A study of stromal riboflavin absorption in ex vivo porcine corneas using new and existing delivery protocols for corneal cross-linking

Enhanced Transepithelial Riboflavin Delivery Across the Cornea Using Magnetic Nanocarriers

Purpose: Keratoconus is a progressive corneal ectasia characterized by irregular astigmatism, leading to corneal scarring and decreased vision. Corneal cross-linking (CXL) is the standard treatment to halt disease progression, but its effectiveness in transepithelial (epithelium-on, epi-on) approaches is limited by the low permeability of the corneal epithelium to riboflavin (Rb). This study aimed to enhance transepithelial Rb penetration in ex vivo bovine corneas using Rb-modified tannic acid-coated superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (Rb-TA-SPIONs) under an external magnetic field. Methods: SPIONs were synthesized via co-precipitation, modified with TA and Rb, and characterized by physicochemical techniques. The average size of the Rb-TA-SPIONs was 46 ± 5.3 nm, with a saturation magnetization of 55.9 emu/g. Ex vivo experiments involved the application of 0.1% Rb to bovine corneas, and penetration was evaluated under epi-on conditions with iontophoresis (1-5 mA, 5 min). In addition, a 0.1% Rb-containing nanocarrier solution was tested under magnetic fields of 1-300 Gauss. Results: Results showed increased Rb penetration with rising electric current density and Rb-TA-SPION penetration with stronger magnetic fields, compared with epi-on control groups. Specifically, Rb penetration increased from 0.036% (P ≤ 0.01) at 1 mA to 0.059% (P ≤ 0.001) at 5 mA in the iontophoresis group and from 0.035% (P ≤ 0.001) at 1 G to 0.054% (P ≤ 0.001) at 300 G in the magnetic group. Conclusion: These findings indicate that magnetic nanoparticle-assisted Rb delivery, guided by an external magnetic field, could improve potential CXL efficacy by enhancing Rb penetration and corneal permeability.

Enhanced Riboflavin Stromal Delivery Using Microchannel-Assisted Iontophoresis for Corneal Crosslinking

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to determine if iontophoresis of riboflavin (Rf) combined with femtosecond generated epithelial microchannels (MCs) could shorten the time required for Rf stromal delivery and subsequent crosslinking (CXL).

Methods

Eighty-four ex vivo rabbit eyes were divided into three groups: group 1 = iontophoresis alone; group 2 = iontophoresis with MC; and group 3 = MC alone. Iontophoresis was performed using a small electric current with varying current and time. MCs were generated using a 1030 nm femtosecond (FS) laser to machine the corneal epithelial surface in a 6 mm diameter region. Ex vivo eyes were treated with topical iso-osmolar Rf solution, and stromal Rf concentration was determined spectrophotometrically by eluting Rf from trephined stromal buttons. In vivo, six rabbits underwent iontophoresis or iontophoresis + MC followed by ultraviolet-A crosslinking (UVA CXL) and imaged for collagen autofluorescence (CAF) signal to determine CXL efficacy.

Results

Ex vivo iontophoresis achieved a threefold increase in stromal Rf concentration when combined with MC for 5 to 10 minutes (equivalent to MC alone for 30 minutes compared to iontophoresis alone). In vivo, iontophoresis + MC resulted in a significantly higher (4-fold) CAF intensity than iontophoresis alone.

Conclusions

MCs and low current iontophoresis produce a significantly higher stromal Rf concentration than iontophoresis alone and equivalent to MC alone at greatly reduced Rf treatment time. Additionally, the combined treatment results in a four-fold increase in CAF intensity over iontophoresis alone.

Translational Relevance

A combined treatment of iontophoresis and MC significantly enhances stromal Rf concentration resulting in increased CXL while significantly reducing procedure time.

Real-time monitoring of riboflavin concentration using different clinically available ophthalmic formulations for epi-off and epi-on corneal cross-linking

PURPOSE

To assess the feasibility of theranostics to determine the riboflavin concentration in the cornea using clinically available ophthalmic formulations during epithelium-off (epi-off) and transepithelial (epi-on) corneal cross-linking procedures.

METHODS

Thirty-two eye bank human donor corneas were equally randomized in eight groups; groups 1 to 3 and groups 4 to 8 underwent epi-off and epi-on delivery of riboflavin respectively. Riboflavin ophthalmic solutions were applied onto the cornea according to the manufacturers' instructions. The amount of riboflavin into the cornea was estimated, at preset time intervals during imbibition time, using theranostic UV-A device (C4V CHROMO4VIS, Regensight srl, Italy) and expressed as riboflavin score (d.u.). Measurements of corneal riboflavin concentration (expressed as µg/cm3) were also performed by spectroscopy absorbance technique (AvaLight-DH-S-BAL, Avantes) for external validation of theranostic measurements.

RESULTS

At the end of imbibition time in epi-off delivery protocols, the average riboflavin score ranged from 0.77 ± 0.38 (the average corneal riboflavin concentration was 213 ± 190 µg/cm3) to 1.79 ± 0.07 (554 ± 103 µg/cm3). In epi-on delivery protocols, the average riboflavin score ranged from 0.17 ± 0.01 to 0.67 ± 0.19 (corneal riboflavin concentration ranged from 6 ± 5 µg/cm3 to 122 ± 39 µg/cm3) at the end of imbibition time. A statistically significant linear correlation (P ≤ 0.05) was found between the theranostic and spectrophotometry measurements in all groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Real-time theranostic imaging provided an accurate strategy for assessing permeation of riboflavin into the human cornea during the imbibition phase of corneal cross-linking, regardless of delivery protocol. A large variability in corneal riboflavin concentration exists between clinically available ophthalmic formulations both in epi-off and epi-on delivery protocols.

Assessment of the Predictive Ability of Theranostics for Corneal Cross-linking in Treating Keratoconus: A Randomized Clinical Trial

PURPOSE

To validate the ability of theranostic imaging biomarkers in assessing corneal cross-linking (CXL) efficacy in flattening the maximum keratometry (Kmax) index.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, multicenter, masked clinical trial (ClinicalTrails.gov identifier, NCT05457647).

