Unlocking internal prestress from protein nanoshells

Seeing and touching adenovirus: complementary approaches for understanding assembly and disassembly of a complex virion

Understanding adenovirus assembly and disassembly poses many challenges due to the virion complexity. A distinctive feature of adenoviruses is the large amount of virus-encoded proteins packed together with the dsDNA genome. Cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures are broadening our understanding of capsid variability along evolution, but little is known about the organization of the non-icosahedral nucleoproteic core and its influence in adenovirus function. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) probes the biomechanics of virus particles, while simultaneously inducing and monitoring their disassembly in real time. Synergistic combination of AFM with EM shows that core proteins play unexpected key roles in maturation and entry, and uncoating dynamics are finely tuned to ensure genome release at the appropriate time and place for successful infection.

Stiffness heterogeneity of small viral capsids

Nanoindentation of viral capsids provides an efficient tool in order to probe their elastic properties. We investigate in the present work the various sources of stiffness heterogeneity as observed in atomic force microscopy experiments. By combining experimental results with both numerical and analytical modeling, we first show that for small viruses, a position-dependent stiffness is observed. This effect is strong and has not been properly taken into account previously. Moreover, we show that a geometrical model is able to reproduce this effect quantitatively. Our work suggests alternative ways of measuring stiffness heterogeneities on small viral capsids. This is illustrated on two different viral capsids: Adeno associated virus serotype 8 (AAV8) and hepatitis B virus (HBV with T=4). We discuss our results in light of continuous elasticity modeling.

Scaling relation between genome length and particle size of viruses provides insights into viral life history

In terms of genome and particle sizes, viruses exhibit great diversity. With the discovery of several nucleocytoplasmic large DNA viruses (NCLDVs) and jumbo phages, the relationship between particle and genome sizes has emerged as an important criterion for understanding virus evolution. We use allometric scaling of capsid volume with the genome length of different groups of viruses to shed light on its relationship with virus life history. The allometric exponents for icosahedral dsDNA bacteriophages and NCDLVs were found to be 1 and 2, respectively, indicating that with increasing capsid size DNA packaging density remains the same in bacteriophages but decreases for NCLDVs. We argue that the exponents are largely shaped by their entry mechanism and capsid mechanical stability. We further show that these allometric size parameters are also intricately linked to the relative energy costs of translation and replication in viruses and can have further implications on viral life history.

•

Capsid and genome size allometric exponent gives insights into viral life history

•

The allometric exponent of NCLDVs is almost twice that of bacteriophages

•

The exponent is largely shaped by the viral entry mechanism and capsid stability

•

The relaxed genome size constraint allows large viruses to evolve greater autonomy

Minimal Cylinder Analysis Reveals the Mechanical Properties of Oncogenic Nucleosomes

Histone variants regulate replication, transcription, DNA damage repair, and chromosome segregation. Though widely accepted as a paradigm, it has not been rigorously demonstrated that histone variants encode unique mechanical properties. Here, we present a new theoretical approach called minimal cylinder analysis that uses strain fluctuations to determine the Young's modulus of nucleosomes from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. Recently, we validated this computational tool against in vitro single-molecule nanoindentation of histone variant nucleosomes. In this report, we further extend minimal cylinder analysis to study the biophysical properties of hybrid nucleosomes that are known to exist in human cancer cells and contain H3 histone variants CENP-A and H3.3. Here, we report that the heterotypic nucleosome has an intermediate elasticity (8.5 ± 0.5 MPa) compared to CENP-A (6.2 ± 0.4 MPa) and H3 (9.8 ± 0.7 MPa) and that the dynamics of both canonical and CENP-A nucleosomes are preserved and partitioned across the nucleosome pseudodyad. Furthermore, we investigate the mechanism by which the elasticity of these heterotypic nucleosomes augments cryptic binding surfaces. From these analyses, we predict that the heterotypic nucleosome is permissive to the binding of one copy of the kinetochore protein CENP-C while still retaining a closed DNA end configuration required for linker histone H1 to bind. We discuss that the ectopic deposition of CENP-A in cancer by H3.3 chaperones HIRA and DAXX may fortuitously result in hybrid nucleosome formation. Using these results, we propose biological outcomes that might arise when such heterotypic nucleosomes occupy large regions of the genome.

