Comparative genomics reveals signature regions used to develop a robust and sensitive multiplex TaqMan real-time qPCR assay to detect the genus Dickeya and Dickeya dianthicola

Development and validation of genome-informed and multigene-based qPCR and LAMP assays for accurate detection of Dickeya solani: a critical quarantine pathogen threatening the potato industry

Dickeya solani one of the most aggressive pectinolytic phytopathogens, causes blackleg disease in potatoes, resulting in significant economic losses and adversely impacting one of the world's most important food crops. The diagnostics methods are critical in monitoring the latent infection for international trade of potato seed tubers and in implementation of control strategies. Our study employed a whole-genome comparative approach, identifying unique target gene loci (LysR and TetR family of transcriptional regulators gene regions) and designing loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) and a multi-gene-based multiplex TaqMan qPCR assays for specific detection and differentiation of D. solani. Both methods underwent meticulous validation with extensive inclusivity and exclusivity panels, exhibiting 100% accuracy and no false positives or negatives. The LAMP method demonstrated the detection limit of 100 fg and 1 CFU per reaction using pure genomic DNA and crude bacterial cell lysate, respectively. The qPCR detection limit was 1 pg, 100 fg and 10 fg with quadplex, triplex, and singleplex, respectively. None of the assays were impacted by any inhibitory or competitive effects after adding host DNA (in qPCR) or crude lysate (in LAMP). The assays proved robust and reproducible in detecting the target pathogen in infected samples, with the LAMP assay being field-deployable due to its simplicity and rapid results acquisition within approximately 9 min. The reproducibility was confirmed by performing the assay in two independent laboratories. These assays offer a robust, rapid, and reliable solution for routine testing, with applications in phytosanitary inspection, disease diagnosis, and epidemiological studies.IMPORTANCEDickeya solani, one of the most aggressive soft rot causing bacteria and a quarantine pathogen, poses a severe threat to food security by causing substantial economic losses to the potato industry. Accurate and timely detection of this bacterium is vital for monitoring latent infections, particularly for international trade of potato seed tubers, and for implementing effective control strategies. In this research, we have developed LAMP and multi-gene-based multiplex TaqMan qPCR assays for specific detection of D. solani. These assays, characterized by their precision, rapidity, and robustness, are crucial for distinguishing D. solani from related species. Offering unparalleled sensitivity and specificity, these assays are indispensable for phytosanitary inspection and epidemiological monitoring, providing a powerful tool enabling management of this threatening pathogen.

Looking for Resistance to Soft Rot Disease of Potatoes Facing Environmental Hypoxia

Plants are exposed to various stressors, including pathogens, requiring specific environmental conditions to provoke/induce plant disease. This phenomenon is called the "disease triangle" and is directly connected with a particular plant-pathogen interaction. Only a virulent pathogen interacting with a susceptible plant cultivar will lead to disease under specific environmental conditions. This may seem difficult to accomplish, but soft rot Pectobacteriaceae (SRPs) is a group virulent of pathogenic bacteria with a broad host range. Additionally, waterlogging (and, resulting from it, hypoxia), which is becoming a frequent problem in farming, is a favoring condition for this group of pathogens. Waterlogging by itself is an important source of abiotic stress for plants due to lowered gas exchange. Therefore, plants have evolved an ethylene-based system for hypoxia sensing. Plant response is coordinated by hormonal changes which induce metabolic and physiological adjustment to the environmental conditions. Wetland species such as rice (Oryza sativa L.), and bittersweet nightshade (Solanum dulcamara L.) have developed adaptations enabling them to withstand prolonged periods of decreased oxygen availability. On the other hand, potato (Solanum tuberosum L.), although able to sense and response to hypoxia, is sensitive to this environmental stress. This situation is exploited by SRPs which in response to hypoxia induce the production of virulence factors with the use of cyclic diguanylate (c-di-GMP). Potato tubers in turn reduce their defenses to preserve energy to prevent the negative effects of reactive oxygen species and acidification, making them prone to soft rot disease. To reduce the losses caused by the soft rot disease we need sensitive and reliable methods for the detection of the pathogens, to isolate infected plant material. However, due to the high prevalence of SRPs in the environment, we also need to create new potato varieties more resistant to the disease. To reach that goal, we can look to wild potatoes and other Solanum species for mechanisms of resistance to waterlogging. Potato resistance can also be aided by beneficial microorganisms which can induce the plant's natural defenses to bacterial infections but also waterlogging. However, most of the known plant-beneficial microorganisms suffer from hypoxia and can be outcompeted by plant pathogens. Therefore, it is important to look for microorganisms that can withstand hypoxia or alleviate its effects on the plant, e.g., by improving soil structure. Therefore, this review aims to present crucial elements of potato response to hypoxia and SRP infection and future outlooks for the prevention of soft rot disease considering the influence of environmental conditions.

