The clinical assessment of chronic pain in rheumatic disease: evaluating the use of two instruments

Patterning of Pain and Power With Guided Imagery

Using Martha Rogers’ science of unitary human beings, changes in pain and power among 42 patients were examined in relation to the use of a guided imagery modality. Participants were randomly assigned to treatment and control groups and repeated measures MANCOVA was used to detect differences in pain and power over a 4-day period of time. The treatment group’s pain decreased during the last 2 days of the study. No differences in power emerged. Guided imagery appeared to have potential as a useful nursing modality for chronic pain sufferers.

Biological mechanisms related to the effectiveness of guided imagery for chronic pain

Specific aims of this pilot study were to (a) determine the effect of a guided imagery (GI) intervention over an 8-week period on pain and pain disability in a sample of persons with chronic noncancer pain (CNCP) and (b) analyze the mediating effects of neuroendocrine and neuroimmune functioning on the effectiveness of GI on outcome variables. A simple interrupted time-series design (12-week period) was used. GI was introduced at Week 4 and used daily by 25 participants for the remaining 8 weeks. Measures of pain and pain disability were obtained at the beginning of the study period and at six repeated 2-week intervals. Measures of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis activation (plasma cortisol), immune-mediated analgesia (lymphocyte subset counts and proliferation), and immune-mediated hyperalgesia (interleukin-1β) were obtained at the beginning of the study and at Week 11. Usual pain levels were lower after the introduction of GI at Week 4 (Wilks' λ = 52.31; df = 2, 22; p = .000). Pain disability levels were lower after the introduction of GI at Week 4 (Wilks' λ = 5.98; df = 6, 18; p = .001). Correlation coefficients between change scores of dependent variables and mediating variables were not significant. GI was effective in reducing pain intensity and pain disability over an 8-week period; however, the results did not support the expected effects of decreased HPA axis activation, improved immune-mediated analgesia, and reduced immune-mediated hyperalgesia in mediating these outcomes. These findings may be related to procedural and theoretical issues and limitations related to the study design.

A home-based pedometer-driven walking program to increase physical activity in older adults with osteoarthritis of the knee: a preliminary study

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether a home-based pedometer-driven walking program with arthritis self-management education (Walk +) would increase physical activity, muscle strength, and functional performance in older adults with osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee as opposed to arthritis self-management education alone (EDU).

DESIGN

A randomized two-by-three (group-by-time) design with participants assigned to Walk + (n = 17, mean age +/- standard deviation = 69.6 +/- 6.7) or EDU (n = 17, age = 70.8 +/- 4.7).

SETTING

Community located in the Baltimore-Washington area.

PARTICIPANTS

Thirty-four community-dwelling adults, aged 60 and older with symptomatic knee OA and self-reported functional impairment.

INTERVENTIONS

Both groups received 12 hours of the Arthritis Self-Management program over 12 weeks and were followed for an additional 12 weeks. In addition, the Walk + group received individualized instruction in the use of a pedometer, with the goal of increasing their step count by 30% of their baseline step count.

MEASUREMENTS

The outcome measures were physical activity (daily step counts and total activity vector magnitude as measured by a pedometer and Tritrac-R3D accelerometer), quadriceps femoris strength (isometric peak torque), and functional performance tasks (100-foot walk-turn-walk, timed stair climb, timed chair rise, and pain status).

RESULTS

Daily steps walked showed a significant group-by-time interaction (P =.04) after controlling for age. From baseline to completion of training, a 23% increase in daily steps occurred in the Walk + group and a 15% decrease in the EDU group. Although steps increased in the Walk + group, total activity vector magnitude was maintained, suggesting a more efficient gait. The Walk + group became quicker than the EDU group in the normal-pace walk-turn-walk (P =.04). An isometric strength gain of 21% postintervention was seen in the Walk + group, compared with a loss of 3.5% in the EDU group.

CONCLUSION

In older adults with symptomatic knee OA, Walk + appears to increase walking, with improvements in muscle strength and walking performance. The use of a home-based pedometer-driven program to increase physical activity, strength, and function in this population warrants further research.

Concurrent validity of an electronic descriptive pain scale

The study objective was to assess the concurrent validity of the Electronic Descriptive Pain Scale (EDPS), a pain scale built into a transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation device. One hundred patients in an outpatient physiotherapy (PT) clinic participated (mean age 41.30 years, SD 13.95). Before and after a PT treatment, subjects rated their current pain intensity with the EDPS, a visual analogue scale, a numerical pain rating scale, and the McGill Pain Questionnaire's Present Pain Intensity. The results showed relatively high significant correlations between the EDPS and each of the other pain scales.

