Sparsity Constrained Mixture Modeling for the Estimation of Kinetic Parameters in Dynamic PET

A prior information-based multi-population multi-objective optimization for estimating 18F-FDG PET/CT pharmacokinetics of hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

18F fluoro-D-glucose (18F-FDG) positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) pharmacokinetics is an approach for efficiently quantifying perfusion and metabolic processes in the liver, but the conventional single-individual optimization algorithms and single-population optimization algorithms have difficulty obtaining reasonable physiological characteristics from estimated parameters. A prior-based multi-population multi-objective optimization (p-MPMOO) approach using two sub-populations based on two categories of prior information was preliminarily proposed for estimating the 18F-FDG PET/CT pharmacokinetics of patients with hepatocellular carcinoma.

METHODS

PET data from 24 hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) tumors of 5-min dynamic PET/CT supplemented with 1-min static PET at 60 min were prospectively collected. A reversible double-input three-compartment model and kinetic parameters (K1, k2, k3, k4, fa, and [Formula: see text]) were used to quantify the metabolic information. The single-individual Levenberg-Marquardt (LM) algorithm, single-population algorithms (Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), Differential Evolution (DE), and Genetic Algorithm (GA)) and p-MPMO optimization algorithms (p-MPMOPSO, p-MPMODE, and p-MPMOGA) were used to estimate the parameters.

RESULTS

The areas under the curve (AUCs) of the three p-MPMO methods were significantly higher than other methods in K1 and k4 (P < 0.05 in the DeLong test) and the single population optimization in k2 and k3 (P < 0.05), and did not differ from other methods in fa and vb (P > 0.05). Compared with single-population optimization, the three p-MPMO methods improved the significant differences between K1, k2, k3, and k4. The p-MPMOPSO showed significant differences (P < 0.05) in the parameter estimation of k2, k3, k4, and fa. The p-MPMODE is implemented on K1, k2, k3, k4, and fa; The p-MPMOGA does it on all six parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

The p-MPMOO approach proposed in this paper performs well for distinguishing HCC tumors from normal liver tissue.

Compartment model-based nonlinear unmixing for kinetic analysis of dynamic PET images

When no arterial input function is available, quantification of dynamic PET images requires a previous step devoted to the extraction of a reference time-activity curve (TAC). Factor analysis is often applied for this purpose. This paper introduces a novel approach that conducts a new kind of nonlinear factor analysis relying on a compartment model, and computes the kinetic parameters of specific binding tissues jointly. To this end, it capitalizes on data-driven parametric imaging methods to provide a physical description of the underlying PET data, directly relating the specific binding with the kinetics of the non-specific binding in the corresponding tissues. This characterization is introduced into the factor analysis formulation to yield a novel nonlinear unmixing model designed for PET image analysis. This model also explicitly introduces global kinetic parameters that allow for a direct estimation of a binding potential that represents the ratio at equilibrium of specifically bound radioligand to the concentration of nondisplaceable radioligand in each non-specific binding tissue. The performance of the method is evaluated on synthetic and real data to demonstrate its potential interest.

Combined diffusion-relaxometry microstructure imaging: Current status and future prospects

Microstructure imaging seeks to noninvasively measure and map microscopic tissue features by pairing mathematical modeling with tailored MRI protocols. This article reviews an emerging paradigm that has the potential to provide a more detailed assessment of tissue microstructure-combined diffusion-relaxometry imaging. Combined diffusion-relaxometry acquisitions vary multiple MR contrast encodings-such as b-value, gradient direction, inversion time, and echo time-in a multidimensional acquisition space. When paired with suitable analysis techniques, this enables quantification of correlations and coupling between multiple MR parameters-such as diffusivity, T 1 , T 2 , and T 2 ∗ . This opens the possibility of disentangling multiple tissue compartments (within voxels) that are indistinguishable with single-contrast scans, enabling a new generation of microstructural maps with improved biological sensitivity and specificity.

