Severe complex I deficiency in a case of neonatal-onset lactic acidosis and fatal liver failure

The p.M292T NDUFS2 mutation causes complex I-deficient Leigh syndrome in multiple families

Isolated complex I deficiency is the most frequently observed oxidative phosphorylation defect in children with mitochondrial disease, leading to a diverse range of clinical presentations, including Leigh syndrome. For most patients the genetic cause of the biochemical defect remains unknown due to incomplete understanding of the complex I assembly process. Nonetheless, a plethora of pathogenic mutations have been described to date in the seven mitochondrial-encoded subunits of complex I as well as in 12 of the nuclear-encoded subunits and in six assembly factors. Whilst several mitochondrial DNA mutations are recurrent, the majority of these mutations are reported in single families. We have sequenced core structural and functional nuclear-encoded subunits of complex I in a cohort of 34 paediatric patients with isolated complex I deficiency, identifying pathogenic mutations in 6 patients. These included a novel homozygous NDUFS1 mutation in an Asian child with Leigh syndrome, a previously identified NDUFS8 mutation (c.236C>T, p.P79L) in a second Asian child with Leigh-like syndrome and six novel, compound heterozygous NDUFS2 mutations in four white Caucasian patients with Leigh or Leigh-like syndrome. Three of these children harboured an identical NDUFS2 mutation (c.875T>C, p.M292T), which was also identified in conjunction with a novel NDUFS2 splice site mutation (c.866+4A>G) in a fourth Caucasian child who presented to a different diagnostic centre, with microsatellite and single nucleotide polymorphism analyses indicating that this was due to an ancient common founder event. Our results confirm that NDUFS2 is a mutational hotspot in Caucasian children with isolated complex I deficiency and recommend the routine diagnostic investigation of this gene in patients with Leigh or Leigh-like phenotypes.

Orthotopic liver transplantation for mitochondrial respiratory chain disorders: a study of 5 children

BACKGROUND

Liver involvement in mitochondrial respiratory chain disorders (MRCD) frequently ends in liver failure and death. Because of the high risk of extrahepatic, particularly neuromuscular, manifestations of the disease, the indication of orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) in these patients remains controversial. We report on 5 such children in whom OLT was carried out, in an attempt to help clarify the matter.

PATIENTS

Patients 1 and 2 presented with fulminant liver failure at ages 7 and 6 months respectively. Emergency liver transplantation was performed before etiological investigations were completed. Retrospective examination of the explanted livers showed defects in complexes I, III and IV. In patient 1, severe neurological deterioration occurred 2 months after OLT with fatal outcome 9 months later. Patient 2 is alive 22 months after OLT with moderate motor impairment. Patients 3, 4 and 5 presented with progressive liver failure before 6 months of age. Surgical liver biopsies displayed a 50% defect in complex IV (patient 3), a defect in complexes I, IV (patient 4) and in complexes I, III, IV (patient 5). Because there was no clinical extrahepatic involvement on investigations, OLT was carried out in these patients. Patient 3 died of multiple organ failure soon after OLT, patients 4 and 5 are alive respectively 21 months and 12 months after OLT with normal neurological examination.

CONCLUSION

OLT may be a valid therapeutic option in infants with delayed liver cell failure due to MRCD, only after performing in emergency a thorough inves tigation to exclude clinically significant extrahepatic, especially neuromuscular, involvement.

Fatal deterioration of neurological disease after orthotopic liver transplantation for valproic acid-induced liver damage

We describe a 12-year-old girl with an early onset neurologic disease of slow progressiveness and electro-encephalography showing epileptic activity. The girl developed fulminant liver failure 5 months after the start of valproic acid treatment. Repeated mitochondrial assays failed to prove a mitochondrial disorder, but muscle biopsies were slightly pathological. Liver histology indicated acute-on-chronic liver disease. Six weeks after a successful orthotopic liver transplantation her neurological condition deteriorated rapidly, soon leading to generalized cortical disease and death. Post-mortem brain examination showed advanced central nervous destruction. We suggest that this is a late-onset Huttenlocher variant of Alpers' syndrome, where fulminant liver failure can be triggered by valproic acid, and orthotopic liver transplantation can subsequently trigger a fatal neurologic deterioration. Our case illustrates that when a referral center receives a previously unknown patient with hepatocellular insufficiency, it might be impossible to differentiate between fulminant vs. acute-on-chronic liver failure, and the decision whether to perform a liver transplantation or not would become difficult.