Resolution and brightness characteristics of short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) images

Comparative Assessment of Real-Time and Offline Short-Lag Spatial Coherence Imaging of Ultrasound Breast Masses

OBJECTIVE

To perform the first known investigation of differences between real-time and offline B-mode and short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) images when evaluating fluid or solid content in 60 hypoechoic breast masses.

METHODS

Real-time and retrospective (i.e., offline) reader studies were conducted with three board-certified breast radiologists, followed by objective, reader-independent discrimination using generalized contrast-to-noise ratio (gCNR).

RESULTS

The content of 12 fluid, solid and mixed (i.e., containing fluid and solid components) masses were uncertain when reading real-time B-mode images. With real-time and offline SLSC images, 15 and 5, respectively, aggregated solid and mixed masses (and no fluid masses) were uncertain. Therefore, with real-time SLSC imaging, uncertainty about solid masses increased relative to offline SLSC imaging, while uncertainty about fluid masses decreased relative to real-time B-mode imaging. When assessing real-time SLSC reader results, 100% (11/11) of solid masses with uncertain content were correctly classified with a gCNR<0.73 threshold applied to real-time SLSC images. The areas under receiver operator characteristic curves characterizing gCNR as an objective metric to discriminate complicated cysts from solid masses were 0.963 and 0.998 with real-time and offline SLSC images, respectively, which are both considered excellent for diagnostic testing.

CONCLUSION

Results are promising to support real-time SLSC imaging and gCNR application to real-time SLSC images to enhance sensitivity and specificity, reduce reader variability, and mitigate uncertainty about fluid or solid content, particularly when distinguishing complicated cysts (which are benign) from hypoechoic solid masses (which could be cancerous).

Spatial Coherence Approaches to Distinguish Suspicious Mass Contents in Fundamental and Harmonic Breast Ultrasound Images

When compared to fundamental B-mode imaging, coherence-based beamforming, and harmonic imaging are independently known to reduce acoustic clutter, distinguish solid from fluid content in indeterminate breast masses, and thereby reduce unnecessary biopsies during a breast cancer diagnosis. However, a systematic investigation of independent and combined coherence beamforming and harmonic imaging approaches is necessary for the clinical deployment of the most optimal approach. Therefore, we compare the performance of fundamental and harmonic images created with short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC), M-weighted SLSC (M-SLSC), SLSC combined with robust principal component analysis with no M-weighting (r-SLSC), and r-SLSC with M-weighting (R-SLSC), relative to traditional fundamental and harmonic B-mode images, when distinguishing solid from fluid breast masses. Raw channel data acquired from 40 total breast masses (28 solid, 7 fluid, 5 mixed) were beamformed and analyzed. The contrast of fluid masses was better with fundamental rather than harmonic coherence imaging, due to the lower spatial coherence within the fluid masses in the fundamental coherence images. Relative to SLSC imaging, M-SLSC, r-SLSC, and R-SLSC imaging provided similar contrast across multiple masses (with the exception of clinically challenging complicated cysts) and minimized the range of generalized contrast-to-noise ratios (gCNRs) of fluid masses, yet required additional computational resources. Among the eight coherence imaging modes compared, fundamental SLSC imaging best identified fluid versus solid breast mass contents, outperforming fundamental and harmonic B-mode imaging. With fundamental SLSC images, the specificity and sensitivity to identify fluid masses using the reader-independent metrics of contrast difference, mean lag one coherence (LOC), and gCNR were 0.86 and 1, 1 and 0.89, and 1 and 1, respectively. Results demonstrate that fundamental SLSC imaging and gCNR (or LOC if no coherence image or background region of interest is introduced) have the greatest potential to impact clinical decisions and improve the diagnostic certainty of breast mass contents. These observations are additionally anticipated to extend to masses in other organs.

Ultrasound Imaging Using the Coherence of Estimated Channel Data

This article introduces a novel method to estimate the coherence of ultrasound channel data from beamformed radio frequency (RF) data. Estimates of ultrasound channel data are obtained by spatially filtering acquired RF data in the frequency domain. The frequency response of the spatial filters yields outputs similar to frequency domain representations of individual channel signals. This technique performs multiple normalized cross-correlations from the outputs of multiple spatial filters. The coefficients are summed together for each pixel in the coherence-based image. Simulation results using a 64 element 2.5-MHz phased array showed an improvement in contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of 67%-93% and a 125%-183% improvement in speckle signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) compared with standard beamformed data. Experimental CNR using a tissue-mimicking phantom showed improvement of 43%-58%, and experimentalSNR improvement was 23%-154%. Comparisons to a previously coherence method, short-lag spatial coherence, are also presented. Preliminary in vivo images of the heart and gall bladder are also shown. This method improves CNR enabling improved visualization of anechoic regions such as cyst and blood vessels.