PARTICIPANTS

Fifty patients with progressive keratoconus.

INTERVENTION

Participants were stratified to undergo epithelium-off (25 eyes) and epithelium-on (25 eyes) CXL protocols using an ultraviolet A (UV-A) medical device with theranostic software. The device controlled UV-A light both for performing CXL and assessing the corneal riboflavin concentration (riboflavin score) and treatment effect (theranostic score). A 0.22% riboflavin formulation was applied onto the cornea for 15 minutes and 20 minutes in epithelium-off and epithelium-on protocols, respectively. All eyes underwent 9 minutes of UV-A irradiance at 10 mW/cm2.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome measure was validation of the combined use of theranostic imaging biomarkers through measurement of their accuracy (proportion of correctly classified eyes) and precision (positive predictive value) to classify eyes correctly and predict a Kmax flattening at 1 year after CXL. Other outcome measures included change in Kmax, endothelial cell density, uncorrected and corrected distance visual acuity, manifest spherical equivalent refraction and central corneal thickness 1 year after CXL.

RESULTS

Accuracy and precision of the theranostic imaging biomarkers in predicting eyes that had >0.1 diopter (D) of Kmax flattening at 1 year were 91% and 95%, respectively. The Kmax value significantly flattened by a median of -1.3 D (IQR, -2.11 to -0.49 D; P < 0.001); both the uncorrected and corrected distance visual acuity improved by a median of -0.1 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR; IQR, -0.3 to 0.0 logMAR [P < 0.001] and -0.2 to 0.0 logMAR [P < 0.001], respectively). No significant changes in endothelial cell density (P = 0.33) or central corneal thickness (P = 0.07) were noted 1 year after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The study demonstrated the efficacy of integrating theranostics in a UV-A medical device for the precise and predictive treatment of keratoconus with epithelium-off and epithelium-on CXL protocols. Concentration of riboflavin and its UV-A light mediated photoactivation in the cornea are the primary factors determining CXL efficacy.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

An in vitro investigation into the impact of corneal rinsing on riboflavin/UVA corneal cross-linking

BACKGROUND

Corneal cross-linking (CXL) using riboflavin and ultraviolet-A light (UVA) is a treatment used to prevent progression of keratoconus. This ex vivo study assesses the impact on CXL effectiveness, as measured by tissue enzymatic resistance and confocal microscopy, of including a pre-UVA corneal surface rinse with balanced salt solution (BSS) as part of the epithelium-off treatment protocol.

METHODS

Sixty-eight porcine eyes, after epithelial debridement, were assigned to six groups in three experimental runs. Group 1 remained untreated. Groups 2-6 received a 16-min application of 0.1% riboflavin/Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) drops, after which Group 3 was exposed to 9 mW/cm2 UVA for 10 min, and Groups 4-6 underwent corneal surface rinsing with 0.25 mL, 1 mL or 10 mL BSS followed by 9 mW/cm2 UVA exposure for 10 min. Central corneal thickness (CCT) was recorded at each stage. Central 8.0 mm corneal buttons from all eyes were subjected to 0.3% collagenase digestion at 37 °C and the time required for complete digestion determined. A further 15 eyes underwent fluorescence confocal microscopy to assess the impact of rinsing on stromal riboflavin concentration.

RESULTS

Application of riboflavin/HPMC solution led to an increase in CCT of 73 ± 14 µm (P < 0.01) after 16 min. All CXL-treated corneas displayed a 2-4 fold greater resistance to collagenase digestion than non-irradiated corneas. There was no difference in resistance between corneas that received no BSS rinse and those that received a 0.25 mL or 1 mL pre-UVA rinse, but each showed a greater level of resistance than those that received a 10 mL pre-UVA rinse (P < 0.05). Confocal microscopy demonstrated reduced stromal riboflavin fluorescence after rinsing.

CONCLUSIONS

All protocols, with and without rinsing, were effective at enhancing the resistance to collagenase digestion, although resistance was significantly decreased, and stromal riboflavin fluorescence reduced with a 10 mL rinse. This suggests that a 10 mL surface rinse can reduce the efficacy of CXL through the dilution of the stromal riboflavin concentration.

A review of the epithelial and stromal effects of corneal collagen crosslinking

Induced corneal collagen crosslinking and mechanical stiffening via ultraviolet-A photoactivation of riboflavin (UVA CXL) is now a common treatment for corneal ectasia and Keratoconus. Some effects of the procedure such as induced mechanical stiffening, corneal flattening, and cellular toxicity are well-known, but others remain more controversial. Authors report a variety of contradictory effects, and provide evidence based on individual results and observations. A full understanding of the effects of and mechanisms behind this procedure are essential to predicting its outcome. A growing interest in modifications to the standard UVA CXL protocol, such as transepithelial or accelerated UVA CXL, makes analyzing the literature as a whole more urgent. This review presents an analysis of both the agreed-upon and contradictory results reported and the various methods used to obtain them.

Early findings in a prospective randomised study on three cross-linking treatment protocols: interruption of the iontophoresis treatment protocol

PURPOSE

To present the outcome of the interrupted iontophoresis-assisted treatment arm in an ongoing randomised clinical trial (NCT04427956).

METHODS

A randomised clinical study of corneal cross-linking (CXL) using continuous UV-A irradiation at a rate of 9 mW/cm2 and three different types of riboflavin and riboflavin delivery mode: (1) iso-osmolar dextran-based riboflavin (epithelium-off), (2) hypo-osmolar dextran-free riboflavin (epithelium-off) and (3) iontophoresis-assisted delivery of riboflavin (epithelium-on) for the treatment of progressive keratoconus. Inclusion criteria were an increase in the maximum keratometry value (Kmax) of 1.0 dioptre over 12 months or 0.5 dioptre over 6 months. The primary outcome in evaluating treatment efficacy was Kmax. Recently presented stratified detection limits were used post hoc to confirm the enrolment of patients with truly progressive keratoconus and in the assessment of the need for re-CXL.

