Multiplexing Readout for Time-of-Flight (TOF) PET Detectors Using Striplines

ASICs in PET: what we have and what we need

BACKGROUND

Designing positron emission tomography (PET) scanners involves several significant challenges. These include the precise measurement of the time of arrival of signals, accurate integration of the pulse shape, maintaining low power consumption, and supporting the readout of thousands of channels. To address these challenges, researchers and engineers frequently develop application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), which are custom-designed readout electronics optimized for specific tasks. As a result, a wide range of ASIC solutions has emerged in PET applications. However, there is currently no comprehensive or standardized comparison of these ASIC designs across the field.

METHODS

In this paper, we evaluate the requirements posed to readout electronics in the field of PET, give an overview of the most important ASICs available for PET applications and discuss how to characterize their essential features and performance parameters. We thoroughly review the hardware characteristics of the different circuits, such as the number of readout channels provided, their power consumption, input and output design. Furthermore, we summarize their performance as characterized in literature.

RESULTS

While the ASICs described show common trends towards lower power consumption or a higher number of readout channels over the past two decades, their characteristics and also their performance assessment by the developers, producers and vendors differ in many aspects. To cope with the challenge of selecting a suitable ASIC for a given purpose and PET application from the varying information available, this article suggests a protocol to assess an ASIC's performance parameters and characteristics.

CONCLUSION

ASICs developed for PET applications are versatile. With novel benchmarks set for the impact of scintillator and photosensor on the time-of-flight performance, the pressure on ASICs to deliver higher timing resolution and cope with an even higher data rate is enormous. Latest developments promise new circuits and improvements in time-of-flight performance. This article provides an overview on existing and emerging readout solutions in PET over the past 20 years, which is currently lacking in literature.

A deep neural network for positioning and inter-crystal scatter identification in multiplexed PET detectors: a simulation study

Objective.High-resolution positron emission tomography (PET) relies on the accurate positioning of annihilation photons impinging the crystal array. However, conventional positioning algorithms in light-sharing PET detectors are often limited due to edge effects and/or the absence of additional information for identifying and correcting scattering within the crystal array (known as inter-crystal scattering). This study explores the feasibility of deep neural network (DNN) techniques for more precise event positioning in finely segmented and highly multiplexed PET detectors with light-sharing.Approach.Initially, a Geant4 Application for Tomographic Emission (GATE) simulation was used to study the spatial and statistical properties of inter-crystal scatter (ICS) events in finely segmented LYSO PET detectors. Next, a DNN for crystal localisation was designed, trained and tested with light distributions of photoelectric (P) and Compton + photoelectric (CP) events simulated using optical GATE and an analytical method to speed up data generation. Using the statistical properties of ICS events, an energy-guided positioning algorithm was then built into the DNN. The positioning algorithm enables selection of the unique or first crystal of interaction in P and CP events, respectively. Performance of the DNN was compared with Anger logic using light distributions from simulated 511 keV point sources placed at different locations around a single PET detector module.Main results. The fraction of events forward and backward scattered in the LYSO detector was 0.54 and 0.46, respectively, whereas naïve application of the Klein-Nishina formulation predicts 70% forward scatter. Despite coarse photodetector data due to signal multiplexing, the DNN demonstrated a crystal classification accuracy of 90% for P events and 82% for CP events. For crystal positioning, the DNN outperformed Anger logic by at least 34% and 14% for P and CP events, respectively. Further improvement is somewhat constrained by the physics-specifically, the ratio of backward to forward scattering of gamma rays within the crystal array being close to 1. This prevents selecting the first crystal of interaction in CP events with a high degree of certainty.Significance.Light sharing and multiplexed PET detectors are common in high-resolution PET, yet their traditional positioning algorithms often underperform due to edge effects and/or the difficulty in correcting ICS events. Our study indicates that DNN-based event positioning has the potential to enhance 2D coincidence event positioning accuracy by nearly a factor of 3 compared to Anger logic. However, further improvements are difficult to foresee without additional information such as event timing.

