Comparison of efficacy and diffusion of three formulations of botulinum toxin type A in two patients with forehead hyperhidrosis

Tailored Indications for Different Neurotoxins

Background

Minimally invasive procedures have become increasingly popular because they require minimal downtime and are effective for achieving a more youthful appearance. All U.S. Food and Drug Administration-approved neurotoxins are indicated for achieving similar effects, even though they are different in regard to structure, manufacturing technique, and storage requirements. It is agreed upon that each neurotoxin is unique and therefore not interchangeable. The aim of the author is to provide an approach for choosing the optimal toxin in different indications regarding the area of treatment, the age and characteristics of the patient, potential risks, and ultimate goals.

Methods

As the country that the author practices carries onabotulinum (ONA), prabotulinum (PRA), and abobotulinum (ABO) toxin type-A, one of these three toxins was preferred for each category. ABO toxins were preferred in wide areas due to the broader action halo. Typical examples include hyperhidrosis treatment, wide forehead area, and calf slimming. In areas where very precise and targeted treatment is required, PRA and ONA toxins were preferred to limit potential side effects due to wider diffusion. First-time patients were typically treated with PRA toxins for a softer trial periods where as "repeat" patients were successfully treated with ABO toxins.

Results

No toxin is superior to the other in terms of producing effects. Yet, small differences in their properties can allow the plastic surgeon to cater to each patient's needs while yielding the most optimal results.

Conclusions

This study is meant to serve as a guideline for choosing the ideal toxin in different patient settings and indications.

Botulinum Toxin Type A for Treatment of Forehead Hyperhidrosis: Multicenter Clinical Experience and Review from Literature

Among the forms of idiopathic hyperhidrosis, those involving the forehead have the greatest impact on patients’ quality of life, as symptoms are not very controllable and are difficult to mask for patients. Although the local injection therapy with Incobotulinum toxin type A (IncoBTX-A therapy) can be considered a rational treatment, data from the literature describing both efficacy and safety of the treatment over the long term are poor. The aim of this report is to describe the single-center experience of five patients seeking treatment, for forehead hyperhidrosis with IncoBTX-A. To evaluate the benefits, safety profile and duration of anhidrosis, patients were treated following a standardized procedure and then followed until clinical relapse. The amount of sweating was measured by gravimetric testing, the extension of hyperhidrosis area was measured through Minor’s iodine starch test, and response to the treatment was evaluated using the Hyperhidrosis Disease Severity Scale (HDSS) and the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI). In all treated patients, a significant anhidrotic effect was observed 4 weeks after the treatment and lasted for approximately 36 weeks. The reduction in sweat production was associated with significant amelioration of symptoms and quality of life for all treated patients. No serious side effects occurred; one patient complained of a mild transient bilateral ptosis. Although further wider studies are required, our preliminary results seem to encourage the use of IncoBTX-A in forehead hyperhidrosis.

Injectable and topical neurotoxins in dermatology: Basic science, anatomy, and therapeutic agents

Botulinum toxin is a potentially deadly anaerobic bacterial toxin that acts by inhibiting release of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction, thereby inhibiting contraction of the exposed striated muscle. There are currently 4 botulinum toxin preparations approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA): onabotulinumtoxin, abobotulinumtoxin, incobotulinumtoxin and rimabotulinumtoxin. While significant overlap exists, each product has unique properties and specifications, including dosing, diffusion, and storage. Extensive physician knowledge of facial anatomy, coupled with key differences of the various neurotoxin types, is essential for safe and successful treatments. The first article in this continuing medical education series reviews key characteristics of each neurotoxin, including new and upcoming agents, and provides an anatomic overview of the most commonly injected cosmetic sites.