RESULTS

Thirteen patients had been randomised to iontophoresis-assisted CXL when the treatment arm was interrupted; two patients dropped out. Of the remaining 11 patients, 7 were deemed as having truly progressive disease according to the more recent stratified detection limits. The disease continued to progress in three patients according to the original definition (increase in Kmax≥1 D), necessitating re-CXL with epithelium-off CXL. This progression was confirmed by post hoc analysis using the stratified detection limits for progression.

CONCLUSIONS

The iontophoresis-assisted CXL protocol failed to halt further disease progression in 27% of the patients. The failure rate increased to 38% when considering only the patients deemed to have truly progressive disease using the stratified detection limits.

Inadequate Hydration Status of Test Subjects Can Affect Bioavailability Studies

This Viewpoint identifies some of the pitfalls in the bioavailability of water-soluble drugs and introduces a novel bias we term the "hypohydration bias". We suggest that future bioavailability studies take some important neglected confounding factors into account, and we propose that, to avoid such a bias, some relevant variables such as serum and urine osmolality, dry weight adjustment, fluid balance, semi-nude body mass, saliva osmolality, saliva total protein concentration, and urine specific gravity should be controlled to increase the precision of the bioavailability measurements. We suggest that a new definition of hydration status is needed, and that systematic protocols of bioavailability studies should be revisited.

Current clinical practice in corneal crosslinking for treatment of progressive keratoconus in four Nordic countries

PURPOSE

To evaluate clinical practice in the diagnosis and treatment of progressive keratoconus with corneal crosslinking (CXL) in four Nordic countries.

METHODS

A questionnaire was sent to all centres at which keratoconus patients are evaluated and CXL is performed in Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Iceland. Nineteen of 20 centres participated.

RESULTS

CXL is performed approximately 1300 times per year in these four Nordic countries with a population of around 21.7 million (2019). In most cases, progression is evaluated using the Pentacam HR, and the maximum keratometry reading (K_max ) is considered the most important parameter. The most frequently used treatment protocol in Scandinavia is the 9 mW/cm² epi-off protocol, using hydroxylpropyl methylcellulose riboflavin (HPMC-riboflavin). The participants deemed the following areas to be in most need of improvement: adaptation of the CXL protocol to individual patients (5/19), the development of effective epi-on treatment protocols (4/19), optimal performance of CXL in thin corneas (4/19), improvement of the definition of progression (2/19), and diagnosis of the need for re-treatment (2/19).

CONCLUSIONS

We concluded that the diagnosis of progressive keratoconus and the diagnostic equipment used are similar. Treatment strategies are also similar but are suitably different to provide an interesting basis for the comparison of treatment outcomes. The high degree of participation in this survey indicates the possibility of future scientific collaboration on CXL focusing on the areas deemed to need improvement. It would also be of interest to evaluate the possibility of creating a Nordic CXL Registry. The high number of CXL treatments performed ensures sufficient statistical power to solve many questions. Such a registry could be an important contribution to evidence-based care and would allow for longitudinal evaluation.

Oxygen-supplemented transepithelial-accelerated corneal crosslinking with pulsed irradiation for progressive keratoconus: 1 year outcomes

PURPOSE

To investigate the effects of combining oxygen supplementation with enhanced UV-A light and increased riboflavin permeability in improving the efficacy of epithelium-on crosslinking (epi-on CXL).

SETTING

Private eye clinic in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.

DESIGN

Retrospective single-center nonrandomized uncontrolled longitudinal cohort case series.

METHODS

Transepithelial CXL was performed on keratoconic eyes. Applications of an oxygen goggle and pulsed UV-A irradiation (1 second on, 1 second off) were used to enhance oxygen kinetics during epi-on CXL. Additional procedural modifications included the use of benzalkonium chloride and high UV-A irradiance level (30 mW/cm 2 ) to improve the stromal bioavailability of riboflavin and UV-A. The main efficacy outcomes were the changes in mean corrected distance visual acuity (CDVA) and safety over 12 months. Additional refractive and keratometry (K) outcomes were also observed.

RESULTS

53 eyes (38 patients) were included in this study. 12 months postoperatively, mean CDVA improved from a mean of 0.18 ± 0.2 at baseline to 0.07 ± 0.1 logMAR ( P < .0001). No statistically significant change was observed in maximum K (Kmax) and mean K, which were respectively 51.7 ± 5.8 diopters (D) and 46.4 ± 3.85 D at baseline and 51.2 ± 5.7 D ( P = .152) and 46.0 ± 3.84 D ( P = .06) 12 months postoperatively. Only 3 eyes experienced an increase of more than 2 D in Kmax; however, none of these eyes experienced a CDVA loss. There were no reported infections, corneal scarring, or other severe adverse effects.

CONCLUSIONS

Performing supplemental oxygen epi-on CXL with accelerated, pulsed UV-A irradiation in conjunction with riboflavin permeability enhancers resulted in improved CDVA ( P < .0001) and stable keratometry up to 12 months postoperatively with a good safety profile.

Design of Besifloxacin HCl-Loaded Nanostructured Lipid Carriers: In Vitro and Ex Vivo Evaluation

Objective: In the treatment of severe cases of bacterial keratitis, conventional eye drops containing antibiotics should be applied daily and very frequently. The aim of this study is to develop low-dose high-effect formulations with the prepared nanostructured lipid carrier (NLC) formulations to reduce antibiotic resistance and increase patient compliance. Methods: NLC formulations were loaded with besifloxacin HCl (BHL) and the besifloxacin HCl: sulfobutyl ether beta-cyclodextrin (SBE-CD) complex. Positive charge was gained with chitosan, and corneal permeation and resolubility were increased with SBE-CD. In vitro characterization studies, permeability studies, and cytotoxicity and ex vivo transport studies were carried out. Results: In this study, it was found that SBE-CD increased BHL's solubility by 8-fold based on phase solubility studies. The optimized NLCs were small in size (13.63-16.09 nm) with a low polydispersity index (0.107-0.181) and adequate BHL drug loading efficiency. In vitro release studies showed that formulations were released approximately for 8 h and at levels over the minimum inhibitory concentration of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. NLC formulations had a better corneal permeation rate than the marketed product during 6 h of ex vivo studies. Conclusions: According to in vitro and ex vivo data, it was determined that the most favorable NLC formulation was the formulation containing BHL/SBE-CD that was covered with chitosan. It has the highest drug loading capacity and one of the highest ex vivo corneal passage levels, along with desired drug release. The formulation containing BHL/SBE-CD and chitosan can be a potential alternative for the treatment of bacterial keratitis.