Validation of the design of a high-sensitivity and high-resolution PET system for a preclinical PET/EPR hybrid scanner

We report the development of a high-sensitivity and high-resolution PET subsystem for a next-generation preclinical PET/EPR hybrid scanner for investigating and improving hypoxia imaging with PET. The PET subsystem consists of 14 detector modules (DM) installed within a cylindrical supporting frame whose outer and inner diameters are 115mm and 60mm, respectively. Each DM contains eight detector units (DU) in a row and each DU is made of a 12×12 array of 1×1×10mm3 LYSO crystals (with a 1.05mm pitch) coupled to a 4×4 silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) array that has a 3.2mm pitch (Hamamatsu multi-pixel photon counter (MPPC) array 14161-3050HS-04). The PET subsystem has a 104mm axial field-of-view (AFOV) that is sufficient for full-body mouse imaging, therefore enabling temporal and spatial correlation studies of tumor hypoxia between PET and EPR. It employs 1mm-width crystals to support sub-millimeter image resolution that is desired for mouse imaging. Al-though a DM contains 1,152 LYSO crystals, by use of a newly devised signal readout method only six outputs are produced. Recently a partial prototype of this subsystem consisting of four DMs is built. In this paper, we present performance measurement results obtained for the developed DMs and initial imaging results obtained by the prototype. The developed DMs show uniformly superior performance in identifying the hit crystal and detector unit, in energy resolution, and in coincidence time resolution. The images obtained for a 22Na point source and a 18F-filled U-shaped tube source show an image resolution of about 1.1mm and 1.2mm FWHM in the transverse and axial directions respectively, and demonstrate successful imaging over the entire 104mm AFOV of the prototype. This estimated image resolution however includes the contribution by the source size.

DOI- and TOF-capable PET array detector using double-ended light readout and stripline-based row and column electronic readout

We investigate a highly multiplexing readout for depth-of-interaction (DOI) and time-of-flight PET detector consisting of an N×N crystals whose light outputs at the front and back ends are detected by using silicon photomultipliers (SiPM). The front N×N SiPM array is read by using a stripline (SL) configured to support discrimination of the row position of the signal-producing crystal. The back N×N SiPM array is similarly read by an SL for column discrimination. Hence, the detector has only four outputs. We built 4×4 and 8×8 detector modules (DM) by using 3.0×3.0×20 mm3 lutetium-yttrium oxyorthosilicates. The outputs were sampled and processed offline. For both DMs, crystal discrimination was successful. For the 4×4 DM, we obtained an average energy resolution (ER) of 14.1%, an average DOI resolution of 2.5 mm, a non DOI-corrected coincidence resolving time (CRT), measured in coincidence with a single-pixel reference detector, of about 495 ps. For the 8×8 DM, the average ER, average DOI resolution and average CRT were 16.4%, 2.9 mm, and 641 ps, respectively. We identified the intercrystal scattering as a probable cause for the CRT deterioration when the DM was increased from 4×4 to 8×8.

A Preclinical Positron Emission Tomography (PET) and Electron-Paramagnetic-Resonance-Imaging (EPRI) Hybrid System: PET Detector Module

We report the design and experimental validation of a compact positron emission tomography (PET) detector module (DM) intended for building a preclinical PET and electron-paramagnetic-resonance-imaging hybrid system that supports sub-millimeter image resolution and high-sensitivity, whole-body animal imaging. The DM is eight detector units (DU) in a row. Each DU contains 12×12 lutetium-yttrium oxyorthosilicate (LYSO) crystals having a 1.05 mm pitch read by 4×4 silicon photomultipliers (SiPM) having a 3.2 mm pitch. A small-footprint, highly-multiplexing readout employing only passive electronics is devised to produce six outputs for the DM, including two outputs derived from SiPM cathodes for determining event time and active DU and four outputs derived from SiPM anodes for determining energy and active crystal. Presently, we have developed two DMs that are 1.28×10.24 cm2 in extent and approximately 1.8 cm in thickness, with their outputs sampled at 0.7 GS/s and analyzed offline. For both DMs, our results show successfully discriminated DUs and crystals. With no correction for SiPM nonlinearity, the average energy resolution for crystals in a DU ranges from 14% to 16%. While not needed for preclinical imaging, the DM may support 300-400 ps time-of-flight resolution.

Advances in Detector Instrumentation for PET

During the last 3 decades, PET has become a standard-of-care imaging technique used in the management of cancer and in the characterization of neurologic disorders and cardiovascular disease. It has also emerged as a prominent molecular imaging method to study the basic biologic pathways of disease in rodent models. This review describes the basics of PET detectors, including a detailed description of indirect and direct 511-keV photon detection methods. We will also cover key detector performance parameters and describe detector instrumentation advances during the last decade.