Spontaneous deswelling of microgels controlled by counterion clouds

Osmotic swelling behavior of surface-charged ionic microgels

In recent years, ionic microgels have garnered much attention due to their unique properties, especially their stimulus-sensitive swelling behavior. The tunable response of these soft, permeable, compressible, charged colloidal particles is increasingly attractive for applications in medicine and biotechnologies, such as controlled drug delivery, tissue engineering, and biosensing. The ability to model and predict variation of the osmotic pressure of a single microgel with respect to changes in particle properties and environmental conditions proves vital to such applications. In this work, we apply both nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann theory and molecular dynamics simulation to ionic microgels (macroions) in the cell model to compute density profiles of microions (counterions, coions), single-microgel osmotic pressure, and equilibrium swelling ratios of spherical microgels whose fixed charge is confined to the macroion surface. The basis of our approach is an exact theorem that relates the electrostatic component of the osmotic pressure to the microion density profiles. Close agreement between theory and simulation serves as a consistency check to validate our approach. We predict that surface-charged microgels progressively deswell with increasing microgel concentration, starting well below close packing, and with increasing salt concentration, in qualitative agreement with experiments. Comparison with previous results for microgels with fixed charge uniformly distributed over their volume demonstrates that surface-charged microgels deswell more rapidly than volume-charged microgels. We conclude that swelling behavior of ionic microgels in solution is sensitive to the distribution of fixed charge within the polymer-network gel and strongly depends on bulk concentrations of both microgels and salt ions.

Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) microgel swelling behavior and suspension structure studied with small-angle neutron scattering

Microgels are of high interest for applications and as model systems due to their volume response to external stimuli. We use small-angle neutron scattering to measure the form and structure factors of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) microgels in dilute and concentrated suspensions and find that microgels keep a constant size up to a concentration, above which they deswell. This happens before random-close packing. We emphasize suspension polydispersity must be considered to obtain accurate form and structure factors. Our results are compatible with microgel deswelling triggered by the osmotic pressure set by counterions associated to charged groups in the microgel periphery, which sharply increases when the counterion clouds surrounding the microgels percolate throughout the suspension volume.

Fluid-solid transitions in photonic crystals of soft, thermoresponsive microgels

Microgels are often discussed as well-suited model system for soft colloids. In contrast to rigid spheres, the microgel volume and, coupled to this, the volume fraction in dispersion can be manipulated by external stimuli. This behavior is particularly interesting at high packings where phase transitions can be induced by external triggers such as temperature in the case of thermoresponsive microgels. A challenge, however, is the determination of the real volume occupied by these deformable, soft objects and consequently, to determine the boundaries of the phase transitions. Here we propose core-shell microgels with a rigid silica core and a crosslinked, thermoresponsive poly-N-isopropylacrylamide (PNIPAM) shell with a carefully chosen shell-to-core size ratio as ideal model colloids to study fluid-solid transitions that are inducible by millikelvin changes in temperature. Specifically, we identify the temperature ranges where crystallization and melting occur using absorbance spectroscopy in a range of concentrations. Slow annealing from the fluid to the crystalline state leads to photonic crystals with Bragg peaks in the visible wavelength range and very narrow linewidths. Small-angle X-ray scattering is then used to confirm the structure of the fluid phase as well as the long-range order, crystal structure and microgel volume fraction in the solid phase. Thanks to the scattering contrasts and volume ratio of the cores with respect to the shells, the scattering data do allow for form factor analysis revealing osmotic deswelling at volume fractions approaching and also exceeding the hard sphere packing limit.

Measuring the counterion cloud of soft microgels using SANS with contrast variation

The behavior of microgels and other soft, compressible colloids depends on particle concentration in ways that are absent in their hard-particulate counterparts. For instance, poly-N-isopropylacrylamide (pNIPAM) microgels can spontaneously deswell and reduce suspension polydispersity when concentrated enough. Despite the pNIPAM network in these microgels is neutral, the key to understanding this distinct behavior relies on the existence of peripheric charged groups, responsible for providing colloidal stability when deswollen, and the associated counterion cloud. When in close proximity, clouds of different particles overlap, effectively freeing the associated counterions, which are then able to exert an osmotic pressure that can potentially cause the microgels to decrease their size. Up to now, however, no direct measurement of such an ionic cloud exists, perhaps even also for hard colloids, where it is referred to as an electric double layer. Here, we use small-angle neutron scattering with contrast variation with different ions to isolate the change in the form factor directly related to the counterion cloud, and obtain its radius and width. Our results highlight that the modeling of microgel suspensions must unavoidably and explicitly consider the presence of this cloud, which exists for nearly all microgels synthesized today.