Physical virology: From virus self-assembly to particle mechanics

Viruses are highly ordered supramolecular complexes that have evolved to propagate by hijacking the host cell's machinery. Although viruses are very diverse, spreading through cells of all kingdoms of life, they share common functions and properties. Next to the general interest in virology, fundamental viral mechanisms are of growing importance in other disciplines such as biomedicine and (bio)nanotechnology. However, in order to optimally make use of viruses and virus-like particles, for instance as vehicle for targeted drug delivery or as building blocks in electronics, it is essential to understand their basic chemical and physical properties and characteristics. In this context, the number of studies addressing the mechanisms governing viral properties and processes has recently grown drastically. This review summarizes a specific part of these scientific achievements, particularly addressing physical virology approaches aimed to understand the self-assembly of viruses and the mechanical properties of viral particles. Using a physicochemical perspective, we have focused on fundamental studies providing an overview of the molecular basis governing these key aspects of viral systems. This article is categorized under: Biology-Inspired Nanomaterials > Protein and Virus-Based Structures Nanotechnology Approaches to Biology > Nanoscale Systems in Biology.

Intermittency of Deformation and the Elastic Limit of an Icosahedral Virus under Compression

Viruses undergo mesoscopic morphological changes as they interact with host interfaces and in response to chemical cues. The dynamics of these changes, over the entire temporal range relevant to virus processes, are unclear. Here, we report on creep compliance experiments on a small icosahedral virus under uniaxial constant stress. We find that even at small stresses, well below the yielding point and generally thought to induce a Hookean response, strain continues to develop in time via sparse, randomly distributed, relatively rapid plastic events. The intermittent character of mechanical compliance only appears above a loading threshold, similar to situations encountered in granular flows and the plastic deformation of crystalline solids. The threshold load is much smaller for the empty capsids of the brome mosaic virus than for the wild-type virions. The difference highlights the involvement of RNA in stabilizing the assembly interface. Numerical simulations of spherical crystal deformation suggest intermittency is mediated by lattice defect dynamics and identify the type of compression-induced defect that nucleates the transition to plasticity.

Editorial: Physical Virology and the Nature of Virus Infections

Virus particles, 'virions', range in size from nano-scale to micro-scale. They have many different shapes and are composed of proteins, sugars, nucleic acids, lipids, water and solutes. Virions are autonomous entities and affect all forms of life in a parasitic relationship. They infect prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. The physical properties of virions are tuned to the way they interact with cells. When virions interact with cells, they gain huge complexity and give rise to an infected cell, also known as 'virus'. Virion-cell interactions entail the processes of entry, replication and assembly, as well as egress from the infected cell. Collectively, these steps can result in progeny virions, which is a productive infection, or in silencing of the virus, an abortive or latent infection. This book explores facets of the physical nature of virions and viruses and the impact of mechanical properties on infection processes at the cellular and subcellular levels.

Structural determinants of mechanical resistance against breakage of a virus-based protein nanoparticle at a resolution of single amino acids

Virus particles and other protein-based supramolecular complexes have a vast nanotechnological potential. However, protein nanostructures are "soft" materials prone to disruption by force. Whereas some non-biological nanoparticles (NPs) may be stronger, for certain applications protein- and virus-based NPs have potential advantages related to their structure, self-assembly, production, engineering, and/or inbuilt functions. Thus, it may be desirable to acquire the knowledge needed to engineer protein-based nanomaterials with a higher strength against mechanical breakage. Here we have used the capsid of the minute virus of mice to experimentally identify individual chemical groups that determine breakage-related properties of a virus particle. Individual amino acid side chains that establish interactions between building blocks in the viral particle were truncated using protein engineering. Indentation experiments using atomic force microscopy were carried out to investigate the role of each targeted side chain in determining capsid strength and brittleness, by comparing the maximum force and deformation each modified capsid withstood before breaking apart. Side chains with major roles in determining capsid strength against breakage included polar groups located in solvent-exposed positions, and did not generally correspond with those previously identified as determinants of mechanical stiffness. In contrast, apolar side chains buried along the intersubunit interfaces that generally determined capsid stiffness had, at most, a minor influence on strength against disruption. Whereas no correlated variations between strength and either stiffness or brittleness were found, brittleness and stiffness were quantitatively correlated. Implications for developing robust protein-based NPs and for acquiring a deeper physics-based perspective of viruses are discussed.

