Experimental strategies in Laue crystallography

Towards time-resolved diffraction studies with glycogen phosphorylase

Laue diffraction with high intensity, broad-spectrum synchrotron radiation sources allows three-dimensional data sets on protein crystals to be recorded in seconds or milliseconds and opens the way for time-resolved studies on dynamic events in crystals. This chapter briefly reviews the field and describes progress towards time-resolved studies with glycogen phosphorylase. Methods for the synchronization of the start of reaction with the start of data collection have been developed for the phosphorolytic reaction of glycogen phosphorylase. The compound 3,5-dinitrophenylphosphate is photolabile, yielding Pi and the by-product, 3,5-dinitrophenol, which is non-reactive with the enzyme. Spectroscopic studies show that the compound has good quantum yield and that photolysis is rapid (greater than 1000 s-1). Release of the dinitrophenylate anion, following a pulse of light from a xenon flash lamp, has been monitored with a diode array spectrophotometer specially adapted for measurements on crystals. In a laboratory X-ray experiment with crystals of glycogen phosphorylase b, release of Pi and formation of the enzyme-product complex have been demonstrated. The way is now open for Laue diffraction studies on the catalytic reaction in the crystal.

The 'fingerprint' that X-rays can leave on structures

BACKGROUND

Exposure of biomacromolecules to ionising radiation results in damage that is initiated by free radicals and progresses through a variety of mechanisms. A widely used technique to study the three-dimensional structures of biomacromolecules is crystallography, which makes use of ionising X-rays. It is crucial to know to what extent structures determined using this technique might be biased by the inherent radiation damage.

RESULTS

The consequences of radiation damage have been investigated for three dissimilar proteins. Similar results were obtained for each protein, atomic B factors increase, unit-cell volumes increase, protein molecules undergo slight rotations and translations, disulphide bonds break and decarboxylation of acidic residues occurs. All of these effects introduce non-isomorphism. The absorbed dose in these experiments can be reached during routine data collection at undulator beamlines of third generation synchrotron sources.

CONCLUSIONS

X-rays can leave a 'fingerprint' on structures, even at cryogenic temperatures. Serious non-isomorphism can be introduced, thus hampering multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) and multiwavelength anomalous dispersion (MAD) phasing methods. Specific structural changes can occur before the traditional measures of radiation damage have signalled it. Care must be taken when assigning structural significance to features that might easily be radiation-damage-induced changes. It is proposed that the electron-affinic disulphide bond traps electrons that migrate over the backbone of the protein, and that the sidechains of glutamic acid and aspartic acid donate electrons to nearby electron holes and become decarboxylated successively. The different disulphide bonds in each protein show a clear order of susceptibility, which might well relate to their intrinsic stability.

Neutron Laue diffractometry with an imaging plate provides an effective data collection regime for neutron protein crystallography

Neutron quasi-Laue diffraction data (2 A resolution) from tetragonal hen egg-white lysozyme were collected in ten days with neutron imaging plates. The data processing Laue software, LAUEGEN, developed for X-ray Laue diffractometry, was adapted for neutron diffractometry with a cylindrical detector. The data analysis software, X-PLOR, was modified and used for the refinement of hydrogen atoms, and the positions of 960 hydrogen atoms in the protein and 157 bound water molecules, were determined. Several examples are given of the methods used to identify hydrogen atoms and water molecules.

Femtosecond time resolution in x-ray diffraction experiments

This paper presents the theoretical background for a synthesis of femtosecond spectroscopy and x-ray diffraction. When a diffraction quality crystal with 0.1-0.3 mm overall dimensions is photoactivated by a femtosecond laser pulse (physical length = 0.3 microm), the evolution of molecules at separated points in the crystal will not be simultaneous because a finite time is required for the laser pulse to propagate through the body of the crystal. Utilizing this lack of global crystal synchronization, topographic x-ray diffraction may enable femtosecond temporal resolution to be achieved from reflection profiles in the diffraction pattern with x-ray exposures of picosecond or longer duration. Such x-ray pulses are currently available, and could be used to study femtosecond reaction dynamics at atomic resolution on crystals of both small- and macromolecules. A general treatment of excitation and diffraction geometries in relation to spatial and temporal resolution is presented.