Multidimensional correlation spectroscopic imaging of exponential decays: From theoretical principles to in vivo human applications

Multiexponential modeling of relaxation or diffusion MR signal decays is a popular approach for estimating and spatially mapping different microstructural tissue compartments. While this approach can be quite powerful, it is also limited by the fact that one-dimensional multiexponential modeling is an ill-posed inverse problem with substantial ambiguities. In this article, we present an overview of a recent multidimensional correlation spectroscopic imaging approach to this problem. This approach helps to alleviate ill-posedness by making advantageous use of multidimensional contrast encoding (e.g., 2D diffusion-relaxation encoding or 2D relaxation-relaxation encoding) combined with a regularized spatial-spectral estimation procedure. Theoretical calculations, simulations, and experimental results are used to illustrate the benefits of this approach relative to classical methods. In addition, we demonstrate an initial proof-of-principle application of this kind of approach to in vivo human MRI experiments.

Simultaneous estimation and segmentation from projection data in dynamic PET

PURPOSE

Dynamic positron emission tomography (PET) is known for its ability to extract spatiotemporal information of a radio tracer in living tissue. Information of different functional regions based on an accurate reconstruction of the activity images and kinetic parametric images has been widely studied and can be useful in research and clinical setting for diagnosis and other quantitative tasks. In this paper, our purpose is to present a novel framework for estimating the kinetic parametric images directly from the raw measurement data together with a simultaneous segmentation accomplished through kinetic parameters clustering.

METHOD

An iterative framework is proposed to estimate the kinetic parameter image, activity map and do the segmentation simultaneously from the complete dynamic PET projection data. The clustering process is applied to the kinetic parameter variable rather than to the traditional activity distribution so as to achieve accurate discrimination between different functional areas. Prior information such as total variation regularization is incorporated to reduce the noise in the PET images and a sparseness constraint is integrated to guarantee the solution for kinetic parameters due to the over complete dictionary. Alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) method is used to solve the optimization problem. The proposed algorithm was validated with experiments on Monte Carlo-simulated phantoms and real patient data. Symbol error rate (SER) was defined to evaluate the performance of clustering. Bias and variance of the reconstruction activity images were calculated based on ground truth. Relative mean square error (MSE) was used to evaluate parametric results quantitatively.

RESULT

In brain phantom experiment, when counting rate is 1 × 10⁶ , the bias (variance) of our method is 0.1270 (0.0281), which is lower than maximum likelihood expectation maximization (MLEM) 0.1637 (0.0410) and direct estimation without segmentation (DE) 0.1511 (0.0326). In the Zubal phantom experiment, our method has the lowest bias (variance) 0.1559 (0.0354) with 1 × 10⁵ counting rate, compared with DE 0.1820 (0.0435) and MLEM 0.3043 (0.0644). As for classification, the SER of our method is 18.87% which is the lowest among MLEM + k-means, DE + k-means, and kinetic spectral clustering (KSC). Brain data with MR reference and real patient results also show that the proposed method can get images with clear structure by visual inspection.

CONCLUSION

In this paper, we presented a joint reconstruction framework for simultaneously estimating the activity distribution, parametric images, and parameter-based segmentation of the ROIs into different functional areas. Total variation regularization is performed on the activity distribution domain to suppress noise and preserve the edges between ROIs. An over complete dictionary for time activity curve basis is constructed. SER, bias, variance, and MSE were calculated to show the effectiveness of the proposed method.

Functional Data Analysis of Dynamic PET Data

One application of positron emission tomography (PET), a nuclear imaging technique, in neuroscience involves in vivo estimation of the density of various proteins (often, neuroreceptors) in the brain. PET scanning begins with the injection of a radiolabeled tracer that binds preferentially to the target protein; tracer molecules are then continuously delivered to the brain via the bloodstream. By detecting the radioactive decay of the tracer over time, dynamic PET data are constructed to reflect the concentration of the target protein in the brain at each time. The fundamental problem in the analysis of dynamic PET data involves estimating the impulse response function (IRF), which is necessary for describing the binding behavior of the injected radiotracer. Virtually all existing methods have three common aspects: summarizing the entire IRF with a single scalar measure; modeling each subject separately; and the imposition of parametric restrictions on the IRF. In contrast, we propose a functional data analytic approach that regards each subject's IRF as the basic analysis unit, models multiple subjects simultaneously, and estimates the IRF nonparametrically. We pose our model as a linear mixed effect model in which population level fixed effects and subject-specific random effects are expanded using a B-spline basis. Shrinkage and roughness penalties are incorporated in the model to enforce identifiability and smoothness of the estimated curves, respectively, while monotonicity and non-negativity constraints impose biological information on estimates. We illustrate this approach by applying it to clinical PET data with subjects belonging to three diagnosic groups. We explore differences among groups by means of pointwise confidence intervals of the estimated mean curves based on bootstrap samples.

