Trans-generational immune priming is not mediated by the sex of the parent primed: a meta-analysis of invertebrate data

Sex-dependent effects of infection on guppy reproductive fitness and offspring parasite resistance

Infection imposes energetic costs on hosts. Hosts typically respond by shifting resources, potentially affecting the quantity and quality of offspring they produce. As the sexes differ in their optimal reproductive strategies, the infection of mothers versus fathers may affect offspring quantity and quality in different ways. Here, we test how experimental infection of guppies Poecilia reticulata with the ectoparasite Gyrodactylus turnbulli affects parental reproductive fitness and offspring parasite resistance. We compared breeding pairs in which one or neither parent had previously been infected. In terms of reproductive fitness, pairs in which fathers had been infected produced more offspring than those in which mothers had been infected. Additionally, fathers who experienced the heaviest infections produced offspring ~55 days sooner than average. This result may represent terminal investment by males, especially those most affected by infection, or that males invest in reproduction at the expense of parasite defence. We found that offspring age, parental infection experience, and parental infection severity together strongly predicted offspring parasite resistance. Only among pairs in which one parent had been infected did older offspring, which were those born soonest after the parent's infection, tend to experience heavier infections. This result may reflect temporary infection-induced reductions in parental investment in offspring quality. Beyond this effect of offspring age, offspring of infected mothers experienced 105 fewer worm days than those of infected fathers: fathers, but not mothers, who experienced heavy infections themselves produced offspring that also experienced heavy infections. The parent-offspring regression for infected fathers is consistent with previous evidence that parasite resistance is heritable in this system and yields a narrow sense heritability estimate of 0.62 ± 0.12. By contrast, the mother-offspring regression (slope: -0.12 ± 0.14) provides novel insight that mothers may engage in transgenerational immune priming. Our results suggest that the sexes strike a different balance between offspring quantity and quality when faced with infection, with potentially broad implications for disease and host-parasite co-evolutionary dynamics in nature.

Parent-Specific Transgenerational Immune Priming Enhances Offspring Defense-Unless Heat Stress Negates It All

Transgenerational immune priming (TGIP) adjusts offspring's immune responses based on parental immunological experiences. It is predicted to be adaptive when parent-offspring environmental conditions match, while mismatches negate those advantages, rendering TGIP potentially costly. We tested these cost-benefit dynamics in the pipefish Syngnathus typhle (Syngnathidae). Because of their unique male pregnancy, egg production and rearing occur in different sexes, providing both parents multiple avenues for TGIP. Parental bacteria exposure in our pipefish was simulated through vaccinations with heat-killed Vibrio aestuarianus before mating the fish to each other or to controls. The resulting offspring were exposed to V. aestuarianus in control or heat stress environments, after which transcriptome and microbiome compositions were investigated. Transcriptomic TGIP effects were only observed in Vibrio-exposed offspring at control temperatures, arguing for low costs of TGIP in non-matching microbiota environments. Transcriptomic phenotypes elicited by maternal and paternal TGIP had limited overlap and were not additive. Parentally induced transcriptomic responses were associated with immune functions, and specifically, the paternal response to the innate immune branch, possibly hinting at trained immunity. TGIP of both parents reduced the relative abundance of the experimental Vibrio in exposed offspring, showcasing its ecological benefits. Despite TGIP's significance in matching biotic environments, no TGIP-associated phenotypes were observed for heat-treated offspring, illustrating its limitations. Heat spikes caused by climate change thus threaten TGIP benefits, potentially increasing susceptibility to emerging marine diseases. We demonstrate the urgent need to understand how animals cope with climate-induced changes in microbial assemblages to assess their vulnerability in light of climate change.

Juvenile responses to immune challenges are not carried through to subsequent life stages in an insect

