Seizures with tonic posturing: Semiologic difference between supplementary sensorimotor area (SSMA) origin and extra-SSMA origin

Bilateral tonic seizures vs. bilateral tonic events in critically ill patients: differences in semiology

PURPOSE

Our primary aim was to analyze bilateral epileptic tonic seizures (ETS) and bilateral non-epileptic tonic events (NTE) in critically ill patients. Our secondary aim was to analyze ETS per their epileptogenic zone.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of clinical signs in patients with bilateral ETS and NTE. Two authors independently reviewed 34 videos of ETS in 34 patients and 15 videos of NTEs in 15 patients. Initial screening and review was performed in an unblinded manner. Subsequently, the semiology was characterized independently and blindly by a co-author. Statistical analysis was conducted using Bonferroni correction and two-tailed Fischer exact test. Positive predictive value (PPV) was calculated for all signs. Cluster analysis of signs with a PPV >80% was performed to evaluate co-occurring semiological features in the two groups.

RESULTS

Compared to patients with ETS, those with NTEs more frequently had predominant involvement of proximal upper extremities (UE) (67% vs. 21%), internal rotation of UE (67% vs. 3%), adduction of UE (80% vs. 6%) and bilateral elbow extension (80% vs. 6%). In contrast, those with ETS more frequently had abduction of UE (82% vs 0%), elevation of UE (91% vs. 33%), open eyelids (74% vs. 20%), and involvement of both proximal and distal UE (79% vs. 27%). In addition, seizures that remained symmetrical throughout were more likely to have a generalized onset than focal (38% vs. 6%), p = 0.032, PPV 86%.

CONCLUSIONS

A careful analysis of semiology can often help differentiate between ETS and NTE in the ICU. The combination of eyelids open, upper extremity abduction, and elevation reached a PPV of 100% for ETS. The combination of bilateral arms extension, internal rotation, and adduction reached a PPV of 90.9% for NTE.

Motor seizure semiology

Motor semiology is a major component of epilepsy evaluation, which provides essential information on seizure classification and helps in seizure localization. The typical motor seizures include tonic, clonic, tonic-clonic, myoclonic, atonic, epileptic spasms, automatisms, and hyperkinetic seizures. Compared to the "positive" motor signs, negative motor phenomena, for example, atonic seizures and Todd's paralysis are also crucial in seizure analysis. Several motor signs, for example, version, unilateral dystonia, figure 4 sign, M2e sign, and asymmetric clonic ending, are commonly observed and have significant clinical value in seizure localization. The purpose of this chapter is to review the localization value and pathophysiology associated with the well-defined motor seizure semiology using updated knowledge from intracranial electroencephalographic recordings, particularly stereoelectroencephalography.

Localisation in focal epilepsy: a practical guide

The semiology of epileptic seizures reflects activation, or dysfunction, of areas of brain (often termed the symptomatogenic zone) as a seizure begins and evolves. Specific semiologies in focal epilepsies provide an insight into the location of the seizure onset zone, which is particularly important for presurgical epilepsy assessment. The correct diagnosis of paroxysmal events also depends on the clinician being familiar with the spectrum of semiologies. Here, we summarise the current literature on localisation in focal epilepsies using illustrative cases and discussing possible pitfalls in localisation.

Focal bilateral motor seizures precipitated by abrupt cessation of chronic lormetazepam abuse and amitriptyline overdose

We report the case of an adult psychiatric patient who developed new-onset focal bilateral motor seizures (FBMS) in the context of a severe benzodiazepine withdrawal syndrome. The patient was forced to interrupt chronic lormetazepam abuse and overdosed on amitriptyline (800 mg in an oral solution) before the onset of seizures. Typical signs of amitriptyline intoxication such as sedation and anticholinergic effects were not observed. Video-EEG recordings revealed a stereotypical ictal motor pattern with asymmetric tonic posturing and bilateral clonic movements of the upper limbs, but there were no abnormalities identified by EEG. Seizures recurred multiple times per day but resolved simultaneously when withdrawal symptomatology subsided eight days after onset. Nonepileptic seizures (NES) were considered in the differential diagnosis because of the patient's psychiatric history including preserved awareness during the bilateral convulsions, the absence of postictal confusion, and normal EEG. The present case indicates that FBMS may occur during benzodiazepine withdrawal in patients who overdosed on amitriptyline. The diagnosis may be challenging as FBMS may mimic NES in the absence of abnormal neurophysiologic findings. This may be especially challenging in patients with an underlying psychiatric disease.

Bilateral asymmetric tonic seizure in insulo-opercular epilepsy: an anatomo-electro-clinical study

Background

Insulo-opercular seizures are highly heterogeneous in seizure semiology and electrical features. Bilateral asymmetric limb posturing, as a classical pattern of supplementary sensorimotor area (SMA) seizure, also occurs in insulo-opercular epilepsy. This study was aimed to study the anatomo-electro-clinical correlations in bilateral asymmetric tonic seizures (BATS), in order to advance the understanding of insulo-opercular epilepsy.

Methods

Eight patients with insulo-opercular epilepsy as confirmed by stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) and manifesting BATS as the major ictal motor sign, in Guangdong Sanjiu Brain Hospital Epilepsy Center from 2014 to 2018, were employed in this study. The BATS of the patients were evaluated, and the semiologic features and concomitant intracerebral EEG changes were quantified. Then the variables were examined with Cluster Analysis, and the semiologic features were correlated with anatomic localization using the Kendall correlation test.

Results

Of the 8 patients, the most frequent initial motor sign was bilateral asymmetric tonic posturing (62.5%). Facial tonic-clonic sign also had a high prevalence in the evolution of seizures (87.5%). The results of Cluster Analysis showed that the semiologic features were subdivided into two main groups, one group comprising exclusively BATS and the other including signs of focal tonic seizure, aura, focal limb tonic-clonic seizure (TCS), facial TCS, hypermotor behavior, eye movement, autonomic changes and generalized TCS. The BATS was strongly associated with the posterior long gyrus (PLG) of insula (t = 0.732) and parietal operculum (t = 1.000); the hypermotor behaviors were associated with the anterior long gyrus (ALG) (t = 0.770); and the autonomic changes were associated with the anterior limiting sulcus (ALS) (t = 0.734) and middle short gyrus (MSG) (t = 0.700).

Conclusions

The seizure semiology of insulo-opercular epilepsy is characterized, in temporal order, by BATS, with or without simultaneous hypermotor behaviors, and frequently ends up with facial tonic-clonic signs, which is different from that of the SMA seizure. The early spread network involving the posterior insular lobe and parietal operculum may contribute to this pattern of manifestation.