Value of sperm morphology assessed by strict criteria for prediction of the outcome of artificial (intrauterine) insemination

Effect of Sperm Morphology on Pregnancy Success via Intrauterine Insemination: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

PURPOSE

Men with abnormal sperm morphology are often counseled that natural conception and intrauterine insemination are ineffective, and in vitro fertilization is the only option. Our objective was to determine the effect of sperm morphology on the pregnancy success of intrauterine insemination.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We systematically searched for studies published prior to January 2017 that 1) reported ultrasound verified clinical pregnancies per intrauterine insemination cycle, 2) assessed sperm morphology using the Kruger strict criteria and 3) described morphology at the greater than 4% and 4% or less and/or the 1% or greater and less than 1% thresholds. In all studies mean female age was between 25 and 40 years and mean total motile sperm count was greater than 10 million. Estimates were pooled using random effects meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Data were extracted from 20 observational studies involving a total of 41,018 cycles. When comparing men at the greater than 4% and 4% or less thresholds, the rate of ultrasound verified pregnancy per intrauterine insemination cycle was not statistically or clinically different (14.2% vs 12.1%, p = 0.06) and the risk difference was 3.0% (95% CI 1.4-4.6), indicating 3.0 additional pregnancies per 100 intrauterine insemination cycles. When comparing men at the 1% or greater and the less than 1% thresholds, there were no statistical or clinical differences in the rate of ultrasound verified pregnancy per cycle of intrauterine insemination (14.0% vs 13.9%, p = 0.97) or in the risk difference (1.6%, 95% CI -4.5-7.6).

CONCLUSIONS

There appears to be no clinical difference in intrauterine insemination pregnancy success among men with normal and abnormal sperm morphology when accounting for total motile sperm count and female age. Abnormal sperm morphology alone should not exclude couples from attempting intrauterine insemination.

Mouse spermatozoa with higher fertilization rates have thinner nuclei

Background

Although spermatozoa with normal morphology are assumed to have uniform fertilization ability, recent data show that even normal spermatozoa have considerable variation in their head shape which is associated with differences in fertilization ability. Appropriate quantitative indicators for good sperm morphology, however, remain unidentified.

Methods

Therefore, in an effort to identify such an indicator, we compared the nuclear contour of normal mouse spermatozoa by quantitative multivariate analysis using elliptic Fourier descriptors combined with principal component analysis. The spermatozoa were obtained from different strains and collection sites which have been shown to be associated with different fertilization abilities.

Results

We found that the head was 5.7% thinner in spermatozoa from the B6D2F1 (BDF1) strain, known to have a higher fertilization rate, than in those from the C57BL/6N (B6N) strain, which has a lower fertilization rate. Moreover, zona-penetrated spermatozoa in the perivitelline space consistently had 5.4% thinner heads than those isolated from the epididymis before ejaculation. The aspect ratio, which represents the sperm head thinness, uniquely distinguished these sperm populations, confirming its validity as a morphological indicator.

Discussion

Because aspect ratio has also been shown to characterize human spermatozoa, this unique morphometric indicator might be applicable to compare normal spermatozoa among multiple patients, which will greatly facilitate and enhance current reproductive technologies.

Role of Abnormal Sperm Morphology in Predicting Pregnancy Outcomes

The evaluation of strict morphology for predicting successful pregnancy has been controversial, nevertheless remains an essential component of semen analysis. Patients with teratozoospermia (abnormal strict morphology) have traditionally been counseled to undergo assisted reproduction. However, recent studies suggest that patients with abnormal sperm morphology alone should not be precluded from attempting natural conception before undergoing assisted reproduction. The goal of this review is to provide an update on the evaluation of sperm morphology for prognosis in assisted reproductive techniques such as intrauterine insemination and in vitro fertilization with or without intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Additionally, we propose a logical approach to the evaluation of a patient with teratozoospermia seeking fertility treatment.

Isolated abnormal strict morphology is not a contraindication for intrauterine insemination

This study sought to investigate whether isolated abnormal strict morphology (<5% normal forms) and very low strict morphology (0-1% normal forms) affects pregnancy rates in intrauterine insemination (IUI). This was a retrospective study performed at an Academic Medical Center/Reproductive Medicine Center. Four hundred and eight couples were included for 856 IUI cycles. 70 IUI cycles were performed in couples with abnormal strict morphology and otherwise normal semen parameters. Outcomes were measured as clinical pregnancy rate per IUI cycle as documented by fetal heart activity on maternal ultrasound. Clinical pregnancy rate did not significantly differ between the group with abnormal strict morphology [11/70 (15.7%)] and the normal morphology group [39/281 (13.9%)]. Additionally, there was no significant difference between the pregnancy rate in the abnormal morphology group compared to that of our overall institutional IUI pregnancy rate [145/856 (16.9%)]. Furthermore, there was no significant difference between pregnancy rate in the very low morphology group [3/14 (21.4%)] compared to those with normal morphology or the overall IUI pregnancy rate. Patients with isolated abnormal strict morphology have clinical pregnancy rates similar to those with normal morphology for IUI. Even in those with very low normal forms, consideration of IUI for assisted reproduction should not be excluded.

Occupation exposures and sperm morphology: a case-referent analysis of a multi-centre study

OBJECTIVE

We examined occupational exposures and sperm morphology to establish whether exposures implicated differed from those affecting motile sperm concentration.