Minimum variance beamforming combined with covariance matrix-based adaptive weighting for medical ultrasound imaging

BACKGROUND

The minimum variance (MV) beamformer can significantly improve the image resolution in ultrasound imaging, but it has limited performance in noise reduction. We recently proposed the covariance matrix-based statistical beamforming (CMSB) for medical ultrasound imaging to reduce sidelobes and incoherent clutter.

METHODS

In this paper, we aim to improve the imaging performance of the MV beamformer by introducing a new pixel-based adaptive weighting approach based on CMSB, which is named as covariance matrix-based adaptive weighting (CMSAW). The proposed CMSAW estimates the mean-to-standard-deviation ratio (MSR) of a modified covariance matrix reconstructed by adaptive spatial smoothing, rotary averaging, and diagonal reducing. Moreover, adaptive diagonal reducing based on the aperture coherence is introduced in CMSAW to enhance the performance in speckle preservation.

RESULTS

The proposed CMSAW-weighted MV (CMSAW-MV) was validated through simulation, phantom experiments, and in vivo studies. The phantom experimental results show that CMSAW-MV obtains resolution improvement of 21.3% and simultaneously achieves average improvements of 96.4% and 71.8% in average contrast and generalized contrast-to-noise ratio (gCNR) for anechoic cyst, respectively, compared with MV. in vivo studies indicate that CMSAW-MV improves the noise reduction performance of MV beamformer.

CONCLUSION

Simulation, experimental, and in vivo results all show that CMSAW-MV can improve resolution and suppress sidelobes and incoherent clutter and noise. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of CMSAW in improving the imaging performance of MV beamformer. Moreover, the proposed CMSAW with a computational complexity of [Formula: see text] has the potential to be implemented in real time using the graphics processing unit.

Spatial Coherence in Medical Ultrasound: A Review

Traditional pulse-echo ultrasound imaging heavily relies on the discernment of signals based on their relative magnitudes but is limited in its ability to mitigate sources of image degradation, the most prevalent of which is acoustic clutter. Advances in computing power and data storage have made it possible for echo data to be alternatively analyzed through the lens of spatial coherence, a measure of the similarity of these signals received across an array. Spatial coherence is not currently explicitly calculated on diagnostic ultrasound scanners but a large number of studies indicate that it can be employed to describe image quality, to adaptively select system parameters and to improve imaging and target detection. With the additional insights provided by spatial coherence, it is poised to play a significant role in the future of medical ultrasound. This review details the theory of spatial coherence in pulse-echo ultrasound and key advances made over the last few decades since its introduction in the 1980s.

Spatiotemporal Coherence to Quantify Sources of Image Degradation in Ultrasonic Imaging

Thermal noise and acoustic clutter signals degrade ultrasonic image quality and contribute to unreliable clinical assessment. When both noise and clutter are prevalent, it is difficult to determine which one is a more significant contributor to image degradation because there is no way to separately measure their contributions in vivo. Efforts to improve image quality often rely on an understanding of the type of image degradation at play. To address this, we derived and validated a method to quantify the individual contributions of thermal noise and acoustic clutter to image degradation by leveraging spatial and temporal coherence characteristics. Using Field II simulations, we validated the assumptions of our method, explored strategies for robust implementation, and investigated its accuracy and dynamic range. We further proposed a novel robust approach for estimating spatial lag-one coherence. Using this robust approach, we determined that our method can estimate the signal-to-thermal noise ratio (SNR) and signal-to-clutter ratio (SCR) with high accuracy between SNR levels of -30 to 40 dB and SCR levels of -20 to 15 dB. We further explored imaging parameter requirements with our Field II simulations and determined that SNR and SCR can be estimated accurately with as few as two frames and sixteen channels. Finally, we demonstrate in vivo feasibility in brain imaging and liver imaging, showing that it is possible to overcome the constraints of in vivo motion using high-frame rate M-Mode imaging.