Retrospective survey of Dickeya fangzhongdai using a novel validated real-time PCR assay

Dickeya fangzhongdai, an aggressive plant pathogen, causes symptoms on a variety of crops and ornamental plants including bleeding canker of Asian pear trees. Historical findings stress the need for a specific detection tool for D. fangzhongdai to prevent overlooking the pathogen or assigning it to general Dickeya spp. Therefore, a qualitative real-time PCR for specific detection of D. fangzhongdai has been developed and validated. The developed assay shows selectivity of 100%, diagnostic sensitivity of 76% and limit of detection with 95% confidence interval in plant matrices ranging from 311 to 2,275 cells/mL of plant extracts. The assay was successfully used in a retrospective survey of selected host plants of relevance to Europe and environmental niches relevant to D. fangzhongdai. Samples of potato tubers and plants, plants from the Malinae subtribe (apple, pear, quince, and Asian pear tree) and fresh surface water from Slovenia were analyzed. D. fangzhongdai was not detected in any plant samples, however, 12% of surface water samples were found to be positive.

Identification and characterization of opportunistic pathogen Pectobacterium polonicum causing potato blackleg in China

Blackleg and aerial stem rot of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.), caused by soft rot enterobacteria of the genera Pectobacterium and Dickeya, has recently increased years in Hebei Province, China. Field surveys were performed during the 2021 potato growing season in Hebei to identify and characterize bacterial pathogens. Sixteen potato plants showing blackleg or aerial stem rot were collected from three potato-producing areas, and ten representative pectinolytic bacteria were isolated from symptomatic plants. 16S rDNA sequencing and multilocus sequence analysis were performed to determine the taxonomic position of the bacterial isolates. The isolates belonged to the genus Pectobacterium, including Pectobacterium atrosepticum, Pectobacterium carotovorum, Pectobacterium brasiliense, and Pectobacterium parmentieri. The exceptions were isolates BY21311 and BY21312, which belonged to a new species of Pectobacterium polonicum previously found in groundwater. The taxonomy of isolate BY21311 was confirmed using whole genome-based analysis. P. polonicum has only been identified in potato plants on one farm in Baoding region in China. Isolates BY21311 and BY21312 displayed similar physiological and biochemical traits to the type strain DPMP315^T. Artificial inoculation assays revealed that isolate BY21311 fulfilled Koch's postulates for potato blackleg. These findings represent the first time P. polonicum, a water-associated Pectobacterium species may be the cause of blackleg in the field. Interestingly, P. polonicum BY21311 has reduced ability to macerate potato tubers when compared to P. atrosepticum, P. brasiliense, P. versatile, and P. parvum, which is more virulent in tubers than the type strain DPMP315^T. The host range of isolate BY21311 was determined by injection method, which can impregnate five plants. Although the genome of isolate BY21311 harbors gene clusters encoding a type III secretion system, it did not elicit a hypersensitive response (HR) in Nicotiana benthamiana or N. tabacum leaves. T3SS effector AvrE and T4SS effector PilN were obtained by predicting isolate BY21311 genome. P. polonicum appears to show significant variations in gene content between two genomes, and gene content varies between isolates BY21311 and DPMP315^T, with strain specific-genes involved in many aspects, including lipopolysaccharide biosynthesis, substrate translocation, T4SS and T6SS among others, suggesting that isolates BY21311 and DPMP315^T might represent distinct clades within the species.

Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for specific and rapid detection of Dickeya fangzhongdai targeting a unique genomic region

Dickeya fangzhongdai, a bacterial pathogen of taro (Colocasia esculenta), onion (Allium sp.), and several species in the orchid family (Orchidaceae) causes soft rot and bleeding canker diseases. No field-deployable diagnostic tool is available for specific detection of this pathogen in different plant tissues. Therefore, we developed a field-deployable loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay using a unique genomic region, present exclusively in D. fangzhongdai. Multiple genomes of D. fangzhongdai, and other species of Dickeya, Pectobacterium and unrelated genera were used for comparative genomic analyses to identify an exclusive and conserved target sequence from the major facilitator superfamily (MFS) transporter gene region. This gene region had broad detection capability for D. fangzhongdai and thus was used to design primers for endpoint PCR and LAMP assays. In-silico validation showed high specificity with D. fangzhongdai genome sequences available in the NCBI GenBank genome database as well as the in-house sequenced genome. The specificity of the LAMP assay was determined with 96 strains that included all Dickeya species and Pectobacterium species as well as other closely related genera and 5 hosts; no false positives or false negatives were detected. The detection limit of the assay was determined by performing four sensitivity assays with tenfold serially diluted purified genomic DNA of D. fangzhongdai with and without the presence of crude host extract (taro, orchid, and onion). The detection limit for all sensitivity assays was 100 fg (18-20 genome copies) with no negative interference by host crude extracts. The assays were performed by five independent operators (blind test) and on three instruments (Rotor-Gene, thermocycler and dry bath); the assay results were concordant. The assay consistently detected the target pathogen from artificially inoculated and naturally infected host samples. The developed assay is highly specific for D. fangzhongdai and has applications in routine diagnostics, phytosanitary and seed certification programs, and epidemiological studies.

Development of a multiplex TaqMan qPCR targeting unique genomic regions for the specific and sensitive detection of Pectobacterium species and P. parmentieri

AIM

The newly defined species P. parmentieri has emerged as an aggressive pathogen that causes soft rot and blackleg diseases on potato and has been widely disseminated across the globe, jeopardizing the productivity and potato food safety. The implementation of a fast and accurate detection tool is imperative to control, monitor and prevent further spread of these pathogens. The objective of this work was to develop a specific and sensitive multiplex TaqMan qPCR to detect P. parmentieri and distinguish it from all known Pectobacterium species. A universal internal control (UIC) was included to enhance the reliability of the assay.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A comparative genomics approach was used to identify O-acetyltransferase and the XRE family transcriptional regulator as specific targets for primers/probe design for the detection of the Pectobacterium genus and P. parmentieri, respectively. Specificity was assessed with 35 and 25 strains included inclusivity and exclusivity panels, respectively, isolated from different geographic locations and sources. The assay specifically detected all 35 strains of Pectobacterium sp. and all 15 P. parmentieri strains. No cross-reactivity was detected during assay validation. Our assay detected up to 10 fg genomic DNA and 1 CFU ml^-1 bacterial culture. No change in the detection threshold (1 CFU ml^-1 ) was observed in spiked assays after adding host tissue to the reactions. The assay was validated with naturally and artificially infected host tissues and soil rhizosphere samples. All infected plant samples containing the target pathogens were accurately amplified.

CONCLUSION

The presented multiplex TaqMan qPCR diagnostic assay is highly specific, sensitive, reliable for the detection of Pectobacterium species and P. parmentieri with no false positives or false negatives.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT

The developed assay can be adopted for multiple purposes such as seed certification programs, surveillance, biosecurity, microbial forensics, quarantine, border protection, inspections, and epidemiology.