METHODS

Computer aided sperm morphometric assessment was undertaken on morphology slides obtained as part of a multi-centre study in 1999-2002 of occupational factors in male infertility. Men attending 14 fertility clinics across the UK were recruited and gave a semen sample. Before results of the semen analysis were known, the men completed detailed questionnaires about their employment and lifestyle. Occupational exposures were assessed by occupational hygienists. Data were analysed using an unmatched case-referent design, allowing for clustering and for confounders. Three case definitions were used: poor morphology (normal morphology <4%), low motile sperm count (MSC) (<4.8×10(6)) and either condition.

RESULTS

Morphology results were available for 1861/2011 men employed at the time of recruitment. Of these 1861, 296 (15.9%) had poor morphology; of the 2011with sperm count, 453 (22.5%) had low MSC; 654/1981 (33.0%) had either condition. Poor morphology, adjusted for confounding, was related to self-reported lifetime exposure to lead (OR=1.33; 95% CI 1.00 to 1.75). Low MSC was also related to self-reported lead and to hygienist-assessed glycol ether exposure. Self-reported use of paint stripper (OR=1.47; 95% CI 1.07 to 2.03) and lead, but not glycol ether, were significantly related to the combined case definition.

CONCLUSIONS

While this study did not identify any occupational exposure uniquely related to sperm morphology, the capacity of the study to detect risk was increased by including morphology with sperm concentration and motility.

Semen quality and prediction of IUI success in male subfertility: a systematic review

Many variables may influence success rates after intrauterine insemination (IUI), including sperm quality in the native and washed semen sample. A literature search was performed to investigate the threshold levels of sperm parameters above which IUI pregnancy outcome is significantly improved and/or the cut-off values reaching substantial discriminative performance in an IUI programme. A search of MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane Library revealed a total of 983 papers. Only 55 studies (5.6%) fulfilled the inclusion criteria and these papers were analysed. Sperm parameters most frequently examined were: (i) inseminating motile count after washing: cut-off value between 0.8 and 5 million; (ii) sperm morphology using strict criteria: cut-off value ⩾5% normal morphology; (iii) total motile sperm count in the native sperm sample: cut-off value of 5-10 million; and (iv) total motility in the native sperm sample: threshold value of 30%. The results indicate a lack of prospective studies, a lack of standardization in semen testing methodology and a huge heterogeneity of patient groups and IUI treatment strategies. More prospective cohort trials and prospective randomized trials investigating the predictive value of semen parameters on IUI outcome are urgently needed. It is generally believed that intrauterine insemination (IUI) with homologous semen should be a first-choice treatment to more invasive and expensive techniques of assisted reproduction in cases of cervical, unexplained and moderate male factor subfertility. The rationale for the use of artificial insemination is to increase gamete density at the site of fertilization. Scientific validation of this strategy is difficult because literature is rather confusing and inconclusive. Many variables may influence success rates after IUI treatment procedures. It seems logical that sperm quality has to be one of the main determinants to predict IUI success. Clinical practice would benefit from the establishment of threshold levels for sperm parameters above which IUI pregnancy outcome is significantly improved and below which a successful outcome is unlikely. We performed a literature search to investigate if such threshold levels are known. Most striking were the lack of standardization in semen-testing methodology and the huge heterogeneity of patient groups and IUI treatment strategies. The four sperm parameters most frequently examined were: (i) inseminating motile count after washing: cut-off value between 0.8 and 5 million; (ii) sperm morphology using strict criteria: cut-off value >4% normal morphology; (iii) total motile sperm count in native sperm sample: cut-off value of 5-10 million; and (iv) total motility in native sperm sample: threshold value of 30%. This review identified an urgent need for more and better prospective cohort trials investigating the predictive value of semen parameters on IUI pregnancy rate.

Semen analysis with regard to sperm number, sperm morphology and functional aspects

The new World Health Organization (WHO) Manual for Semen Analysis contains several improvements. One is that the 20 million spermatozoa per mL paradigm has been ousted in favour of proper calculations of lower reference limits for semen from men, whose partners had a time-to-pregnancy of 12 months or less. The recommendation to grade the progressive motility as described in the third and fourth editions of the WHO manual was not evidence-based, and WHO was therefore motivated to abandon it. However, the new recommendation is not evidence-based either, and it is difficult to understand the rational for the new assessment. It may have been a compromise to avoid returning to the rather robust system recommended in the first edition (1980). The unconditional recommendation of the 'Tygerberg strict criteria' is not evidence-based, and seems to be the result of an unfortunate bias in the composition of the Committee in favour of individuals known to support the 'strict criteria' method. This recommendation will have negative effects on the development of andrology as a scientific field. Given the importance of the WHO manual, it is unfortunate that the recommendations for such important variables, as motility and morphology, lack evidence-based support.

Sperm function and assisted reproduction technology

The evaluation of different functional sperm parameters has become a tool in andrological diagnosis. These assays determine the sperm's capability to fertilize an oocyte. It also appears that sperm functions and semen parameters are interrelated and interdependent. Therefore, the question arose whether a given laboratory test or a battery of tests can predict the outcome in in vitro fertilization (IVF). One-hundred and sixty-one patients who underwent an IVF treatment were selected from a database of 4178 patients who had been examined for male infertility 3 months before or after IVF. Sperm concentration, motility, acrosin activity, acrosome reaction, sperm morphology, maternal age, number of transferred embryos, embryo score, fertilization rate and pregnancy rate were determined. In addition, logistic regression models to describe fertilization rate and pregnancy were developed. All the parameters in the models were dichotomized and intra- and interindividual variability of the parameters were assessed. Although the sperm parameters showed good correlations with IVF when correlated separately, the only essential parameter in the multivariate model was morphology. The enormous intra- and interindividual variability of the values was striking. In conclusion, our data indicate that the andrological status at the end of the respective treatment does not necessarily represent the status at the time of IVF. Despite a relatively low correlation coefficient in the logistic regression model, it appears that among the parameters tested, the most reliable parameter to predict fertilization is normal sperm morphology. (Reprod Med Biol 2005; 4: 7-30).