Covariance Matrix-Based Statistical Beamforming for Medical Ultrasound Imaging

Medical ultrasound image quality is often limited by clutter, which is the dominant mechanism of image degradation. A variety of beamforming methods have been extensively studied to reduce clutter and, thus, enhance ultrasound image quality. This article introduces a new beamforming approach, called covariance matrix-based statistical beamforming (CMSB), to improve the image contrast and preserve the background speckle pattern while simultaneously achieving a high-resolution performance. In CMSB, adaptive selection of subarray length, diagonal reducing, and mean-to-standard-deviation ratio-based subarray averaging are inherently combined to differentiate and reduce off-axis energy effectively. Moreover, rotary averaging prior to diagonal reducing is introduced to preserve speckle statistics. Simulated, experimental, and in vivo datasets were used to evaluate the imaging performance of the proposed method. The quantitative results indicate that, compared with delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming, CMSB leads to average improvements of 44.5% and 97.3% in lateral resolution and contrast, respectively, in phantom experiments. Our work shows that CMSB is capable of improving image resolution and contrast while maintaining the speckle reliably. Preliminary in vivo study also demonstrates that the CMSB can enhance image contrast and lesion detection.

Spatial Coherence Adaptive Clutter Filtering in Color Flow Imaging-Part I: Simulation Studies

The appropriate selection of a clutter filter is critical for ensuring the accuracy of velocity estimates in ultrasound color flow imaging. Given the complex spatio-temporal dynamics of flow signal and clutter, however, the manual selection of filters can be a significant challenge, increasing the risk for bias and variance introduced by the removal of flow signal and/or poor clutter suppression. We propose a novel framework to adaptively select clutter filter settings based on color flow image quality feedback derived from the spatial coherence of ultrasonic backscatter. This framework seeks to relax assumptions of clutter magnitude and velocity that are traditionally required in existing adaptive filtering methods to generalize clutter filtering to a wider range of clinically-relevant color flow imaging conditions. In this study, the relationship between color flow velocity estimation error and the spatial coherence of clutter filtered channel signals was investigated in Field II simulations for a wide range of flow and clutter conditions. This relationship was leveraged in a basic implementation of coherence-adaptive clutter filtering (CACF) designed to dynamically adapt clutter filters at each imaging pixel and frame based on local measurements of spatial coherence. In simulation studies with known scatterer and clutter motion, CACF was demonstrated to reduce velocity estimation bias while maintaining variance on par with conventional filtering.

Spatial Coherence Beamforming With Multi-Line Transmission to Enhance the Contrast of Coherent Structures in Ultrasound Images Degraded by Acoustic Clutter

This work demonstrates that the combination of multi-line transmission (MLT) and short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) imaging improves the contrast of highly coherent structures within soft tissues when compared to both traditional SLSC imaging and conventional delay and sum (DAS) beamforming. Experimental tests with small (i.e., [Formula: see text]-3 mm) targets embedded in homogeneous and heterogeneous backgrounds were conducted. DAS or SLSC images were reconstructed when implementing MLT with varying numbers of simultaneously transmitted beams. In images degraded by acoustic clutter, MLT SLSC achieved up to 34.1 dB better target contrast and up to 16 times higher frame rates when compared to the more conventional single-line transmission SLSC images, with lateral resolution improvements as large as 38.2%. MLT SLSC thus represents a promising technique for clinical applications in which ultrasound visualization of highly coherent targets is required (e.g., breast microcalcifications, kidney stones, and percutaneous biopsy needle tracking) and would otherwise be challenging due to the strong presence of acoustic clutter.

Photoacoustic-Guided Laparoscopic and Open Hysterectomy Procedures Demonstrated With Human Cadavers

