Learning curve for fetoscopic laser surgery using cumulative sum analysis

Fetoscopic laser coagulation for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome: a comparison of flexible 1.0/1.2 mm fetoscopes with curved sheaths of 2.7/3.3 mm2 vs. 2 mm fetoscopic lens technique with sheaths of 6.6/11.3 mm2

OBJECTIVES

Fetoscopic laser coagulation of placental anastomoses is usually performed for a treatment of twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS). A common complication of fetoscopic laser coagulation for TTTS is preterm preliminary rupture of fetal membranes (PPROM) aggravating the neonatal outcome significantly. However, use of an flexible 1 mm fetoscope with an curved sheath could reduce iatrogenic damage of the amniotic membrane and improve neonatal outcomes after laser treatment. The aim of this study was to compare neonatal outcomes using this flexible fetoscope with curved sheath vs. use of a standard lens technique.

METHODS

Outcomes were retrospective analyzed after use of a standard lens fetoscope of 2 mm (sheath 6.63 mm2 or 11.27 mm2 for anterior placenta) and a flexible fetoscope of 1 mm or 1.2 mm (sheath 2.65 mm2 or 3.34 mm2) in two German centers of fetal surgery, performed during 2006-2019.

RESULTS

Neonatal outcome of 247 TTTS patients were analyzed including the rates of double and single fetal survival. The survival of at least one fetus was 97.2 % in the group with the ultrathin technique (n=154) compared to 88.3 % (n=93) in the group with the standard lens fetoscope (p=0.008). Survival of both fetuses was not different between groups (81.0 vs. 75.3 %). The procedure to delivery interval was significantly increased using the ultrathin fetoscope (89.1±35.0 d vs. 71.4±35.4 d, p=0.001) resulting in an increased gestational age at delivery by 11 days on average (231.9±28.1 d vs. 221.1±32.7 d, p=0.012).

CONCLUSIONS

Fetal survival can be significantly increased following TTTS using flexible fetoscope of 1 mm or 1.2 mm (sheath 2.65 mm2 or 3.34 mm2).

Patient Survey Regarding Non-Medical Burdens of Care at a Parental Fetal Care Center

Recognizing the paucity of literature describing the non-medical effects of care at a tertiary parental fetal care center upon families, the purpose of the study was to better examine the potential barriers that our patients face related to care in a parental fetal care center. An anonymous survey was sent via email to patients who received care from 2015 to 2021. The survey included questions regarding demographics, fetal diagnoses, non-medical expenses related to care, and the impact of care on patient relationships, employment, and other children. 453 patients (15.9%) responded out of the 2684 emails sent. 58.3% of patients traveled >100 miles to reach our referral center, with 20% traveling >300 miles. 42.6% of patients reported non-medical expenditures exceeding $1000, with nearly 1 in 10 reporting expenditures of >$5000 (8.6%). Overall, 38.2% of women reported moderate to severe financial burdens related to receiving care at the parental fetal care center. This study illuminates the financial and social burdens that care at a tertiary parental fetal care center imposes upon families. By acknowledging these barriers, we can strive to minimize them to best provide equitable access to high-quality fetal care services.

Perinatal and neonatal outcomes for fetoscopic laser ablation for the treatment of twin twin transfusion syndrome at a single center

OBJECTIVE

To describe the perinatal and neonatal outcomes of fetal laser ablation (FLA) for the treatment of twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) in our single center institution.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective study of 76 treated pregnant women. Procedural complications, perinatal and neonatal outcomes analyzed. Differences in outcomes between two procedural techniques, selective and Solomon, compared.

RESULTS

FLA occurred at median gestational age (GA) of 20.8 weeks (IQR 18.1-22.9) with low incidence of procedural complications (5.3%). High survival rate with delivery of at least one neonate (96%) [95% CI: 88.9-99.2%]; 73.7% [95% CI: 62.3-83.1%] were twins. Median GA at birth was 33.1 weeks (IQR 28.0-35.0). Neonatal mortality and morbidities were 9.4% and 48.3% of cases respectively, and associated with lower GA. Solomon cases had comparatively higher median GA, and lower incidences of neonatal morbidities.

CONCLUSION

Our small single center study showed favorable outcomes for using the Solomon technique in the treatment of TTTS.

Pregnancy outcomes following early fetoscopic laser photocoagulation for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome at 16 weeks' gestation

BACKGROUND

Ample evidence supports fetoscopic laser photocoagulation of placental anastomoses as a first-line treatment for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome, but little is known about the outcomes following procedures conducted in the early second trimester.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to evaluate perinatal outcomes following early fetoscopic laser placental photocoagulation performed for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome at 16 weeks' gestation.

STUDY DESIGN

This retrospective review included monochorionic twin pregnancies complicated by twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome necessitating fetoscopic laser photocoagulation at a single tertiary center from 2012 to 2021. The 2 cohorts were defined as cases undergoing laser surgery at 16+0/7 to 16+6/7 weeks' gestation (early laser group) and those undergoing laser surgery ≥17 weeks' gestation (standard laser group), respectively. Primary outcomes included rates of immediate chorioamniotic membrane separation, preterm premature rupture of membranes, and clinical chorioamnionitis. Secondary outcomes included twin survival rates at birth and 30 days of life. Outcomes were compared between cohorts with a P value of <.05 denoting statistical significance.