Clinical Laboratory Evaluation of Male Subfertility

Male subfertility is a common problem with a complex etiology, requiring a complete andrological work-up for proper diagnosis. The male reproductive tract is controlled by a well-balanced hormonal system, in which hypothalamic (GnRH), pituitary (LH, FSH) and testicular hormones (androgens, inhibin B) participate. Any disturbance of this hormonal system may therefore lead to testicular dysfunction and interfere with the spermatogenesis process. In addition, also other components along the ductal system, such as epididymis, prostate and seminal vesicles, that improve sperm fertility by contributing their secretions to the semen, might function inadequately and thus fail to enhance the fertilizing capacity of the sperm cells. External factors (heat, chemicals, life style) and anatomical abnormalities (varicocele) were shown to have a negative influence on male fertility. In a number of patients genetic defects can be identified as the cause of their infertility. Laboratory tests are available to assess hormone concentrations, semen composition, accessory gland function and sperm cell function. Conventional semen analysis includes the determination of sperm concentration, semen volume, sperm motility (qualitative and quantitative), sperm morphology, sperm cell vitality, pH, leucocytes and antibodies. The usefulness of the determination of these parameters as predictor of fertility appears to be rather limited, however. Therefore, alternative tests, some based on more functional aspects (sperm penetration, capacitation, acrosome reaction), have been developed. Furthermore, there is an increasing attention for the assessment of DNA integrity, for instance by the flowcytometer-based Sperm Chromation Structure Assay (SCSA), as an additional or alternative parameter of sperm quality. It is likely and desirable that further assays with better predictive value are being developed in the near future.

The effect of human immunodeficiency virus on sperm parameters and the outcome of intrauterine insemination following sperm washing

BACKGROUND

This is the first study to assess the outcome of sperm washing and intrauterine insemination (IUI) cycles in human immunodeficiency virus-positive (HIV(+)) men to determine any predictors of success, as well as evaluating the effect of HIV on sperm parameters.

METHODS

Semen characteristics were evaluated in 106 HIV(+) men and a control group of 234 HIV(-) men, and the effect of markers of HIV disease assessed. Age, stimulation regime, sperm parameters, markers of HIV disease and the use of anti-retrovirals were assessed as predictors of the outcome of sperm washing/IUI cycles in the HIV(+) men.

RESULTS

Ejaculate volume, sperm concentration, total count, progressive motility and normal morphology were all significantly higher in the control group compared to the HIV(+) men (P<0.05). A significant positive correlation was observed between CD4 count and sperm concentration, total count, motility, progressive motility type 'a'+'b' and post-preparation concentration and a significant negative correlation with normal sperm morphology of both raw and post-preparation samples. No correlation was observed between viral load (VL), years since diagnosis, use of anti-retrovirals or duration of use and any sperm parameter. The only factors that significantly improved IUI outcome were a VL <1000 copies/ml and the use of anti-retrovirals.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate that sperm parameters are significantly impaired by the presence of HIV infection and in particular correlate with CD4 count. Undetectable VL and the use of anti-retrovirals improve the outcome of IUI/sperm washing in HIV(+) men.

Relationship between human sperm morphology and acrosomal function

PURPOSE

In this study, we investigated the relationship between functionality of the acrosome and sperm morphology.

METHODS

Acrosome reaction (AR) was separately determined in live and dead sperm and in those with normal, small, and large sized acrosomes by means of the triple stain. Morphology was analyzed according to strict criteria after Papanicolaou stain.

RESULTS

AR and morphology correlated regarding detection of large and small sized acrosomes, but not for normal sized acrosomes. Spontaneous AR was significantly influenced by acrosomal size. Sperm with large (11.4%) and normal (9.2%) acrosomes exhibited a significantly higher percentage of life spontaneously acrosome-reacted sperm than those with small acrosomes (4.5%). Sperm with small acrosomes were associated with a higher percentage of cell death.

CONCLUSION

The results indicate that sperm with small acrosomes are more susceptible to cell death and nonphysiological acrosomal loss. Acrosome size reflects the physiological capability of sperm function and therefore male fertility potential.

Prediction of pregnancy by intrauterine insemination using CASA estimates and strict criteria in patients with male factor infertility