Transepithelial Diluted Alcohol and Iontophoresis-Assisted Corneal Crosslinking for Progressive Keratoconus in Adults: 4-Year Clinical Results

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to compare the 4-year clinical outcomes of transepithelial diluted alcohol and iontophoresis-assisted corneal crosslinking (DAI-CXL) and standard corneal crosslinking (S-CXL) in adults with progressive keratoconus.

METHODS

This retrospective study included 36 eyes of 36 keratoconic patients who underwent DAI-CXL (n = 18) or S-CXL (n = 18). Best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) and corneal topography parameters were analyzed at baseline and at 1, 2, 3, and 4 years of follow-up. Corneal demarcation line depth (DLD) at 1 month was measured, and the relation of DLD with corneal thickness (DL%) was assessed.

RESULTS

BSCVA improved significantly only in S-CXL (P = 0.01). A significant decrease in maximum keratometry and mean keratometry occurred at 4 years in both groups (all P < 0.05), and these changes were similar in both groups (all P > 0.05). There was a significant reduction in the thinnest corneal thickness in S-CXL (P = 0.01); however, the mean thinnest corneal thickness in DAI-CXL remained stable (P = 0.094). Higher-order aberrations and coma aberration decreased significantly in both groups at 4 years (all P < 0.05), with a higher decrease in S-CXL (all P < 0.05). Spherical aberration showed a significant reduction only in S-CXL (P = 0.005). In contrast to the similar mean DLD in both groups, DL% in DAI-CXL was significantly greater than that in S-CXL (P = 0.032). There were no correlations between the improvement in BSCVA, maximum keratometry, mean keratometry, higher-order aberrations, and the mean DLD and DL% (all P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

DAI-CXL was as effective as S-CXL in arresting the progression of keratoconus and showed similar clinical results to S-CXL at the 4-year follow-up.

Biomechanics of Ophthalmic Crosslinking

Crosslinking involves the formation of bonds between polymer chains, such as proteins. In biological tissues, these bonds tend to stiffen the tissue, making it more resistant to mechanical degradation and deformation. In ophthalmology, the crosslinking phenomenon is being increasingly harnessed and explored as a treatment strategy for treating corneal ectasias, keratitis, degenerative myopia, and glaucoma. This review surveys the multitude of exogenous crosslinking strategies reported in the literature, both "light" (involving light energy) and "dark" (involving non-photic chemical processes), and explores their mechanisms, cytotoxicity, and stage of translational development. The spectrum of ophthalmic applications described in the literature is then discussed, with particular attention to proposed therapeutic mechanisms in the cornea and sclera. The mechanical effects of crosslinking are then discussed in the context of their proposed site and scale of action. Biomechanical characterization of the crosslinking effect is needed to more thoroughly address knowledge gaps in this area, and a review of reported methods for biomechanical characterization is presented with an attempt to assess the sensitivity of each method to crosslinking-mediated changes using data from the experimental and clinical literature. Biomechanical measurement methods differ in spatial resolution, mechanical sensitivity, suitability for detecting crosslinking subtypes, and translational readiness and are central to the effort to understand the mechanistic link between crosslinking methods and clinical outcomes of candidate therapies. Data on differences in the biomechanical effect of different crosslinking protocols and their correspondence to clinical outcomes are reviewed, and strategies for leveraging measurement advances predicting clinical outcomes of crosslinking procedures are discussed. Advancing the understanding of ophthalmic crosslinking, its biomechanical underpinnings, and its applications supports the development of next-generation crosslinking procedures that optimize therapeutic effect while reducing complications.

Keratoconus: cross-linking the window of the eye

Keratoconus is a condition in which the cornea progressively thins and weakens, leading to severe, irregular astigmatism and a significant reduction in quality of life. Although the precise cause of keratoconus is still not known, biochemical and structural studies indicate that overactive enzymes within the cornea break down the constituent proteins (collagen and proteoglycans) and cause the tissue to weaken. As the disease develops, collagen fibres slip past each other and are redistributed across the cornea, causing it to change shape. In recent years, it was discovered that the photochemical induction of cross-links within the corneal extracellular matrix, through the use of riboflavin and ultraviolet (UVA) light, could increase the strength and enzymatic resistance of the tissue and thereby halt keratoconus progression. Worldwide acceptance and use of riboflavin/UVA corneal cross-linking therapy for halting keratoconus progression has increased rapidly, in accordance with the growing body of evidence supporting its long-term effectiveness. This review focusses on the inception of riboflavin/UVA corneal cross-linking therapy for keratoconus, its clinical effectiveness and the latest scientific advances aimed at reducing patient treatment time, improving patient comfort and increasing patient eligibility for treatment.

Plain language summary

Review of current treatments using cross-linking to halt the progress of keratoconus Keratoconus is a disease in which the curved cornea, the transparent window at the front of the eye, weakens, bulges forward into a cone-shape and becomes thinner. This change of curvature means that light is not focussed onto the retina correctly and vision is progressively impaired. Traditionally, the effects of early keratoconus were alleviated by using glasses, specialist contact lenses, rings inserted into the cornea and in severe cases, by performing a corneal transplant. However, it was discovered that by inducing chemical bonds called cross-links within the cornea, the tissue could be strengthened and further thinning and shape changes prevented. The standard cross-linking procedure takes over an hour to perform and involves the removal of the cells at the front of the cornea, followed by the application of Vitamin B2 eye drops and low energy ultraviolet light (UVA) to create new cross-links within the tissue. Clinical trials have shown this standard procedure to be safe and effective at halting keratoconus progression. However, there are many treatment modifications currently under investigation that aim to reduce patient treatment time and increase comfort, such as accelerated cross-linking procedures and protocols that do not require removal of the surface cells. This review describes the different techniques being developed to carry out corneal cross-linking efficiently and painlessly, to halt keratoconus progression and avoid the need for expensive surgery.

