Plant-associated microbiota as a source of antagonistic bacteria against the phytopathogen Erwinia amylovora

Reference Genes for Expression Analyses by qRT-PCR in Enterobacter cancerogenus

The Enterobacter cancerogenus strain EcHa1 was isolated from the dead larvae of Helicoverpa armigera, and has the potential for biocontrol of some Lepidoptera insects. In order to screen insecticidal-related genes by qRT-PCR, stable endogenous reference genes used for normalizing qRT-PCR data were selected and evaluated from 13 housekeeping genes (HKGs). The expression levels of the HKGs were determined using qRT-PCR under different experimental conditions, including two culture temperatures and three bacterial OD values. Five stability analysis methods (Ct, BestKeeper, NormFinder, geNorm, and RefFinder) were used to comprehensively rank the candidate genes. The results showed that the optimal reference genes varied under different experimental conditions. The combination of gyrA and gyrB was recommended as the best reference gene combination at 28 °C, while gyrA and rpoB was the best combination at 37 °C. When the OD values were 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0, the recommended reference gene combinations were ftsZ and gyrA, rpoB and gyrB, and gyrA and pyk, respectively. The most suitable reference genes were gyrA and gyrB under all experimental conditions. Using gyrA and gyrB as the reference genes for qRT-PCR, EcHa1 was found to invade all tissues of the H. armigera larvae, and expressed a candidate pathogenic factor Hcp at high levels in gut, Malpighian tubules, and epidermis tissues. This study not only establishes an accurate and reliable normalization for qRT-PCR in entomopathogenic bacteria but also lays a solid foundation for further study of functional genes in E. cancerogenus.

Screening for Novel Beneficial Environmental Bacteria for an Antagonism-Based Erwinia amylovora Biological Control

Erwinia amylovora, the bacterial species responsible for fire blight, causes major economic losses in pome fruit crops worldwide. Chemical control is not always effective and poses a serious threat to the environment and human health. Social demands for eco-sustainable and safe control methods make it necessary to search for new biocontrol strategies such as those based on antagonists. A bacterial collection from different fire blight-free Mediterranean environments was tested for antagonistic activity against Spanish strains of E. amylovora. Antagonistic assays were carried out in vitro in culture medium and ex vivo in immature loquat and pear fruits. Results revealed that 12% of the 82 bacterial isolates tested were able to inhibit the growth of several strains of the pathogen. Some of the isolates also maintained their antagonistic activity even after chloroform inactivation. Selected isolates were further tested ex vivo, with several of them being able to delay and/or reduce fire blight symptom severity in both loquats and pears and having activity against some E. amylovora strains. The isolates showing the best antagonism also produced different hydrolases linked to biocontrol (protease, lipase, amylase, and/or DNAse) and were able to fix molecular nitrogen. Based on this additional characterization, four biocontrol strain candidates were further selected and identified using MALDI-TOF MS. Three of them were Gram-positive bacteria belonging to Bacillus and Paenarthrobacter genera, and the fourth was a Pseudomonas strain. Results provide promising prospects for an improvement in the biological control strategies against fire blight disease.

Microbiome Signature of Endophytes in Wheat Seed Response to Wheat Dwarf Bunt Caused by Tilletia controversa Kühn

Wheat dwarf bunt leads to the replacement of seeds with fungal galls containing millions of teliospores of the pathogen Tilletia controversa Kühn. As one of the most devastating internationally quarantined wheat diseases, wheat dwarf bunt spreads to cause distant outbreaks by seeds containing teliospores. In this study, based on a combination of amplicon sequencing and isolation approaches, we analyzed the seed microbiome signatures of endophytes between resistant and susceptible cultivars after infection with T. controversa. Among 310 bacterial species obtained only by amplicon sequencing and 51 species obtained only by isolation, we found 14 overlapping species by both methods; we detected 128 fungal species only by amplicon sequencing, 56 only by isolation, and 5 species by both methods. The results indicated that resistant uninfected cultivars hosted endophytic communities that were much more stable and beneficial to plant health than those in susceptible infected cultivars. The susceptible group showed higher diversity than the resistant group, the infected group showed more diversity than the uninfected group, and the microbial communities in seeds were related to infection or resistance to the pathogen. Some antagonistic microbes significantly suppressed the germination rate of the pathogen's teliospores, providing clues for future studies aimed at developing strategies against wheat dwarf bunt. Collectively, this research advances the understanding of the microbial assembly of wheat seeds upon exposure to fungal pathogen (T. controversa) infection. IMPORTANCE This is the first study on the microbiome signature of endophytes in wheat seed response to wheat dwarf bunt caused by Tilletia controversa Kühn. Some antagonistic microbes suppressed the germination of teliospores of the pathogen significantly, which will provide clues for future studies against wheat dwarf bunt. Collectively, this research first advances the understanding of the microbial assembly of wheat seed upon exposure to the fungal pathogen (T. controversa) infection.