Self-Healing of Charged Microgels in Neutral and Charged Environments

The softness of microgels depends on many aspects, such as particle characteristic lengths, sample concentration, chemical composition of the sample, and elastic moduli of the particle. Here, the response to crowding of ionic microgels is studied. Charged and uncharged ionic microgels are studied in concentrated suspensions of both neutral and ionic microgels with the same swollen size. The combination of small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering with contrast variation allows us to probe both the particle-to-particle arrangement and the response of individual ionic microgels to crowding. When the ionic microgels are uncharged, initial isotropic deswelling followed by faceting is observed. Therefore, the ionizable groups in the polymeric network do not affect the response of the ionic microgel to crowding, which is similar to what has been reported for neutral microgels. In contrast, the kind of microgels composing the matrix plays a key role once the ionic microgels are charged. If the matrix is composed of neutral microgels, a pronounced faceting and negligible deswelling is observed. When only charged ionic microgels are present in the suspension, isotropic deswelling without faceting is dominant.

Concentration and temperature dependent interactions and state diagram of dispersions of copolymer microgels

We investigate by means of small angle neutron scattering experiments and numerical simulations the interactions and inter-particle arrangements of concentrated dispersions of copolymer poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-poly(ethylene glycol methyl ether methacrylate) (PNIPAM-PEGMA) microgels across the volume phase transition (VPT). The scattering data of moderately concentrated dispersions are accurately modeled at all temperatures by using a star polymer form factor and static structure factors calculated from the effective potential obtained from simulations. Interestingly, for temperatures below the VPT temperature (VPTT), the radius of gyration and blob size of the particles significantly decrease with increasing the effective packing fraction in the non-overlapping regime. This is attributed to the presence of charges in the system associated with the use of an ionic initiator in the synthesis. Simulations using the experimentally corroborated interaction potential are used to explore the state diagram in a wide range of effective packing fractions. Below and slightly above the VPTT, the system undergoes an arrest transition mainly driven by the soft repulsion between the particles. Only well above the VPTT the system is found to phase separate before arresting. Our results highlight the versatility and potential of copolymer PNIPAM-PEGMA microgels to explore different kinds of arrested states balancing attraction and repulsion by changing temperature and packing fraction.

Beyond simple self-healing: How anisotropic nanogels adapt their shape to their environment

The response of soft colloids to crowding depends sensitively on the particles’ compressibility. Nanogel suspensions provide model systems that are often studied to better understand the properties of soft materials and complex fluids from the formation of colloidal crystals to the flow of viruses, blood, or platelet cells in the body. Large spherical nanogels, when embedded in a matrix of smaller nanogels, have the unique ability to spontaneously deswell to match their size to that of the nanogel composing the matrix. In contrast to hard colloids, this self-healing mechanism allows for crystal formation without giving rise to point defects or dislocations. Here, we show that anisotropic ellipsoidal nanogels adapt both their size and their shape depending on the nature of the particles composing the matrix in which they are embedded. Using small-angle neutron scattering with contrast variation, we show that ellipsoidal nanogels become spherical when embedded in a matrix of spherical nanogels. In contrast, the anisotropy of the ellipsoid is enhanced when they are embedded in a matrix of anisotropic nanogels. Our experimental data are supported by Monte Carlo simulations that reproduce the trend of decreasing aspect ratio of ellipsoidal nanogels with increasing crowding by a matrix of spherical nanogels.

How Softness Matters in Soft Nanogels and Nanogel Assemblies

Softness plays a key role in determining the macroscopic properties of colloidal systems, from synthetic nanogels to biological macromolecules, from viruses to star polymers. However, we are missing a way to quantify what the term "softness" means in nanoscience. Having quantitative parameters is fundamental to compare different systems and understand what the consequences of softness on the macroscopic properties are. Here, we propose different quantities that can be measured using scattering methods and microscopy experiments. On the basis of these quantities, we review the recent literature on micro- and nanogels, i.e. cross-linked polymer networks swollen in water, a widely used model system for soft colloids. Applying our criteria, we address the question what makes a nanomaterial soft? We discuss and introduce general criteria to quantify the different definitions of softness for an individual compressible colloid. This is done in terms of the energetic cost associated with the deformation and the capability of the colloid to isotropically deswell. Then, concentrated solutions of soft colloids are considered. New definitions of softness and new parameters, which depend on the particle-to-particle interactions, are introduced in terms of faceting and interpenetration. The influence of the different synthetic routes on the softness of nanogels is discussed. Concentrated solutions of nanogels are considered and we review the recent results in the literature concerning the phase behavior and flow properties of nanogels both in three and two dimensions, in the light of the different parameters we defined. The aim of this review is to look at the results on micro- and nanogels in a more quantitative way that allow us to explain the reported properties in terms of differences in colloidal softness. Furthermore, this review can give researchers dealing with soft colloids quantitative methods to define unambiguously which softness matters in their compound.

