (instead of smooth ones) as a tuning parameter is changed. However, in different cases there are still scarce microscopic models reproducing such above trademarks. With these ideas in mind, we investigate the key ingredients underpinning the discontinuous transition in one of the simplest systems with up-down Z₂ symmetry recently ascertained in [Phys. Rev. E 95, 042304 (2017)]. Such system, in the presence of an extra ingredient-the inertia- has its continuous transition being switched to a discontinuous one in complex networks. We scrutinize the role of three central ingredients: inertia, system degree, and the lattice topology. Our analysis has been carried out for regular lattices and random regular networks with different node degrees (interacting neighborhood) through mean-field theory (MFT) treatment and numerical simulations. Our findings reveal that not only the inertia but also the connectivity constitute essential elements for shifting the phase transition. Astoundingly, they also manifest in low-dimensional regular topologies, exposing a scaling behavior entirely different than those from the complex networks case. Therefore, our findings put on firmer bases the essential issues for the manifestation of discontinuous transitions in such relevant class of systems with Z₂ symmetry.

Finite-size scaling for discontinuous nonequilibrium phase transitions

A finite-size scaling theory, originally developed only for transitions to absorbing states [Phys. Rev. E 92, 062126 (2015)PLEEE81539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.92.062126], is extended to distinct sorts of discontinuous nonequilibrium phase transitions. Expressions for quantities such as response functions, reduced cumulants, and equal area probability distributions are derived from phenomenological arguments. Irrespective of system details, all these quantities scale with the volume, establishing the dependence on size. The approach generality is illustrated through the analysis of different models. The present results are a relevant step in trying to unify the scaling behavior description of nonequilibrium transition processes.