CO2 sensitivity in humans breathing 1 or 2% CO2 in air

Physio-metabolic and clinical consequences of wearing face masks—Systematic review with meta-analysis and comprehensive evaluation

Background

As face masks became mandatory in most countries during the COVID-19 pandemic, adverse effects require substantiated investigation.

Methods

A systematic review of 2,168 studies on adverse medical mask effects yielded 54 publications for synthesis and 37 studies for meta-analysis (on n = 8,641, m = 2,482, f = 6,159, age = 34.8 ± 12.5). The median trial duration was only 18 min (IQR = 50) for our comprehensive evaluation of mask induced physio-metabolic and clinical outcomes.

Results

We found significant effects in both medical surgical and N95 masks, with a greater impact of the second. These effects included decreased SpO2 (overall Standard Mean Difference, SMD = −0.24, 95% CI = −0.38 to −0.11, p < 0.001) and minute ventilation (SMD = −0.72, 95% CI = −0.99 to −0.46, p < 0.001), simultaneous increased in blood-CO2 (SMD = +0.64, 95% CI = 0.31–0.96, p < 0.001), heart rate (N95: SMD = +0.22, 95% CI = 0.03–0.41, p = 0.02), systolic blood pressure (surgical: SMD = +0.21, 95% CI = 0.03–0.39, p = 0.02), skin temperature (overall SMD = +0.80 95% CI = 0.23–1.38, p = 0.006) and humidity (SMD +2.24, 95% CI = 1.32–3.17, p < 0.001). Effects on exertion (overall SMD = +0.9, surgical = +0.63, N95 = +1.19), discomfort (SMD = +1.16), dyspnoea (SMD = +1.46), heat (SMD = +0.70), and humidity (SMD = +0.9) were significant in n = 373 with a robust relationship to mask wearing (p < 0.006 to p < 0.001). Pooled symptom prevalence (n = 8,128) was significant for: headache (62%, p < 0.001), acne (38%, p < 0.001), skin irritation (36%, p < 0.001), dyspnoea (33%, p < 0.001), heat (26%, p < 0.001), itching (26%, p < 0.001), voice disorder (23%, p < 0.03), and dizziness (5%, p = 0.01).

Discussion

Masks interfered with O2-uptake and CO2-release and compromised respiratory compensation. Though evaluated wearing durations are shorter than daily/prolonged use, outcomes independently validate mask-induced exhaustion-syndrome (MIES) and down-stream physio-metabolic disfunctions. MIES can have long-term clinical consequences, especially for vulnerable groups. So far, several mask related symptoms may have been misinterpreted as long COVID-19 symptoms. In any case, the possible MIES contrasts with the WHO definition of health.

Conclusion

Face mask side-effects must be assessed (risk-benefit) against the available evidence of their effectiveness against viral transmissions. In the absence of strong empirical evidence of effectiveness, mask wearing should not be mandated let alone enforced by law.

Systematic review registration

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?ID=CRD42021256694, identifier: PROSPERO 2021 CRD42021256694.

Possible toxicity of chronic carbon dioxide exposure associated with face mask use, particularly in pregnant women, children and adolescents - A scoping review

Introduction

During the SARS-CoV-2-pandemic, face masks have become one of the most important ubiquitous factors affecting human breathing. It increases the resistance and dead space volume leading to a re-breathing of CO2. So far, this phenomenon and possible implications on early life has not been evaluated in depth.

Method

As part of a scoping review, literature was systematically reviewed regarding CO2 exposure and facemask use.

Results

Fresh air has around 0.04% CO2, while wearing masks more than 5 min bears a possible chronic exposure to carbon dioxide of 1.41% to 3.2% of the inhaled air. Although the buildup is usually within the short-term exposure limits, long-term exceedances and consequences must be considered due to experimental data. US Navy toxicity experts set the exposure limits for submarines carrying a female crew to 0.8% CO2 based on animal studies which indicated an increased risk for stillbirths. Additionally, mammals who were chronically exposed to 0.3% CO2 the experimental data demonstrate a teratogenicity with irreversible neuron damage in the offspring, reduced spatial learning caused by brainstem neuron apoptosis and reduced circulating levels of the insulin-like growth factor-1. With significant impact on three readout parameters (morphological, functional, marker) this chronic 0.3% CO2 exposure has to be defined as being toxic. Additional data exists on the exposure of chronic 0.3% CO2 in adolescent mammals causing neuron destruction, which includes less activity, increased anxiety and impaired learning and memory. There is also data indicating testicular toxicity in adolescents at CO2 inhalation concentrations above 0.5%.

