Optimization of the hot balloon ablation strategy using real‐time pulmonary vein potential monitoring

Impact of monitoring surface temperature during pulmonary vein isolation in a second-generation hot balloon system

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Utility of hot-balloon-based pulmonary vein isolation under balloon surface temperature monitoring: First clinical experience

INTRODUCTION

A new hot balloon system that registers balloon surface temperature (BST) during energy delivery is now available for clinical use in Japan. This study sought to investigate the utility of BST measurement for achievement of pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) by a single-shot energy delivery strategy during hot balloon ablation (HBA).

METHODS

We applied and tested the system in 30 consecutive patients undergoing HBA for paroxysmal or early-persistent atrial fibrillation (AF). We also performed real-time PV potential monitoring using a circular catheter.

RESULTS

Acute PVI was achieved with single hot balloon shots in 88% (106/120) of the PVs. Real-time BSTs and PV potentials were recorded in all cases. Mean BST at documentation of PVI was 49.4°C, and acute reconnections were observed in most cases (86%, 12/14) in which the single-shot technique was ineffective. Time-to-isolation (TTI) (23.1 ± 8.7 s vs. 36.3 ± 9.3 s, p < .01) and median BST (59.9 ± 2.6°C vs. 55.7 ± 1.9°C, p < .01) differed significantly between cases in which PVI was achieved (vs. those in which PVI was not achieved). Multivariable analysis revealed strong association between both TTI and median BST and acute PVI. The best median BST cutoff value for achieving PVI with a single shot was >58.7°C (sensitivity 67.0%, specificity 100%).

CONCLUSION

Our data suggest that real-time BST monitoring during energy applications is useful for predicting achievement of acute PVI by a single shot during HBA.

A porcine study of the area of heated tissue during hot-balloon ablation: Implications for the clinical efficacy and safety

INTRODUCTION

Hot-balloon ablation depends solely on thermal conduction, and myocardial tissue is ablated by only conductive heating from the balloon surface. Despite growing clinical evidence of the efficacy and safety of hot-balloon ablation for atrial fibrillation (AF), the actual tissue temperature and the mechanism of heating during such ablation has not been clarified. To determine, by means of a porcine study, the temperatures of tissues targeted during hot-balloon ablation of AF performed with hot-balloon set temperatures of 73°C or 70°C, in accordance with the temperatures now used clinically.

METHODS

After a right thoracotomy, thermocouples with markers were implanted epicardially on the superior vena cava (SVC) and pulmonary veins (PVs) in six pigs. The tissue temperatures during hot-balloon ablation (balloon set temperatures of 73°C and 70°C, 180 s/PV) were recorded, and the maximum tissue temperatures and fluoroscopically measured distance from the balloon surface to the target tissues were assessed.

RESULTS

Sixteen SVC- and 18 PV-targeted energy deliveries were performed. Full-thickness circumferential PV lesions were created with all hot-balloon applications. A significant inverse relation was found between the recorded tissue temperatures and distance (r = -.67; p < .001) from the balloon surface. No tissue temperature exceeded either of the balloon set temperatures. The best distance cutoff value for achieving lethal tissue temperatures more than 50°C was 3.6 mm.

CONCLUSION

The hot-balloon set temperature, energy delivery time, and tissue temperature data obtained in this porcine study supported the clinical efficacy and safety of the hot-balloon ablation as currently practiced in patients with AF.