RESULTS

A total of 343 cases were included (35 early laser participants and 308 standard laser participants). The early laser group typically had higher Quintero staging at the time of the procedure. Following intervention, the early laser group had significantly higher rates of chorioamniotic separation than the standard laser group (34.3% vs 1.3% of cases; P<.001) and higher rates of preterm prelabor rupture of membranes (45.7% vs 25.0%; P=.009) and chorioamnionitis (11.4% vs 1.3%; P=.005). Even after adjustment for higher Quintero staging in the early laser group, twin survival was not significantly different between study groups.

CONCLUSION

Early laser surgery for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome performed at 16 weeks' gestation is associated with significantly higher rates of chorioamniotic separation, preterm rupture of membranes, and chorioamnionitis. However, twin survival does not seem to be negatively impacted following early laser surgery.

International Society for Prenatal Diagnosis 2022 DEBATE: There should be formal accreditation and ongoing quality assurance/review for units offering fetal therapy that includes public reporting of outcomes

The field of fetal therapy has so far escaped from formal accreditation and quality control. Despite that, current published evidence shows that outcomes of interventions in younger fetal therapy centers are similar to what is achieved in more experienced centers and outcomes of interventions have improved over time. The question however remains what is not being published and what should be the standard of care, given the lack of level 1 evidence from randomized controlled trials for many interventions. Formal collaborative networks such as NAFTnet and others allow for anonymized benchmarking of center outcomes, without publicly shaming (and financially punishing) underperforming centers. Large registries also allow for tracking of rare complications and may result in improved patient outcomes over time. Core outcome sets, which could serve as a basis for outcome reporting, are available for some conditions, but certainly not for all, resulting in communication difficulties between centers. Formal accreditation, quality control, and outcome reporting are hard to implement, expensive, and may result in decreasing access to care by pushing smaller centers out of the market. Despite the existing difficulties, international societies have committed to quality improvement, and fetal therapy programs are strongly recommended to participate in voluntary outcome tracking.

Care Levels for Fetal Therapy Centers

Fetal therapies undertaken to improve fetal outcome or to optimize transition to neonate life often entail some level of maternal, fetal, or neonatal risk. A fetal therapy center needs access to resources to carry out such therapies and to manage maternal, fetal, and neonatal complications that might arise, either related to the therapy per se or as part of the underlying fetal or maternal condition. Accordingly, a fetal therapy center requires a dedicated operational infrastructure and necessary resources to allow for appropriate oversight and monitoring of clinical performance and to facilitate multidisciplinary collaboration between the relevant specialties. Three care levels for fetal therapy centers are proposed to match the anticipated care complexity, with appropriate resources to achieve an optimal outcome at an institutional and regional level. A level I fetal therapy center should be capable of offering fetal interventions that may be associated with obstetric risks of preterm birth or membrane rupture but that would be very unlikely to require maternal medical subspecialty or intensive care, with neonatal risks not exceeding those of moderate prematurity. A level II center should have the incremental capacity to provide maternal intensive care and to manage extreme neonatal prematurity. A level III therapy center should offer the full range of fetal interventions (including open fetal surgery) and be able manage any of the associated maternal complications and comorbidities, as well as have access to neonatal and pediatric surgical intervention including indicated surgery for neonates with congenital anomalies.

Placental Abruption after Fetoscopic Laser Surgery in Twin-Twin Transfusion Syndrome: The Role of the Solomon Technique

INTRODUCTION

Twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) is a complication in monochorionic twin pregnancies which is preferably treated with fetoscopic laser surgery. A few small studies suggested a possible association between the Solomon laser technique and placental abruption.

METHODS

The objective of this study is to compare the rate of and to explore potential risk factors for placental abruption in TTTS treated with fetoscopic laser surgery according to the Selective and Solomon laser technique. We conducted a large retrospective cohort study of consecutive TTTS-cases treated with fetoscopic laser surgery in Shanghai, China, and Leiden, The Netherlands treated with either the Selective laser technique (Selective group) or Solomon laser technique (Solomon group).

RESULTS

The rate of placental abruption in the Selective group versus the Solomon group was 1.7% (5/289) and 3.4% (15/441), respectively (p = 0.184). No risk factors for placental abruption were identified. Placental abruption was associated with lower gestational age at birth (p = 0.003) and severe cerebral injury (p = 0.003).

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of placental abruption in TTTS after fetoscopic laser surgery is low, although it appears higher than in the overall population. Placental abruption is associated with a lower gestational age at birth, which is associated with severe cerebral injury. The rate of placental abruption was not significantly increased with the use of the Solomon technique. Continued research of placental abruption in TTTS is necessary to determine why the rate is higher than in the overall population.

Cervical pessary plus vaginal progesterone in a singleton pregnancy with a short cervix: an experience-based analysis of cervical pessary's efficacy

BACKGROUND

Several studies were published about cervical pessary, with controversial results. These studies demonstrated that the patient follow-up after pessary insertion is very different between the study centers and the number of pessary insertions per center was often <30 cases. This study aims to determine cervical pessary performance in singleton pregnancies with a short cervix based on a single center learning curve.