Hysterectomy (i.e., surgical removal of the uterus) requires severing the main blood supply to the uterus (i.e., the uterine arteries) while preserving the nearby, often overlapping, ureters. In this paper, we investigate dual-wavelength and audiovisual photoacoustic imaging-based approaches to visualize and differentiate the ureter from the uterine artery and to provide the real-time information needed to avoid accidental ureteral injuries during hysterectomies. Dual-wavelength 690/750 nm photoacoustic imaging was implemented during laparoscopic and open hysterectomies performed on human cadavers, with a custom display approach designed to visualize the ureter and uterine artery. The proximity of the surgical tool to the ureter was calculated and conveyed by tracking the surgical tool in photoacoustic images and mapping distance to auditory signals. The dual-wavelength display showed up to 10 dB contrast differences between the ureter and uterine artery at three separation distances (i.e., 4 mm, 5 mm, and 6 mm) during the open hysterectomy. During the laparoscopic hysterectomy, the ureter and uterine artery were visualized in the dual-wavelength image with up to 24 dB contrast differences. Distances between the ureter and the surgical tool ranged from 2.47 to 7.31 mm. These results are promising for the introduction of dual-wavelength photoacoustic imaging to differentiate the ureter from the uterine artery, estimate the position of the ureter relative to a surgical tool tip, map photoacoustic-based distance measurements to auditory signals, and ultimately guide hysterectomy procedures to reduce the risk of accidental ureteral injuries.

Real-Time In Vivo Imaging of Human Liver Vasculature Using Coherent Flow Power Doppler: A Pilot Clinical Study

Power Doppler (PD) is a commonly used technique for flow detection and vessel visualization in radiology clinics. Despite its broad set of applications, PD suffers from multiple noise sources and artifacts, such as thermal noise, clutter, and flash artifacts. In addition, a tradeoff exists between acquisition time and Doppler image quality. These limit the ability of clinical PD imaging in deep-lying and small-vessel detection and visualization, particularly among patients with high body mass indices (BMIs). To improve the Doppler vessel detection, we have previously proposed coherent flow PD (CFPD) imaging and demonstrated its performance on porcine vasculature. In this article, we report on a pilot clinical study of CFPD imaging on healthy human volunteers and patients with high BMI to assess the clinical feasibility of the technique in liver imaging. In this study, we built a real-time CFPD imaging system using a graphical processing unit (GPU)-based software beamformer and a CFPD processing module. Using the real-time CFPD imaging system, the liver vasculature of 15 healthy volunteers with normal BMI below 25 and 15 patients with BMI greater than 25 was imaged. Both PD and CFPD image streams were produced simultaneously. The generalized contrast-to-noise ratio (gCNR) of the PD and CFPD images was measured to provide the quantitative evaluation of image quality and vessel detectability. Comparison of PD and CFPD image shows that gCNR is improved by 35% in healthy volunteers and 28% in high BMI patients with CFPD compared to PD. Example images are provided to show that the improvement in the Doppler image gCNR leads to greater detection of small vessels in the liver. In addition, we show that CFPD can suppress in vivo reverberation clutter in clinical imaging.

Iterative Model-Based Beamforming for High Dynamic Range Applications

Clutter produced using bright acoustic sources can obscure weaker acoustic targets, degrading the quality of the image in scenarios with high dynamic ranges. Many adaptive beamformers seek to improve image quality by reducing these sidelobe artifacts, generating a boost in contrast ratio or contrast-to-noise ratio. However, some of these beamformers inadvertently introduce a dark region artifact in place of the strong clutter, a situation that occurs when both clutter and the underlying signal of interest are removed. We introduce the iterative aperture domain model image reconstruction (iADMIRE) method that is designed to reduce clutter while preserving the underlying signal. We compare the contrast ratio dynamic range (CRDR) of iADMIRE to several other adaptive beamformers plus delay-and-sum (DAS) to quantify the accuracy and reliability of the reported measured contrast for each beamformer over a wide range of contrast levels. We also compare all beamformers in the presence of bright targets ranging from 40 to 120 dB to observe the presence of sidelobes. In cases with no added reverberation clutter, iADMIRE had a CRDR of 75.6 dB when compared with the next best method DAS with 60.8 dB. iADMIRE also demonstrated the best performance for levels of reverberation clutter up to 0-dB signal-to-clutter ratio. Finally, iADMIRE restored underlying speckle signal in dark artifact regions while suppressing sidelobes in bright target cases up to 100 dB.