Discussion

There is a possible negative impact risk by imposing extended mask mandates especially for vulnerable subgroups. Circumstantial evidence exists that extended mask use may be related to current observations of stillbirths and to reduced verbal motor and overall cognitive performance in children born during the pandemic. A need exists to reconsider mask mandates.

The effects of cloth face masks on cardiorespiratory responses and VO2 during maximal incremental running protocol among apparently healthy men

We aimed to determine the effects of wearing a cloth face mask on cardiorespiratory response, peak oxygen uptake (Vo₂), respiratory muscle effort, and exercise tolerance during incremental exercise. The study had a randomized crossover design: 11 apparently healthy young men performed the Bruce protocol treadmill test in two conditions, wearing a cloth face mask (CFM) and without CFM (CON), in random order. Minute ventilation and oxygen uptake were measured using a mass spectrometry metabolic analyzer; cardiac output (CO) was measured using an impedance CO monitor; and mouth pressure (P_m) was measured and calculated as an integral P_m to assess respiratory muscle effort. Maximal minute ventilation was 13.4 ± 10.7% lower in the CFM condition than in the CON condition (P < 0.001). The peak Vo₂ (52.4 ± 5.6 and 55.0 ± 5.1 mL/kg/min in CFM and CON, respectively) and CO were not significantly different between the two conditions. However, the integral value of P_m was significantly higher (P = 0.02), and the running time to exhaustion was 2.6 ± 3.2% lower (P = 0.02) in the CFM condition than in the CON condition. Our results suggest that wearing a cloth face mask increased respiratory muscle effort and decreased ventilatory volume in healthy young men; however, Vo₂ remained unchanged. Exercise tolerance also decreased slightly.

Integrated respiratory chemoreflex-mediated regulation of cerebral blood flow in hypoxia: Implications for oxygen delivery and acute mountain sickness

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? To what extent do hypoxia-induced changes in the peripheral and central respiratory chemoreflex modulate anterior and posterior cerebral oxygen delivery, with corresponding implications for susceptibility to acute mountain sickness? What is the main finding and its importance? We provide evidence for site-specific regulation of cerebral blood flow in hypoxia that preserves oxygen delivery in the posterior but not the anterior cerebral circulation, with minimal contribution from the central respiratory chemoreflex. External carotid artery vasodilatation might prove to be an alternative haemodynamic risk factor that predisposes to acute mountain sickness.

ABSTRACT

The aim of the present study was to determine the extent to which hypoxia-induced changes in the peripheral and central respiratory chemoreflex modulate anterior and posterior cerebral blood flow (CBF) and oxygen delivery (CDO₂ ), with corresponding implications for the pathophysiology of the neurological syndrome, acute mountain sickness (AMS). Eight healthy men were randomly assigned single blind to 7 h of passive exposure to both normoxia (21% O₂ ) and hypoxia (12% O₂ ). The peripheral and central respiratory chemoreflex, internal carotid artery, external carotid artery (ECA) and vertebral artery blood flow (duplex ultrasound) and AMS scores (questionnaires) were measured throughout. A reduction in internal carotid artery CDO₂ was observed during hypoxia despite a compensatory elevation in perfusion. In contrast, vertebral artery and ECA CDO₂ were preserved, and the former was attributable to a more marked increase in perfusion. Hypoxia was associated with progressive activation of the peripheral respiratory chemoreflex (P < 0.001), whereas the central respiratory chemoreflex remained unchanged (P > 0.05). Symptom severity in participants who developed clinical AMS was positively related to ECA blood flow (Lake Louise score, r = 0.546-0.709, P = 0.004-0.043; Environmental Symptoms Questionnaires-Cerebral symptoms score, r = 0.587-0.771, P = 0.001-0.027, n = 4). Collectively, these findings highlight the site-specific regulation of CBF in hypoxia that maintains CDO₂ selectively in the posterior but not the anterior cerebral circulation, with minimal contribution from the central respiratory chemoreflex. Furthermore, ECA vasodilatation might represent a hitherto unexplored haemodynamic risk factor implicated in the pathophysiology of AMS.