Genome-informed loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay for specific detection of Pectobacterium parmentieri in infected potato tissues and soil

Pectobacterium parmentieri (formerly Pectobacterium wasabiae), which causes soft rot disease in potatoes, is a newly established species of pectinolytic bacteria within the family Pectobacteriaceae. Despite serious damage caused to the potato industry worldwide, no field-deployable diagnostic tests are available to detect the pathogen in plant samples. In this study, we aimed to develop a reliable, rapid, field-deployable loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for the specific detection of P. parmentieri. Specific LAMP primers targeting the petF1 gene region, found in P. parmentieri but no other Pectobacterium spp., were designed and validated in silico and in vitro using extensive inclusivity (15 strains of P. parmentieri) and exclusivity (94 strains including all other species in the genus Pectobacterium and host DNA) panels. No false positives or negatives were detected when the assay was tested directly with bacterial colonies, and with infected plant and soil samples. Sensitivity (analytical) assays using serially diluted bacterial cell lysate and purified genomic DNA established the detection limit at 10 CFU/mL and 100 fg (18-20 genome copies), respectively, even in the presence of host crude DNA. Consistent results obtained by multiple users/operators and field tests suggest the assay's applicability to routine diagnostics, seed certification programs, biosecurity, and epidemiological studies.

First Report of Pectobacterium brasiliense causing soft rot on mizuna (Brassica rapa var. japonica) in the United States

Mizuna (Brassica rapa var. japonica), a member of family Brassicaceae, is a leafy vegetable having phenolic and other compounds beneficial to human health, such as natural antioxidants (Khanam et al. 2012). In October 2020, a field of mizuna (variety: Early) on Oahu island was observed having 20-30% diseased plants. Four randomly selected infected mizuna plants, showing the symptoms of wilt and stem rot (Figure 1A-D), were collected and isolations were made to determine the pathogen. Small sections of infected stems were cut, surface sterilized with 0.6% sodium hypochlorite solution for 30 sec, followed by three consecutive rinses in distilled water. The tissues were macerated in a sterile 1.5 ml centrifuge tube containing 100 μl sterile water-macerated tissues were streaked onto crystal violet pectate medium (CVP) (Hélias et al. 2011) and incubated at 26 ± 2°C for 48 h. Isolated bacterial colonies that formed pits on the CVP plates were re-streaked onto dextrose peptone agar: Peptone (10 g/L), Dextrose (5 g/L) and Agar (17 g/L) (DPA-without tetrazolium chloride; Norman and Alvarez 1989) to obtain purified colonies for DNA isolation using DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit (Qiagen, Germantown, MA). The two housekeeping genes (dnaA and gapA) were amplified and sequenced following the protocols used by Dobhal et al. (2020) and Boluk et al. (2020), for identity confirmation and phylogenetic analysis. Cleaned PCR products were sent to the GENEWIZ facility (Genewiz, La Jolla, CA) for sequencing of sense and antisense strands. The obtained sequences were aligned, manually edited, and consensus sequences were analyzed with BLASTn using the NCBI GenBank nucleotide and genome databases for identity confirmation. The BLASTn results demonstrated 100% query coverage of all four strains (PL248-PL251); and showed 100% identity of PL248 and PL249, and 99% identity of PL250 and PL251 with Pectobacterium brasiliense. All the sequences were submitted to the NCBI GenBank database under the following accession numbers: dnaA gene MW560271 - MW560274 (PL248 - PL251); and gapA gene MW560275 - MW560278 (PL248 - PL251). Pathogenicity was assessed by artificially inoculating 100 µl bacterial suspension of each strain (PL248 - 1.12x 10⁸ CFU/ml; PL249 - 1.32x 10⁸ CFU/ml; PL 250 - 1.2x 10⁸ CFU/ml and PL251 - 1.15x 10⁸ CFU/ml) onto four-week-old mizuna (variety: Leafy Asian Greens) plants in three replicates, using sterile pipette tips, which was stabbed into stem halfway and wrapped with parafilm. The inoculated plants were well maintained under controlled greenhouse conditions. As negative controls, three plants were inoculated with 100 µl distilled water. Soft rot and wilt symptoms (Figure 1E-H) were observed 24 hours post inoculation. No symptoms were observed on control plants (Figure 1F). All four strains were re-isolated from the inoculated plants and confirmed as P. brasiliense based on resequencing of the dnaA region and 100% homology with the sequences of original strain. In the phylogenetic tree (Figure 2), based on two housekeeping genes (dnaA and gapA), the bacterial strains from mizuna grouped with other P. brasiliense retrieved from the NCBI GenBank database. To our knowledge, this is the first report of P. brasiliense infecting mizuna plants in Hawaii or in the USA and is important because this species is one of the most aggressive pectolytic pathogens in the genus Pectobacterium. Understanding the diversity of different pectolytic phytopathogens is essential to formulating risk mitigation strategies as P. brasiliense could potentially pose a threat to additional vegetable crops, especially the crucifers vegetables (Arizala et al. 2019; Klair et al, 2021).