METHODS

Between 2011 and 2018, 128 singleton pregnancies between 18 and 24 gestational weeks with a short cervix (<25 mm) were referred to our clinic. All cases were treated with progesterone, and when available in our supplies (due to low resources) cervical pessary was also offered. Three groups were created for statistical analysis: Group 1 (n = 33), treated with progesterone-only; Groups 2 and 3, treated with cervical pessary plus progesterone. Group 2 included the first cases (n = 30) of pessary, defined by a learning curve and cumulative sum analysis, while Group 3 included the subsequent 65 cases. The primary outcome was preterm birth (PTB) < 34 gestational weeks.

RESULTS

The learning curve was performed with all cases of pessary plus progesterone, and 30 patients were obtained as the number needed for learning, in our study with two operators. The PTB rate < 34 weeks was 27.3, 20, and 4.6% in groups 1, 2, and 3, respectively. There was no significant difference between Group 1 and 2 (OR 1.1; 95% CI 0.066 - 18.45; p = .945). When comparing Groups 1 and 3 there was a significant difference in PTB rates (OR 0.08; CI95% 0.01-0.42; p = .003). Considering Kaplan-Meyer Survival analysis, we can observe that the performance of progesterone alone (Group 1) was similar to Group 2 (progesterone + first 30 cases of pessary) (p = .432), but the performance of Group 3 (progesterone + subsequent 65 cases of pessary) and Group 1 shows a statistically significant difference (p = .011).

CONCLUSION

Learning curve and cumulative sum analysis determined that the application and surveillance of at least 30 patients is required to see significant improvements in the primary outcome of PTB < 34 weeks.

Assessment of operator performance during oocyte retrievals: residents' learning curve and continuous monitoring of senior physicians

BACKGROUND

The learning curve cumulative summation test (LC CUSUM test) allows to define an individualized learning curve and determine the moment when clinical proficiency is attained. After acquisition of the skills, the cumulative summation test (CUSUM test) allows to monitor the maintenance of the required level over time. The LC CUSUM test has been frequently used in the field of Obstetrics and Gynecology (Ob/Gyn) for several procedures, but only once for OR.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective study at Angers university hospital between May 2017 and September 2018. Seven Ob/Gyn residents and 5 senior physicians were included, and all OR performed during that time (n = 690) were analyzed. The performance index assessed was the oocyte retrieval rate (ORR), defined as the ratio of oocytes retrieved to follicles aspirated. We used the LC CUSUM test to analyze the learning curves of residents, and the CUSUM test to monitor the performance of senior physicians. An ORR ≥50% in 60% of retrievals was defined as the threshold for clinical proficiency.

RESULTS

Six hundred seventy-four oocyte retrieval (OR) were included: 315 were performed by residents, 220 by senior physicians, and 139 by both residents and physicians (mixed retrievals). Four residents (57%) reached the threshold after aspirating 82, 67, 53 and 46 ovaries, respectively. The mean number of ovaries aspirated in order to reach clinical proficiency was 62, and the mean number of weeks needed was 21. The duration of the learning period varied between 26 and 80 days. Two senior physicians (40%) remained proficient across the duration of the study, while two physicians (40%) had one statistically "suboptimal" OR, and one physician (20%) had two suboptimal retrievals.

CONCLUSION

There is a large variability in the duration of the learning period and the number of procedures needed for a resident to master OR. Senior physicians maintain an adequate performance.

Validation of a high-fidelity training model for fetoscopic spina bifida surgery

Open fetal surgery for spina bifida (SB) is safe and effective yet invasive. The growing interest in fetoscopic SB repair (fSB-repair) prompts the need for appropriate training. We aimed to develop and validate a high-fidelity training model for fSB-repair. fSB-repair was simulated in the abdominal cavity and on the stomach of adult rabbits. Laparoscopic fetal surgeons served either as novices (n = 2) or experts (n = 3) based on their experience. Technical performance was evaluated using competency Cumulative Sum (CUSUM) analysis and the group splitting method. Main outcome measure for CUSUM competency was a composite binary outcome for surgical success, i.e. watertight repair, operation time ≤ 180 min and Objective-Structured-Assessment-of-Technical-Skills (OSATS) score ≥ 18/25. Construct validity was first confirmed since competency levels of novices and experts during their six first cases using both methods were significantly different. Criterion validity was also established as 33 consecutive procedures were needed for novices to reach competency using learning curve CUSUM, which is a number comparable to that of clinical fSB-repair. Finally, we surveyed expert fetal surgeons worldwide to assess face and content validity. Respondents (26/49; 53%) confirmed it with ≥ 71% of scores for overall realism ≥ 4/7 and usefulness ≥ 3/5. We propose to use our high-fidelity model to determine and shorten the learning curve of laparoscopic fetal surgeons and retain operative skills.

A novel "video-game" simulator for training fetoscopic laser coagulation of anastomoses in twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome

We have developed a high-fidelity interactive "video-game" simulator in order to teach fetoscopic laser ablation of placental anastomoses for twin-twin transfusion syndrome This simulator may be used by teachers in order to provide metrics-based simulator education to multiple trainees, in both hands-on and distanced learning settings WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ABOUT THIS TOPIC?: The use of simulation improves training of the fetoscopic laser techniques utilized in the treatment of twin-twin transfusion syndrome A number of mannequins have been developed to aid this education WHAT DOES THIS STUDY ADD?: Two new simulators are described for twin-twin transfusion syndrome training-silicone and digital The digital simulator is a novel digital video game virtual format This new format has enhanced interactivity and has the potential to enable distance learning.