Impact of wearing a surgical and cloth mask during cycle exercise

We sought to determine the impact of wearing cloth or surgical masks on the cardiopulmonary responses to moderate-intensity exercise. Twelve subjects (n = 5 females) completed three, 8-min cycling trials while breathing through a non-rebreathing valve (laboratory control), cloth, or surgical mask. Heart rate (HR), oxyhemoglobin saturation (SpO₂), breathing frequency, mouth pressure, partial pressure of end-tidal carbon dioxide (P_etCO₂) and oxygen (P_etO₂), dyspnea were measured throughout exercise. A subset of n = 6 subjects completed an additional exercise bout without a mask (ecological control). There were no differences in breathing frequency, HR or SpO₂ across conditions (all p > 0.05). Compared with the laboratory control (4.7 ± 0.9 cmH₂O [mean ± SD]), mouth pressure swings were smaller with the surgical mask (0.9 ± 0.7; p < 0.0001), but similar with the cloth mask (3.6 ± 4.8 cmH₂O; p = 0.66). Wearing a cloth mask decreased P_etO₂ (-3.5 ± 3.7 mm Hg) and increased P_etCO₂ (+2.0 ± 1.3 mm Hg) relative to the ecological control (both p < 0.05). There were no differences in end-tidal gases between mask conditions and laboratory control (both p > 0.05). Dyspnea was similar between the control conditions and the surgical mask (p > 0.05) but was greater with the cloth mask compared with laboratory (+0.9 ± 1.2) and ecological (+1.5 ± 1.3) control conditions (both p < 0.05). Wearing a mask during short-term moderate-intensity exercise may increase dyspnea but has minimal impact on the cardiopulmonary response. Novelty: Wearing surgical or cloth masks during exercise has no impact on breathing frequency, tidal volume, oxygenation, and heart rate However, there are some changes in inspired and expired gas fractions that are physiologically irrelevant. In young healthy individuals, wearing surgical or cloth masks during submaximal exercise has few physiological consequences.

Face Masks and the Cardiorespiratory Response to Physical Activity in Health and Disease

To minimize transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), the novel coronavirus responsible for coronavirus disease (COVID-19), the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Health Organization recommend wearing face masks in public. Some have expressed concern that these may affect the cardiopulmonary system by increasing the work of breathing, altering pulmonary gas exchange and increasing dyspnea, especially during physical activity. These concerns have been derived largely from studies evaluating devices intentionally designed to severely affect respiratory mechanics and gas exchange. We review the literature on the effects of various face masks and respirators on the respiratory system during physical activity using data from several models: cloth face coverings and surgical masks, N95 respirators, industrial respirators, and applied highly resistive or high-dead space respiratory loads. Overall, the available data suggest that although dyspnea may be increased and alter perceived effort with activity, the effects on work of breathing, blood gases, and other physiological parameters imposed by face masks during physical activity are small, often too small to be detected, even during very heavy exercise. There is no current evidence to support sex-based or age-based differences in the physiological responses to exercise while wearing a face mask. Although the available data suggest that negative effects of using cloth or surgical face masks during physical activity in healthy individuals are negligible and unlikely to impact exercise tolerance significantly, for some individuals with severe cardiopulmonary disease, any added resistance and/or minor changes in blood gases may evoke considerably more dyspnea and, thus, affect exercise capacity.

