Estimation of Shear Wave Speed in the Rhesus Macaques' Uterine Cervix

Biomechanical Cervical Assessment Using 2-Dimentional Transvaginal Shear Wave Elastography in Nonpregnant and Pregnant Women: A Prospective Pilot Study

ABSTRACT

This study evaluated the technical feasibility of 2-dimensional transvaginal shear wave elastography to quantify cervical stiffness in nonpregnant and pregnant women and established normal values in each group. With institutional review board approval, we performed a prospective study with an age-matched historical control design. Sixteen premenopausal nonpregnant women without cervical pathology and 17 low-risk pregnant women (gestational age 17-33 weeks) were enrolled. Cervical shear wave speeds were measured on a SuperSonic Aixplorer machine. The mean shear wave speeds of anterior cervix were 4.96 ± 1.96 m/s in nonpregnant women and 1.92 ± 0.31 m/s in pregnant women. No significant stiffness difference was found between the anterior and posterior cervix (P = 0.15). The upper cervix was stiffer than the lower cervix in the pregnant women (P = 0.00012). Transvaginal shear wave elastography reveals that cervix at a midterm gestation is significantly softer than nonpregnant cervix (P < 0.0001) and suggests a spatial stiffness gradient along the length of the cervix, consistent with histopathology and limited elastography literature. Our results indicate the potential of transvaginal shear wave elastography to provide objective and quantitative estimates of cervical stiffness, especially during pregnancy.

Shear wave dispersion as a potential biomarker for cervical remodeling during pregnancy: evidence from a non-human primate model

Shear wave dispersion (variation of phase velocity with frequency) occurs in tissues with layered and anisotropic microstructure and viscous components, such as the uterine cervix. This phenomenon, mostly overlooked in previous applications of cervical Shear Wave Elasticity Imaging (SWEI) for preterm birth risk assessment, is expected to change drastically during pregnancy due to cervical remodeling. Here we demonstrate the potential of SWEI-based descriptors of dispersion as potential biomarkers for cervical remodeling during pregnancy. First, we performed a simulation-based pre-selection of two SWEI-based dispersion descriptors: the ratio R of group velocities computed with particle-velocity and particle-displacement, and the slope S of the phase velocity vs. frequency. The pre-selection consisted of comparing the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of dispersion descriptors in materials with different degrees of dispersion with respect to a low-dispersive medium. Shear waves induced in these media by SWEI were simulated with a finite-element model of Zener viscoelastic solids. The pre-selection also considered two denoising strategies to improve CNR: a low-pass filter with automatic frequency cutoff determination, and singular value decomposition of shear wave displacements. After pre-selection, the descriptor-denoising combination that produced the largest CNR was applied to SWEI cervix data from 18 pregnant Rhesus macaques acquired at weeks 10 (mid-pregnancy stage) and 23 (late pregnancy stage) of the 24.5-week full pregnancy. A maximum likelihood linear mixed-effects model (LME) was used to evaluate the dependence of the dispersion descriptor on pregnancy stage, maternal age, parity and other experimental factors. The pre-selection study showed that descriptor S combined with singular value decomposition produced a CNR 11.6 times larger than the other descriptor and denoising strategy combinations. In the Non-Human Primates (NHP) study, the LME model showed that descriptor S significantly decreased from mid to late pregnancy (-0.37 ± 0.07 m/s-kHz per week, p <0.00001) with respect to the base value of 15.5 ± 1.9 m/s-kHz. This change was more significant than changes in other SWEI features such as the group velocity previously reported. Also, S varied significantly between the anterior and posterior portions of the cervix (p =0.02) and with maternal age (p =0.008). Given the potential of shear wave dispersion to track cervical remodeling, we will extend its application to ongoing longitudinal human studies.

Quantitative assessment of cervical softening during pregnancy with shear wave elasticity imaging: an in vivo longitudinal study

We report here the results of a longitudinal study of cervix stiffness during pregnancy. Thirty women, ages ranging from 19 to 37 years, were scanned with ultrasound at five time points beginning at their normal first-trimester screening (8-13 weeks) through term pregnancy (nominally 40 week) using a clinical ultrasound imaging system modified with a special ultrasound transducer and system software. The system estimated the shear wave speed (its square proportional to the shear modulus under idealized conditions) in the cervix. We found a constant fractional reduction (about 4% per week) in shear wave speed with increasing gestational age. We also demonstrated a spatial gradient in shear wave speed along the length of the cervix (softest at the distal end). Results were consistent with our previous ex vivo and in vivo work in women. Shear wave elasticity imaging may be a potentially useful clinical tool for objective assessment of cervical softening in pregnancy.

