Qualitative research: is it becoming a new orthodoxy?

Spiritual coping mechanisms in chronically ill patients

Addressing spiritual needs is acknowledged as an essential component of holistic nursing care. Findings are emerging that suggest that chronic illness demands significant changes in patients' lifestyle. In such circumstances it is claimed that spiritual care can be therapeutic to patients (Cohen et al, 2000; Sherwood, 2000). This study was carried out in order to understand further the spiritual coping mechanisms of patients suffering from chronic illness. A qualitative methodology based on descriptive phenomenology was used to capture participants' lived experience. The main themes emerging from this study suggest that chronic illness led participants to use the following spiritual coping mechanisms: faith, prayer, and related sources of support. Patients coping with chronic illness were engaged in both a personal and private struggle. Patients may benefit from nursing interventions that are sensitive, supportive, and responsive to their spiritual needs.

Ideological implications of paradigm discourse

Whilst the notions of paradigm and paradigm shift have become popularized in nursing's scholarly literature, there has been relatively little critical analysis of their impact upon theoretical understanding. In this paper, the authors attempt to deconstruct the ways in which paradigm discourse has been applied in nursing scholarship, looking beyond the claims that are made in the name of paradigm shifts to the apparent motivation underlying those claims. Comparing discourse associated with the paradigm shifts that have emerged in nursing education, research and practice theory, they reveal an inherently divisive purpose to which paradigm language is commonly used, and examine the implications of the discourse for nursing knowledge development. On the basis of this analysis, the authors urge a cautious approach to the extremes of paradigm claims, and argue for a more thoughtful and lively dialogue regarding the interests served by locating ideological positions within paradigm language.