Influence of cell line and cell cycle phase on sonoporation transfection efficiency in cervical carcinoma cells under the same physical conditions

Influence of cell shape on sonoporation efficiency in microbubble-facilitated delivery using micropatterned cell arrays

Microbubble-facilitated sonoporation is a rapid, versatile, and non-viral intracellular delivery technique with potential for clinical and ex vivo cell engineering applications. We developed a micropatterning-based approach to investigate the impact of cell shape on sonoporation efficacy. Cationic microbubbles were employed to enhance sonoporation by binding to the cell membrane electrostatically. NIH/3T3 fibroblasts were micropatterned into circle, square, triangle, and rectangle. A two-plate system ensured high-throughput and efficient sonoporation by controlling cationic microbubble-cell attachment. High-speed video microscopy captured the acoustic dynamics of microbubbles under short ultrasound pulses. Our findings reveal that for NIH/3T3 fibroblasts, rectangular cells achieved the highest sonoporation and survival rate, while square-shaped cells demonstrated the greatest propidium iodide uptake. Triangle-shaped NIH/3T3 fibroblasts displayed an initial rise then a plateau in the sonoporation and survival rate as the ultrasound pulse duration increased from 10 cycles to 100 cycles, and then to 200 cycles. Conversely, rectangle-shaped cells showed a decrease followed by a stabilization. Circle-shaped and rectangle-shaped HeLa cells exhibited similar sonoporation outcomes, which were not as effective as NIH/3T3 fibroblasts. This study underscores the significance of cell shape in optimizing sonoporation efficiency and highlights the potential of combining micropatterning with controlled targeting sonoporation to advance intracellular delivery technologies.

Barrier-breaking effects of ultrasonic cavitation for drug delivery and biomarker release

Recently, emerging evidence has demonstrated that cavitation actually creates important bidirectional channels on biological barriers for both intratumoral drug delivery and extratumoral biomarker release. To promote the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation for both therapy and diagnosis, we first reviewed recent technical advances of ultrasound and its contrast agents (microbubbles, nanodroplets, and gas-stabilizing nanoparticles) and then reported the newly-revealed cavitation physical details. In particular, we summarized five types of cellular responses of cavitation in breaking the plasma membrane (membrane retraction, sonoporation, endocytosis/exocytosis, blebbing and apoptosis) and compared the vascular cavitation effects of three different types of ultrasound contrast agents in breaking the blood-tumor barrier and tumor microenvironment. Moreover, we highlighted the current achievements of the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation in mediating drug delivery and biomarker release. We emphasized that the precise induction of a specific cavitation effect for barrier-breaking was still challenged by the complex combination of multiple acoustic and non-acoustic cavitation parameters. Therefore, we provided the cutting-edge in-situ cavitation imaging and feedback control methods and suggested the development of an international cavitation quantification standard for the clinical guidance of cavitation-mediated barrier-breaking effects.

Landscape of Cellular Bioeffects Triggered by Ultrasound-Induced Sonoporation

Sonoporation is the process of transient pore formation in the cell membrane triggered by ultrasound (US). Numerous studies have provided us with firm evidence that sonoporation may assist cancer treatment through effective drug and gene delivery. However, there is a massive gap in the body of literature on the issue of understanding the complexity of biophysical and biochemical sonoporation-induced cellular effects. This study provides a detailed explanation of the US-triggered bioeffects, in particular, cell compartments and the internal environment of the cell, as well as the further consequences on cell reproduction and growth. Moreover, a detailed biophysical insight into US-provoked pore formation is presented. This study is expected to review the knowledge of cellular effects initiated by US-induced sonoporation and summarize the attempts at clinical implementation.

Ultrasound-Mediated Drug Delivery: Sonoporation Mechanisms, Biophysics, and Critical Factors

Sonoporation, or the use of ultrasound in the presence of cavitation nuclei to induce plasma membrane perforation, is well considered as an emerging physical approach to facilitate the delivery of drugs and genes to living cells. Nevertheless, this emerging drug delivery paradigm has not yet reached widespread clinical use, because the efficiency of sonoporation is often deemed to be mediocre due to the lack of detailed understanding of the pertinent scientific mechanisms. Here, we summarize the current observational evidence available on the notion of sonoporation, and we discuss the prevailing understanding of the physical and biological processes related to sonoporation. To facilitate systematic understanding, we also present how the extent of sonoporation is dependent on a multitude of factors related to acoustic excitation parameters (ultrasound frequency, pressure, cavitation dose, exposure time), microbubble parameters (size, concentration, bubble-to-cell distance, shell composition), and cellular properties (cell type, cell cycle, biochemical contents). By adopting a science-backed approach to the realization of sonoporation, ultrasound-mediated drug delivery can be more controllably achieved to viably enhance drug uptake into living cells with high sonoporation efficiency. This drug delivery approach, when coupled with concurrent advances in ultrasound imaging, has potential to become an effective therapeutic paradigm.