Reconfigurable artificial microswimmers with internal feedback

Self-propelling microparticles are often proposed as synthetic models for biological microswimmers, yet they lack the internally regulated adaptation of their biological counterparts. Conversely, adaptation can be encoded in larger-scale soft-robotic devices but remains elusive to transfer to the colloidal scale. Here, we create responsive microswimmers, powered by electro-hydrodynamic flows, which can adapt their motility via internal reconfiguration. Using sequential capillary assembly, we fabricate deterministic colloidal clusters comprising soft thermo-responsive microgels and light-absorbing particles. Light absorption induces preferential local heating and triggers the volume phase transition of the microgels, leading to an adaptation of the clusters' motility, which is orthogonal to their propulsion scheme. We rationalize this response via the coupling between self-propulsion and variations of particle shape and dielectric properties upon heating. Harnessing such coupling allows for strategies to achieve local dynamical control with simple illumination patterns, revealing exciting opportunities for developing tactic active materials.

Characterization of the volume fraction of soft deformable microgels by means of small-angle neutron scattering with contrast variation

The volume occupied by colloids in a suspension - namely the volume fraction - is the thermodynamic variable that determines the phase behavior of these systems. While for hard incompressible spheres this quantity is well defined, for soft compressible colloids such as microgels - polymeric crosslinked networks swollen in a good solvent - the determination of the real volume occupied by these particles in solution is particularly challenging. This fact depends on two aspects: first the surface and, therefore, the volume of the microgels is hard to define properly given their external fuzziness; second, microgels can osmotically deswell, deform or interpenetrate their neighbors, i.e. change their shape and size depending on the solution concentration. Here, the form factors of few hydrogenated microgels embedded in a matrix of deuterated but otherwise identical microgels are measured using small-angle neutron scattering with contrast variation. From the analysis of the scattering data, the variation of the volume of the microgels as a function of concentration is obtained and used to calculate the real microgel volume fraction in solution. Soft neutral microgels are shown to facet already at low concentrations while in contrast, harder microgels maintain their shape and change their volume.

Collapse-induced phase transitions in binary interfacial microgel monolayers

Microgels, consisting of a swollen polymer network, exhibit a more complex self-assembly behavior compared to incompressible colloidal particles, because of their ability to deform at a liquid interface or collapse upon compression. Here, we investigate the collective phase behavior of two-dimensional binary mixtures of microgels confined at the air/water interface. We use stimuli-responsive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) microgels with different crosslinking densities, and therefore different morphologies at the interface. We find that the minority microgel population introduces lattice defects in the ordered phase of the majority population, which, in contrast to bulk studies, do not heal out by partial deswelling to accommodate in the lattice. We subsequently investigate the interfacial phase behavior of these binary interfacial assemblies under compression. The binary system exhibits three distinct isostructural solid-solid phase transitions, during which the coronae between two small particles collapse first, followed by the collapse between small-large and large-large microgel pairs. A similar hierarchy of phase transitions is found for mixtures of microgels and core-shell particles. Simulations based on augmented potentials qualitatively reproduce the experimentally observed phase transitions. We rationalize the presence of this hierarchy in phase transitions from differences in the interfacial morphology between the species: the larger coronae of softer (and therefore larger) microgels provide a higher resistance to phase transitions compared to the smaller coronae of the more crosslinked microgels and core-shell particles. The control of phase transitions via the molecular architecture further allows the formation of characteristic, flower-like defects by introducing particles with "weaker" coronae that are more prone to collapse with their neighboring particles. Our findings underline the dominating role of the corona for interfacial microgel assemblies, which acts as an energy barrier, shifting the collapse to higher surface pressures.

Internal structure of ultralow-crosslinked microgels: From uniform deswelling to phase separation

We perform small angle neutron scattering on ultralow-crosslinked microgels and find that while in certain conditions both the particle size and the characteristic internal length scale change in unison, in other instances this is not the case. We show that nonuniform deswelling depends not only on particle size, but also on the particular way the various contributions to the free energy combine to result in a given size. Only when polymer-solvent demixing strongly competes with ionic or electrostatic effects do we observe nonuniform behavior, reflecting internal microphase separation. The results do not appreciably depend on particle number density; even in concentrated suspensions, we find that at relatively low temperature, where demixing is not very strong, the deswelling behavior is uniform, and that only at sufficiently high temperature, where demixing is very strong, does the microgel structure change akin to internal microphase separation.