Nonlinear optical crosslinking (NLO CXL) for correcting refractive errors

Ultraviolet A (UVA) light-based photoactivation of riboflavin (Rf) to induce corneal crosslinking (CXL) and mechanical stiffening is now a well-known treatment for corneal ectasia and Keratoconus that is being used in a topographically guided photorefractive intrastromal CXL (PiXL) procedure to treat low degrees of refractive errors. Alternative approaches for non-invasive treatment of refractive errors have also been proposed that use femtosecond lasers (FS) that provide much faster, more precise, and safer results than UVA CXL. One such treatment, nonlinear optical crosslinking (NLO CXL), has been able to replicate the effects of UVA CXL, while producing a smaller area of cellular damage and requiring a shorter procedure time. Unlike UVA CXL, the treatment volume of NLO CXL only occurs within the focal volume of the laser, which can be placed at any depth and scanned into any pattern for true topographically guided refractive correction. This review presents our experience with using FS lasers to photoactivate Rf and perform highly controlled corneal CXL that leads to mechanical stiffening and changes in corneal shape.

Transepithelial corneal cross-linking assisted by two continuous cycles of iontophoresis for progressive keratoconus in adults: retrospective 5-year analysis

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to compare the long-term effects of transepithelial corneal crosslinking with two continuous cycles of iontophoresis (EI-CXL) and conventional corneal crosslinking (C-CXL) in adults with progressive keratoconus.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted in adults who underwent C-CXL or EI-CXL between 2013 and 2015. Visual acuity, corneal tomography, anterior segment optical coherence tomography, in vivo corneal confocal microscopy (IVCM), and endothelial cell count (ECC) were performed preoperatively and 5 years postoperatively.

RESULTS

Sixty-eight patients with a mean age of (24.3 ± 3.8) years were included, 34 for each group. After CXL, UCVA or BCVA remained stable, while the spherical diopter, cylinder diopter, spherical equivalent, and K_max significantly decreased at 1, 2, and 3 years in both groups than baseline (P < 0.05). No significant differences were found in any refractive or tomographic parameters as well as the minimal corneal thickness between groups during follow-up. At 5 years, K_max was slightly higher in EI-CXL group (58.16 ± 6.28) than that of C-CXL group (57.46 ± 4.98). At 3 and 5 years, the minimal corneal thickness in C-CXL group was still significantly lower than baseline (P < 0.05). IVCM demonstrated the demarcation zone at a mean depth of (302.0 ± 41.7) μm after C-CXL, and at (251.2 ± 28.1) μm after EI-CXL (P < 0.001). Keratocyte repopulation was detectable at all follow-up timepoint in both groups. Postoperative complications including progression were recorded in 6 patients (11.7%) after C-CXL and 3 patients (8.8%) after EI-CXL. ECC remained stable in both groups.

CONCLUSION

EI-CXL showed approximate efficacy with C-CXL in stabilizing progressive keratoconus in adults. EI-CXL has the potential to be a preferable transepithelial protocol.

Design of ocular drug delivery platforms and in vitro - in vivo evaluation of riboflavin to the cornea by non-interventional (epi-on) technique for keratoconus treatment

AIM

Keratoconus is a common and progressive eye disease characterized by thinning and tapering of the cornea. This degenerative eye disease is currently treated in the clinic with an interventional technique ("epi-off") that can cause serious side effects as a result of the surgical procedure. The aim of this project is to design innovative formulations for the development of a riboflavin-containing medicinal product to develop a non-invasive ("epi-on") keratoconus treatment as an alternative to current treatment modalities.

METHODS

Nanostructured lipid carriers (NLCs) were successfully loaded with either riboflavin base of riboflavin-5-phosphate sodium and designed with either Stearylamine (positive charge) or Trancutol P (permeation enhancer). In vitro characterization studies, cytotoxicity and permeability studies were performed. Selected formulations and commercial preparations were applied and compared in ex-vivo corneal drug accumulation and transition studies. Furthermore, in vivo studies were performed to assess drug accumulation in the rat cornea and the corneal stability after NLC treatment was investigated via a biomechanical study on isolated rabbit corneas.

RESULTS

Both in vitro and ex-vivo as well as in vivo data showed that from the prepared NLC formulations, the most effective formulation was riboflavin-5-phosphate sodium containing NLC with Transcutol P as permeation enhancer. It possessed the highest drug loading content, low accumulation in the cornea but high permeability through the cornea as well as the highest functional performance in corneal crosslinking.

CONCLUSION

Topical application of riboflavin-5-phosphate sodium loaded NLC systems designed with permeation enhancer Transcutol P may act as a potential alternative for non-invasive keratoconus treatments.

Enhanced Transepithelial Riboflavin Delivery Using Femtosecond Laser-Machined Epithelial Microchannels

Purpose

This study describes a femtosecond laser (FS) approach to machine corneal epithelial microchannels for enhancing riboflavin (Rf) penetration into the cornea prior to corneal crosslinking (CXL).

Methods

Using a 1030-nm FS laser with 5- to 10-µJ pulse energy, the corneal epithelium of slaughterhouse rabbit eyes was machined to create 2-µm-diameter by 25-µm-long microchannels at a density of 100 or 400 channels/mm². Rf penetration through the microchannels was then determined by applying 1% Rf in phosphate-buffered saline for 30 minutes followed by removal of the cornea and extraction from the central stromal button. Stromal Rf concentrations were then compared to those obtained using standard epithelial debridement or 0.01% benzalkonium chloride (BAK) to disrupt the epithelial barrier.