Mechanisms underlying sonoporation: Interaction between microbubbles and cells

The past several decades have witnessed great progress in "smart drug delivery", an advance technology that can deliver genes or drugs into specific locations of patients' body with enhanced delivery efficiency. Ultrasound-activated mechanical force induced by the interactions between microbubbles and cells, which can stimulate so-called "sonoporation" process, has been regarded as one of the most promising candidates to realize spatiotemporal-controllable drug delivery to selected regions. Both experimental and numerical studies were performed to get in-depth understanding on how the microbubbles interact with cells during sonoporation processes, under different impact parameters. The current work gives an overview of the general mechanism underlying microbubble-mediated sonoporation, and the possible impact factors (e.g., the properties of cavitation agents and cells, acoustical driving parameters and bubble/cell micro-environment) that could affect sonoporation outcomes. Finally, current progress and considerations of sonoporation in clinical applications are reviewed also.

The relation of Bleomycin Delivery Efficiency to Microbubble Sonodestruction and Cavitation Spectral Characteristics

The concurrent assessment of principal sonoporation factors has been accomplished in a single systemic study. Microbubble sonodestruction dynamics and cavitation spectral characteristics, ultrasound scattering and attenuation, were examined in relation to the intracellular delivery of anticancer drug, bleomycin. Experiments were conducted on Chinese hamster ovary cells coadministered with Sonovue microbubbles. Detailed analysis of the scattering and attenuation temporal functions culminated in quantification of metrics, inertial cavitation dose and attenuation rate, suitable for cavitation control. The exponents, representing microbubble sonodestruction kinetics were exploited to derive dosimetric, microbubble sonodestruction rate. High intracorrelation between empirically-attained metrics defines the relations which indicate deep physical interdependencies within inherent phenomena. Subsequently each quantified metric was validated to be well-applicable to prognosticate the efficacy of bleomycin delivery and cell viability, as indicated by strong overall correlation (R² > 0.85). Presented results draw valuable insights in sonoporation dosimetry and contribute towards the development of universal sonoporation dosimetry model. Both bleomycin delivery and cell viability reach their respective plateau levels by the time, required to attain total microbubble sonodestruction, which accord with scattering and attenuation decrease to background levels. This suggests a well-defined criterion, feasible through signal-registration, universally employable to set optimal duration of exposure for efficient sonoporation outcome.

Ultrasound- and Microbubble-Assisted Gemcitabine Delivery to Pancreatic Cancer Cells

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is a major cause of cancer death worldwide. Poor drug delivery to tumours is thought to limit chemotherapeutic treatment efficacy. Sonoporation combines ultrasound (US) and microbubbles to increase the permeability of cell membranes. We assessed gemcitabine uptake combined with sonoporation in vitro in three PDAC cell lines (BxPC-3, MIA PaCa-2 and PANC-1). Cells were cultured in hypoxic bioreactors, while gemcitabine incubation ± sonoporation was conducted in cells with operational or inhibited nucleoside membrane transporters. Intracellular active metabolite (dFdCTP), extracellular gemcitabine, and inactive metabolite (dFdU) concentrations were measured with liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. Sonoporation with increasing US intensities resulted in decreasing extracellular gemcitabine concentrations in all three cell lines with inhibited membrane transporters. In cells with inhibited membrane transporters, without sonoporation, dFdCTP concentrations were reduced down to 10% of baseline. Sonoporation partially restored gemcitabine uptake in these cells, as indicated by a moderate increase in dFdCTP concentrations (up to 37% of baseline) in MIA PaCa-2 and PANC-1. In BxPC-3, gemcitabine was effectively inactivated to dFdU, which might represent a protective mechanism against dFdCTP accumulation in these cells. Intracellular dFdCTP concentrations did not change significantly following sonoporation in any of the cell lines with operational membrane transporters, indicating that the gemcitabine activation pathway may have been saturated with the drug. Sonoporation allowed a moderate increase in gemcitabine transmembrane uptake in all three cell lines, but pre-existing nucleoside transporters were the major determinants of gemcitabine uptake and retention.

Breast Cancer Cell Line Phenotype Affects Sonoporation Efficiency Under Optimal Ultrasound Microbubble Conditions

Background

Ultrasound/microbubble (USMB)-mediated sonoporation is a new strategy with minimal procedural invasiveness for targeted and site-specific drug delivery to tumors. The purpose of this study was to explore the effect of different breast cancer cell lines on sonoporation efficiency, and then to identify an optimal combination of USMB parameters to maximize the sonoporation efficiency for each tumor cell line.