Laue diffraction as a tool in dynamic studies: hydrolysis of a transiently stable intermediate in catalysis by trypsin

A transiently stable intermediate in trypsin catalysis, guanidinobenzoyl-Ser-195 trypsin, can be trapped and then released by control of the pH in crystals of the enzyme. This effect has been investigated by static and dynamic white-beam Laue crystallography. Comparison of structures determined before and immediately after a pH jump reveals the nature of concerted changes that accompany activation of the enzyme. Careful analysis of the results of several structure determinations gives information about the reliability of Laue results in general. A study of multiple exposures taken under differing conditions of beam intensity, crystal quality, and temperature revealed information about ways to control damage of specimens by the X-ray beam.

Time-resolved X-ray diffraction studies of enzymes under cryoconditions

Cryoenzymological techniques provide a means of initiating enzymatic reactions in crystals homogeneously and of prolonging the lifetimes of intermediate reaction steps. Catalytic intermediates may accumulate to sufficiently high population for X-ray crystal structure analysis by time-resolved monochromatic or Laue diffraction data collection using synchrotron radiation. Due to short exposure times, intermediates may be studied at moderately low temperatures. A combination of cryoenzymology and time-resolved crystallography has been applied to crystal structure analysis at high resolution of an acyl-enzyme intermediate of a productive reaction catalysed by porcine pancreatic elastase.

Art is long and time is fleeting: the current problems and future prospects for time-resolved enzyme crystallography

I offer comments on the challenges and problems of the future based on the papers in this volume. First, the requirement of the Laue technique for a very well-ordered crystal is a major obstacle to many studies. Efforts to ease this problem are needed. Secondly, the fundamental issues in time-resolved crystallography are now chemical rather than crystallographic. Methods for the rapid initiation of many reactions must be developed. Thirdly, it is imperative that the kinetics of the process in question be studied in the crystal before any diffraction experiments are done. We need better ways to make those solid state kinetic measurements. Fourthly, we should make use of combined methods, such as cryoenzymology plus Laue diffraction or site-directed mutagenesis plus Laue diffraction, to bring many processes into the time regime in which we currently can work. Fifthly, we have to be able to deconvolute diffraction data that come from a mixture of two or three discrete species. Finally, no matter how powerful our synchrotrons get, it seems to me that some of the most important events in any enzymatic reaction are not going to be accessible: consider the formation and decomposition of a transition state as an example. I close by discussing the role of computational biochemistry in filling in those frames of our enzymatic movie that we cannot observe directly by time-resolved X-ray crystallography.

Laue and monochromatic diffraction studies on catalysis in phosphorylase b crystals

The conversion of substrate, heptenitol, to product, beta-1-C-methyl, alpha-D-glucose-1-phosphate (heptulose-2-P), in crystals of glycogen phosphorylase b has been studied by Laue and monochromatic diffraction methods. The phosphorolysis reaction in the crystal was started following liberation of phosphate from a caged phosphate compound, 3,5-dinitrophenyl phosphate (DNPP). The photolysis of DNPP, stimulated by flashes from a xenon flash lamp, was monitored in the crystal with a diode array spectrophotometer. In the Laue diffraction experiments, data to 2.8 A resolution were collected and the first time shot was obtained at 3 min from the start of reaction, and data collection comprised three 800-ms exposures. Careful data processing of Laue photographs for the large enzyme resulted in electron density maps of almost comparable quality to those produced by monochromatic methods. The difference maps obtained from the Laue measurements showed that very little catalysis had occurred 3 min and 1 h after release of phosphate, and a distinct peak consistent with the position expected for phosphate, in the attacking position was observed. Data collection times with monochromatic crystallographic methods on a home source took 16 h for data to 2.3 A resolution. Sufficient phosphate was released from the caged phosphate in the crystal from 5 flashes with a xenon flashlamp within 1 min for the reaction to go to completion within the time scale of the monochromatic data collection procedures. The heptulose-2-P product complex has been refined and the model agrees with that obtained previously with the major difference that the interchange of an aspartic acid (Asp 283) by an arginine (Arg 569) was not observed at the catalytic site. This change is part of the activation process of glycogen phosphorylase and may not have taken place in the current experiments because the caged compound binds weakly at the inhibitor site, restricting conformational change, and because activators of the enzymic reaction were not present in the crystal. In experiments with monochromatic radiation in which low phosphate concentrations were generated either by fewer photons or by diffusion of known phosphate concentrations, mixtures of substrate and product were observed. It was not possible through crystallographic refinement at 2.3 A resolution to establish the fractional occupancies of the enzyme-substrate and enzyme-product complexes, but the results did indicate that the reaction was proceeding slowly, consistent with approximate calculations for the likely rate of the reaction in the crystal.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)