Learning curves of open and endoscopic fetal spina bifida closure: systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

The Management of Myelomeningocele Study (MOMS) trial demonstrated the safety and efficacy of open fetal surgery for spina bifida aperta (SBA). Recently developed alternative techniques may reduce maternal risks without compromising the fetal neuroprotective effects. The aim of this systematic review was to assess the learning curve (LC) of different fetal SBA closure techniques.

METHODS

MEDLINE, Web of Science, EMBASE, Scopus and Cochrane databases and the gray literature were searched to identify relevant articles on fetal surgery for SBA, without language restriction, published between January 1980 and October 2018. Identified studies were reviewed systematically and those reporting all consecutive procedures and with postnatal follow-up ≥ 12 months were selected. Studies were included only if they reported outcome variables necessary to measure the LC, as defined by fetal safety and efficacy. Two authors independently retrieved data, assessed the quality of the studies and categorized observations into blocks of 30 patients. For meta-analysis, data were pooled using a random-effects model when heterogeneous. To measure the LC, we used two complementary methods. In the group-splitting method, competency was defined when the procedure provided results comparable to those in the MOMS trial for 12 outcome variables representing the immediate surgical outcome, short-term neonatal neuroprotection and long-term neuroprotection at ≥ 12 months of age. Then, when raw patient data were available, we performed cumulative sum analysis based on a composite binary outcome defining successful surgery. The composite outcome combined four clinically relevant variables for safety (absence of extreme preterm delivery < 30 weeks, absence of fetal death ≤ 7 days after surgery) and efficacy (reversal of hindbrain herniation and absence of any neonatal treatment of dehiscence or cerebrospinal fluid leakage at the closure site).

RESULTS

Of 6024 search results, 17 (0.3%) studies were included, all of which had low, moderate or unclear risk of bias. Fetal SBA closure was performed using standard hysterotomy (11 studies), mini-hysterotomy (one study) or fetoscopy by either exteriorized-uterus single-layer closure (one study), percutaneous single-layer closure (three studies) or percutaneous two-layer closure (one study). Only outcomes for standard hysterotomy could be meta-analyzed. Overall, outcomes improved significantly with experience. Competency was reached after 35 consecutive cases for standard hysterotomy and was predicted to be achieved after ≥ 57 cases for mini-hysterotomy and ≥ 56 for percutaneous two-layer fetoscopy. For percutaneous and exteriorized-uterus single-layer fetoscopy, competency was not reached in the 81 and 28 cases available for analysis, respectively, and LC prediction analysis could not be performed.

CONCLUSIONS

The number of cases operated is correlated with the outcome of fetal SBA closure, and the number of operated cases required to reach competency ranges from 35 for standard hysterotomy to ≥ 56-57 for minimally invasive modifications. Our observations provide important information for institutions looking to establish a new fetal center, develop a new fetal surgery technique or train their team, and inform referring clinicians, potential patients and third parties. Copyright © 2019 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Distance Traveled to a Fetal Center and Pregnancy Outcomes in Twin-Twin Transfusion Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Fetoscopic laser photocoagulation (FLP) is the definitive treatment for twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS). Due to variability in geographic proximity to high-volume fetal centers, many patients travel great distances to receive experienced care. We sought to determine whether distance traveled (DT) is associated with gestational age (GA) at delivery and neonatal survival.

METHODS

A prospective cohort study of patients within the continental United States referred to our center between September 23, 2011 and July 25, 2018 undergoing planned FLP for TTTS (n = 393; GA 20.6 ± 2.5 weeks; stage I: n = 50; stage II: n = 118; stage III: n = 208; stage IV: n = 17) was performed. The great-circle distance to our center was calculated using patients' home zip codes. DT was stratified into groups containing equal patient numbers and pregnancy outcomes assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 393 patients met the inclusion criteria. The threshold distance from our center was <250 miles (n = 181), 250-499 miles (n= 119), and ≥500 miles (n = 93). There was no significant difference between any of the preoperative variables among the three groups, with the exception of race and rural status. Furthermore, there was no significant association between DT and GA at delivery (p = 0.34), time interval from procedure to delivery (p = 0.37), and the number of neonatal survivors (p= 0.21). Preterm premature rupture of membranes (PPROM) at <34 weeks was highest (47.9%, p = 0.04) in the group traveling 250-499 miles.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the largest study to show that in TTTS, DT is not associated with GA at delivery, time interval from procedure to delivery, or neonatal survival. Although PPROM at <34 weeks was higher in the group traveling 250-499 miles, there was no significant difference in GA at delivery. While patients with advanced disease may choose to seek treatment based on proximity, traveling long distances does not adversely affect pregnancy outcomes.