CohereNet: A Deep Learning Architecture for Ultrasound Spatial Correlation Estimation and Coherence-Based Beamforming

Deep fully connected networks are often considered "universal approximators" that are capable of learning any function. In this article, we utilize this particular property of deep neural networks (DNNs) to estimate normalized cross correlation as a function of spatial lag (i.e., spatial coherence functions) for applications in coherence-based beamforming, specifically short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) beamforming. We detail the composition, assess the performance, and evaluate the computational efficiency of CohereNet, our custom fully connected DNN, which was trained to estimate the spatial coherence functions of in vivo breast data from 18 unique patients. CohereNet performance was evaluated on in vivo breast data from three additional patients who were not included during training, as well as data from in vivo liver and tissue mimicking phantoms scanned with a variety of ultrasound transducer array geometries and two different ultrasound systems. The mean correlation between the SLSC images computed on a central processing unit (CPU) and the corresponding DNN SLSC images created with CohereNet was 0.93 across the entire test set. The DNN SLSC approach was up to 3.4 times faster than the CPU SLSC approach, with similar computational speed, less variability in computational times, and improved image quality compared with a graphical processing unit (GPU)-based SLSC approach. These results are promising for the application of deep learning to estimate correlation functions derived from ultrasound data in multiple areas of ultrasound imaging and beamforming (e.g., speckle tracking, elastography, and blood flow estimation), possibly replacing GPU-based approaches in low-power, remote, and synchronization-dependent applications.

GPU implementation of photoacoustic short-lag spatial coherence imaging for improved image-guided interventions

SIGNIFICANCE

Photoacoustic-based visual servoing is a promising technique for surgical tool tip tracking and automated visualization of photoacoustic targets during interventional procedures. However, one outstanding challenge has been the reliability of obtaining segmentations using low-energy light sources that operate within existing laser safety limits.

AIM

We developed the first known graphical processing unit (GPU)-based real-time implementation of short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) beamforming for photoacoustic imaging and applied this real-time algorithm to improve signal segmentation during photoacoustic-based visual servoing with low-energy lasers.

APPROACH

A 1-mm-core-diameter optical fiber was inserted into ex vivo bovine tissue. Photoacoustic-based visual servoing was implemented as the fiber was manually displaced by a translation stage, which provided ground truth measurements of the fiber displacement. GPU-SLSC results were compared with a central processing unit (CPU)-SLSC approach and an amplitude-based delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming approach. Performance was additionally evaluated with in vivo cardiac data.

RESULTS

The GPU-SLSC implementation achieved frame rates up to 41.2 Hz, representing a factor of 348 speedup when compared with offline CPU-SLSC. In addition, GPU-SLSC successfully recovered low-energy signals (i.e., ≤268  μJ) with mean ± standard deviation of signal-to-noise ratios of 11.2  ±  2.4 (compared with 3.5  ±  0.8 with conventional DAS beamforming). When energies were lower than the safety limit for skin (i.e., 394.6  μJ for 900-nm wavelength laser light), the median and interquartile range (IQR) of visual servoing tracking errors obtained with GPU-SLSC were 0.64 and 0.52 mm, respectively (which were lower than the median and IQR obtained with DAS by 1.39 and 8.45 mm, respectively). GPU-SLSC additionally reduced the percentage of failed segmentations when applied to in vivo cardiac data.

CONCLUSIONS

Results are promising for the use of low-energy, miniaturized lasers to perform GPU-SLSC photoacoustic-based visual servoing in the operating room with laser pulse repetition frequencies as high as 41.2 Hz.

Application of the generalized contrast-to-noise ratio to assess photoacoustic image quality

The generalized contrast-to-noise ratio (gCNR) is a relatively new image quality metric designed to assess the probability of lesion detectability in ultrasound images. Although gCNR was initially demonstrated with ultrasound images, the metric is theoretically applicable to multiple types of medical images. In this paper, the applicability of gCNR to photoacoustic images is investigated. The gCNR was computed for both simulated and experimental photoacoustic images generated by amplitude-based (i.e., delay-and-sum) and coherence-based (i.e., short-lag spatial coherence) beamformers. These gCNR measurements were compared to three more traditional image quality metrics (i.e., contrast, contrast-to-noise ratio, and signal-to-noise ratio) applied to the same datasets. An increase in qualitative target visibility generally corresponded with increased gCNR. In addition, gCNR magnitude was more directly related to the separability of photoacoustic signals from their background, which degraded with the presence of limited bandwidth artifacts and increased levels of channel noise. At high gCNR values (i.e., 0.95-1), contrast, contrast-to-noise ratio, and signal-to-noise ratio varied by up to 23.7-56.2 dB, 2.0-3.4, and 26.5-7.6×10²⁰, respectively, for simulated, experimental phantom, and in vivo data. Therefore, these traditional metrics can experience large variations when a target is fully detectable, and additional increases in these values would have no impact on photoacoustic target detectability. In addition, gCNR is robust to changes in traditional metrics introduced by applying a minimum threshold to image amplitudes. In tandem with other photoacoustic image quality metrics and with a defined range of 0 to 1, gCNR has promising potential to provide additional insight, particularly when designing new beamformers and image formation techniques and when reporting quantitative performance without an opportunity to qualitatively assess corresponding images (e.g., in text-only abstracts).