Quantitative Ultrasound Parameters Based on the Backscattered Echo Power Signal as Biomarkers of Cervical Remodeling: A Longitudinal Study in the Pregnant Rhesus Macaque

Clinical prediction and especially prevention of abnormal birth timing, particularly pre-term, is poor. The cervix plays a key role in birth timing; it first serves as a rigid barrier to protect the developing fetus, then becomes the pathway to delivery of that fetus. Imaging biomarkers to define this remodeling process could provide insights to improve prediction of birth timing and elucidate novel targets for preventive therapies. Quantitative ultrasound (QUS) approaches that appear promising for this purpose include shear wave speed (SWS) estimation to quantify softness, as well as parameters based on backscattered power, such as the mean backscattered power difference (mBSPD) and specific attenuation coefficient (SAC), to quantify the organization of tissue microstructure. Invasive studies in rodents demonstrated that as pregnancy advances, cervical microstructure disorganizes as tissue softness and compliance increase. Our non-invasive studies in pregnant women and rhesus macaques suggested that QUS can detect these microstructural changes in vivo. Our previous study in the same cohort showed a progressive decline in SWS during pregnancy, consistent with increasing tissue softness, and we hypothesized that backscatter parameters would also decrease, consistent with increasing microstructural disorganization. In this study, we analyzed the mBSPD and SAC in the cervices of rhesus macaques (n = 18). We found that both mBSPD and SAC decreased throughout pregnancy (p < 0.001 for both parameters) and that the former appears to be a more reliable biomarker. In summary, biomarkers that can characterize tissue microstructural organization are promising for comprehensive characterization of cervical remodeling in pregnancy.

Quantitative Ultrasound Biomarkers Based on Backscattered Acoustic Power: Potential for Quantifying Remodeling of the Human Cervix during Pregnancy

As pregnancy progresses, the cervix remodels from a rigid structure to one pliable enough to allow delivery of a fetus, a process that involves progressive disorganization of cervical microstructure. Quantitative ultrasound biomarkers that may detect this process include those derived from the backscattered echo signal, namely, acoustic attenuation and backscattered power loss. We recently reported that attenuation and backscattered power loss are affected by tissue anisotropy and heterogeneity in the ex vivo cervix. In this study, we compared attenuation and backscattered power difference in a group of women in early pregnancy (first trimester) with those in a group in late pregnancy (third trimester). We observed a significant decrease in the backscattered power difference in late as compared with early pregnancy, suggesting decreased microstructural organization in late pregnancy, a finding that is consistent with animal models of cervical remodeling. In contrast, we found no difference in attenuation between the time points. These results suggest that the backscattered power difference, but perhaps not attenuation, may be a useful clinical biomarker of cervical remodeling.

Quantitative assessment of cervical softening during pregnancy in the Rhesus macaque with shear wave elasticity imaging

Abnormal parturition, e.g. pre- or post-term birth, is associated with maternal and neonatal morbidity and increased economic burden. This could potentially be prevented by accurate detection of abnormal softening of the uterine cervix. Shear wave elasticity imaging (SWEI) techniques that quantify tissue softness, such as shear wave speed (SWS) measurement, are promising for evaluation of the cervix. Still, interpretation of results can be complicated by biological variability (i.e. spatial variations of cervix stiffness, parity), as well as by experimental factors (i.e. type of transducer, posture during scanning). Here we investigated the ability of SWEI to detect cervical softening, as well as sources of SWS variability that can affect this task, in the pregnant and nonpregnant Rhesus macaque. Specifically, we evaluated SWS differences when imaging the cervix transabdominally with a typical linear array abdominal transducer, and transrectally with a prototype intracavitary linear array transducer. Linear mixed effects (LME) models were used to model SWS as a function of menstrual cycle day (in nonpregnant animals) and gestational age (in pregnant animals). Other variables included parity, shear wave direction, and cervix side (anterior versus posterior). In the nonpregnant cervix, the LME model indicated that SWS increased by 2% (95% confidence interval 0-3%) per day, starting eight days before menstruation. During pregnancy, SWS significantly decreased at a rate of 6% (95% CI 5-7%) per week (intracavitary approach) and 3% (95% CI 2-4%) per week (transabdominal approach), and interactions between the scanning approach and other fixed effects were also significant. These results suggest that, while absolute SWS values are influenced by factors such as scanning approach and SWEI implementation, these sources of variability do not compromise the sensitivity of SWEI to cervical softening. Our results also highlight the importance of standardizing SWEI approaches to improve their accuracy for cervical assessment.