The value of echocardiography and Doppler in the prediction of fetal demise after laser coagulation for TTTS: A systematic review and meta-analysis

This study aimed to investigate the value of echocardiography and Doppler before fetoscopic laser coagulation for twin‐twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) in the prediction of intrauterine fetal demise (IUFD). We performed a systematic review and meta‐analysis to compare preoperative parameters between fetuses with and without demise after laser surgery. Eighteen studies were included. Recipient twins have an increased risk of demise in case of preoperative absent/reversed flow (A/REDF) in the umbilical artery (odds ratio [OR] 2.76, 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.78‐4.28), absent or reversed a‐wave in the ductus venosus (OR 2.32, 95% CI, 1.70‐3.16), or a middle cerebral artery peak systolic velocity > 1.5 multiples of the median (MoM) (OR 7.59, 95% CI, 2.56‐22.46). In donors, only A/REDF in the umbilical artery (OR 3.40, 95% CI, 2.68‐4.32) and absent or reversed a‐wave in the ductus venosus (OR 1.66, 95% CI, 1.12‐2.47) were associated with IUFD. No association was found between donor‐IUFD and preoperative myocardial performance index (MPI). Two studies found an association between abnormal MPI and recipient demise. With this study, we have identified a set of preoperative Doppler parameters predictive of fetal demise after laser surgery. More research is needed to assess the utility of preoperative echocardiographic parameters such as the MPI in predicting IUFD.

What's already known about this topic?

Doppler parameters are associated with fetal demise after laser surgery.

Echocardiographic parameters are currently not used in risk stratification.

What does this study add?

A more extensive set of preoperative Doppler parameters is defined to predict post‐laser fetal demise.

The utility of preoperative echocardiographic parameters such as the MPI in predicting fetal demise remains unclear.

Fetal Survival Immediate after Fetoscopic Laser Ablation in Twin to Twin Transfusion Syndrome

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine prognostic factors that can affect the fetal survival immediate after fetoscopic laser ablation.

METHODS

The study population consisted of consecutive twin pregnant women who underwent fetoscopic laser ablation with the diagnosis of twin to twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) from 2011 to 2018 in Seoul National University Hospital. Fetal survival immediate after procedure was defined as survival to 48 hours after procedure and neonatal survival was defined as survival to 28 days of life. Clinical characteristics and ultrasound findings were compared according to the fetal survival immediate after procedure.

RESULTS

A total of 57 pregnant women with TTTS were included, and the overall fetal survival immediate after procedure was 71.1% (81/114) after fetoscopic laser ablation. Fetuses who survived immediate after procedure had higher gestational age at procedure and lower frequency of abnormal Doppler studies than those did not survive. However, the frequency of hydrops was not different between cases with fetal survival and those with fetal death. The earlier gestational age at procedure and the presence of abnormal Doppler studies were significant risk factors for fetal death even after adjustment.

CONCLUSION

Based on this data, the fetal survival immediate after procedure (fetoscopic laser treatment) in TTTS can be affected by the gestational age at procedure and the presence of abnormal Doppler studies.

Outcome reporting across randomized trials and observational studies evaluating treatments for twin-twin transfusion syndrome: systematic review

OBJECTIVE

Twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) is associated with significant mortality and morbidity. Potential treatments for the condition require robust evaluation. The aim of this study was to evaluate outcome reporting across observational studies and randomized controlled trials assessing treatments for TTTS.

METHODS

Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE and MEDLINE were searched from inception to August 2016. Observational studies and randomized controlled trials reporting outcome following treatment for TTTS in monochorionic-diamniotic twin pregnancy and monochorionic-triamniotic or dichorionic-triamniotic triplet pregnancy were included. Outcome reporting was systematically extracted and categorized.

RESULTS

Six randomized trials and 94 observational studies were included, reporting data from 20 071 maternal participants and 3199 children. Six different treatments were evaluated. Included studies reported 62 different outcomes, including six fetal, seven offspring mortality, 25 neonatal, six early childhood and 18 maternal/operative outcomes. Outcomes were reported inconsistently across trials. For example, when considering offspring mortality, 31 (31%) studies reported live birth, 31 (31%) reported intrauterine death, 49 (49%) reported neonatal mortality and 17 (17%) reported perinatal mortality. Four (4%) studies reported respiratory distress syndrome. Only 19 (19%) studies were designed for long-term follow-up and 11 (11%) of these reported cerebral palsy.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies evaluating treatments for TTTS have often neglected to report clinically important outcomes, especially neonatal morbidity outcomes, and most are not designed for long-term follow-up. The development of a core outcome set could help standardize outcome collection and reporting in TTTS studies. Copyright © 2018 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Fetoscopic laser photocoagulation for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome treatment: initial experience in tertiary reference center in Brazil

Objective

To evaluate the initial maternal and perinatal outcomes of fetoscopic laser photocoagulation for the treatment of twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) in a referral center in Brazil.

Methods

This prospective observational study analyzed 24 fetoscopic laser photocoagulation procedures at 18–26 weeks of gestation. TTTS severity was determined using the Quintero classification. Blood vessels that crossed the interamniotic membrane were nonselectively photocoagulated. The χ² test and Mann-Whitney U test were used for the statistical analysis.

Results

The mean (±standard deviation) age of pregnant women, gestational age at surgery, surgical time, gestational age at birth, and newborn weight were 32.2±4.1 years, 20.7±2.9 weeks, 51.8±16.7 minutes, 30.5±4.1 weeks, and 1,531.0±773.1 g, respectively. Using the Quintero classification, there was a higher percentage of cases in stage III (54.2%), followed by stages IV (20.8%), II (16.7%), and I (8.3%). Ten (41.7%) donor fetuses died and 14 (58.3%) donor fetuses survived until the end of gestation. Placental insertion location (anterior vs. posterior) did not affect the incidence of iatrogenic septostomy, surface bleeding, and premature rupture of membranes until the end of gestation. The death rate of donor and recipient fetuses before 24th gestational week increased with severity of TTTS.