PROBING IN VIVO MICROSTRUCTURE WITH T 1-T 2 RELAXATION CORRELATION SPECTROSCOPIC IMAGING

Quantitative MR relaxometry can provide unique subvoxel information about the microscopic tissue compartments that are present in a large imaging voxel. However, unambiguously distinguishing between these tissue compartments continues to be challenging with conventional methods due to the illposedness of the inverse problem. This paper describes a new imaging approach, which we call T ₁ Relaxation-T ₂ Relaxation Correlation Spectroscopic Imaging (RR-CSI), that uses two-dimensional relaxation encoding combined with spatially-constrained reconstruction to help overcome illposedness. Results are shown with real data, including what we believe to be the first in vivo demonstration of multidimensional relaxation correlation spectroscopic imaging.

Diffusion-relaxation correlation spectroscopic imaging: A multidimensional approach for probing microstructure

PURPOSE

To propose and evaluate a novel multidimensional approach for imaging subvoxel tissue compartments called Diffusion-Relaxation Correlation Spectroscopic Imaging.

THEORY AND METHODS

Multiexponential modeling of MR diffusion or relaxation data is commonly used to infer the many different microscopic tissue compartments that contribute signal to macroscopic MR imaging voxels. However, multiexponential estimation is known to be difficult and ill-posed. Observing that this ill-posedness is theoretically reduced in higher dimensions, diffusion-relaxation correlation spectroscopic imaging uses a novel multidimensional imaging experiment that jointly encodes diffusion and relaxation information, and then uses a novel constrained reconstruction technique to generate a multidimensional diffusion-relaxation correlation spectrum for every voxel. The peaks of the multidimensional spectrum are expected to correspond to the distinct tissue microenvironments that are present within each macroscopic imaging voxel.

RESULTS

Using numerical simulations, experiment data from a custom-built phantom, and experiment data from a mouse model of traumatic spinal cord injury, diffusion-relaxation correlation spectroscopic imaging is demonstrated to provide substantially better multicompartment resolving power compared to conventional diffusion- and relaxation-based methods.

CONCLUSION

The diffusion-relaxation correlation spectroscopic imaging approach provides powerful new capabilities for resolving the different components of multicompartment tissue models, and can be leveraged to significantly expand the insights provided by MRI in studies of tissue microstructure. Magn Reson Med 78:2236-2249, 2017. © 2017 International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine.

Population Pharmacokinetics of Tracers: A New Tool for Medical Imaging?

Positron emission tomography-computed tomography is a medical imaging method measuring the activity of a radiotracer chosen to accumulate in cancer cells. A recent trend of medical imaging analysis is to account for the radiotracer's pharmacokinetic properties at a voxel (three-dimensional-pixel) level to separate the different tissues. These analyses are closely linked to population pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling. Kineticists possess the cultural background to improve medical imaging analysis. This article stresses the common points with population pharmacokinetics and highlights the methodological locks that need to be lifted.

Joint arterial input function and tracer kinetic parameter estimation from undersampled dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI using a model consistency constraint

PURPOSE

To develop and evaluate a model-based reconstruction framework for joint arterial input function (AIF) and kinetic parameter estimation from undersampled brain tumor dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI (DCE-MRI) data.

METHODS

The proposed method poses the tracer-kinetic (TK) model as a model consistency constraint, enabling the flexible inclusion of different TK models and TK solvers, and the joint estimation of the AIF. The proposed method is evaluated using an anatomic realistic digital reference object (DRO), and nine retrospectively down-sampled brain tumor DCE-MRI datasets. We also demonstrate application to 30-fold prospectively undersampled brain tumor DCE-MRI.

RESULTS

In DRO studies with up to 60-fold undersampling, the proposed method provided TK maps with low error that were comparable to fully sampled data and were demonstrated to be compatible with a third-party TK solver. In retrospective undersampling studies, this method provided patient-specific AIF with normalized root mean-squared-error (normalized by the 90th percentile value) less than 8% at up to 100-fold undersampling. In the 30-fold undersampled prospective study, the proposed method provided high-resolution whole-brain TK maps and patient-specific AIF.