Multiple internal controls enhance reliability for PCR and real time PCR detection of Rathayibacter toxicus

Rathayibacter toxicus is a toxigenic bacterial plant pathogen indigenous to Australia and South Africa. A threat to livestock industries globally, the bacterium was designated a U.S. Select Agent. Biosecurity and phytosanitary concerns arise due to the international trade of seed and hay that harbor the bacterium. Accurate diagnostic protocols to support phytosanitary decisions, delineate areas of freedom, and to support research are required to address those concerns. Whole genomes of three genetic populations of R. toxicus were sequenced (Illumina MiSeq platforms), assembled and genomic regions unique to each population identified. Highly sensitive and specific TaqMan qPCR and multiplex endpoint PCR assays were developed for the detection and identification of R. toxicus to the population level of discrimination. Specificity was confirmed with appropriate inclusivity and exclusivity panels; no cross reactivity was observed. The endpoint multiplex PCR and TaqMan qPCR assays detected 10 fg and 1 fg of genomic DNA, respectively. To enhance reliability and increase confidence in results, three types of internal controls with no or one extra primer were developed and incorporated into each assay to detect both plant and artificial internal controls. Assays were validated by blind ring tests with multiple operators in three international laboratories.

First Report of Bacterial Soft Rot Disease on Pak Choi (Brassica rapa subsp. chinensis) caused by Pectobacterium brasiliense in the United States

Pak choi (Brassica rapa subsp. chinensis) is an important vegetable crop native to China, known for high water content and low caloric value, containing high quality of protein, carbohydrates, fiber, vitamins, minerals, and secondary plant metabolites (Acikgoz, 2016). A pak choi field (8,000 sq. ft.) on Oahu, Hawaii, was visited in May 2020. About 10% plants were infected and showed characteristic symptoms of soft rot, wet lesions, macerated infected stem and necrotic leaves (Figure1A-D); leading to the suspect of one of the most devastating bacterial pathogens within genus Pectobacterium (Boluk et al. 2020; Li et al. 2019; Arizala et al. 2020; Arizala and Arif, 2019). Four infected plants were collected from the field, and stems were surface sterilized with 0.6% sodium hypochlorite solution for 30 sec, followed by three consecutive rinses in distilled water. The stems were aseptically macerated, streaked on Crystal violet pectate medium (CVP) (Hélias et al. 2011), and incubated for 48 h at 26 ± 2°C. The peculiar morphological characteristic of pectolytic bacterial pathogen, forming pits on CVP, were observed (Meng et al. 2016) (Figure 1E). Purification of bacterial colonies were done by re-streaking of a single colony on dextrose peptone agar (DPA-without tetrazolium chloride; Norman and Alvarez 1989). DNA was isolated from bacterial cultures using the DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit (Qiagen, Germantown, MA), respectively. Molecular identification of four strains (PL243-246) were performed by the sequencing region of the housekeeping gene dnaA (chromosomal replication initiation protein) using Pec. dnaA-F1/R1 primer set (Dobhal et al. 2020). The amplified PCR product was enzymatically cleaned using ExoSAP-ITTM (Affymetrix Inc, Santa Clara, CA), and sent for sequencing at the GENEWIZ facility (Genewiz, La Jolla, CA) using both forward and reverse primers. The dnaA gene sequences were aligned using Geneious, and manually edited to remove the errors. The consensus sequences were analyzed with the NCBI BLASTn tool and were deposited in the NCBI GenBank under the accession numbers MT899920-MT899923. The NCBI BLASTn report indicated that all the sequences shared 99-100% identity and query cover with Pectobacterium brasiliense accession numbers MN544627-29. A phylogenetic analysis, using Geneious, was performed with the dnaA sequences representing different Pectobacterium spp., all strains grouped within the clade of P. brasiliense (Figure 2; Arizala et al, 2020). A pathogenicity assay was carried out in three replications on pak choi grown in pots containing commercial pot mixture, and maintained in the controlled-greenhouse (temperature 26-30°C; relative humidity 50-58%). Three-weeks old plant stems were artificially inoculated with 100 µl bacterial suspensions of PL243 (1.3x 10⁸ CFU/ml), PL244 (1.2x 10⁸ CFU/ml), PL 245 (1.2x 10⁸ CFU/ml) and PL246 (1.1x 10⁸CFU/ml); control plants were inoculated with 100 µl of distilled water (Figure 1F). Two days after inoculation, the soft rot and wilting symptoms (Figure 1G-H), similar to the ones observed on the field, were developed for all four strains tested. Bacteria was successfully re-isolated from the inoculated plants; DNA was isolated, amplified, sequenced for dnaA region and analyzed for 100% homology with original strains, to fulfill Koch's postulates. Based on the molecular characteristics re-isolates were identical to the original strains. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of P. brasiliense on pak choi in the USA. Recent reports indicated that the pathogen could potentially pose a threat to cruciferous crops, therefore, highlighting a need to conduct a state-wide survey for pectinolytic bacteria, and implement better management strategies to combat the vegetable crop losses.