Results

Microchannels formed using a 5-µJ/pulse at a density of 400 channels/mm² achieved a stromal Rf concentration that was 50% of that achieved by removal of the corneal epithelium and imbibing with 1% Rf. Stromal Rf levels were also equal to that of debrided corneas soaked with 0.5% Rf, threefold higher than those soaked with 0.1% Rf, and twofold higher than corneas soaked in BAK without epithelial debridement. Organ culture of treated corneas showed a normal corneal epithelium following FS machining while BAK-treated corneas showed extensive epithelial and stromal damage at 24 hours posttreatment.

Conclusions

FS corneal epithelial machining can be used to enhance penetration of Rf into the stroma for corneal CXL.

Translational Relevance

The creation of epithelial microchannels allows for stromal Rf concentrations high enough to perform true transepithelial crosslinking.

Comparison between standard and transepithelial corneal crosslinking using a theranostic UV-A device

PURPOSE

To assess corneal concentration of riboflavin in two different corneal crosslinking protocols performed by a novel image-guided therapeutic (or "theranostic") UV-A device.

METHODS

Ten human eye bank donor tissues were used in this work. The tissues underwent corneal cross-linking according to the conventional treatment protocol (n = 5; 30 min of stromal soaking followed by 30 min of 3 mW/cm² UV-A irradiance) and the iontophoresis-assisted transepithelial protocol (n = 5; soaking for 5 min at 1 mA/min and 9 min of 10 mW/cm² UV-A irradiance) using a theranostic UV-A device (Vision Engineering Italy srl, Italy). The device provided real time assessment of riboflavin concentration by hyperspectral image analysis of the cornea. A 0.1% riboflavin hypotonic solution (Ricrolin+, Sooft Italia Spa, Italy) was used in all cases.

RESULTS

Manual application of hypotonic riboflavin for 30 min into the stroma achieved greater corneal riboflavin concentration (425 ± 77 μg/cm³) than transepithelial delivery of riboflavin by corneal iontophoresis (195 ± 35 μg/cm³; P = 0.001). In both UV-A irradiation protocols, corneal riboflavin concentration decreased exponentially with a constant energy rate of 2.3 ± 0.5 J/cm² and 1.8 ± 0.3 J/cm² respectively. At the end of treatment, the average corneal concentration of riboflavin decreased by ≥ 85%, with values of 54 ± 29 μg/cm³ and 31 ± 9 μg/cm³ (P = 0.11), respectively.

CONCLUSION

Manual application of riboflavin onto the stroma achieved almost 50% greater concentration of riboflavin than transepithelial delivery by corneal iontophoresis. The theranostic UV-A device provided a novel approach to estimate corneal concentration of riboflavin non-invasively during treatment.

Clinical and microstructural changes with different iontophoresis-assisted corneal cross-linking methods for keratoconus

AIM

To compare the clinical and microstructural changes induced by different transepithelial iontophoresis-assisted corneal cross-linking (I-CXL) methods for keratoconus.

METHODS

A total of 42 eyes of 42 patients with progressive keratoconus were divided into two groups. Group A received I-CXL for 5min, while group B received I-CXL for 10min. Visual acuity, optical coherence tomography (OCT), specular microscopy and confocal microscopy were evaluated preoperatively and at 1, 3, 6, and 12mo postoperatively.

RESULTS

Twelve months after the operation, uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) and corrected distance visual acuity (CDVA) were improved in both groups, with a better outcome in the I-CXL 10min group (P=0.025, 0.021, respectively). Kmax values decreased by 0.94±3.00 D in the I-CXL 10min group (P=0.033) but increased by 1.87±3.29 D in the I-CXL 5min group (P=0.012). OCT scans showed that the demarcation line was most visible and substantially deeper in the I-CXL 10min group. Confocal microscopy showed greater anterior stromal keratocyte decreases in the I-CXL 10min group than in the I-CXL 5min group at 3 and 6mo postoperatively (P<0.001); however, anterior stromal keratocytes and subbasal nerve density were not significantly different between the two groups at 12mo postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

I-CXL for 10min more effectively halts the progression of keratoconus than I-CXL for 5min after 12mo of follow-up. However, long-term studies are needed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of I-CXL.

Comparison of Epithelium-Off Versus Transepithelial Corneal Collagen Cross-Linking for Keratoconus: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

PURPOSE

To systematically compare standard epithelium-off corneal collagen cross-linking (SCXL) and transepithelial corneal collagen cross-linking (TECXL) for treating keratoconus.

METHODS

PubMed, EMBASE, the Cochrane Library, the US trial registry (ClinicalTrials.gov), VIP Database, Wanfang Databse, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure searches up to February 2017 were conducted. Primary outcomes were changes at 1 year in uncorrected distance visual acuity, maximum keratometry (Kmax), and mean keratometry (mean K). Secondary outcomes were changes at 1 year in corrected distance visual acuity, mean refractive spherical equivalent, central corneal thickness, endothelial cell density, and the occurrence of adverse events.

RESULTS

Eight studies with a total of 455 eyes were included. For primary outcomes, SCXL showed a greater reduction in mean K [standardized mean difference (SMD) 0.28; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.03-0.53; P = 0.03] compared with TECXL. Subgroup analysis indicated that SCXL had a comparable effect on reducing mean K with TECXL protocols using chemical enhancers (SMD 0.05; 95% CI, -0.36 to 0.45; P = 0.82) but a greater reduction in mean K compared with TECXL with current iontophoretic protocols (SMD 0.43; 95% CI, 0.10-0.75; P = 0.01). For the other outcomes, there were no statistically significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS

With the exception of less reduction in mean K with current iontophoretic protocols, analysis of the limited number of comparative studies available seems to demonstrate that SCXL and TECXL have a comparable effect on visual, refractive, pachymetric, and endothelial parameters at 1 year after surgery. Further follow-up is required to determine whether these techniques are comparable in the long-term.