Coherence-Based Beamforming Increases the Diagnostic Certainty of Distinguishing Fluid from Solid Masses in Breast Ultrasound Exams

Ultrasound is often used as a supplement for mammography to detect breast cancer. However, one known limitation is the high false-positive rates associated with breast ultrasound. We investigated the use of coherence-based beamforming (which directly displays spatial coherence) as a supplement to standard ultrasound B-mode images in 25 patients recommended for biopsy (26 masses in total), with the eventual goal of decreasing false-positive rates. Because of the coherent signal present within solid masses, coherence-based beamforming methods allow solid and fluid-filled masses to appear significantly different (p < 0.001). When presented to five board-certified radiologists, the inclusion of robust short-lag spatial coherence (R-SLSC) images in the diagnostic pipeline reduced the uncertainty of fluid-filled mass contents from 47.5% to 15.8% and reduced the percentage of fluid-filled masses unnecessarily recommended for biopsy from 43.3% to 13.3%. These results are promising for the potential introduction of R-SLSC (and related coherence-based beamforming methods) into the breast clinic to improve diagnostic certainty and reduce the number of unnecessary biopsies.

Robust Short-Lag Spatial Coherence Imaging of Breast Ultrasound Data: Initial Clinical Results

Ultrasound is frequently used in conjunction with mammography in order to detect breast cancer as early as possible. However, due largely to the heterogeneity of breast tissue, ultrasound images are plagued with clutter that obstructs important diagnostic features. Short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) imaging has proven to be effective at clutter reduction in noisy ultrasound images. M -Weighted SLSC and Robust-SLSC (R-SLSC) imaging were recently introduced to further improve image quality at higher lag values, while R-SLSC imaging has the added benefit of enabling the adjustment of tissue texture to produce a tissue signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) that is quantitatively similar to B-mode speckle SNR. This paper investigates the initial application of SLSC, M -Weighted SLSC, and R-SLSC imaging to nine targets in the female breast [two simple cysts, one complicated cyst, two fibroadenomas, one hematoma, one complex cystic and solid mass, one invasive ductal carcinoma (IDC), and one ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS)]. As expected, R-SLSC beamforming improves cyst and hematoma contrast by up to 6.35 and 1.55 dB, respectively, when compared to the original B-mode image, and similar improvements are achieved with SLSC and M -Weighted SLSC imaging. However, an interesting finding from this initial investigation is that the solid masses (i.e., fibroadenoma, complex cystic and solid mass, IDC, and DCIS), which appear as hypoechoic in the B-mode image, have similarly high coherence to that of surrounding tissue in coherence-based images. This work holds promise for using SLSC, M -Weighted SLSC, and/or R-SLSC imaging to distinguish between fluid-filled and solid hypoechoic breast masses.

Clinical Utility of Fetal Short-Lag Spatial Coherence Imaging

In this study, we evaluate the clinical utility of fetal short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) imaging. Previous work has documented significant improvements in image quality with fetal SLSC imaging as quantified by measurements of contrast and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). The objective of this study was to examine whether this improved technical efficacy is indicative of the clinical utility of SLSC imaging. Eighteen healthy volunteers in their first and second trimesters of pregnancy were scanned using a modified Siemens SC2000 clinical scanner. Raw channel data were acquired for routinely examined fetal organs and used to generate fully matched raw and post-processed harmonic B-mode and SLSC image sequences, which were subsequently optimized for dynamic range and other imaging parameters by a blinded sonographer. Optimized videos were reviewed in matched B-mode and SLSC pairs by three blinded clinicians who scored each video based on overall quality, target conspicuity and border definition. SLSC imaging was highly favored over conventional imaging with SLSC scoring equal to (28.2 ± 10.5%) or higher than (63.9 ± 12.9%) B-mode for video pairs across all examined structures and processing conditions. Multivariate modeling revealed that SLSC imaging is a significant predictor of improved image quality with p ≤ 0.002. Expert-user scores for image quality support the application of SLSC in fetal ultrasound imaging.

