Errors in biased estimators for parametric ultrasonic imaging

Tissue typing using ultrasound RF time series: experiments with animal tissue samples

PURPOSE

This article provides experimental evidence to show that the time series of radiofrequency (RF) ultrasound data can be used for tissue typing. It also explores the tissue typing information in RF time series. Clinical and high-frequency ultrasound are studied.

METHODS

Bovine liver, pig liver, bovine muscle, and chicken breast were used in the experiments as the animal tissue types. In the proposed approach, the authors record RF echo signals backscattered from tissue, while the imaging probe and the tissue are stationary. This sequence of recorded RF data generates a time series of RF echoes for each spatial sample of the RF signal. The authors use spectral and fractal features of ultrasound RF time series averaged over a region of interest, along with feedforward neural networks for tissue typing. The experiments are repeated at ultrasound frequency of 6.6 and also 55 MHz. The effects of increasing power and frame rate are studied.

RESULTS

The methodology yielded an average two-class classification accuracy of 95.1% when ultrasound data were acquired at 6.6 MHz and 98.1% when data were collected with a high-frequency probe operating at 55 MHz. In four-class classification experiments, the recorded accuracies were 78.6% and 86.5% for low and high-frequency ultrasound data, respectively. A set of 12 texture features extracted from the B-mode image equivalents of the RF data yields an accuracy of only 77.5% in typing the analyzed tissues. An increase in acoustic power and the frame rate of ultrasound results in an improvement in classification results.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study demonstrate that RF time series can be used for ultrasound-based tissue typing. Further investigation of the underlying physical mechanisms is necessary.

Ultrasonic data compression via parameter estimation

Ultrasonic imaging in medical and industrial applications often requires a large amount of data collection. Consequently, it is desirable to use data compression techniques to reduce data and to facilitate the analysis and remote access of ultrasonic information. The precise data representation is paramount to the accurate analysis of the shape, size, and orientation of ultrasonic reflectors, as well as to the determination of the properties of the propagation path. In this study, a successive parameter estimation algorithm based on a modified version of the continuous wavelet transform (CWT) to compress and denoise ultrasonic signals is presented. It has been shown analytically that the CWT (i.e., time x frequency representation) yields an exact solution for the time-of-arrival and a biased solution for the center frequency. Consequently, a modified CWT (MCWT) based on the Gabor-Helstrom transform is introduced as a means to exactly estimate both time-of-arrival and center frequency of ultrasonic echoes. Furthermore, the MCWT also has been used to generate a phase x bandwidth representation of the ultrasonic echo. This representation allows the exact estimation of the phase and the bandwidth. The performance of this algorithm for data compression and signal analysis is studied using simulated and experimental ultrasonic signals. The successive parameter estimation algorithm achieves a data compression ratio of (1-5N/J), where J is the number of samples and N is the number of echoes in the signal. For a signal with 10 echoes and 2048 samples, a compression ratio of 96% is achieved with a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) improvement above 20 dB. Furthermore, this algorithm performs robustly, yields accurate echo estimation, and results in SNR enhancements ranging from 10 to 60 dB for composite signals having SNR as low as -10 dB.