EMDR in the treatment of chronic pain

Chronic pain presents a persistent and significant clinical challenge. Research examining commonly used psychotherapeutic treatments suggests that the results are not always well maintained, and that pain often is unrelieved. Continued exploration of new and more effective approaches is necessary. This article outlines an application of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), developed to improve coping and reduce chronic pain and suffering. The effectiveness of the EMDR Chronic Pain Protocol was investigated with three adult chronic pain sufferers. Intervention effectiveness was measured at baseline, during, and postintervention, with a two-month follow-up. All clients reported substantially decreased pain levels, decreased negative affect, and increased ability to control their pain following treatment. These results indicate that EMDR may be efficacious in the treatment of chronic pain and that further research is warranted.

Background pain in fibromyalgia patients affecting clinical examination of the skin

The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between on-going pain and acute thermal pain in patients suffering from chronic pain. This experimental study in cold and heat sensitivity was performed in order to test the following hypothesis: that fibromyalgia patients scoring high in current background pain tolerate less experimental thermal pain in the skin than patients with low scores. Ethical aspects of the study are discussed. The level of tolerable experimental thermal stimuli was tested and compared between the 'low-score' and the 'high-score' patients. Background pain seemed to affect the intensity of experimental cold pain. Clinical routine examinations and bodily care of the skin that might interfere with background pain in the fibromyalgia patients are discussed. Clinical practice should be carefully planned in order to assist fibromyalgia patients in understanding and coping with thermal conditions that might influence background pain.

Severity of a case for outcome assessment in health care--definitions and classification of instruments

Severity of a case is one of the ingredients in management systems. Severity adjustment systems have limitations, and confusion and diversity characterize definitions of severity of a case. These facts may be a consequence of lack of conceptual knowledge. Based on a holistic theory of health, we introduce a definition of severity of a case from a patient perspective. Here severity is characterized as having two basic components: disease severity and illness severity; and five dimensions: suffering, disabilities, risk of suffering, risk of disabilities and risk of death. A classification of instruments as measures of severity dimensions is presented. This classification is based on definition and application criteria. The article's main contribution is to combine theoretical and practical knowledge about severity of a case, which may empower implementations of outcome management systems in health care.

Choosing the correct pain relief for extracorporeal lithotripsy

OBJECTIVES

To determine the best choice of analgesic for patients undergoing lithotripsy, and to attempt to identify factors which might predict which patients are most likely to find the procedure painful.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Sixty patients with stones in the pelvicalyceal system of the kidney were randomized prospectively to undergo lithotripsy with the Dornier MPL9000 lithotripter (Dormier Medical Systems, Marietta, GA, USA) after receiving either diclofenac 100 mg per rectum (n = 30) or pethidine 50 mg intravenously (n = 30) for analgesia. The patients completed a detailed questionnaire prior to treatment, and the level of pain perceived during lithotripsy was monitored using visual analogue scales (VASs). Arterial oxygen saturation (SaO2) was monitored before analgesia was given, throughout the treatment and for 30 min after cessation of treatment.

RESULTS

The VASs were available for 56 patients and the results of pulse oximetry for 51 patients. Although a higher kilovoltage was recorded in the group who received pethidine this difference was not significant. Patients who received diclofenac or pethidine alone, showed a non-significant fall of SaO2 30 minutes after the end of treatment, although the largest fall in SaO2 observed with pethidine was 10%. Patients who received diclofenac and pethidine similarly showed a non-significant fall in SaO2. Four patients received intravenous benzodiazepines in addition to pethidine, and in this group there was a dramatic fall in SaO2 which persisted more than 30 min after the end of treatment (P < 0.0027). Diclofenac provided effective analgesia for most of the patients who underwent lithotripsy. Overall 11 patients (18%) required additional analgesia. Diclofenac or pethidine alone, in the doses used in this study, did not cause a significant drop in SaO2 during ESWL. The only response found to be of value in predicting a painful experience was fear of the dentist.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that modern lithotripsy, in addition to being safe and effective, can be performed as an out-patient procedure using simple non-opiate analgesics. The need for stronger analgesia and/or sedation should be tailored to the needs of the individual patient, although it remains difficult to predict which patients will require such measures.

Comprehensive and multidimensional assessment and measurement of pain

Current theories of pain and clinical experience support a multidimensional framework for the experience of pain that has implications for assessment and management in any setting. Six major dimensions have been identified: physiologic, sensory, affective, cognitive, behavioral, and sociocultural. Any clinical assessment process must address relevant dimensions of pain in the given setting. In acute care settings, for example, clinicians may focus on physiologic and sensory dimensions, whereas in chronic care settings, the affective, cognitive, and behavioral dimensions might assume priority. Various tools are available for multidimensional assessment of pain, spanning the dimensions of the experience from physiologic to sociocultural. The clinician in any setting must use appropriate tools that provide useful information. Guidelines helpful in a selection process include identification of relevant dimensions of pain, type of pain, patient population and setting, psychometric properties of the tool, and issues of time, clinical relevance, and feasibility. When a careful selection process occurs, the resulting data should simultaneously meet clinicians' needs for information as well as provide the foundation for initiation of multidisciplinary interventions.