Robust Short-Lag Spatial Coherence Imaging

Short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) imaging displays the spatial coherence between backscattered ultrasound echoes instead of their signal amplitudes and is more robust to noise and clutter artifacts when compared with traditional delay-and-sum (DAS) B-mode imaging. However, SLSC imaging does not consider the content of images formed with different lags, and thus does not exploit the differences in tissue texture at each short-lag value. Our proposed method improves SLSC imaging by weighting the addition of lag values (i.e., M-weighting) and by applying robust principal component analysis (RPCA) to search for a low-dimensional subspace for projecting coherence images created with different lag values. The RPCA-based projections are considered to be denoised versions of the originals that are then weighted and added across lags to yield a final robust SLSC (R-SLSC) image. Our approach was tested on simulation, phantom, and in vivo liver data. Relative to DAS B-mode images, the mean contrast, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) improvements with R-SLSC images are 21.22 dB, 2.54, and 2.36, respectively, when averaged over simulated, phantom, and in vivo data and over all lags considered, which corresponds to mean improvements of 96.4%, 121.2%, and 120.5%, respectively. When compared with SLSC images, the corresponding mean improvements with R-SLSC images were 7.38 dB, 1.52, and 1.30, respectively (i.e., mean improvements of 14.5%, 50.5%, and 43.2%, respectively). Results show great promise for smoothing out the tissue texture of SLSC images and enhancing anechoic or hypoechoic target visibility at higher lag values, which could be useful in clinical tasks such as breast cyst visualization, liver vessel tracking, and obese patient imaging.

Improved Sensitivity in Ultrasound Molecular Imaging With Coherence-Based Beamforming

Ultrasound molecular imaging (USMI) is accomplished by detecting microbubble (MB) contrast agents that have bound to specific biomarkers, and can be used for a variety of imaging applications, such as the early detection of cancer. USMI has been widely utilized in preclinical imaging in mice; however, USMI in humans can be challenging because of the low concentration of bound MBs and the signal degradation caused by the presence of heterogenous soft tissue between the transducer and the lesion. Short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) beamforming has been proposed as a robust technique that is less affected by poor signal quality than standard delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming. In this paper, USMI performance was assessed using contrast-enhanced ultrasound imaging combined with DAS (conventional CEUS) and with SLSC (SLSC-CEUS). Each method was characterized by flow channel phantom experiments. In a USMI-mimicking phantom, SLSC-CEUS was found to be more robust to high levels of additive thermal noise than DAS, with a 6dB SNR improvement when the thermal noise level was +6dB or higher. However, SLSC-CEUS was also found to be insensitive to increases in MB concentration, making it a poor choice for perfusion imaging. USMI performance was also measured in vivo using VEGFR2-targeted MBs in mice with subcutaneous human hepatocellular carcinoma tumors, with clinical imaging conditions mimicked using a porcine tissue layer between the tumor and the transducer. SLSC-CEUS improved the SNR in each of ten tumors by an average of 41%, corresponding to 3.0dB SNR. These results indicate that the SLSC beamformer is well-suited for USMI applications because of its high sensitivity and robust properties under challenging imaging conditions.

Short-lag Spatial Coherence Ultrasound Imaging with Adaptive Synthetic Transmit Aperture Focusing

The short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC) imaging has been demonstrated to be advantageous over the traditional B-mode ultrasound imaging. With focused scanning beams, the SLSC imaging has an excellent performance in clutter reduction and lesion detection, especially in the low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) scenarios. The synthetic aperture (SA) imaging is an appropriate mode for the SLSC imaging as the dynamic transmit focusing could keep a good focusing quality at any depth. However, the SLSC image may still suffer a bad resolution performance when a low lag value is used in the coherence summation to ensure the contrast enhancement. In this paper, an adaptive synthetic transmit (Tx) aperture focusing strategy is proposed for the SLSC imaging with the SA mode. Based on the achievements of adaptive beamforming, a minimum variance beamformer is applied in the Tx aperture to realize adaptive focusing. Spatial coherence is then measured in the receive aperture to form the SLSC image. Simulation and experimental studies were conducted to evaluate the proposed method. Experiments showed that the proposed method not only improved the poor resolution of the original SLSC image but also enhanced the speckle performance, which led to increased contrast-to-noise ratio and speckle SNR values.