Planning health care in developing countries

Moving towards universal health coverage: The need for a strengthened planning process

As countries embrace the ambitious universal health coverage (UHC) agenda whose major tenents include reaching everyone with the needed good quality services, strengthening the planning process to work towards a common objective is paramount. Drawing from country experiences-Swaziland and Zanzibar, we reviewed strategic planning processes to assess the extent to which they impact on realising alignment towards a collective health sector objective. Employing qualitative approaches, we reviewed strategic plans under implementation in the health sector and using an interview guide consisting of open-ended questions, interviewed key informants at the national and district level. Results showed that strategic plans are too many with majority of program strategies not well aligned to the health sector strategic plan, are not costed, and there overlaps in objectives among the several strategies addressing the same program. Weaknesses in the development process, perceived poor quality of the strategies, limited capacity, high staff turnover, and inadequate funding were the identified challenges that abate the utility of the strategic plans. Moving towards UHC starts with a robust planning process that rallies all actors and all available resources around a common objective. The planning process should be strengthened through ensuring participatory processes, evidence informed prioritisation, MoH institutional capacity to lead the process, and consideration for implementation feasibility. Flexibility to take into consideration emerging evidence and new developments in global health needs consideration.

Assessing unmet anaesthesia need in Sierra Leone: a secondary analysis of a cluster-randomized, cross-sectional, countrywide survey

OBJECTIVES

To determine the unmet anaesthesia need in a low resource region.

INTRODUCTION

Surgery and anæsthesia services in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are under-equipped, under-staffed, and unable to meet current surgical need. There is little objective measure as to the true extent and nature of unmet need. Without such an understanding it is impossible to formulate solutions. Therefore, we re-examined Surgeons OverSeas (SOSAS) unmet surgical need data to extrapolate unmet anaesthesia need.

METHODS

For the untreated surgical conditions identified by SOSAS, we assigned anaesthetic technique required to carry out the procedure. The chosen anaesthetic was based on common practice in the region. Procedures were categorized into minimal anaesthesia, spinal anæsthesia, regional anaesthesia, ketamine/monitored anaesthesia care (MAC), and general endotracheal anæsthesia (GETA).

DISCUSSIONS

Ninety-two per cent (687 of 745) of untreated surgical conditions in Sierra Leone would require some form of anaesthesia. Seventeen per cent (125 of 745) would require MAC, 22% (167 of 745) would require spinal anaesthesia, and 53% (395 of 745) would require GETA.

CONCLUSION

Analyses such as this can provide guidance as to the rational and efficient production and distribution of personnel, drugs and equipment.

Surgery, public health, and Pakistan

BACKGROUND

Surgical healthcare is rapidly gaining recognition as a major public health issue. Surgical disparities are large, with poorest populations receiving the least amount of emergency and essential surgical care. In light of recent evidence, developing countries, such as Pakistan, must acknowledge surgical disease as a major public health issue and prioritize research and intervention accordingly.

METHODS

We review information from various sources and describe the current situation of surgical health care in Pakistan and highlight areas of neglect.

RESULTS

Pakistan suffers an annual deficit of 17 million surgeries. Surgical disease kills more people than infectious diseases inclusive of tuberculosis, HIV/AIDS, diarrheal disease, and childhood infections. The incidence of trauma and maternal mortality ratio are staggeringly high. There is a severe dearth of surgical and anesthesia-related epidemiological data. Important information that would help to drive policy and planning is not available. Corruption and neglect have led to a dilapidated health care infrastructure. Surgical care is largely inaccessible to the poor, especially those living in rural areas. The country faces a dearth of healthcare professionals, especially paramedics, anesthetists, and surgeons. Unsafe surgery and anesthesia poses a significant risk to patients. There is no national policy on surgical illness and the preventive aspects of surgery are nonexistent.

CONCLUSIONS

Consistent with other underdeveloped countries, surgical care in Pakistan is dismal. Neglecting surgery and safe anesthesia has led to countless deaths and disability. Physicians, researchers, policy makers, and the government health care system must engage and commit to provide access to emergency, essential, and safe surgical care.

Pediatric cardiac anesthesia in the developing world

More children die of congenital heart disease (CHD) in low-income countries and acquired cardiac disease is more frequent. Advances in diagnosis, surgery, perfusion and anesthesia in the developed world have had dramatic results on children's lives, and many forms of CHD can now be safely corrected or palliated. However, in developing countries, for the children who receive cardiac surgery, perioperative mortality and morbidity remain high. Pediatric cardiac anesthesia is a specialty in its infancy worldwide, and in developing countries, it is often nonexistent. Visiting 'specialists' as part of medical mission teams often provides anesthesia, but the hope for the future is that local staff will be trained in pediatric cardiac anesthesia and collaborative regional cardiac centers will be the mainstay of care, offering safer surgery to more children.