Effects of short-term mild hypercapnia during head-down tilt on intracranial pressure and ocular structures in healthy human subjects

Many astronauts experience ocular structural and functional changes during long-duration spaceflight, including choroidal folds, optic disc edema, globe flattening, optic nerve sheath diameter (ONSD) distension, retinal nerve fiber layer thickening, and decreased visual acuity. The leading hypothesis suggests that weightlessness-induced cephalad fluid shifts increase intracranial pressure (ICP), which contributes to the ocular structural changes, but elevated ambient CO2 levels on the International Space Station may also be a factor. We used the spaceflight analog of 6° head-down tilt (HDT) to investigate possible mechanisms for ocular changes in eight male subjects during three 1-h conditions: Seated, HDT, and HDT with 1% inspired CO2 (HDT + CO2). Noninvasive ICP, intraocular pressure (IOP), translaminar pressure difference (TLPD = IOP-ICP), cerebral and ocular ultrasound, and optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans of the macula and the optic disc were obtained. Analysis of one-carbon pathway genetics previously associated with spaceflight-induced ocular changes was conducted. Relative to Seated, IOP and ICP increased and TLPD decreased during HDT During HDT + CO2 IOP increased relative to HDT, but there was no significant difference in TLPD between the HDT conditions. ONSD and subfoveal choroidal thickness increased during HDT relative to Seated, but there was no difference between HDT and HDT + CO2 Visual acuity and ocular structures assessed with OCT imaging did not change across conditions. Genetic polymorphisms were associated with differences in IOP, ICP, and end-tidal PCO2 In conclusion, acute exposure to mild hypercapnia during HDT did not augment cardiovascular outcomes, ICP, or TLPD relative to the HDT condition.

Interaction between the ventilatory and cerebrovascular responses to hypo- and hypercapnia at rest and during exercise

Cerebrovascular reactivity to changes in the partial pressure of arterial carbon dioxide (P(a,CO(2))) via limiting changes in brain [H(+)] modulates ventilatory control. It remains unclear, however, how exercise-induced alterations in respiratory chemoreflex might influence cerebral blood flow (CBF), in particular the cerebrovascular reactivity to CO(2). The respiratory chemoreflex system controlling ventilation consists of two subsystems: the central controller (controlling element), and peripheral plant (controlled element). In order to examine the effect of exercise-induced alterations in ventilatory chemoreflex on cerebrovascular CO(2) reactivity, these two subsystems of the respiratory chemoreflex system and cerebral CO(2) reactivity were evaluated (n = 7) by the administration of CO(2) as well as by voluntary hypo- and hyperventilation at rest and during steady-state exercise. During exercise, in the central controller, the regression line for the P(a,CO(2))-minute ventilation (VE) relation shifted to higher VE and P(a,CO(2)) with no change in gain (P = 0.84). The functional curve of the peripheral plant also reset rightward and upward during exercise. However, from rest to exercise, gain of the peripheral plant decreased, especially during the hypercapnic condition (-4.1 +/- 0.8 to -2.0 +/- 0.2 mmHg l(-1) min(-1), P = 0.01). Therefore, under hypercapnia, total respiratory loop gain was markedly reduced during exercise (-8.0 +/- 2.3 to -3.5 +/- 1.0 U, P = 0.02). In contrast, cerebrovascular CO(2) reactivity at each condition, especially to hypercapnia, was increased during exercise (2.4 +/- 0.2 to 2.8 +/- 0.2% mmHg(-1), P = 0.03). These findings indicate that, despite an attenuated chemoreflex system controlling ventilation, elevations in cerebrovascular reactivity might help maintain CO(2) homeostasis in the brain during exercise.

Effects of inhaled CO2 and added dead space on idiopathic central sleep apnea

We hypothesized that reductions in arterial PCO2 (PaCO2) below the apnea threshold play a key role in the pathogenesis of idiopathic central sleep apnea syndrome (ICSAS). If so, we reasoned that raising PaCO2 would abolish apneas in these patients. Accordingly, patients with ICSAS were studied overnight on four occasions during which the fraction of end-tidal CO2 and transcutaneous PCO2 were measured: during room air breathing (N1), alternating room air and CO2 breathing (N2), CO2 breathing all night (N3), and addition of dead space via a face mask all night (N4). Central apneas were invariably preceded by reductions in fraction of end-tidal CO2. Both administration of a CO2-enriched gas mixture and addition of dead space induced 1- to 3-Torr increases in transcutaneous PCO2, which virtually eliminated apneas and hypopneas; they decreased from 43.7 +/- 7.3 apneas and hypopneas/h on N1 to 5.8 +/- 0.9 apneas and hypopneas/h during N3 (P < 0.005), from 43.8 +/- 6.9 apneas and hypopneas/h during room air breathing to 5.9 +/- 2.5 apneas and hypopneas/h of sleep during CO2 inhalation during N2 (P < 0.01), and to 11.6% of the room air level while the patients were breathing through added dead space during N4 (P < 0.005). Because raising PaCO2 through two different means virtually eliminated central sleep apneas, we conclude that central apneas during sleep in ICSA are due to reductions in PaCO2 below the apnea threshold.

