1
|
Tyler B, Walford H, Tamblyn J, Keay SD, Mavrelos D, Yasmin E, Al Wattar BH. Interventions to optimize embryo transfer in women undergoing assisted conception: a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analyses. Hum Reprod Update 2022; 28:480-500. [PMID: 35325124 PMCID: PMC9631462 DOI: 10.1093/humupd/dmac009] [Citation(s) in RCA: 9] [Impact Index Per Article: 4.5] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Figures] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 10/15/2021] [Revised: 02/02/2022] [Indexed: 12/14/2022] Open
Abstract
BACKGROUND Several interventions and techniques are suggested to improve the outcome of embryo transfer (ET) in assisted conception. However, there remains no consensus on the optimal practice, with high variations among fertility specialists. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE We conducted a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) aiming to identify effective interventions that could be introduced around the time of ET to improve reproductive outcomes. SEARCH METHODS We searched the electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane CENTRAL) from inception until March 2021 using a multi-stage search strategy of MeSH terms and keywords, and included all RCTs that evaluated an intervention in the 24-h period before/after ET in women undergoing IVF/ICSI. Our primary outcome was clinical pregnancy rate post-ET confirmed as viable pregnancy on ultrasound scan. We assessed the risk of bias in included trials and extracted data in duplicate. We pooled data using a random-effect meta-analysis and reported using risk ratio (RR) with 95% CI. We explored publication bias and effect modifiers using subgroup analyses. OUTCOMES Our search yielded 3685 citations of which we included 188 RCTs (38 interventions, 59 530 participants) with a median sample size of 200 (range 26-1761). The quality of included RCTs was moderate with most showing a low risk of bias for randomization (118/188, 62.8%) and attrition (105/188, 55.8%) but there was a significant risk of publication bias (Egger's test P = 0.001). Performing ET with ultrasound guidance versus clinical touch (n = 24, RR 1.265, 95% CI 1.151-1.391, I2 = 38.53%), hyaluronic acid versus routine care (n = 9, RR 1.457, 95% CI 1.197-1.261, I2 = 46.48%) and the use of a soft versus hard catheter (n = 27, RR 1.122, 95% CI 1.028-1.224, I2 = 57.66%) led to higher clinical pregnancy rates. Other pharmacological add-ons also showed a beneficial effect including granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF: n = 4, RR 1.774, 95% CI 1.252-2.512, I2 = 0), Atosiban (n = 7, RR 1.493, 95% CI 1.184-1.882, I2 = 68.27%) and hCG (n = 17, RR 1.232, 95% CI 1.099-1.382, I2 = 57.76%). Bed rest following ET was associated with a reduction in clinical pregnancy (n = 6, RR 0.857, 95% CI 0.741-0.991, I2 = 0.01%). Other commonly used interventions, such as non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, prophylactic antibiotics, acupuncture and cervical mucus removal, did not show a significant benefit on reproductive outcomes. Our effect estimates for other important outcomes, including miscarriage and live birth, were limited by the varied reporting across included RCTs. WIDER IMPLICATIONS Using ultrasound guidance, soft catheters and hyaluronic acid at the time of ET appears to increase clinical pregnancy rates. The use of Atosiban, G-CSF and hCG showed a trend towards increased clinical pregnancy rate, but larger trials are required before adopting these interventions in clinical practice. Bed rest post-ET was associated with a reduction in clinical pregnancy and should not be recommended.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Bede Tyler
- UCL Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK
| | - Hugo Walford
- UCL Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK
| | - Jennifer Tamblyn
- Institute of Metabolism and Systems Research (IMSR), University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
| | - Stephen D Keay
- Centre for Reproductive Medicine, University Hospital of Coventry & Warwickshire, Coventry, UK
| | - Dimitrios Mavrelos
- UCL Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK,Reproductive Medicine Unit, Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Wing, University College London Hospitals, London, UK
| | - Ephia Yasmin
- UCL Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK,Reproductive Medicine Unit, Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Wing, University College London Hospitals, London, UK
| | - Bassel H Al Wattar
- Correspondence address. Reproductive Medicine Unit, Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Wing, University College London Hospitals, London, UK, WC1E 6DB. E-mail:
| |
Collapse
|
3
|
Fernandes N, Bryant D, Griffith L, El-Rabbany M, Fernandes NM, Kean C, Marsh J, Mathur S, Moyer R, Reade CJ, Riva JJ, Somerville L, Bhatnagar N. Outcomes for patients with the same disease treated inside and outside of randomized trials: a systematic review and meta-analysis. CMAJ 2014; 186:E596-609. [PMID: 25267774 PMCID: PMC4216275 DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.131693] [Citation(s) in RCA: 20] [Impact Index Per Article: 2.0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [MESH Headings] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 11/01/2022] Open
Abstract
BACKGROUND It is unclear whether participation in a randomized controlled trial (RCT), irrespective of assigned treatment, is harmful or beneficial to participants. We compared outcomes for patients with the same diagnoses who did ("insiders") and did not ("outsiders") enter RCTs, without regard to the specific therapies received for their respective diagnoses. METHODS By searching the MEDLINE (1966-2010), Embase (1980-2010), CENTRAL (1960-2010) and PsycINFO (1880-2010) databases, we identified 147 studies that reported the health outcomes of "insiders" and a group of parallel or consecutive "outsiders" within the same time period. We prepared a narrative review and, as appropriate, meta-analyses of patients' outcomes. RESULTS We found no clinically or statistically significant differences in outcomes between "insiders" and "outsiders" in the 23 studies in which the experimental intervention was ineffective (standard mean difference in continuous outcomes -0.03, 95% confidence interval [CI] -0.1 to 0.04) or in the 7 studies in which the experimental intervention was effective and was received by both "insiders" and "outsiders" (mean difference 0.04, 95% CI -0.04 to 0.13). However, in 9 studies in which an effective intervention was received only by "insiders," the "outsiders" experienced significantly worse health outcomes (mean difference -0.36, 95% CI -0.61 to -0.12). INTERPRETATION We found no evidence to support clinically important overall harm or benefit arising from participation in RCTs. This conclusion refutes earlier claims that trial participants are at increased risk of harm.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Natasha Fernandes
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont.
| | - Dianne Bryant
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Lauren Griffith
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Mohamed El-Rabbany
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Nisha M Fernandes
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Crystal Kean
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Jacquelyn Marsh
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Siddhi Mathur
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Rebecca Moyer
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Clare J Reade
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - John J Riva
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Lyndsay Somerville
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| | - Neera Bhatnagar
- Faculty of Medicine (Natasha Fernandes, Mathur), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.; Faculty of Health Sciences (Bryant, Marsh, Moyer) and Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry (Bryant), The University of Western Ontario, London, Ont.; Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Bryant, Griffith), Department of Medicine (Nisha Fernandes), Health Sciences Library (Bhatnagar), Department of Family Medicine (Riva) and Division of Gynecologic Oncology (Reade), McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.; Faculty of Dentistry (El-Rabbany), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; School of Medical and Applied Sciences (Kean), Central Queensland University, Rockhampton, Australia; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Somerville), London Health Sciences Centre, London, Ont
| |
Collapse
|