This study was performed to predict pregnancy by intrauterine insemination (IUI) using computer-aided sperm analysis (CASA) estimates and strict criteria in patients with male factor infertility. IUI was performed in 682 cycles on 160 male factor infertile patients. Semen examinations were carried out by CASA and strict criteria before and after sperm preparation using continuous-step density gradient centrifugation. Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves were constructed for assessment of the effectiveness of each individual parameter in predicting pregnancy by IUI. A clinically acceptable threshold was calculated when sensitivity plus specificity were maximum. The average cycle of IUI performed was 4.3 +/- 2.4. Pregnancy rate per cycle and per patient were 7.2% (49/682) and 28.1% (45/160), respectively. Using ROC curve, it was shown that normal sperm morphology assessed by the strict criteria before sperm separation and five parameters after sperm separation including rapid, progressive motility, average path velocity (VAP), curvilinear velocity (VCL), and straight line velocity (VSL) were able to predict pregnancy by IUI. Correlation between sperm parameters and pregnancy outcome was examined by the logistic regression model. In a multivariate analysis normal morphology before sperm separation >or=15.5% [odds ratio (OR) = 2.2, p = 0.02], rapid after sperm separation >or=25.5% [OR = 3.9, p = 0.029], and VCL after sperm separation >or=102.65 microm/sec [OR = 3.2, p = 0.002] were the parameters of predictive value for pregnancy outcome. Adjustment of the model for female age, female infertility factors, and the methods of ovulation induction did not change this finding, and the final model still had the same covariates. Pregnancy rates per cycle according to the number (0, 1, 2 and 3) of variables satisfied with the three parameters were 0% (0/110), 1.6% (3/183), 9.7% (21/217) and 15.1% (23/151), respectively. Three semen parameters including normal morphology before sperm separation, rapid and VCL after sperm separation were identified as predictors of pregnancy by IUI. These variables would be helpful when counselling patients before they make the decision to proceed with in vitro fertilization (IVF)/intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)-ET.

Isolated teratozoospermia and intrauterine insemination

OBJECTIVE

This study tests the hypothesis that IUI treatment in cases with isolated teratozoospermia (<10% normal forms using strict criteria, normal motility and normal count), results in a lower cumulative live birth rate compared to cases with normozoospermia.

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

An academic fertility center.

PATIENT(S)

Eight hundred seventy-two IUI cycles in 440 couples were analyzed.

INTERVENTION(S)

Couples (n = 440) were classified in three groups: normozoospermia (n = 213), isolated teratozoospermia (n = 104), and male factor infertility (n = 123).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Live birth rate per cycle and cumulative live birth rate (CLBR).

RESULT(S)

The three groups were similar with regard to female age, female infertility factors, and ovarian response after hormonal stimulation. The overall CLBR after four cycles was 41.5%, and was significantly increased in the normozoospermic group (52.8%) when compared to the isolated teratozoospermia group (33.4%) and the male factor infertility group (31.4%).

CONCLUSION(S)

This study documents for the first time that the CLBR after four IUI cycles is significantly and similarly reduced in couples with isolated teratozoospermia as in couples with other sperm defects, when compared to couples with normozoospermia. As with couples with male factor infertility, couples with isolated teratozoospermia should be counseled about other treatment options such as IVF, as the CLBR after three IVF cycles is 70%-80% in our program.

Efficacy and pregnancy outcome of two methods of semen preparation for intrauterine insemination: a prospective randomized study

OBJECTIVE

To examine pregnancy outcome with two methods of semen preparation for intrauterine insemination (IUI).

DESIGN

Prospective and randomized study.

SETTINGS

Academic tertiary center.

PATIENT(S)

Three hundred eleven couples undergoing 676 consecutive cycles of assisted conception using IUI.

INTERVENTION(S)

Semen samples collected for IUI were randomized to wash only or density gradient centrifugation (DGC) processing.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Various prepreparation and postpreparation semen parameters were used for IUI. The influence of the method of semen processing, and impact of various semen parameters and female factors on pregnancy were examined by receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves, logistic regression, and life table analysis.

RESULT(S)

Of the 676 cycles, 88 resulted in conception leading to an overall clinical pregnancy rate of 13.0% per cycle and 28.3% per patient with a miscarriage rate of 34.0%. Eighty-eight percent of pregnancies occurred in the first three cycles of IUI and 95.5% within the first four cycles. The pregnancy rate for wash only was 11.6% (37 of 319) and the rate for DGC was 14.3% (51 of 356). However, in samples with <22 million motile sperm in the inseminate, pregnancy rates were 4% for wash and 18% for DGC. The woman's age for both methods and the percentage of sperm in the original semen with a velocity of > or =80 micro m/s for the wash method influenced pregnancy outcome.

CONCLUSION(S)

Although samples with an acceptable number of motile sperm can be processed efficiently by wash only, poor quality semen samples should be processed using DGC.

Optimal treatment for poor responders to ovarian stimulation: does in vitro insemination offer any advantages to intrauterine insemination?

A retrospective study was performed of 1832 consecutive in vitro insemination (IVF)/intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycles over 18 months, to analyse the benefits or otherwise to the patient of continuing with in vitro treatment or converting the assisted conception cycle to intrauterine insemination (IUI). Two hundred and seventy cycles were identified in which three follicles or fewer were obtained after controlled ovarian hyperstimulation; in 143 of these cycles, the clinicians or patients elected to abandon all treatment, whereas treatment was continued in 127 patients. In 79 cycles, the patients proceeded with IVF/ICSI and in 48 patients, the cycles were converted to IUI. Data were analysed with regard to the clinical pregnancy rate. In addition, the data for IUI were compared with eight cycles of supraovulation IUI (S/IUI) performed over the same period. There were no significant differences in clinical pregnancy rates among any treatment modality 6/48 (12.5%), 6/79 (7.7%) and 1/8 (12.5%) for IUI, IVF and S/IUI, respectively (P = 0.64). The lowest total number of motile spermatozoa required to achieve pregnancy using IUI was 2.0 x 10(6). In conclusion, it appears that, if the treatment is suitable, patients who respond poorly to controlled hyperstimulation for IVF would not be disadvantaged in achieving a pregnancy by offering them conversion to the medically and financially less interventional IUI.

Relationship between zona pellucida-induced acrosome reaction, sperm morphology, sperm-zona pellucida binding, and in vitro fertilization

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the possible relationships between sperm morphology, acrosome responsiveness to solubilized human zona pellucida, and sperm-zona binding potential among [1] consecutive andrology referrals and [2] randomly selected in vitro fertilization (IVF) cases.