Non-invasive optical method for real-time assessment of intracorneal riboflavin concentration and efficacy of corneal cross-linking

Keratoconus is the primary cause of corneal transplantation in young adults worldwide. Riboflavin/UV-A corneal cross-linking may effectively halt the progression of keratoconus if an adequate amount of riboflavin enriches the corneal stroma and is photo-oxidated by UV-A light for generating additional cross-linking bonds between stromal proteins and strengthening the biomechanics of the weakened cornea. Here we reported an UV-A theranostic prototype device for performing corneal cross-linking with the ability to assess corneal intrastromal concentration of riboflavin and to estimate treatment efficacy in real time. Seventeen human donor corneas were treated according to the conventional riboflavin/UV-A corneal cross-linking protocol. Ten of these tissues were probed with atomic force microscopy in order to correlate the intrastromal riboflavin concentration recorded during treatment with the increase in elastic modulus of the anterior corneal stroma. The intrastromal riboflavin concentration and its consumption during UV-A irradiation of the cornea were highly significantly correlated (R = 0.79; P = .03) with the treatment-induced stromal stiffening effect. The present study showed an ophthalmic device that provided an innovative, non-invasive, real-time monitoring solution for estimating corneal cross-linking treatment efficacy on a personalized basis.

Efficacy of iontophoresis-assisted epithelium-on corneal cross-linking for keratoconus

Corneal cross-linking (CXL) is a noninvasive therapeutic procedure for keratoconus that is aimed at improving corneal biomechanical properties by induction of covalent cross-links between stromal proteins. It is accomplished by ultraviolet A (UVA) radiation of the cornea, which is first saturated with photosensitizing riboflavin. It has been shown that standard epithelium-off CXL (S-CXL) is efficacious, and it has been recommended as the standard of care procedure for keratoconus. However, epithelial removal leads to pain, transient vision loss, and a higher risk of corneal infection. To avoid these disadvantages, transepithelial CXL was developed. Recently, iontophoresis has been adopted to increase riboflavin penetration through the epithelium. Several clinical observations have demonstrated the safety and efficacy of iontophoresis-assisted epithelium-on CXL (I-CXL) for keratoconus. This review aimed to provide a comprehensive summary of the published studies regarding I-CXL and a comparison between I-CXL and S-CXL. All articles used in this review were mainly retrieved from the PubMed database. Original articles and reviews were selected if they were related to the I-CXL technique or related to the comparison between I-CXL and S-CXL.

Current perspectives on corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL)

Corneal collagen crosslinking has revolutionized the treatment of keratoconus and post-refractive corneal ectasia in the past decade. Corneal crosslinking with riboflavin and ultraviolet A is proposed to halt the progression of keratectasia. In the original "Conventional Dresden Protocol" (C-CXL), the epithelium is removed prior to the crosslinking process to facilitate better absorption of riboflavin into the corneal stroma. Studies analyzing its short- and long-term outcomes revealed that although there are inconsistencies as to the effectiveness of this technique, the advantages prevail over the disadvantages. Therefore, corneal crosslinking (CXL) is widely used in current practice to treat keratoconus. In an attempt to improve the visual and topographical outcomes of C-CXL and to minimize time-related discomfort and endothelial-related side effects, various modifications such as accelerated crosslinking and transepithelial crosslinking methods have been introduced. The comparison of outcomes of these modified techniques with C-CXL has also returned contradictory results. Hence, it is difficult to clearly identify an optimal procedure that can overcome issues associated with the CXL. This review provides an up-to-date analysis on clinical and laboratory findings of these popular crosslinking protocols used in the treatment of keratoconus. It is evident from this review that in general, these modified techniques have succeeded in minimizing the immediate complications of the C-CXL technique. However, there were contradictory viewpoints regarding their effectiveness when compared with the conventional technique. Therefore, these modified techniques need to be further investigated to arrive at an optimal treatment option for keratoconus.

Iontophoretic collagen cross-linking versus epithelium-off collagen cross-linking for early stage of progressive keratoconus - 3 years follow-up study

PURPOSE

To compare 3-year iontophoretic corneal collagen cross-linking (I-CXL) outcomes with epithelium-off corneal collagen cross-linking (epi-off CXL) for early stage of progressive keratoconus.

METHODS

Eighty eyes of 80 patients with early progressive keratoconus treated by I-CXL (n = 40) or epi-off CXL (n = 40) were included in this study. Uncorrected (UDVA) and corrected (CDVA) distance visual acuities, refraction, corneal topography and pachymetry were assessed at baseline and at 1, 3, 6, 12, 24 and 36 months of follow-up.

RESULTS

Visual acuity (VA) showed a significant improvement (p < 0.05) at the end of follow-up in both groups. In the I-CXL group, the UDVA showed a rapid recovery after 3 months (p = 0.04). There was a statistically significant different trend in CDVA between groups with a more favourable outcome for the standard CXL group (p < 0.01). The cylinder improved beginning with 3 months after CXL in both groups. Maximum keratometry showed a significant reduction by 0.9 dioptres (D) in the I-CXL group and by 1.2 D in the epi-off CXL group after 36 months (p = 0.283). Pachymetry values decreased at 3 months while a statistically significant increase occurred in both groups at 24 months. Progression occurred to one patient (2.5%) in I-CXL group. Adverse effects occurred to eight eyes (20%) in the epi-off CXL group.

CONCLUSION

Iontophoretic corneal collagen cross-linking (I-CXL) is non-inferior to epi-off CXL for stopping the progression of keratoconus in its early stages with a higher degree of safety for the patients and a faster recovery of VA.

Human in vitro Model Reveals the Effects of Collagen Cross-linking on Keratoconus Pathogenesis

Keratoconus (KC) is a corneal thinning disorder that leads to severe vision impairment As opposed to corneal transplantation; corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL) is a relatively non-invasive procedure that leads to an increase in corneal stiffness. In order to evaluate the effect of CXL on human corneal stromal cells in vitro, we developed a 3-D in vitro CXL model, using primary Human corneal fibroblasts (HCFs) from healthy patients and Human Keratoconus fibroblasts (HKCs) from KC patients. Cells were plated on transwell polycarbonate membranes and stimulated by a stable vitamin C. CXL was performed using a mixed riboflavin 0.1% PBS solution followed by UVA irradiation. Our data revealed no significant apoptosis in either HCFs or HKCs following CXL. However, corneal fibrosis markers, Collagen III and α-smooth muscle actin, were significantly downregulated in CXL HKCs. Furthermore, a significant downregulation was seen in SMAD3, SMAD7, and phosphorylated SMADs -2 and -3 expression in CXL HKCs, contrary to a significant upregulation in both SMAD2 and Lysyl oxidase expression, compared to HCFs. Our novel 3-D in vitro model can be utilized to determine the cellular and molecular effects on the human corneal stroma post CXL, and promises to establish optimized treatment modalities in patients with KC.