Maturation of adenovirus primes the protein nano-shell for successful endosomal escape

The ability of adenoviruses to infect a broad range of species has spurred a growing interest in nanomedicine to use adenovirus as a cargo delivery vehicle. While successful maturation of adenovirus and controlled disassembly are critical for efficient infection, the underlying mechanisms regulating these processes are not well understood. Here, we present Atomic Force Microscopy nanoindentation and fatigue studies of adenovirus capsids at different maturation stages to scrutinize their dynamic uncoating properties. Surprisingly, we find that the early intermediate immature (lacking DNA) capsid is mechanically indistinguishable in both break force and spring constant from the mature (containing DNA) capsid. However, mature and immature capsids do display distinct disassembly pathways, as revealed by our mechanically-induced fatigue analysis. The mature capsid first loses the pentons, followed by either long-term capsid stability or abrupt and complete disassembly. However, the immature capsid has a stable penton region and undergoes a stochastic disassembly mechanism, thought to be due to the absence of genomic pressure. Strikingly, the addition of the genome alone is not sufficient to achieve penton destabilization as indicated by the penton stability of the maturation-intermediate mutant, G33A. Full penton destabilization was achieved only when the genome was present in addition to the successful maturation-linked proteolytic cleavage of preprotein VI. Therefore these findings strongly indicate that maturation of adenovirus in concert with genomic pressure induces penton destabilization and thus, primes the capsid for controlled disassembly. This latter aspect is critical for efficient infection and successful cargo delivery.

Loading the dice: The orientation of virus-like particles adsorbed on titanate assisted organosilanized surfaces

The organization of virus-like particles (VLPs) on surfaces is a relevant matter for both fundamental and biomedical sciences. In this work, the authors have tailored surfaces with different surface tension components aiming at finding a relationship with the affinity of the different geometric/surface features of icosahedral P22 VLPs. The surfaces have been prepared by titanate assisted organosilanization with glycidyloxy, amino, and perfluoro silanes. Vibrational and photoelectron spectroscopies have allowed identifying the different functional groups of the organosilanes on the surfaces. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) showed that, irrespective of the organosilane used, the final root mean square roughness remains below 1 nm. Contact angle analyses confirm the effective formation of a set of surface chemistries exhibiting different balance among surface tension components. The study of the adsorption of P22 VLPs has involved the analysis of the dynamics of virus immobilization by fluorescence microscopy and the interpretation of the final VLP orientation by AFM. These analyses give rise to statistical distributions pointing to a higher affinity of VLPs toward perfluorinated surfaces, with a dominant fivefold conformation on this hydrophobic surface, but threefold and twofold symmetries dominating on hydrophilic surfaces. These results can be explained in terms of a reinforced hydrophobic interaction between the perfluorinated surface and the dominating hydrophobic residues present at the P22 pentons.

Determination of prestress and elastic properties of virus capsids

Virus capsids are protein shells that protect the virus genome, and determination of their mechanical properties has been a topic of interest because of their potential use in nanotechnology and therapeutics. It has been demonstrated that stresses exist in virus capsids, even in their equilibrium state, due to their construction. These stresses, termed "prestresses" in this study, closely affect the capsid's mechanical behavior. Three methods-shape-based metric, atomic force microscope indentation, and molecular dynamics-have been proposed to determine the capsid elastic properties without fully accounting for prestresses. In this paper, we theoretically analyze the three methods used for mechanical characterization of virus capsids and numerically investigate how prestresses affect the capsid's mechanical properties. We consolidate all the results and propose that by using these techniques collectively, it is possible to accurately determine both the mechanical properties and prestresses in capsids.