Environmental variability can significantly impact individual survival and reproduction. Meanwhile, high population densities can lead to resource scarcity and increased exposure to parasites and pathogens. Studies with insects can offer valuable insights into eco-immunology, allowing us to explore the connections between these variables. Here we use the moth Anticarsia gemmatalis to examine how increases in population density and immunological challenge during the larval stage shape its investment in immune defence and reproduction. Larvae reared at a high population density exhibited greater lytic activity against bacteria compared to those reared at low density, whilst bacterial challenge (i.e. bacteria-immersed needles) also increased lytic activity. There was no interaction between the variables population density and bacterial challenge, indicating that these are independent. Surprisingly, neither increase in lytic activity carried through to activity in prepupal haemolymph. Rearing of larvae at a high density delayed pupation and decreased pupal weight. The immunological stimulus did not significantly influence pupal development. Lower population density as a larva resulted in greater adult weight, but did not significantly influence lytic activity in the eggs or the number of eggs laid. Negative correlations were found between lytic activity in the eggs and the number of eggs, as well as between adult weight and the number of eggs. Overall, this study demonstrates that high population density and immune challenge trigger increased lytic activity in caterpillars, but this effect is transient, not persisting into later stages. The trade-offs observed, such as delayed pupation and reduced prepupal weights under high density, suggest a balancing act between immune investment and developmental aspects. The findings hint at a short-term adaptive response rather than a sustained strategy. The implications of delayed pupation and smaller adult moths could influence the moth's life history strategy, impacting its role in the ecosystem. Further research tracking larval immune investment and subsequent reproductive success will unveil the evolutionary dynamics of this relationship in changing environments.

Metabolism and immune memory in invertebrates: are they dissociated?

Since the discovery of specific immune memory in invertebrates, researchers have investigated its immune response to diverse microbial and environmental stimuli. Nevertheless, the extent of the immune system's interaction with metabolism, remains relatively enigmatic. In this mini review, we propose a comprehensive investigation into the intricate interplay between metabolism and specific immune memory. Our hypothesis is that cellular endocycles and epigenetic modifications play pivotal roles in shaping this relationship. Furthermore, we underscore the importance of the crosstalk between metabolism and specific immune memory for understanding the evolutionary costs. By evaluating these costs, we can gain deeper insights into the adaptive strategies employed by invertebrates in response to pathogenic challenges. Lastly, we outline future research directions aimed at unraveling the crosstalk between metabolism and specific immune memory. These avenues of inquiry promise to illuminate fundamental principles governing host-pathogen interactions and evolutionary trade-offs, thus advancing our understanding of invertebrate immunology.

Generation of specific immune memory by bacterial exposure in the major malaria vector Anopheles arabiensis (Diptera: Culicidae)

There is a growing body of evidence that invertebrates can generate improved secondary responses after a primary challenge. This immunological memory can be primed by a range of pathogens, including bacteria. The generation of immunological memory has been demonstrated in mosquitoes, with the memory primed by a range of initial stimuli. This study aimed to examine whether insecticide resistance affects the capacity to generate immunological memory. The primary hypothesis was tested by examining the capacity of genetically related laboratory-reared Anopheles arabiensis strains that differ by insecticide resistant phenotype to generate immunological memory. The competing hypothesis tested was that the bacterial virulence was the key determinant in generating immunological memory. Immune memory was generated in F1 females but not males. Immunological memory was demonstrated in both laboratory strains, but the efficacy differed by the insecticide resistant phenotype of the strain. An initial oral challenge provided by a blood meal resulted generated better memory than an oral challenge by sugar. The efficacy of memory generation between the two bacterial strains differed between the two mosquito strains. Regardless of the challenge, the two strains differed in their capacity to generate memory. This study therefore demonstrated that insecticide resistant phenotype affected the capacity of the two strains to generate immunological memory. Although this study needs to be replicated with wild mosquitoes, it does suggest that a potential role for insecticide resistance in the functioning of the immune system and memory generation of An. arabiensis.

The plasticity of immune memory in invertebrates

Whether specific immune protection after initial pathogen exposure (immune memory) occurs in invertebrates has long been uncertain. The absence of antibodies, B-cells and T-cells, and the short lifespans of invertebrates led to the hypothesis that immune memory does not occur in these organisms. However, research in the past two decades has supported the existence of immune memory in several invertebrate groups, including Ctenophora, Cnidaria, Nematoda, Mollusca and Arthropoda. Interestingly, some studies have demonstrated immune memory that is specific to the parasite strain. Nonetheless, other work does not provide support for immune memory in invertebrates or offers only partial support. Moreover, the expected biphasic immune response, a characteristic of adaptive immune memory in vertebrates, varies within and between invertebrate species. This variation may be attributed to the influence of biotic or abiotic factors, particularly parasites, on the outcome of immune memory. Despite its critical importance for survival, the role of phenotypic plasticity in immune memory has not been systematically examined in the past two decades. Additionally, the features of immune responses occurring in diverse environments have yet to be fully characterized.