Evaluation of a programme to increase referrals to stop-smoking services using Children's Centres and smoke-free families schemes

The Feasibility of a Primary Care Based Navigation Service to Support Access to Health and Social Resources: The Access to Resources in the Community (ARC) Model

INTRODUCTION

We established a patient centric navigation model embedded in primary care (PC) to support access to the broad range of health and social resources; the Access to Resources in the Community (ARC) model.

METHODS

We evaluated the feasibility of ARC using the rapid cycle evaluations of the intervention processes, patient and PC provider surveys, and navigator log data. PC providers enrolled were asked to refer patients in whom they identified a health and/or social need to the ARC navigator.

RESULTS

Participants: 26 family physicians in four practices, and 82 of the 131 patients they referred. ARC was easily integrated in PC practices and was especially valued in the non-interprofessional practices. Patient overall satisfaction was very high (89%). Sixty patients completed the post-intervention surveys, and 33 reported accessing one or more service(s).

CONCLUSION

The ARC Model is an innovative approach to reach and support a broad range of patients access needed resources. The Model is feasible and acceptable to PC providers and patients, and has demonstrated potential for improving patients' access to health and social resources. This study has informed a pragmatic randomized controlled trial to evaluate the ARC navigation to an existing web and telephone navigation service (Ontario 211).

Understanding willingness to access and experiences of NHS Stop Smoking Services: a qualitative systematic review with meta-aggregation synthesis

OBJECTIVES

NHS Stop Smoking Services (NHS-SSS) have been available in the United Kingdom (UK) since 2000. The service has proven to be effective, however uptake remains below aspirations. Understanding people's willingness and reasons for accessing and engaging with NHS-SSS is, therefore, important. The aim of this systematic review is to summarise the findings from qualitative research to understand people's views, perceptions and willingness to access NHS-SSS.

STUDY DESIGN

Qualitative systematic review with meta-aggregation synthesis.

METHODS

Four electronic databases were searched for published qualitative studies, from Jan 2000 to Jan 2020. Following the screening, data extraction and quality assessment, data synthesis was conducted using meta-aggregation based on a patient-centred theoretical framework. We explored five 'demand-side' dimensions of service accessibility: the ability to perceive, seek, reach, pay and engage. Confidence in the synthesised findings relating to dependability and credibility was established using CONQual.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies were included in the review. Twelve categories emerged, contributing to five synthesised statements, all with a CONQual rating of moderate confidence. Access and willingness to use NHS-SSS were found to be related to an individual's readiness to perceive that smoking is a problem for which a solution should be sought, their ability to seek a perceived effective treatment, to conveniently reach NHS-SSS, their perceptions around associated costs and tailoring care to improve engagement with individuals.

CONCLUSIONS

By using a theoretical framework incorporating healthcare access, this study provides policymakers valuable insights into people's willingness to access these services. Willingness to access NHS-SSS is multifaceted, nuanced and complex. Strategies to promote NHS-SSS uptake should include making services more attractive, relevant and responsive to individual perceptions around smoking and health. Given the higher prevalence of smoking in less affluent socioeconomic groups and in some ethnic minority groups, the importance of having a comprehensive and inclusive tobacco control policy, one that is linguistically and culturally sensitive, cannot be overstated.

Factors associated with parental smoking in the presence of school-aged children: a cross-sectional study

Background

In 2009, the Tobacco Hazards Prevention Act (Taiwan) was amended to more effectively restrict smoking in indoor public places and workplaces in Taiwan. However, the lack of prohibitions for smoking in private homes may place family members at increased risk for exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). The aim of our study was to determine the factors associated with parental smoking in the presence of children at home.

Methods

In 2010, we performed a cross-sectional study of factors associated with parental smoking in the presence of children at home in Taiwan using self-administered questionnaires. Quota sampling was used to select five primary schools from four different regions of Taiwan. Parents were surveyed to identify parental smokers and 307 parental smokers were selected for participation in our study. Questionnaire data regarding parental smoking in the presence of children at home and related interactions among family members were analyzed. Hierarchical logistic regression was used to determine the best-fit model for examining the relationships among the variables related to parental smoking in the presence of children at home.

Results

Two-thirds of parents who smoked reported smoking in the presence of their children. The results of the hierarchical logistic regression analysis identified the smokers’ compliance with their family’s antismoking responses, mutual agreement with smoking bans, daily smoking, smoking more than 20 cigarettes per day, the education level of the parental smoker, and the annual family income as determinants of smoking in the presence of children at home.

Conclusions

Households with smoking parents should be targeted for interventions to encourage the adoption and enforcement of home smoking bans. Educational interventions that promote smoke-free homes for children and provide support to help parents stop smoking are critical factors in reducing the frequency of children’s ETS exposure in the home.

Developing the evidence base for addressing inequalities and smoking in the United Kingdom

AIMS

Smoking is an increasing cause of health inequalities in high-income countries. This supplement describes pilot projects set up in England to develop and test pathways to ensure that disadvantaged groups, where smoking is frequently the norm, are reached, encouraged and supported to stop their tobacco use. Target groups were: smokers attending centres set up for highly deprived parents; smokers with serious and enduring mental illness; pregnant smokers; prisoners/other offenders who smoked; South Asian tobacco chewers; and recent quitters from 'routine and manual' occupational groups.

METHODS

Commonalities observed across the six projects are summarized, alongside recommendations for implementation.

RESULTS

A significant barrier to implementation was the lack of mandatory identification of tobacco users across primary, secondary and community health-care settings and routine use of expired air carbon monoxide monitoring, particularly for high-risk groups. Appropriate use of financial incentives and national guidance is probably necessary to achieve both this and the adoption of 'joined-up' tobacco dependence treatment pathways for these target groups. Further research is needed on the impact of 'opt out' pathways: while resulting in increased referral rates, success rates were lower. In general, smoking cessation service targets were a barrier to implementation. Flexibility and tailoring of interventions were required and most projects trained those already working in relevant settings, given their greater understanding of target groups. Mandatory training of all frontline health-care staff was deemed desirable.

CONCLUSIONS

Implementing the findings of these projects will require resources, for training, incentivizing health-care workers and further research. However, continuing with the status quo may result in sustained tobacco use health inequalities for the foreseeable future.