Conclusion

The maternal and perinatal outcomes resulting from the implementation of a new minimally invasive surgical technique are in line with those obtained in major centers worldwide, considering the learning curves and infrastructures.

Fetoscopic laser coagulation in 1020 pregnancies with twin-twin transfusion syndrome demonstrates improvement in double-twin survival rate

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the growing experience and learning curve of fetoscopic laser coagulation of the placental vascular anastomoses in severe mid-trimester twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) and its influence on perinatal outcome in a single-center setting.

METHODS

Between January 1995 and March 2013 we performed laser therapy in 1020 consecutive pregnancies with TTTS between 15.1 and 27.4 weeks' gestation. We compared perinatal outcome in blocks of five sequential groups of 200 cases, taking into account several covariates in order to adjust for case mix and to demonstrate learning curves and success rates.

RESULTS

The percentage of pregnancies with survival of both fetuses increased from 50.0% (n = 100) in the first 200 cases to 69.5% (n = 153) in the last 220 cases (P = 0.018 for trend) and the overall survival rate for both fetuses in the complete series of 1019 cases with known outcome was 63.3% (n = 645). The survival rate of at least one fetus increased from 80.5% (161/200) in the first group to 91.8% (202/220) in the last group (P = 0.072 for trend) and the overall survival rate of at least one fetus in the complete series was 86.7% (883/1019). In the total population, the mean gestational age at delivery of pregnancies with at least one liveborn neonate was 33.7 ± 3.2 weeks, with a mean interval of 12.9 ± 4.0 weeks between intervention and delivery. Among the first two groups, 124 pregnancies had anterior placentae and were treated with a 0° fetoscope. These cases had the poorest overall outcome, with a double-twin survival rate of 44.4% (55/124), which increased to 65.1% (207/318; P = 0.001) after the introduction of a 30° fetoscope for cases with anterior placenta. The success rate for double-twin survival reached a plateau of 69% at 600 procedures, a rate equalled by a new operator who was trained hands-on and performed 174 of the last 400 procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

We report the largest single-center experience of laser coagulation in TTTS. We observed a continuous increase in double-twin survival rate owing to the growing experience based on the learning curve and refinements in fetoscopic instruments and techniques. These data provide strong arguments for the centralization of minimally invasive intrauterine surgery in specialized high-volume centers. Copyright © 2017 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

[Fetoscopic laser coagulation in 200 consecutive monochorionic pregnancies with twin-twin transfusion syndrome]

OBJECTIVES

To report preoperative data, surgical characteristics, complications and perinatal outcome of twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) managed with laser ablation surgery, to analyze predictors of neonatal survival and to compare the 100 most recent cases with the older 100.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Observational cohort moncentric study of 200 cases of TTTS consecutively treated with fetoscopic laser coagulation between January 2004 and December 2014.

RESULTS

There were 49 stage I, 88 stage II, 55 stage III and eight stage IV. Median gestation at time of laser was 20.1±3.0 weeks' gestation (WG) whereas median gestation at delivery was 31.6±5.4 WG. Overall perinatal survival rate was 68.0% and 84.0% have one or more surviving twins. Preterm premature rupture of membranes occurred in 39 cases with and the median gestational age for this complication was 28.8±4.6 SA. Predictive factors to have at least one living birth were Quintero stage and gestational age at delivery. In the most recent period, there were significantly more TTTS Quintero stage I treated with laser, more coagulation by the Solomon technique and a larger number of coagulated vessels.

CONCLUSION

The neonatal survival of TTTS is improved by fetoscopic laser coagulation, preferely by using Solomon tecnhique. The use of active management of stage I is currently on research.

Increased Risk Of Early-Onset Neonatal Sepsis After Laser Surgery For Twin-to-Twin Transfusion Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the occurrence of early-onset neonatal sepsis (EOS) in twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) managed with laser surgery.

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a prospective cohort study of all consecutive TTTS cases treated with laser surgery (TTTS group) delivered at the Leiden University Medical Center. We recorded the occurrence of EOS, defined as a positive blood culture ≤72 hours postpartum (proven sepsis) or administration of a full course of antibiotics due to risk factors or signs of sepsis, in the absence of a positive blood culture (suspected sepsis). Perinatal variables in the TTTS group were compared with uncomplicated monochorionic twins (no-TTTS group). A multivariate model was generated, examining the association between EOS and gestational age at birth, interval between laser surgery and birth, anterior placenta, laser period (first study period: 2002-2008; second study period: 2009-2015), and preterm premature rupture of membranes (PPROM).

RESULTS

The rates of combined suspected and proven EOS in the TTTS group and no-TTTS group were 16% (68/416) and 10% (55/542), respectively (relative ratio [RR] 1.74, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.19-2.55). Multivariate analysis showed that EOS in the TTTS group was independently associated with lower gestational age at birth (odds ratio [OR] 0.75, 95% CI 0.63-0.88), first study period (OR 2.25, 95% CI 1.08-4.67) and PPROM (OR 2.47, 95% CI 1.28-4.75).

CONCLUSION

The rate of EOS in the TTTS group is low, but increased compared to the no-TTTS group. EOS in TTTS is independently associated with premature delivery, earlier laser period, and PPROM.