DESIGN

Prospective analytical study.

SETTING

Academic training hospital.Randomly selected couples consulting for infertility.

INTERVENTION(S)

Acrosome reaction response to solubilized human zona pellucida was recorded.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

We determined the difference in the percentage of sperm that acrosome reacted after exposure to solubilized zona pellucida and spontaneous acrosome reaction. The results were expressed as percentage zona induced acrosome reaction (ZIAR).

RESULT(S)

Data were analyzed using correlation coefficients (r) and receiver operator characteristics (ROC curve analyses). The ROC curve analyses indicated ZIAR to be a sensitive indicator for fertilization failure during IVF therapy, with sensitivity and specificity of 81% and 75%, respectively. For andrology referrals, a positive and statistically significant correlation existed between ZIAR data and sperm morphology (r = 0.65) and sperm-zona binding (r = 0.57).

CONCLUSION(S)

ZIAR results provide further information regarding dysfunctional sperm and can be used as an additional diagnostic test. Our results predicted fertilization failure during IVF treatment.

Semen quality and intrauterine insemination

There is good evidence in literature that intrauterine insemination (IUI) is the best first line treatment and most cost-effective procedure for moderate male factor subfertility. It seems very difficult to identify individual semen parameters predicting the likelihood of pregnancy after IUI. This can be explained by a lack of standardization of semen analysis, but many other methodological variables may also influence IUI success rates such as the patient selection, type of ovarian stimulation and number of inseminations per cycle. A review of the literature confirmed that sperm morphology using strict criteria and the inseminating motile sperm count (IMC) after sperm preparation are the two most important sperm parameters to assess the real impact of semen quality on IUI outcome. A universal threshold level above which IUI can be performed with acceptable pregnancy rates has not been determined yet, although IUI success seems to be impaired with <5% normal spermatozoa and an IMC of <1 x 10(6). Until now, no method of sperm preparation has been shown to be superior with regard to pregnancy rate after IUI. Whether supplementation of culture media with substances such as antioxidants and platelet activating factor may improve the results remains the subject of further research.

Sperm morphology analysis using strict criteria as a prognostic factor in intrauterine insemination

The objective of this study was to investigate the predictive value of Kruger's criteria for sperm morphology on intrauterine insemination (IUI) outcome. A total of 209 infertile patients underwent 244 IUI treatment cycles. These include 75 couples (80 cycles) with teratozoospermia and 134 couples (164 cycles) with unexplained infertility. The pregnancy rates per IUI cycle were 3.8 (1/26), 18.5 (10/54) and 29.9% (49/164) in patients with sperm morphology with <4, 4-9 and >9% normal forms, respectively, according to Kruger's criteria. A statistical difference in outcome was seen between couples with <4 and >9% normal forms (p = 0.005). Although the difference in pregnancy rates between those with 4-9 and <4% normal forms was not statistically significant, the pregnancy rate for those with 4-9% normal forms was acceptable and still higher than in those with <4% normal forms. Therefore, we suggest that IUI is a reasonable first-line therapy for patients with sperm morphology >4% normal forms, while couples with <4% normal forms should be advised to use in vitro fertilization with intracytoplasmic sperm injection instead of IUI.

Prospective, randomized, blinded evaluation of donor semen quality provided by seven commercial sperm banks

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate variability in donor semen quality between seven commercial donor sperm banks, within sperm banks, and between intracervical insemination and intrauterine insemination.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, blind evaluation of commercially available donor semen samples.

SETTING

An academic andrology laboratory.

PATIENT(S)

Seventy-five cryopreserved donor semen samples were evaluated.

INTERVENTION(S)

Samples were coded, then blindly evaluated for semen quality.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Standard semen quality parameters, including concentration, motility parameters, World Health Organization criteria morphology, and strict criteria morphology.

RESULT(S)

Significant differences were observed between donor semen banks for most semen quality parameters analyzed in intracervical insemination samples. In general, the greatest variability observed between banks was in percentage progressive sperm motility (range, 8.8 +/- 5.8 to 42.4 +/- 5.5) and normal sperm morphology (strict criteria; range, 10.1 +/- 3.3 to 26.6 +/- 4.7). Coefficients of variation within sperm banks were generally high.

CONCLUSION(S)

These data demonstrate the variability of donor semen quality provided by commercial sperm banks, both between banks and within a given bank. No relationship was observed between the size or type of sperm bank and the degree of variability. The data demonstrate the lack of uniformity in the criteria used to screen potential semen donors and emphasize the need for more stringent screening criteria and strict quality control in processing samples.

Sperm morphological defects related to environment, lifestyle and medical history of 1001 male partners of pregnant women from four European cities

BACKGROUND

Recently, differences in semen quality have been found among the partners of pregnant women from four European cities: Turku, Copenhagen, Edinburgh and Paris.

METHODS

During this study, slides from the four centres were subjected to a centralized assessment of sperm morphology. The percentages of sperm defects were recorded using a multiple-entry classification enabling the calculation of the multiple anomalies index (MAI), which is the mean number of anomalies per abnormal sperm. The relationships between various sperm abnormalities and self-reported data on medical history, lifestyle and occupational factors were examined.

RESULTS

Significant differences in the MAI and most of the sperm defects were found between the four cities, and more abnormalities were found in spring than in winter. An increase in some sperm abnormalities was related to medical treatment of the mother during pregnancy, higher birthweight and previous treatment for cryptorchidism. Significant variations of several sperm defects were related to stress, weekly working time, occupational posture and metal welding, suggesting directions for further exposure studies.