Ventilatory sensitivity to single breaths of CO2 around the control point in man

We used single inspiratory capacity breaths of 5, 6 or 8% CO2 in air to obtain ventilatory responses in normal subjects, with ensemble averaging of repeated runs to define stimulus and response (Protocol 1). We also compared the effect of an inspiratory capacity (IC) breath of 8% CO2 with that of two tidal volumes (TV) at the same concentration (Protocol 2). The ventilatory response was defined first as the ratio of peak changes in ventilation and end-tidal PCO2, and secondly by the ratio of their integrals. We obtained group mean values of 0.21 L min-1 mmHg-1 for the peak method and 0.80 L min-1 mmHg-1 for integrals (Protocol 1). There was no significant difference between IC and TV response values (Protocol 2) either by the peak method (0.17 vs 0.19 L min-1 mmHg-1) or by integrals (0.47 vs 0.53 L min-1 mmHg-1). A significant decrease in ventilation was seen in the second tidal volume 8% CO2 breath, even though the stimulus was unperceived by four out of five subjects. CO2 responses can be obtained from these techniques, but the necessary analysis is too cumbersome for general use. Taking a deep breath had no detectable separate effect, but CO2 in the airway may depress ventilation even at concentrations which the subject cannot detect.

Arterial PCO2 and pH in man during 3 days' exposure to 2.8 kPa CO2 in the inspired gas

It has not been firmly established how respiration adapts to long-term CO2 exposure in man. We have therefore exposed five healthy human subjects to 2.8 kPa CO2 in the inspired gas for about 70 h in a chamber with controlled atmospheric conditions at ambient pressure PCO2 and pH were determined in arterial or arterialized venous blood drawn before, during and after the exposure. One subject was studied twice. We found that PaCO2 increased acutely and then increased further within the 5- to 24-h period of exposure to 2.8 kPa CO2. No consistent change was observed during the following 2 days. At the end of exposure the PaCO2 was 0.5 kPa above the pre-exposure level. When the breathing gas was switched back to room air, PaCO2 promptly returned to pre-exposure values. The secondary rise in PaCO2 within the first day would correspond to a decrease in alveolar ventilation of about 10% assuming constant production and elimination of CO2. Arterial pH remained slightly below the pre-exposure level during the entire exposure period. A slight renal compensation resulting in an increase in base excess of about 1 mmol l-1 may have occurred in the middle part of the exposure period. We conclude that a significant, but moderate, respiratory adaptation takes place during the first day of exposure to an increased inspired load of CO2.

Arterial P CO2 and lung ventilation in man exposed to 1-5% CO2 in the inspired gas

Conflicting results have been published on the shape of the curve relating the change in lung ventilation to the change in alveolar or arterial PCO2 induced by increased inspired CO2 (the CO2 sensitivity). In this study eight human subjects with in-dwelling arterial cannulae were each exposed to five different levels of increased inspired CO2 (1-5%). Arterial PCO2 and ventilation were measured in the 7th minute of each period of CO2 exposure. Each CO2 exposure period was flanked by control periods in which similar measurements were carried out during air breathing. We found non-linear increases in both ventilation and arterial PCO2 with increasing levels of inspired CO2. When 5% CO2 in air was inspired the arterial PCO2 increased by about 15% of the inspired CO2 load. There was no significant non-linearity in the relation between change in alveolar ventilation (normalized to body surface) and change in arterial PCO2. The inter-individual variation in CO2 sensitivity was less when alveolar ventilation was normalized to the CO2 output rather than to body surface area. We conclude that the sensitivity to CO2 is close to constant within the range 0-5% CO2 in the inspired gas.