Material/Methods

Three drug-sensitive breast cell lines – MCF-7, MDA-MB-231, and MDA-MB-468 – and 1 multidrug resistance (MDR) cell line – MCF-7/ADR – were chosen. An orthogonal array experimental design approach based on 3 levels of 3 parameters (A: microbubble concentration, 10%, 20%, and 30%, B: sound intensity, 0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 W/cm², C: irradiation time, 30, 60, and 90 s) was employed to optimize the sonoporation efficiency.

Results

The optimal USMB parameter combinations for different cell lines were diverse. Under optimal parameter combinations, the maximum sonoporation efficiency differences between different breast tumor cell lines were statistically significant (MDA-MB-231: 46.70±5.79%, MDA-MB-468: 53.44±5.69%, MCF-7: 59.88±5.53%, MCF-7/ADR: 65.39±4.01%, P<0.05), so were between drug-sensitive cell line and MDR cell line (MCF-7: 59.88±5.53%, MCF-7/ADR: 65.39±4.01%, p=0.026).

Conclusions

Different breast tumor cell lines have their own optimal sonoporation. Drug-resistant MCF-7/ADR cells had higher sonoporation efficiency than drug-sensitive MCF-7 cells. The molecular subtype of tumors should be considered when sonoporation is applied, and optimal parameter combination may have the potential to improve drug-delivery efficiency by increasing the sonoporation efficiency.

Effect of Molecular Weight on Sonoporation-Mediated Uptake in Human Cells

Ultrasound-induced microbubble destruction can enhance drug delivery to cells. The molecular weight of therapeutic compounds varies significantly (from <1 kDa for small molecule drugs, to 7-15 kDa for siRNAs/miRNAs, to >1000 kDa for DNA plasmids). Therefore, the objective of this study was to determine the relationship between uptake efficiency and molecular weight using equal molar concentrations. Uptake efficiency of fluorescent compounds with different molecular weights (0.3, 10 and 2000 kDa) was explored in vitro using human cardiac mesenchymal cells and breast cancer cells exposed to microbubbles and 2.5-MHz ultrasound pulses. Uptake by viable cells was quantified using flow cytometry. After correction for the fluorescence yield of each compound, there was a significant size-dependent difference in fluorescence intensity, indicating an inverse relationship between size and uptake efficiency. These results suggest that diffusion of therapeutic compounds across permeabilized cell membranes may be an important mechanism for ultrasound-mediated drug delivery.

Advances in mechanism studies on ultrasonic gene delivery at cellular level

Ultrasound provides a means for intracellular gene delivery, contributing to a noninvasive and spatiotemporally controllable strategy suitable for clinical applications. Many studies have been done to provide mechanisms of ultrasound-mediated gene delivery at the cellular level. This review summarizes the studies on the important aspects of the mechanisms, providing an overview of recent progress in cellular experiment of ultrasound-mediated gene delivery.

Synthetic siRNA targeting human papillomavirus 16 E6: a perspective on in vitro nanotherapeutic approaches

High-risk human papillomaviruses infect skin and mucosa, causing approximately 5% of cancers worldwide. In the search for targeted nanotherapeutic approaches, siRNAs against the viral E6 transcript have been molecules of interest but have not yet seen successful translation into the clinic. By reviewing the past approximately 15 years of in vitro literature, we identify the need for siRNA validation protocols which concurrently evaluate ranges of key treatment parameters as well as characterize downstream process restoration in a methodical, quantitative manner and demonstrate their implementation using our own data. We also reflect on the future need for more appropriate cell culture models to represent patient lesions as well as the application of personalized approaches to identify optimal treatment strategies.

Cell-cycle-specific Cellular Responses to Sonoporation

Microbubble-mediated sonoporation has shown its great potential in facilitating intracellular uptake of gene/drugs and other therapeutic agents that are otherwise difficult to enter cells. However, the biophysical mechanisms underlying microbubble-cell interactions remain unclear. Particularly, it is still a major challenge to get a comprehensive understanding of the impact of cell cycle phase on the cellular responses simultaneously occurring in cell membrane and cytoskeleton induced by microbubble sonoporation. Methods: Here, efficient synchronizations were performed to arrest human cervical epithelial carcinoma (HeLa) cells in individual cycle phases. The, topography and stiffness of synchronized cells were examined using atomic force microscopy. The variations in cell membrane permeabilization and cytoskeleton arrangement induced by sonoporation were analyzed simultaneously by a real-time fluorescence imaging system. Results: The results showed that G1-phase cells typically had the largest height and elastic modulus, while S-phase cells were generally the flattest and softest ones. Consequently, the S-Phase was found to be the preferred cycle for instantaneous sonoporation treatment, due to the greatest enhancement of membrane permeability and the fastest cytoskeleton disassembly at the early stage after sonoporation. Conclusion: The current findings may benefit ongoing efforts aiming to pursue rational utilization of microbubble-mediated sonoporation in cell cycle-targeted gene/drug delivery for cancer therapy.