CONCLUSION

The present study indicated that the detailed assessment of sperm abnormalities is a useful biomarker of the effect of various external factors which may qualitatively affect human spermatogenesis.

Stepwise regression analysis to study male and female factors impacting on pregnancy rate in an intrauterine insemination programme

The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of male and female factors on the pregnancy rate in an intrauterine insemination (IUI) programme. Data on 522 cycles were retrospectively studied. All patients 39 years or younger were included in the study where data were available on male and female diagnosis, as well as on ovulation induction methodology. Regression analysis was possible on 495 cycles to study different factors affecting the pregnancy rate per treatment cycle. Logistic regression identified variables which were related to outcome and were subsequently incorporated into a statistical model. The number of follicles was found to have a linear association with the risk ratio (chance) of pregnancy. The age of the woman was also found to have a linear (negative) association with pregnancy. The percentage motility and percentage normal morphology (by strict criteria) of spermatozoa in the fresh ejaculate were the male factors that significantly and independently predicted the outcome. Percentage motility > or = 50 was associated with a risk ratio of pregnancy of 2.95 compared to percentage motility < 50. Percentage normal sperm morphology > 14% was associated with a risk ratio of pregnancy of 1.8 compared to percentage normal morphology < or = 14%. Female patients with idiopathic infertility were divided into three groups according to normal sperm morphology. The pregnancy rate per cycle was 2.63% (1/38) for the P (poor) pattern group (0-4% normal forms), 11.4% (17/149) for the G (good) pattern group (5-14%), and 24% (18/75) for the N (normal) pattern group (> 14% normal forms). A female diagnosis of endometriosis or tubal factor impacted negatively on the probability of pregnancy (risk ratio of 0.17), compared with other female diagnoses. Male and female factors contribute to pregnancy outcome, but the clinician can influence prognosis by increasing the number of follicles, especially in severe male factor cases.

[Predictive value of non-automated spermatic parameters and automated kinetic parameters on cleavage rate in fertilization in vitro]

The aim of this work was to determine retrospectively in 114 couples the predictive value of semen analysis for the in vitro fertilization (IVF) outcome when sperm evaluation before IVF was assessed by either conventional parameters or a Hamilton-Thorne automated motility analyser. A backward logistic regression analysis was used to study the relative contribution of each conventional or computerized parameter. Computerized sperm values were the worst index for predicting oocyte fertilization. However a tight relationship between morphology and cleavage ratio was observed. Using ROC analysis, under a 18% threshold, cleavage failure was noted in 71% of couples undergoing an IVF program. This study indicates that morphology is the best parameter for predicting cleavage failure.

A study of semen parameters with emphasis on sperm morphology in a fertile population: an attempt to develop clinical thresholds

The aim of the study was to determine the semen parameters of a proven fertile population and to compare these parameters with that of a subfertile group in the same region. Sixty-nine fertile male patients were studied and compared with 93 patients recruited at an infertility clinic. A sub-sample of patients was matched according to age. Sixty-one were studied in the fertile group and 62 in the infertile group. Receiver operator characteristics analysis was done on the sub-sample. The threshold value of the progressive motility was 42% and it was the best parameter with sperm morphology to distinguish between the two groups. At 69% sensitivity and 67% specificity the sperm morphology threshold was 12% normal forms. If the positive and negative predictive value was used to screen the general population to identify the subfertile group, a 5% normal morphology threshold was indicated with 14% progressive motility, 30% motility and a concentration of 9x10(6)/ml or lower. The negative predictive values of the parameters were good and achieved 90% in most cases. The sensitivity of the semen parameters at the reported thresholds was poor and indicated a large overlap in the distributions of these variables in the fertile and infertile groups. To distinguish between the fertile and subfertile population, the most significant finding of this study was the progressive motility with a threshold level of 14%. The cut-off value of the sperm morphology (5%) in vivo was consistent with the previous publications in assisted reproduction programmes for sperm morphology.

Intrauterine insemination in male factor subfertility: significance of sperm motility and morphology assessed by strict criteria

The study was conducted to evaluate the results of IUI treatment in a homogenous group with male factor infertility, and to assess the correlation of sperm variables, including sperm morphology by strict criteria, with pregnancy achievement after IUI. A total of 108 couples with no apparent female aetiology for infertility underwent 264 intrauterine insemination treatment cycles. A comparison was made between the sperm variables in two groups in which the achievement of pregnancy differed. The percentage of motile spermatozoa, degree of motility and normal morphology (by strict criteria) were significantly higher in the pregnant group compared with that of the nonpregnant group. A significant difference in pregnancy rates per couple after intrauterine insemination was demonstrated among three groups according to the percentage of sperm morphology, i.e. poor (< 4%), fair (4-14%) or good (> 14%) (11.1%; 36.1% and 50.0%, respectively). Intrauterine insemination is a valid mode of treatment in cases with male infertility, provided that normal morphology by strict criteria is higher than 4%.

A randomized study of the effect of 10 minutes of bed rest after intrauterine insemination

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effects of 10 minutes of bed rest after intrauterine insemination (IUI) on the pregnancy rate.

DESIGN

Prospective randomized study.

SETTING

University teaching hospital.

PATIENT(S)

One hundred sixteen couples with unexplained infertility.

INTERVENTION(S)

Patients were prospectively randomized either to immediate mobilization after IUI (group I) or to remain in a supine position for 10 minutes after the procedure (group II).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Cumulative pregnancy rate.

