Complex suicide by self-stabbing with subsequent drowning in the sea

Complex suicides involving the use of firearms and hanging: A retrospective study and review of the literature

INTRODUCTION

Suicides are the second most common cause of non-natural death in Germany after accidents. Most common is death by hanging, followed by the use of firearms. More frequent "simple" suicides in which one suicide method is used are distinguished from rare "complex" suicides, in which several methods are applied, whereby the combination of gunshot and strangulation is frequently chosen. Such cases require a thorough criminalistic and forensic medical examination to check the plausibility of assumed sequences of events and to detect covered-up homicides.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis of 5,400 post-mortem examinations at the Institute of Legal Medicine Giessen (2009-2018) revealed three cases in which gunshot and hanging were used to commit a planned complex suicide.

RESULTS

Case 1: The body of a 66-year-old carcinoma patient was found hanging from a tree in a kneeling position with a bullet through the head. The post-mortem examination revealed a penetrating head shot, uninjured soft tissues of the neck, no injuries to the hyoid bone or larynx and no signs of congestion. After autopsy, the gunshot through the head was considered as cause of death. Case 2: An 82-year-old man was found dead with two bullet wounds in the chest, hanging in free suspension in a factory hall. The necropsy showed two chest entry wounds with injuries to the heart and lungs as well as a vital ligature mark and fractures of the hyoid bone and larynx without signs of congestion. The combination of hanging and the gunshot wounds was concluded as cause of death. Case 3: The body of an 81-year-old pain patient was found in his home next to a small-caliber rifle, with a noose around his neck, attached to a suspension torn from the wall. The autopsy revealed a tangential shot through the skull with superficial injury to the frontal brain and a vital cord mark on the neck with fractures of the hyoid bone and larynx without signs of strangulation. In this case, hanging was identified as cause of death.

CONCLUSION

Complex suicides are rare events, that require a thorough criminalistic and forensic medical examination Although being called complex suicides and one of the methods usually being suitable to cause death, the cause of death is not always a combined one.

Complex suicides: 21 cases and a review of the literature

Background

The use of more than one potentially lethal method together and sequentially to complete suicide is called “complex suicide.” Complex suicides are divided into two groups: planned and unplanned. This study aimed to discuss with literature 21 complex suicide cases identified after a 2-year retrospective study.

Results

This study included 21 complex suicide cases. Eleven were classified as planned complex suicides, and 10 were labeled as unplanned complex suicides. The average age of all cases was 42.5 ± 17.7 (min: 19, max: 76) years. Suicide notes were present in six (28.5%) cases. Fifteen victims (71.4%) suffered from psychiatric diseases. Twelve victims ingested a toxic dose of medication, nine cases jumped from a height, eight cases used stabbing, six cases used hanging, two cases ingested a corrosive substance, two cases drowned, two cases inhaled a toxic gas, one case ingested cyanide, one case ingested insecticide, and one case used suffocation with a plastic bag. In two cases, three methods of suicide were used together. In the current study, “corrosive substance intake + cyanide intoxication” and “corrosive substance intake + jumping from a height” were defined for the first time and have not been previously described in the literature.

Conclusions

Complex suicides are highly likely to be potentially mistaken for murder. The cause of death in these cases can be determined with a comprehensive autopsy along with a detailed examination of the scene, statements of relatives, and eyewitnesses.

Suicide by drowning: A forensic challenge

In the case of suicidal drowning forensic examination is difficult, particularly with regard to differentiating between suicide, accident, homicide and natural death. Bondage and weighting with objects, putrescence and attendant lesions aggravate interpretation and investigation of postmortal forensic findings. In this respect, two cases of seemingly homicidal drowning with leg and arm bondage and weighting, to prevent resurfacing, are presented and discussed.