Detection of Changes in Cervical Softness Using Shear Wave Speed in Early versus Late Pregnancy: An in Vivo Cross-Sectional Study

The aim of this study was to assess the ability of shear wave elasticity imaging (SWEI) to detect changes in cervical softness between early and late pregnancy. Using a cross-sectional study design, shear wave speed (SWS) measurements were obtained from women in the first trimester (5-14 wk of gestation) and compared with estimates from a previous study of women at term (37-41 wk). Two sets of five SWS measurements were made using commercial SWEI applications on an ultrasound system equipped with a prototype catheter transducer (128 elements, 3-mm diameter, 14-mm aperture). Average SWS estimates were 4.42 ± 0.32 m/s (n = 12) for the first trimester and 2.13 ± 0.66 m/s (n = 18) for the third trimester (p <0.0001). The area under the curve was 0.95 (95% confidence interval: 0.82-0.99) with a sensitivity and specificity of 83%. SWS estimates indicated that the third-trimester cervix is significantly softer than the first-trimester cervix. SWEI methods may be promising for assessing changes in cervical softness.

Cervical elastography during pregnancy: clinical perspectives

Uterine cervix is a part of the uterus responsible for maintaining pregnancy till term. As long as the cervix remains long and firm and its internal orifice (os) is closed, it can withstand enlargement of the uterine contents and resultant growing pressure. Mechanical properties of the cervix change during pregnancy; the cervix ripens prior to delivery, then effaces and dilates with contractions of the uterus. Ripening of the cervix can be assessed using the Bishop score and ultrasonographically determined length of the cervical canal and internal os. Consistency is one of the cervical properties that change during the course of the maturation process. Until recently, cervical consistency has been assessed only manually, but in 2007, the first report on elastographic imaging of the cervix during pregnancy has been published. Elastography presents the ability of a tissue to deform under pressure. The softer the tissue, the easier it changes its shape. Different methods of elastography are used - static, when tissue displacement in response to manual compression or physiological movements of vessels is measured, or dynamic, when the speed of shear wave propagation is determined. Irrespective of the method, elastography provides information on the internal os stiffness; this parameter, impossible for manual assessment, was shown to correlate with pregnancy outcome and is a strong predictor of preterm delivery or successful labor induction. Although elastography seems to be a highly promising diagnostic option, still no consensus has been reached regarding an optimal method for uterine cervix assessment, and virtually all previous studies of various elastographic methods produced highly satisfactory results. Future studies need to identify the most promising and objective elastographic method which may serve as a novel tool for pregnancy management, preventing adverse events, such as preterm delivery and unsuccessful labor induction.

Assessment of Structural Heterogeneity and Viscosity in the Cervix Using Shear Wave Elasticity Imaging: Initial Results from a Rhesus Macaque Model

Shear wave elasticity imaging has shown promise in evaluation of the pregnant cervix. Changes in shear wave group velocity have been attributed exclusively to changes in stiffness. This assumes homogeneity within the region of interest and purely elastic tissue behavior. However, the cervix is structurally/microstructurally heterogeneous and viscoelastic. We therefore developed strategies to investigate these complex tissue properties. Shear wave elasticity imaging was performed ex vivo on 14 unripened and 13 misoprostol-ripened cervix specimens from rhesus macaques. After tests of significant and uniform shear wave displacement, as well as reliability of estimates, group velocity decreased significantly from the distal (vaginal) to proximal (uterine) end of unripened, but not ripened, specimens. Viscosity was quantified by the slope of the phase velocity versus frequency. Dispersion was observed in both groups (median: 5.5 m/s/kHz, interquartile range: 1.5-12.0 m/s/kHz), also decreasing toward the proximal cervix. This work suggests that comprehensive assessment of complex tissues such as cervix requires consideration of structural heterogeneity and viscosity.