RESULT(S)

Ninety-five couples were included in the analysis. Group I consisted of 40 couples (90 cycles), and group II consisted of 55 couples (120 cycles). The pregnancy rate per couple in group I (4 of 40 [10%]) was significantly lower than in group II (16 of 55 [29%]). The pregnancy rate per cycle in group I (4.4%) was also lower than in group II (13. 3%). With use of life-table analysis, the cumulative probability of pregnancy in group II was significantly higher than in group I.

CONCLUSION(S)

A 10-minute interval of bed rest after IUI has a positive effect on the pregnancy rate. We recommend that mandatory bed rest for 10 minutes after IUI should be adopted into a standard practice.

The effect of patient and semen characteristics on live birth rates following intrauterine insemination: a retrospective study

PURPOSE

To identify characteristics of female patients and of semen that were associated with live birth following intrauterine insemination (IUI).

METHODS

Retrospective review of medical and laboratory results from 533 women who underwent IUI with partner's sperm from 1993 through 1995.

RESULTS

Among 1728 cycles, 116 (6.7%) resulted in live deliveries. Among the 38 patient and semen variables analyzed, only 3 were associated with successful IUI outcome: female age < 37.7 years at the time of treatment (P = 0.02); the absence of any corrective pelvic surgery (P < 0.001); and postwash sperm motility (P = 0.006). Couples with none of these three risk factors achieved per-cycle pregnancy rates of 12.4%. Women with two risk factors (age and pelvic surgery) achieved per-cycle pregnancy rates of 4.6% when sperm had good postwash motility. No pregnancies were achieved when low postwash motility was combined with any other risk factor.

CONCLUSIONS

Advanced female age, poor postwash sperm motility, and a history of corrective pelvic surgery are significant risk factors for poor IUI success rates. Poor postwash sperm motility in combination with either of these other two risk factors resulted in no successful pregnancies.

Assessment of the dominant abnormal form is useful for predicting the outcome of intracytoplasmic sperm injection in the case of severe teratozoospermia

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to investigate the relation between the dominant sperm anomaly and sperm morphology and the outcome of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI).

METHODS

Two hundred ninety-five patients who underwent a total of 181 cycles of in vitro fertilization (n = 168) and/or 217 cycles of ICSI (n = 177) between July 1995 and May 1997 at Keio University Hospital were investigated.

RESULTS

The rates of fertilization and pregnancy were 63.3 and 27.8%, respectively, in ICSI cycles with < or = 4% normal forms. When the percentage of strictly normal morphology was < or = 4, the fertilization rate was lower in the case of severely tapered head (13.0%; n = 4) than in the cases of other deformities in ICSI. The acrosomal defect made no difference in the fertilization rate with ICSI.

CONCLUSIONS

The predominant abnormal form affects the ICSI outcome in the case of < or = 4% normal forms.

Intra- and inter-laboratory variability in the assessment of sperm morphology by strict criteria: impact of semen preparation, staining techniques and manual versus computerized analysis

We designed prospective studies to compare manual and computerized analysis of sperm morphology by strict criteria using different semen processing and staining techniques. A total of 54 semen samples were studied; slides were prepared from each subject from liquefied semen and after washing, and stained with Diff-Quik or Papanicolaou. An intra-laboratory, blind assessment was performed manually (two observers) and using a computerized analyser (two readings). This demonstrated a very good correlation between manual analysis of liquefied and washed samples with both staining techniques [intraclass coefficient (ICC) = 0.93 and 0.83]. Greater agreement was observed between computerized readings (washed samples) of Diff-Quik (ICC = 0.93) than of Papanicolaou-stained slides (ICC = 0.66). An excellent intra-laboratory correlation was observed for within-computer readings (ICC = 0.93). There was moderate agreement between inter-laboratory computer readings (two centres, ICC = 0.72). Although there was lower inter-laboratory agreement for manual and manual versus computer readings, overall results of all manual and computer analyses showed good agreement (ICC = 0.73). Diff-Quik staining is reliable for both manual (liquefied) and computer (washed) analysis of strict sperm morphology. Intra- and inter-computer analyses using this method reached satisfactory levels of agreement. There is still high inter-laboratory variability for the manual method.

Multicenter study on reproducibility of sperm morphology assessments

Sperm morphology has always been considered an important tool in evaluating a man's fertilizing potential. The objective of this multicentric study was to evaluate intra- and interindividual variability and between-laboratory variation using the same or different criteria of sperm morphology assessment. Semen samples were obtained from 20 males and 32 smears were made of all samples. Eighty coded smears (4 per patient) were sent to 8 laboratories for morphology assessment. The centers applied different classification systems (strict criteria, WHO 1987, Düsseldorf criteria) and participants were asked to analyze the 80 smears twice, with an interval of 1 week between each participant's two analyses. Intraclass correlations between repeats showed that sperm morphology can be assessed with acceptable within observer reproducibility. Expected increases in imprecision were observed up to coefficients of variation of >30% with decreasing morphology scores, regardless of the classification system used. Agreement in correct classification of samples as normal/abnormal was obtained in 80% of cases. Differences in reproducibility between slides may reflect an important source of heterogeneity due to smear preparation. These results emphasize the importance of external quality control systems to improve the value of sperm morphology assessments in the investigation of the male partner in a subfertile couple.