Capsids and Genomes of Jumbo-Sized Bacteriophages Reveal the Evolutionary Reach of the HK97 Fold

Large icosahedral viruses that infect bacteria represent an extreme of the coevolution of capsids and the genomes they accommodate. One subset of these large viruses is the jumbophages, tailed phages with double-stranded DNA genomes of at least 200,000 bp. We explored the mechanism leading to increased capsid and genome sizes by characterizing structures of several jumbophage capsids and the DNA packaged within them. Capsid structures determined for six jumbophages were consistent with the canonical phage HK97 fold, and three had capsid geometries with novel triangulation numbers (T=25, T=28, and T=52). Packaged DNA (chromosome) sizes were larger than the genome sizes, indicating that all jumbophages use a head-full DNA packaging mechanism. For two phages (PAU and G), the sizes appeared very much larger than their genome length. We used two-dimensional DNA gel electrophoresis to show that these two DNAs migrated abnormally due to base modifications and to allow us to calculate their actual chromosome sizes. Our results support a ratchet model of capsid and genome coevolution whereby mutations lead to increased capsid volume and allow the acquisition of additional genes. Once the added genes and larger capsid are established, mutations that restore the smaller size are disfavored.

A large family of viruses share the same fold of the capsid protein as bacteriophage HK97, a virus that infects bacteria. Members of this family use different numbers of the capsid protein to build capsids of different sizes. Here, we examined the structures of extremely large capsids and measured their DNA content relative to the sequenced genome lengths, aiming to understand the process that increases size. We concluded that mutational changes leading to larger capsids become locked in by subsequent changes to the genome organization.

AFM nanoindentation of protein shells, expanding the approach beyond viruses

The archetypical protein nanoshell is the capsid that surrounds viral genomes. These capsids protect the viral RNA or DNA and function as transport vehicle for their nucleic acid. The material properties of a variety of viral capsids have been probed by Atomic Force Microscopy. In particular nanoindentation measurements revealed the complex mechanics of these shells and the intricate interplay of the capsid with its genomic content. Furthermore, effects of capsid protein mutations, capsid maturation and the effect of environmental changes have been probed. In addition, biological questions have been addressed by AFM nanoindentation of viruses and a direct link between mechanics and infectivity has been revealed. Recently, non-viral protein nanoshells have come under intense scrutiny and now the nanoindentation approach has been expanded to such particles as well. Both natural as well as engineered non-viral protein shells have been probed by this technique. Next to the material properties of viruses, therefor also the mechanics of encapsulins, carboxysomes, vault particles, lumazine synthase and artificial protein nanoshells is discussed here.

Vertex-Specific Proteins pUL17 and pUL25 Mechanically Reinforce Herpes Simplex Virus Capsids

Using atomic force microscopy imaging and nanoindentation measurements, we investigated the effect of the minor capsid proteins pUL17 and pUL25 on the structural stability of icosahedral herpes simplex virus capsids. pUL17 and pUL25, which form the capsid vertex-specific component (CVSC), particularly contributed to capsid resilience along the 5-fold and 2-fold but not along the 3-fold icosahedral axes. Our detailed analyses, including quantitative mass spectrometry of the protein composition of the capsids, revealed that both pUL17 and pUL25 are required to stabilize the capsid shells at the vertices. This indicates that herpesviruses withstand the internal pressure that is generated during DNA genome packaging by locally reinforcing the mechanical sturdiness of the vertices, the most stressed part of the capsids.IMPORTANCE In this study, the structural, material properties of herpes simplex virus 1 were investigated. The capsid of herpes simplex virus is built up of a variety of proteins, and we scrutinized the influence of two of these proteins on the stability of the capsid. For this, we used a scanning force microscope that makes detailed, topographic images of the particles and that is able to perform mechanical deformation measurements. Using this approach, we revealed that both studied proteins play an essential role in viral stability. These new insights support us in forming a complete view on viral structure and furthermore could possibly help not only to develop specific antivirals but also to build protein shells with improved stability for drug delivery purposes.

