Systematic review of the association of venous oxygenation and outcome in adult hospitalized patients

Relation Between Multiplication of Venous Carbon Dioxide Partial Pressure (PvCO2) and the Ratio of Gas Flow to Pump Flow (Ve/Q) with Hyperlactatemia During Cardiopulmonary Bypass

BACKGROUND

The incidence of hyperlactatemia due to hypoperfusion during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) increases morbidity. Carbon dioxide production during CPB is one of the lactate production markers, in addition to other markers such as delivery oxygen (DO2), oxygen consumption (VO2), mixed vein oxygen saturation (SvO2), and oxygen extraction ratio (O2ER).

METHOD

This observational analytic study was conducted on 40 adult cardiac surgery patients using a CPB machine. Initial lactate is taken when entering CPB and final lactate is examined 15 min after coming off bypass. The values of DO2, VO2, SvO2, VCO2, respiratory quotient (RQ), DO2/VCO2, PvCO2 × Ve/Q were calculated from the results of blood and venous gas analysis 1 h after entering CPB in the nadir of core temperature and lowest pump flow.

RESULT

The multivariate test showed that the value of PvCO2 × Ve/Q was more effective than other oxygenation and carbon dioxide parameters in predicting an increase in the percentage of lactate. Each increase of 1 mmHg PvCO2 ×× Ve/Q can predict a final lactate increase of 29% from the initial lactate. The high PvCO2 × Ve/Q value is also the strongest correlation factor for the incidence of hyperlactatemia after CPB (final lactate >3 mmol/L). The cutoff value of this marker is >19.3 mmHg, which has a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 55.6% with a strong correlation value.

CONCLUSION

The PvCO2 × Ve/Q value proved to be one of the significant markers in predicting hyperlactatemia during cardiac surgery using CPB.

Perioperative estimations of oxygen consumption from LiDCO™plus-derived cardiac output and Ca-cvO2 difference: Relationship with measurements by indirect calorimetry in elderly patients undergoing major abdominal surgery

BACKGROUND

Feasible estimations of perioperative changes in oxygen consumption (VO2) could enable larger studies of its role in postoperative outcomes. Current methods, either by reverse Fick calculations using pulmonary artery catheterisation or metabolic by breathing gas analysis, are often deemed too invasive or technically requiring. In addition, reverse Fick calculations report generally lower values of oxygen consumption.

METHODS

We investigated the relationship between perioperative estimations of VO2 (EVO2), from LiDCO™plus-derived (LiDCO Ltd, Cambridge, UK) cardiac output and arterial-central venous oxygen content difference (Ca-cvO2), with indirect calorimetry (GVO2) by QuarkRMR (COSMED srl. Italy), using data collected 2017-2018 during a prospective observational study on perioperative oxygen transport in 20 patients >65 years during epidural and general anaesthesia for open pancreatic or liver resection surgery. Eighty-five simultaneous intra- and postoperative measurements at different perioperative stages were analysed for prediction, parallelity and by traditional agreement assessment.

RESULTS

Unadjusted bias between GVO2 and EVO2 indexed for body surface area was 26 (95% CI 20 to 32) with limits of agreement (1.96SD) of -32 to 85 ml min-1m-2. Correlation adjusted for the bias was moderate, intraclass coefficient(A,1) 0.51(95% CI 0.34 to 0.65) [F (84,84) = 3.07, P<0.001]. There was an overall association between GVO2 and EVO2, in a random coefficient model [GVO2 = 73(95% CI 62 to 83) + 0.45(95% CI 0.29 to 0.61) EVO2 ml min-1m-2, P<0.0001]. GVO2 and EVO2 changed in parallel intra- and postoperatively when normalised to their respective overall means.

CONCLUSION

Based on this data, estimations from LiDCO™plus-derived cardiac output and Ca-cvO2 are not reliable as a surrogate for perioperative VO2. Results were in line with previous studies comparing Fick-based and metabolic measurements but limited by variability of data and possible underpowering. The parallelity at different perioperative stages and the prediction model can provide useful guidance and methodological tools for future studies on similar methods in larger samples.

The effects of general anaesthesia on oxygen consumption: A meta-analysis guiding future studies on perioperative oxygen transport

BACKGROUND

Increased oxygen extraction, the ratio of consumption to delivery, has been associated with poor outcome after surgery. Oxygen consumption (VO2) can change in several ways in the perioperative period, but is seldom monitored directly in routine care. This study investigates the effects of general anaesthesia on VO2.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library 1946-2018 for studies including VO2 measurements before and after anaesthesia induction. Quality was assessed by Cochrane risk of bias tool and NIH Quality Assessment tool for before-and-after studies. Changes in VO2 after anaesthesia induction were pooled in a random effects model meta-analysis with standardized mean differences transformed to absolute changes of VO2. Changes in VO2 after surgical incision and after recovery from anaesthesia were analysed as secondary outcomes in the included studies.

RESULTS

Twenty-four studies including 453 patients were analysed for VO2 changes induced by anaesthesia. Studies were published during 1969-2000 and mean age of patients ranged 28-70 years. VO2 decreased after anaesthesia induction by -65 (-75; -55, 95% CI) mL min^-1 and indexed VO2 (VO2I) by -33 (-38; -28, 95% CI) mL min^-1  m^-2 . After surgical incision and in the post-operative period VO2 increased again. Heterogeneity was considerable among the studies and the overall quality of evidence was very low.

CONCLUSIONS

General anaesthesia probably reduces oxygen consumption but the effect estimate is uncertain. Given the limited generalizability and low quality of the available evidence, new studies in modern perioperative settings and in today's older high-risk surgical patient populations are needed.

Peripheral measurements of venous oxygen saturation and lactate as a less invasive alternative for hemodynamic monitoring

Background

Peripheral measurement of venous oxygen saturation and lactate is a less invasive alternative to monitor tissue oxygenation as compared to measurements from a central venous catheter. However, there is a lack of evidence to support the use of peripheral measurements. In this study, we investigated the agreement between central and peripheral venous oxygen saturation and lactate.

Methods

We conducted a prospective observational study including 115 patients who underwent elective cardiac surgery between April and May 2015 at Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark. Measurements were obtained simultaneously at induction of anaesthesia, upon arrival in the ICU and 3–4 h postoperatively. Bias and trending ability was identified using Bland-Altman analysis and a four-quadrant plot.

Results

Bias was 13.37% for venous oxygen saturation preoperatively (95% CI: 11.52–15.22, LoA: ±19.10, PE: 22.08%), 11.29% at arrival to the ICU (95% CI: 8.81–13.77, LoA: ±25.10, PE: 32.39%) and 16.49% at 3–4 h postoperatively (95% CI: 14.16–18.82, LoA: ±21.20, PE: 26.82%). A four-quadrant plot demonstrated an 89% concordance. Central and peripheral lactate showed a bias of 0.14 mmol/L preoperatively (95% CI: 0.11–0.17, LoA: ±0.30, PE: 32.08%), 0.16 mmol/L at arrival to ICU (95% CI: 0.09–0.23, LoA: ±0.70, PE: 38.88%) and 0.23 mmol/L at 3–4 h postoperatively (95% CI: 0.11–0.35, LoA: ±0.50, 25.18%).

Discussion

Measurements of peripheral oxygen saturation and lactate may be valuable in an emergency setting, avoiding unnecessary and time consuming application of a CVC.

Conclusion

We found a high bias but an acceptable trending ability between central and peripheral venous oxygenation. Central and peripheral lactate had excellent agreement. Further studies are necessary to validate the use of peripheral venous samples to identify patients at risk of impaired tissue oxygenation.