Percentage of normal sperm heads is significantly increased by Percoll separation of semen

The purpose of this study was to assess objectively the effects of Percoll separation on human sperm head morphometry. Semen samples were washed and smears were prepared on slides. An aliquot of each sample was centrifuged on a Percoll gradient and spermatozoa were prepared on slides. Dimensions of sperm heads from each sample were assessed by computer-aided sperm head morphometry analysis and manual sperm morphology was assessed for each sample. The percentage of normal sperm heads and morphometric dimensions from washed and post-Percoll separated samples were compared across all men by a paired t-test. Correlations between normal sperm head morphometry and manual sperm morphology were assessed in washed and Percoll-separated samples. The percentage of normal sperm head morphometry was significantly (p < 0.001) higher in Percoll-separated samples than in washed samples (23.6 vs. 12.6%). No differences (p > 0.1) in mean sperm head measurements were detected between washed samples and Percoll-separated samples. Coefficients of variation for mean sperm head measurements were significantly lower in Percoll-separated samples. No correlation (p > 0.1) in percentage normal was found between computer-assisted sperm head morphometry and manual morphology for washed and post-Percoll samples. These results indicate that percentage normal sperm head morphometry is increased by Percoll separation. While sperm head dimensions were unchanged, sample variability was decreased.

Zona pellucida mediated acrosome reaction and sperm morphology

Sperm samples from 29 men randomly selected from the andrology laboratory, were used to evaluate acrosome reaction response to solubilized human zona pellucida. Capacitated sperm samples were exposed to a solution containing 2 zona pellucidae (ZP) per microl for 60 min, after which acrosomal status were recorded using a PSA-FITC technique. Controls included samples supplied by fertile sperm donors. After completion of acrosome reaction studies, patient samples were divided according to the percentage of morphologically normal spermatozoa. Three basic groups were identified, namely, fertile donors, teratozoospermic (normal sperm morphology 5-14%; n = 25) and severely teratozoospermic (normal sperm morphology < 4%; n = 4) groups. The mean percent normal sperm were 15.8 +/- 0.9, 10.4 +/- 0.7 and 2.7 +/- 0.7, respectively, for normozoospermic donors, teratozoospermic and severely teratozoospermic men. The mean percentage (+/-SE) ZP mediated acrosome reacted sperm among teratozoospermic and severely teratozoospermic cases was 25.8% +/- 0.9 and 19.0% +/- 0.9 (P = 0.001), compared to 36.8% +/- 0.9 for the donor controls. Results were analysed and expressed as correlations between sperm morphology and acrosomal response to human solubilized zona pellucida, spontaneous and calcium ionophore induced acrosome reaction. Predictive values for acrosome responsiveness were depicted with ROC curve analyses. Sperm morphology evaluated by strict criteria correlated positively and highly significantly with the responsiveness of the acrosome reaction (r = 0.91, P = 0.0001). At a morphology cut-off value of 4%, the ROC curve analysis showed sperm morphology to be highly predictive of zona pellucida induced acrosome responsiveness with a sensitivity of 100% and negative predictive value of 100%. Spontaneous and calcium ionophore induced acrosome reactions revealed no correlation with sperm morphology. It was concluded that (i) morphological features of human spermatozoa are indicative of specific functional characteristics; (ii) zona pellucida induction of the acrosome reaction is superior, as a predictor of sperm morphology, compared to calcium ionophore induced and spontaneous acrosome reactions.

Morphometric differences in sperm head dimensions of fertile and subfertile stallions

Gross morphological evaluation of stallion spermatozoa is of clinical value in assessing male fertility in the horse. While of value, methods of subjective sperm classification yield highly variable results. Recent development of computer-assisted sperm morphometry analysis (ASMA) technology has allowed for the objective analysis of sperm head morphometry. In the current study, ASMA was employed to determine morphometric differences in sperm head dimensions between fertile and subfertile stallions. At least 200 spermatozoa from each of 10 fertile and 10 subfertile stallions were analyzed by a commercial ASMA instrument. The mean measurements for length, width, area, perimeter, and width/length for each stallion were recorded and group means compared by a two-sample t-test. The mean measurements for length, area and perimeter were significantly larger in the subfertile than the fertile group (5.77 microm vs 5.33 microm, 12.66 microm vs 11.37 microm and 14.59 microm vs 13.64 microm, respectively). The width of sperm heads from stallions in the subfertile group also tended to be larger than those of fertile stallions. The data suggest that differences in the dimensions of sperm heads may exist between fertile and subfertile stallions.

Strict criteria for the evaluation of human sperm morphology and its impact on assisted reproduction

Sperm morphology abnormalities can be identified in a large proportion of patients with failed and delayed fertilization when assessing this parameter with strict criteria. Statistical analyses of a large IVF population confirm that, in patients with severe teratozoospermia, fertilization rates can be enhanced in many cases by increasing insemination concentration. However, implantation rates are impaired, thereby affecting the ability of these patients to establish a viable pregnancy. Data from couples undergoing controlled ovarian stimulation/intrauterine insemination seem to support the use of strict morphology as a predictor of outcome in this setting, too. Although a descriptive parameter, sperm morphology assessed by strict criteria can be used as a biomarker of sperm dysfunction(s). These dysfunctions are multiple and include abnormalities of motion parameters, poorer capacity to bind to homologous zona pellucidae and penetrate zona-free eggs, and low incidence of spontaneous and induced acrosome reaction. At a cellular level, poor morphology is associated with a higher content of creatine kinase and impaired capacity to undergo appropriate changes in intracellular calcium concentration. Whether nuclear/DNA abnormalities are present still remains to be fully determined. A definitively objective evaluation of morphology based on these criteria may allow all centres specializing in assisted reproduction to analyse semen in a homogeneous fashion.