CONCLUSION

The proposed model-based DCE-MRI reconstruction enables the use of different TK solvers with a model consistency constraint and enables joint estimation of patient-specific AIF. TK maps and patient-specific AIF with high fidelity can be reconstructed at up to 100-fold undersampling in k,t-space. Magn Reson Med 79:2804-2815, 2018. © 2017 International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine.

A Bayesian spatial temporal mixtures approach to kinetic parametric images in dynamic positron emission tomography

PURPOSE

Estimation of parametric maps is challenging for kinetic models in dynamic positron emission tomography. Since voxel kinetics tend to be spatially contiguous, the authors consider groups of homogeneous voxels together. The authors propose a novel algorithm to identify the groups and estimate kinetic parameters simultaneously. Uncertainty estimates for kinetic parameters are also obtained.

METHODS

Mixture models were used to fit the time activity curves. In order to borrow information from spatially nearby voxels, the Potts model was adopted. A spatial temporal model was built incorporating both spatial and temporal information in the data. Markov chain Monte Carlo was used to carry out parameter estimation. Evaluation and comparisons with existing methods were carried out on cardiac studies using both simulated data sets and a pig study data. One-compartment kinetic modeling was used, in which K1 is the parameter of interest, providing a measure of local perfusion.

RESULTS

Based on simulation experiments, the median standard deviation across all image voxels, of K1 estimates were 0, 0.13, and 0.16 for the proposed spatial mixture models (SMMs), standard curve fitting, and spatial K-means methods, respectively. The corresponding median mean squared biases for K1 were 0.04, 0.06, and 0.06 for abnormal region of interest (ROI); 0.03, 0.03, and 0.04 for normal ROI; and 0.007, 0.02, and 0.05 for the noise region.

CONCLUSIONS

SMM is a fully Bayesian algorithm which determines the optimal number of homogeneous voxel groups, voxel group membership, parameter estimation, and parameter uncertainty estimation simultaneously. The voxel membership can also be used for classification purposes. By borrowing information from spatially nearby voxels, SMM substantially reduces the variability of parameter estimates. In some ROIs, SMM also reduces mean squared bias.

Direct estimation of tracer-kinetic parameter maps from highly undersampled brain dynamic contrast enhanced MRI

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work was to develop and evaluate a T₁ -weighted dynamic contrast enhanced (DCE) MRI methodology where tracer-kinetic (TK) parameter maps are directly estimated from undersampled (k,t)-space data.

THEORY AND METHODS

The proposed reconstruction involves solving a nonlinear least squares optimization problem that includes explicit use of a full forward model to convert parameter maps to (k,t)-space, utilizing the Patlak TK model. The proposed scheme is compared against an indirect method that creates intermediate images by parallel imaging and compressed sensing before to TK modeling. Thirteen fully sampled brain tumor DCE-MRI scans with 5-second temporal resolution are retrospectively undersampled at rates R = 20, 40, 60, 80, and 100 for each dynamic frame. TK maps are quantitatively compared based on root mean-squared-error (rMSE) and Bland-Altman analysis. The approach is also applied to four prospectively R = 30 undersampled whole-brain DCE-MRI data sets.

RESULTS

In the retrospective study, the proposed method performed statistically better than indirect method at R ≥ 80 for all 13 cases. This approach provided restoration of TK parameter values with less errors in tumor regions of interest, an improvement compared to a state-of-the-art indirect method. Applied prospectively, the proposed method provided whole-brain, high-resolution TK maps with good image quality.

CONCLUSION

Model-based direct estimation of TK maps from k,t-space DCE-MRI data is feasible and is compatible up to 100-fold undersampling. Magn Reson Med 78:1566-1578, 2017. © 2016 International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine.

Greedy Algorithms for Nonnegativity-Constrained Simultaneous Sparse Recovery

This work proposes a family of greedy algorithms to jointly reconstruct a set of vectors that are (i) nonnegative and (ii) simultaneously sparse with a shared support set. The proposed algorithms generalize previous approaches that were designed to impose these constraints individually. Similar to previous greedy algorithms for sparse recovery, the proposed algorithms iteratively identify promising support indices. In contrast to previous approaches, the support index selection procedure has been adapted to prioritize indices that are consistent with both the nonnegativity and shared support constraints. Empirical results demonstrate for the first time that the combined use of simultaneous sparsity and nonnegativity constraints can substantially improve recovery performance relative to existing greedy algorithms that impose less signal structure.