Corneal collagen crosslinking for corneal ectasias: a review

PURPOSE

To review the published literature on corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL).

METHODS

Importance has been placed on seminal publications, systemic reviews, meta-analyses, and randomized controlled clinical trials. Where such evidence was not available, cohort studies, case-controlled studies, and case series with follow-up greater than 12 months were examined.

RESULTS

Corneal collagen crosslinking with riboflavin and ultraviolet A (UVA) 370 nm radiation appears to be capable of arresting the progression of ectatic corneal disorders, with most studies reporting significant improvements in visual, keratometric, and topographic measurements. Its mode of action at the molecular level is undetermined. Follow-up is limited to 5-10 years but suggests sustained stability and enhancement in corneal shape with time. Nearly all published long-term data and comparative studies are with epithelium-off techniques. Epithelium-on investigations suggest some efficacy but less than with epithelium-off treatments and long-term data are unavailable. Accelerated techniques with higher UVA fluencies and shorter treatments times, delivering the same UVA energy dosage, are the subject of recent investigation, with some laboratory and clinical studies suggesting reduced efficacy compared to the standard 3 mW/cm2 for 30 minutes irradiation procedure. Combined methodologies of CXL with techniques such as photorefractive keratectomy and intrastromal rings show promise but long-term follow-up is indicated. Sight-threatening complications of CXL are rare.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies of epithelium-off CXL with irradiation at 3 mW/cm2 for 30 minutes support its efficacy. Refinement in techniques may allow for safer and more rapid procedures with less patient discomfort but require further investigation.

Standard corneal collagen crosslinking versus transepithelial iontophoresis-assisted corneal crosslinking, 24 months follow-up: randomized control trial

Purpose

To compare the results of standard corneal crosslinking (CXL) and transepithelial iontophoresis‐assisted CXL after 24 months follow‐up.

Material and methods

Corneal crosslinking (CXL) was performed in a series of 149 eyes of 119 patients with keratoconus I–II of Amsler classification. Depending on the CXL method, patients were divided into two groups: (1) 73 eyes with standard CXL and (2) 76 eyes with transepithelial iontophoresis‐assisted CXL. Depending on the group, epithelium removal or administration of riboflavin solution by iontophoresis for 10 min was performed, after which standard surface UVA irradiation (370 nm, 3 mW/cm²) was performed at a 5‐cm distance for 30 min.

Results

A statistically significant difference in corrected distance visual acuity (CDVA) was observed between the two groups, with a better outcome in the second group after 6 months (p = 0.037); however, no significant difference was found 24 months after treatment (p = 0.829). Stabilization and regression of keratometry values were achieved in both groups, but standard CXL was more effective. The average demarcation line depth in the standard CXL group was 292 ± 14 μm after 14 days and 172 ± 16 μm in the transepithelial iontophoresis‐assisted CXL group. No demarcation line was detected after 1 month and 3 months in 45% and 100% of the eyes in the second group respectively.

Conclusion

Transepithelial iontophoresis‐assisted collagen crosslinking showed to be less effective than standard CXL after 24 months of follow‐up, possibly due to a more superficial formation of corneal collagen crosslinks, however the stopping of disease progression was achieved 24 months after procedure.

An investigation into corneal enzymatic resistance following epithelium-off and epithelium-on corneal cross-linking protocols

The aim of this study was to investigate corneal enzymatic resistance following epithelium off and on riboflavin/UVA cross-linking (CXL). One hundred and fourteen porcine eyes were divided into four non-irradiated control groups and seven CXL groups. The latter comprised; (i) epithelium-off, 0.1% iso-osmolar riboflavin, 9 mW UVA irradiation for 10 min, (ii) disrupted epithelium, 0.1% hypo-osmolar riboflavin, 9 mW UVA for 10 min, (iii) epithelium-on, 0.25% hypo-osmolar riboflavin with 0.01% benzylalkonium chloride (BACS), 9 mW UVA for 10 min, (iv) epithelium-on, 5 min iontophoresis at 0.1 mA for 5 min with 0.1% riboflavin solution, 9 mW UVA for 10 min or (v) 12.5 min, (vi) epithelium-on, prolonged iontophoresis protocol of 25 min with 1.0 mA for 5 min and 0.5 mA for 5 min with 0.25% riboflavin with 0.01% BACS, 9 mW UVA for 10 min or (vii) 12.5 min. Enzymatic resistance was assessed by daily measurement of a corneal button placed in pepsin solution and measurement of corneal button dry weight after 11 days of digestion. This study revealed that the enzymatic resistance was greater in CXL corneas than non-irradiated corneas (p < 0.0001). Epithelium-off CXL showed the greatest enzymatic resistance (p < 0.0001). The prolonged iontophoresis protocol was found to be superior to all other trans-epithelial protocols (p < 0.0001). A 25% increase in UVA radiance significantly increased corneal enzymatic resistance (p < 0.0001). In conclusion, although epithelium-on CXL appears to be inferior to epithelium-off CXL in terms of enzymatic resistance to pepsin digestion, the outcome of epithelium-on CXL may be significantly improved through the use of higher concentrations of riboflavin solution, a longer duration of iontophoresis and an increase in UVA radiance.

•

Epi-off CXL is superior to epi-on CXL in terms of enzymatic resistance.

•

Epi-on CXL effectiveness can be improved by using a prolonged iontophoresis protocol.

•

Higher riboflavin concentrations and increased UVA radiance may also enhance epi-on CXL.