Tuning Viral Capsid Nanoparticle Stability with Symmetrical Morphogenesis

Virus-like particles (VLPs) provide engineering platforms for the design and implementation of protein-based nanostructures. These capsids are comprised of protein subunits whose precise arrangement and mutual interactions determine their stability, responsiveness to destabilizing environments, and ability to undergo morphological transitions. The precise interplay between subunit contacts and the overall stability of the bulk capsid population remains poorly resolved. Approaching this relationship requires a combination of techniques capable of accessing nanoscale properties, such as the mechanics of individual capsids, and bulk biochemical procedures capable of interrogating the stability of the VLP ensemble. To establish such connection, a VLP system is required where the subunit interactions can be manipulated in a controlled fashion. The P22 VLP is a promising platform for the design of nanomaterials and understanding how nanomanipulation of the particle affects bulk behavior. By contrasting single-particle atomic force microscopy and bulk chemical perturbations, we have related symmetry-specific anisotropic mechanical properties to the bulk ensemble behavior of the VLPs. Our results show that the expulsion of pentons at the vertices of the VLP induces a concomitant chemical and mechanical destabilization of the capsid and implicates the capsid edges as the points of mechanical fracture. Subsequent binding of a decoration protein at these critical edge regions restores both chemical and mechanical stability. The agreement between our single molecule and bulk techniques suggests that the same structural determinants govern both destabilizing and restorative mechanisms, unveiling a phenomenological coupling between the chemical and mechanical behavior of self-assembled cages and laying a framework for the analysis and manipulation of other VLPs and symmetric self-assembled structures.

Stability of Norwalk Virus Capsid Protein Interfaces Evaluated by in Silico Nanoindentation

Norwalk virus causes severe gastroenteritis for which there is currently no specific anti-viral therapy. A stage of the infection process is uncoating of the protein capsid to expose the viral genome and allow for viral replication. A mechanical characterization of the Norwalk virus may provide important information relating to the mechanism of uncoating. The mechanical strength of the Norwalk virus has previously been investigated using atomic force microscopy (AFM) nanoindentation experiments. Those experiments cannot resolve specific molecular interactions, and therefore, we have employed a molecular modeling approach to gain insights into the potential uncoating mechanism of the Norwalk capsid. In this study, we perform simulated nanoindentation using a coarse-grained structure-based model, which provides an estimate of the spring constant in good agreement with the experimentally determined value. We further analyze the fracture mechanisms and determine weak interfaces in the capsid structure, which are potential sites to inhibit uncoating by stabilization of these weak interfaces. We conclude by identifying potential target sites at the junction of a weak protein–protein interface.

Material properties of viral nanocages explored by atomic force microscopy

Single-particle nanoindentation by atomic force microscopy (AFM) is an emergent technique to characterize the material properties of nano-sized proteinaceous systems. AFM uses a very small tip attached to a cantilever to scan the surface of the substrate. As a result of the sensitive feedback loop of AFM, the force applied by the tip on the substrate during scanning can be controlled and monitored. By accurately controlling this scanning force, topographical maps of fragile substrates can be acquired to study the morphology of the substrate. In addition, mechanical properties of the substrate like stiffness and breaking point can be determined by using the force spectroscopy capability of AFM. Here we discuss basics of AFM operation and how this technique is used to determine the structure and mechanical properties of protein nanocages, in particular viral particles. Knowledge of morphology as well as mechanical properties is essential for understanding viral life cycles, including genome packaging, capsid maturation, and uncoating, but also contributes to the development of diagnostics, vaccines, imaging modalities, and targeted therapeutic devices based on viruslike particles.

Recent Developments in Molecular Simulation Approaches to Study Spherical Virus Capsids

Viruses are a particularly challenging systems to study via molecular simulation methods. Virus capsids typically consist of over 100 subunit proteins and reach dimensions of over 100 nm; solvated viruses capsid systems can be over 1 million atoms in size. In this review, I will present recent developments which have attempted to overcome the significant computational expense to perform simulations which can inform experimental studies, make useful predictions about biological phenomena and calculate material properties relevant to nanotechnology design efforts.

Integrin and defensin modulate the mechanical properties of adenovirus

The propensity for capsid disassembly and uncoating of human adenovirus is modulated by interactions with host cell molecules like integrins and alpha defensins. Here, we use atomic force microscopy (AFM) nanoindentation to elucidate, at the single-particle level, the mechanism by which binding of these host molecules affects virus particle elasticity. Our results demonstrate the direct link between integrin or defensin binding and the mechanical properties of the virus. We show that the structure and geometry of adenovirus result in an anisotropic elastic response that relates to icosahedral symmetry. This elastic response changes upon binding host molecules. Whereas integrin binding softens the vertex regions, binding of a human alpha defensin has exactly the opposite effect. Our results reveal that the ability of these host molecules to influence adenovirus disassembly correlates with a direct effect on the elastic strength of the penton region. Host factors that influence adenovirus infectivity thus modulate the elastic properties of the capsid. Our findings reveal a direct link between virus-host interactions and capsid mechanics.