Future Directions in the Management of Twin-to-Twin Transfusion Syndrome

Twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) is the major complication of monochorionic (MC) pregnancy. The outcomes of this condition have been significantly improved after the introduction and widespread uptake of fetoscopic laser ablation over the last decade. However, there is still a significant fetal loss rate and morbidity associated with this condition. Improvements in the management of TTTS will require improvements in many areas. They are likely to involve refinements in the prediction of the disease and clarification of the optimum frequency of surveillance and monitoring. Improvements in training for fetoscopic surgery as well as in the technique of fetoscopic laser ablation may lead to better outcomes. New technologies as well as a better understanding of the pathophysiology of TTTS may lead to adjuvant medical therapies that may also improve short- and long-term results.

Balancing Patient Access to Fetoscopic Laser Photocoagulation for Twin-to-Twin Transfusion Syndrome With Maintaining Procedural Competence: Are Collaborative Services Part of the Solution?

The benefits of fetoscopic laser photocoagulation (FLP) for treatment of twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) have been recognized for over a decade, yet access to FLP remains limited in many settings. This means at a population level, the potential benefits of FLP for TTTS are far from being fully realized. In part, this is because there are many centers where the case volume is relatively low. This creates an inevitable tension; on one hand, wanting FLP to be readily accessible to all women who may need it, yet on the other, needing to ensure that a high degree of procedural competence is maintained. Some of the solutions to these apparently competing priorities may be found in novel training solutions to achieve, and maintain, procedural proficiency, and with the increased utilization of 'competence based' assessment and credentialing frameworks. We suggest an under-utilized approach is the development of collaborative surgical services, where pooling of personnel and resources can improve timely access to surgery, improve standardized assessment and management of TTTS, minimize the impact of the surgical learning curve, and facilitate audit, education, and research. When deciding which centers should offer laser for TTTS and how we decide, we propose some solutions from a collaborative model.

Operator competence in fetoscopic laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome: validation of a procedure-specific evaluation tool

OBJECTIVES

Fetoscopic laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome is a procedure for which no objective tools exist to assess technical skills. To ensure that future fetal surgeons reach competence prior to performing the procedure unsupervised, we developed a performance assessment tool. The aim of this study was to validate this assessment tool for reliability and construct validity.

METHODS

We made use of a procedure-specific evaluation instrument containing all essential steps of the fetoscopic laser procedure, which was previously created using Delphi methodology. Eleven experts and 13 novices from three fetal medicine centers performed the procedure on the same simulator. Two independent observers assessed each surgery using the instrument (maximum score: 52). Interobserver reliability was assessed using Spearman correlation. We compared the performance of novices and experts to assess construct validity.

RESULTS

The interobserver reliability was high (Rs  = 0.974, P < 0.001). Checklist scores for experts and novices were significantly different; the median score for novices was 28/52 (54%), whereas that for experts was 47.5/52 (91%) (P < 0.001). The procedure time and fetoscopy time were significantly shorter (P < 0.001) for experts. Residual anastomoses were found in 1/11 (9%) procedures performed by experts and in 9/13 (69%) procedures performed by novices (P = 0.005). Multivariable analysis showed that the checklist score, independent of age and gender, predicted competence.

CONCLUSIONS

The procedure-specific assessment tool for fetoscopic laser surgery shows good interobserver reliability and discriminates experts from novices. This instrument may therefore be a useful tool in the training curriculum for fetal surgeons. Further intervention studies with reassessment before and after training may increase the construct validity of the tool. Copyright © 2015 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Fetoscopic versus Open Repair for Spina Bifida Aperta: A Systematic Review of Outcomes

Objective: To compare outcomes of fetoscopic spina bifida aperta repair (FSBAR) with the results of the open approach (OSBAR) as in the Management Of Myelomeningocele Study (MOMS). Methods: This was a systematic comparison of reports on FSBAR with data from the MOMS (n = 78). Inclusion criteria were studies of spina bifida aperta patients who underwent FSBAR and were followed for ≥12 months. Primary outcome was perinatal mortality. Secondary outcomes included operative, maternal, fetal, neonatal and infant outcomes. Results: Out of 16 reports, we included 5 from 2 centers. Due to bias and heterogeneity, analysis was restricted to two overlapping case series (n = 51 and 71). In those, FSBAR was technically different from OSBAR, had comparable perinatal mortality (7.8 vs. 2.6%, p = 0.212) and shunt rate at 12 months (45 vs. 40%, p = 0.619), longer operation time (223 vs. 105 min, p < 0.001), higher preterm prelabor membrane rupture rate (84 vs. 46%, p < 0.001), earlier gestational age at birth (32.9 vs. 34.1 weeks, p = 0.03), higher postnatal reoperation rate (28 vs. 2.56%, p < 0.001) and absence of uterine thinning or dehiscence (0 vs. 36%, p < 0.001). Functional outcomes were not available. Conclusion: FSBAR utilizes a different neurosurgical technique, takes longer to complete, induces more prematurity, requires additional postnatal procedures, yet has a comparable shunt rate and is not associated with uterine thinning or dehiscence. Long-term functional data are awaited.

Simulator training in fetoscopic laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome: a pilot randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of a newly developed training curriculum on the performance of fetoscopic laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) using an advanced high-fidelity simulator model.