Improved multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay with universal internal control offers reliable and accurate detection of Clavibacter michiganensis

AIM

Clavibacter michiganensis (Cm) is a seed-borne plant pathogen that significantly reduces tomato production worldwide. Due to repeated outbreaks and rapid spread of the disease, seeds/transplants need to be certified free of the pathogen before planting. To this end, we developed a multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay that can accurately detect Cm in infected samples.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A specific region of Cm (clvG gene) was selected for primer design using comparative genomics approach. A fully synthetic universal internal control (UIC) was also designed to detect PCR inhibitors and false-negative results in qPCRs. The Cm primers can be used alone or in a triplex TaqMan qPCR assay with UIC and previously described Clavibacter primers. The assay was specific for Cm and detected up to 10 fg of Cm DNA in sensitivity and spiked assays. Addition of the UIC did not change the specificity or sensitivity of the multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay.

CONCLUSION

The triplex TaqMan qPCR provides a specific and sensitive diagnostic assay for Cm.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

This assay can be used for biosecurity surveillance, routine diagnostics, estimating bacterial titres in infected material and for epidemiological studies. The UIC is fully synthetic, efficiently amplified and multiplex compatible with any other qPCR assay.

Genome-Informed Recombinase Polymerase Amplification Assay Coupled with a Lateral Flow Device for In-Field Detection of Dickeya Species

Dickeya spp. cause blackleg and soft rot diseases of potato and several other plant species worldwide, resulting in high economic losses. Rapid detection and identification of the pathogen is essential for facilitating efficient disease management. Our aim in this research was to develop a rapid and field-deployable recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) assay coupled with a lateral flow device (LFD) that will accurately detect Dickeya spp. in infected plant tissues without the need for DNA isolation. A unique genomic region (mglA/mglC genes) conserved among Dickeya spp. was used to design highly specific robust primers and probes for an RPA assay. Assay specificity was validated with 34 representative strains from all Dickeya spp. and 24 strains from other genera and species; no false positives or negatives were detected. An RPA assay targeting the internal transcribed spacer region of the host genome was included to enhance the reliability and accuracy of the Dickeya assay. The detection limit of 1 fg was determined by both sensitivity and spiked sensitivity assays; no inhibitory effects were observed when 1 µl of host sap, macerated in Tris-EDTA buffer, was added to each reaction in the sensitivity tests. The developed RPA assay is rapid, highly accurate, sensitive, and fully field deployable. It has numerous applications in routine diagnostics, surveillance, biosecurity, and disease management.