Influence of tumor cell lines derived from different tissue on sonoporation efficiency under ultrasound microbubble treatment

To reveal the effect of tumor cell lines derived from different tissue on sonoporation efficiency under ultrasound microbubble (USMB) treatment, and meanwhile to determine the optimum parameter combination for each tumor cell line. Human breast tumor (MCF-7), ovarian tumor (A2780), liver tumor (Bel7402) and thyroid tumor (ARO) were exposed to ultrasound in the presence of SonoVue MBs. The major parameters for the designed experiments including MB concentration (A1:10%, A2:20%, A3:30%), sound intensity (B1:0.5, B2:1.0, B3:1.5W/cm²), irradiation time (C1:30, C2:60, C3:90s). An orthogonal array experimental design based on three levels L9 (3³) of the above three parameters was employed to optimize the sonoporation efficiency. MTT experiment was used to calculate cell survival rate. FD500 uptake assay and cytometry were performed to evaluate transference percentage. The optimum parameter combination for each tumor cell line was different (MCF-7: A3B1C1, A2780: A1B3C3, Bel7402: A2B3C2, ARO: A2B3C2). Under their own optimum parameter combination, four kinds of tumor cell line exhibited different optimum sonoporation efficiency (MCF-7: 55.05±5.29%; A2780: 45.62±7.35%; Bel7402: 39.37±4.11%; ARO: 53.37±3.94%). Multiple comparison with LSD-t test showed that the sonoporation efficiency between four kinds of cell line was statistically significant (P<0.05), with the exception of MCF-7 VS. ARO (P=0.487). Tumor cell lines derived from different tissue can impact the sonoporation efficiency, and optimizing the exposure parameters can safely and efficiently increase the cell membrane permeability.

Sonoporation efficacy on SiHa cells in vitro at raised bath temperatures-experimental validation of a prototype sonoporation device

BACKGROUND

A device was devised which aimed to reduce the time and expertise required to perform sonoporation on adherent cell cultures. This prototype device was used to examine the superficial effect of bath temperature on sonoporation efficacy.

METHODS

The prototype device consisted of six ultrasound transducers affixed beneath an Opticell stage. Six transducers with nominal diameters of 20 mm were constructed and the acoustic field of each was characterized using hydrophone scanning. A near field treatment plane was chosen for each transducer to minimize field heterogeneity in the near field. Cervical cancer-derived SiHa cells were exposed to nine different treatments in the presence of plasmid DNA-expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP). Ultrasound treatment with Definity ultrasound contrast agent (US+UCA) present, ultrasound treatment without contrast agent present (US), and a sham ultrasound treatment in the presence of ultrasound contrast agent (CA) were each performed at bath temperatures of 37, 39.5, and 42 °C. Each treatment was performed in biological triplicate. GFP expression and PARP expression following treatment were measured using fluorescent microscopy and digital image processing. Cell detachment was measured using phase contrast microscopy before and after treatment.

RESULTS

Mean (± s.d.) transfection rates for the US+UCA treatment were 5.4(±0.92), 5.8(±1.3), and 5.3(±1.1) % at 37, 39.5, and 42 °C, respectively. GFP expression and cell detachment were both significantly affected by the presence of ultrasound contrast agent (p < 0.001, p < 0.001). Neither GFP expression, PARP expression, or detachment differed significantly between bath temperatures.

CONCLUSIONS

Bath temperature did not impact the efficacy of sonoporation treatment on SiHa cells in vitro. The prototype device was found to be suitable for performing sonoporation on adherent cell cultures and will reduce the time and expertise required for conducting sonoporation experiments on adherent cell cultures in the future.

Cell experimental studies on sonoporation: state of the art and remaining problems

Sonoporation is the formation of transient pores on cell membrane by ultrasound exposure. Sonoporation can be applied to the increasing delivery of drug or gene into cells. However, there are some problems encountered in sonoporation studies. The mechanisms to produce sonoporation are very complicated; there are too many experimental parameters affecting the sonoporation results; and there are many bio-effects accompanied with sonoporation. In the article, the cell experimental studies on sonoporation were sorted, including experimental methods, mechanisms to produce sonoporation, correlations between sonoporation experimental parameters and results, and bioeffects accompanied with sonoporation. We'd like to make the concepts about sonoporation clearer. The sonoporation technology may be a promising auxiliary technology to promote drug or gene therapy in the future.