METHODS

Ten novices were randomized to receive verbal instructions and either skills training using the simulator (study group; n = 5) or no training (control group; n = 5). Both groups were evaluated with a pre-training and post-training test on the simulator. Performance was assessed by two independent observers and comprised a 52-item checklist for surgical performance (SP) score, measurement of procedure time and number of anastomoses missed. Eleven experts set the benchmark level of performance. Face validity and educational value of the simulator were assessed using a questionnaire.

RESULTS

Both groups showed an improvement in SP score at the post-training test compared with the pre-training test. The simulator-trained group significantly outperformed the control group, with a median SP score of 28 (54%) in the pre-test and 46 (88%) in the post-test vs 25 (48%) and 36 (69%), respectively (P = 0.008). Procedure time decreased by 11 min (from 44 to 33 min) in the study group vs 1 min (from 39 to 38 min) in the control group (P = 0.69). There was no significant difference in the number of missed anastomoses at the post-training test between the two groups (1 vs 0). Subsequent feedback provided by the participants indicated that training on the simulator was perceived as a useful educational activity.

CONCLUSIONS

Proficiency-based simulator training improves performance, indicated by SP score, for fetoscopic laser therapy. Despite the small sample size of this study, practice on a simulator is recommended before trainees carry out laser therapy for TTTS in pregnant women.

Twenty-Five Years of Fetoscopic Laser Coagulation in Twin-Twin Transfusion Syndrome: A Systematic Review

Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the perinatal outcome of pregnancies with twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) treated with laser therapy over the past 25 years, and in relation to different techniques used in this time period. Methods: A systematic review of studies reporting on perinatal outcome according to the Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) guidelines was conducted. The MEDLINE, Embase and Cochrane Library databases were systematically searched. Comparisons were made in respect to time period and laser technique and Quintero stages. Results: In total, 34 studies reporting on 3,868 monochorionic twin pregnancies were included. The mean survival of both twins increased from 35 to 65% (p = 0.012) and for at least one twin from 70 to 88% (p = 0.009) over the past 25 years. Mean gestational age at birth remained stable over the years at 32 weeks gestation. Also, we showed a significantly improved perinatal survival with the evolution of the laser technique from non-selective to selective, selective sequential and the Solomon technique (p = 0.010). Discussion: Since the introduction of laser therapy for TTTS more than two decades ago, perinatal survival improved significantly. Improved outcome is probably associated with several factors, including evolution of the laser technique, learning curve effect, better referral and improved early neonatal care.

Outcome following selective fetoscopic laser ablation for twin to twin transfusion syndrome: an 8 year national collaborative experience

OBJECTIVE

With the recognition of the role of fetoscopic laser ablation for twin to twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS), there is a requirement for auditable standards for this technically challenging and specialized treatment. The purpose of this study is to report on the perinatal and medium-term neurodevelopmental outcomes following an 8-year national single center experience in the management of TTTS using the selective fetoscopic laser ablation technique.

STUDY DESIGN

An audit of all cases of TTTS treated with selective laser ablation by a single national fetal medicine team was performed. Overall perinatal survival and medium-term neurodevelopmental outcomes were reported and correlated with gestational age at diagnosis, placental location, volume of amnio-reduction, Quintero staging and percentage inter-twin growth discordance. Procedure-related complications were recorded.

RESULTS

The overall fetal survival for the first 105 consecutive cases of TTTS was 61% (128/210 fetuses). Dual survival occurred in 47% (49/105) of cases, and with a single survival rate of 28% (30/105), perinatal survival of least one infant was achieved in 75% (79/105) of cases. No correlation was found between any clinical or sonographic marker and perinatal outcome, although dual survival was noted to be significantly decreased with increasing Quintero stage (p=0.041). Currently, 86% of survivors have been reported to have a normal medium-term neurological outcome.

CONCLUSION

Fetoscopic laser ablation is the established optimal treatment for severe twin to twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS). We report comparable short and medium-term outcomes following the selective fetoscopic technique comparing results from our national program with internationally published single-center outcomes, supporting the efficacy and safety of this treatment at our center.

A worldwide survey of laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate differences between international fetal centers in their treatment of twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) by fetoscopic placental laser coagulation.

METHODS

Fetal therapy centers worldwide were sent a web-based questionnaire. Participants were identified through networks and through scientific presentations and papers. Questions included physician and center demographics, treatment criteria, operative technique and instrumentation. Laser treatment was compared between low-volume (< 20 procedures/year) and high-volume (≥ 20 procedures/year) centers. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics.

RESULTS

Of 106 fetal therapy specialists approached, 76 (72%) from 64 centers in 25 countries responded. Of these, 48% (31/64) of centers and 63% (48/76) of operators performed fewer than 20 laser procedures annually. Comparison of low- and high-volume centers showed differences in technique, gestational age limits for treatment and geography. High-volume centers more often used the Solomon technique and applied wider gestational age limits for treatment. Europe and Asia had more high-volume centers, whereas South America, the Middle East and Australia had mainly low-volume centers.

CONCLUSION

This survey revealed significant differences between fetal centers in several aspects of fetoscopic placental laser therapy for TTTS. Increasing awareness of TTTS, and of laser coagulation as its preferred treatment, will lead to an increase in centers offering this modality, especially in Asia, Africa, South America and the Middle East. Considering the rarity of TTTS and the relative complexity of the procedure, developing international guidelines for techniques, instrumentation and suggested minimum volumes per center may aid in optimizing perinatal outcome.