Absence of crystals in the phase behavior of hollow microgels

Solutions of microgels have been widely used as model systems to gain insight into atomic condensed matter and complex fluids. We explore the thermodynamic phase behavior of hollow microgels, which are distinguished from conventional colloids by a central cavity. Small-angle neutron and x-ray scattering are used to probe hollow microgels in crowded environments. These measurements reveal an interplay among deswelling, interpenetration, and faceting and an unusual absence of crystals. Monte Carlo simulations of model systems confirm that, due to the cavity, solutions of hollow microgels more readily form a supercooled liquid than for microgels with a cross-linked core.

Osmotic pressure of suspensions comprised of charged microgels

We determine the osmotic pressure of microgel suspensions using membrane osmometry and dialysis, for microgels with different softnesses. Our measurements reveal that the osmotic pressure of solutions of both ionic and neutral microgels is determined by the free ions that leave the microgel periphery to maximize their entropy and not by the translational degrees of freedom of the microgels themselves. Furthermore, up to a given concentration it is energetically favorable for the microgels to maintain a constant volume without appreciable deswelling. The concentration where deswelling starts weakly depends on the crosslinker concentration, which affects the microgel dimension; we explain this by considering the dependence of the osmotic pressure and the microgel bulk modulus on the particle size.

Phase behavior of ultrasoft spheres show stable bcc lattices

The phase behavior of supersoft spheres is explored using solutions of ultralow cross-linked poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-based microgels as a model system. For these microgels, the effects of the electric charges on their surfaces can be neglected and therefore only the role of softness on the phase behavior is investigated. The samples show a liquid-to-crystal transition at higher volume fraction with respect to both hard spheres and stiffer microgels. Furthermore, stable body centered cubic (bcc) crystals are observed in addition to the expected face centered cubic (fcc) crystals. Small-angle x-ray and neutron scattering with contrast variation allow the characterization of both the microgel-to-microgel distance and the architecture of single microgels in crowded solutions. The measurements reveal that the stable bcc crystals depend on the interplay between the collapse and the interpenetration of the external shell of the ultralow cross-linked microgels.

Pathways and challenges towards a complete characterization of microgels

Due to their controlled size, sensitivity to external stimuli, and ease-of-use, microgel colloids are unique building blocks for soft materials made by crosslinking polymers on the micrometer scale. Despite the plethora of work published, many questions about their internal structure, interactions, and phase behavior are still open. The reasons for this lack of understanding are the challenges arising from the small size of the microgel particles, complex pairwise interactions, and their solvent permeability. Here we describe pathways toward a complete understanding of microgel colloids based on recent experimental advances in nanoscale characterization, such as super-resolution microscopy, scattering methods, and modeling.

Controlling the morphology of microgels by ionic stimuli

Stimuli-responsive microgels have attracted much interest for their use as vehicles for drug delivery or as the building blocks of adaptive materials. Ionic microgel particles, including popular poly(NIPAM-co-acrylic acid), show strong mechanical responsiveness to many external stimuli, including changes in ionic strength or acidity. In this work, we demonstrate that combining multiple ionic stimuli can enable detailed control over the morphology of microgels. To this extent, we analyze the particle morphology in various surroundings with light-scattering techniques. First, we find strong indications of an inverted density profile in the core of the particles. Secondly, we show that the swelling of this hydrogel core and the corona of dangling polymer ends can be targeted separately by a combination of deionization and deprotonation steps. Hence, this work represents an advance in tailoring particle morphologies after synthesis in a predictable fashion.

Numerical insights on ionic microgels: structure and swelling behaviour

Recent progress has been made in the numerical modelling of neutral microgel particles with a realistic, disordered structure. In this work we extend this approach to the case of co-polymerised microgels where a thermoresponsive polymer is mixed with acidic groups. We compare the cases where counterions directly interact with microgel charges or are modelled implicitly through a Debye-Hückel description. We do so by performing extensive numerical simulations of single microgels across the volume phase transition (VPT) varying the temperature and the fraction of charged monomers. We find that the presence of charges considerably alters the microgel structure, quantified by the monomer density profiles and by the form factors of the microgels, particularly close to the VPT. We observe significant deviations between the implicit and explicit models, with the latter comparing more favourably to available experiments. In particular, we observe a shift of the VPT temperature to larger values as the amount of charged monomers increases. We also find that below the VPT the microgel-counterion complex is almost neutral, while it develops a net charge above the VPT. Interestingly, under these conditions the collapsed microgel still retains a large amount of counterions inside its structure. Since these interesting features cannot be captured by the implicit model, our results show that it is crucial to explicitly include the counterions in order to realistically model ionic thermoresponsive microgels.