Clinical utility of local impedance monitoring during pulmonary vein isolation

Comparison of voltages between atria: differences in sinus rhythm and atrial fibrillation

BACKGROUND

Ultra high-density mapping systems allow for comparison of atrial electroanatomical maps in unprecedented detail. Atrial scar determined by voltages and surface area between atria, rhythm and atrial fibrillation (AF) types was assessed.

METHODS

Left (LA) and right atrial (RA) maps were created using Rhythmia HDx in patients listed for ablation for paroxysmal (PAF, sinus rhythm (SR) maps only) or persistent AF (PeAF, AF and SR maps). Electrograms on corresponding SR/AF maps were paired for direct comparison. Percentage surface area of scar was assigned low- (LVM, ≤ 0.05 mV), intermediate- (IVM, 0.05-0.5 mV) or normal voltage myocardium, (NVM, > 0.5 mV).

RESULTS

Thirty-eight patients were recruited generating 96 maps using 913,480 electrograms. Paired SR-AF bipolar electrograms showed fair correlation in LA (Spearman's ρ = 0.32) and weak correlation in RA (ρ = 0.19) and were significantly higher in SR in both (LA: 0.61 mV (0.20-1.67) vs 0.31 mV (0.10-0.74), RA: 0.68 mV (0.19-1.88) vs 0.47 mV (0.14-1.07), p < 0.0005 both). Voltages were significantly higher in patients with PAF over PeAF, (LA: 1.13 mV (0.39-2.93) vs 0.52 mV (0.16-1.49); RA: 0.93 mV (0.24-2.46) vs 0.57 mV (0.17-1.69)). Minimal differences were seen in electrogram voltages between atria. Significantly more IVM/LVM surface areas were seen in AF over SR (LA only, p < 0005), and PeAF over PAF (LA: p = 0.01, RA: p = 0.04). There was minimal difference between atria within patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultra high-density mapping shows paired electrograms correlate poorly between SR and AF. SR electrograms are typically (but not always) larger than those in AF. Patients with PeAF have a lower global electrogram voltage than those with PAF. Electrogram voltages are similar between atria within individual patients.

Impact of contact force on the lesion characteristics of very high-power short-duration ablation using a QDOT-MICRO catheter

Background

Lesion size is reported to become larger as contact force (CF) increases. However, this has not been systematically evaluated in temperature-guided very high-power short-duration (vHPSD) ablation, which was therefore the purpose of this study.

Methods

Radiofrequency applications (90 W/4 s, temperature-control mode) were performed in excised porcine myocardium with four different CFs of 5, 15, 25, and 35 g using QDOT-MICRO™ catheter. Ten lesions for each combination of settings were created, and lesion metrics and steam-pops were compared.

Results

A total of 320 lesions were analyzed. Lesion depth, surface area, and volume were smallest for CF of 5 g than for 15, 25, and 35 g (depth: 2.7 mm vs. 2.9 mm, 3.0 mm, 3.15 mm, p < .01; surface area: 38.4 mm2 vs. 41.8 mm2, 43.3 mm2, 41.5 mm2, p < .05; volume: 98.2 mm3 vs. 133.3 mm3, 129.4 mm3, 126.8 mm3, p < .01 for all pairs of groups compared to CF = 5 g). However, no significant differences were observed between CFs of 15-35 g. Average power was highest for CF of 5 g, followed by 15, 25, and 35 g (83.2 W vs. 82.1 W vs. 77.1 W vs. 66.1 W, p < .01 for all pairs), reflecting the higher incidence of temperature-guided power titration with greater CFs (5 g:8.8% vs. 15 g:52.5% vs. 25 g:77.5% vs. 35 g:91.2%, p < .01 for all pairs except for 25 g vs. 35 g). The incidence of steam-pops did not significantly differ between four groups (5 g:3.8% vs. 15 g:10% vs. 25 g:6.2% vs. 35 g:2.5%, not significant for all pairs).

Conclusions

For vHPSD ablation, lesion size does not become large once the CF reaches 15 g, and the risk of steam-pops may be mitigated through power titration even in high CFs.

Radiofrequency lesion formation prediction with contact force versus local impedance

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Safe and effective radiofrequency (RF) myocardial ablation requires real-time monitoring of lesion formation. Here, we review conventional and novel approaches proposed to guide titration of RF energy application.

RECENT FINDINGS

Conventional monitoring modalities, such as ablation electrode temperature, generator impedance, and tissue electrophysiological properties have been of limited value in predicting efficacy and safety of ablation. Therefore, several input-driven indices have been proposed to improve the quality and durability of RF ablation lesion while maintaining safety. These metrics predominantly incorporate RF power output, duration of RF application, and firmness and stability of electrode-tissue contact. More recently, novel catheters have enabled measuring local impedance at the catheter-tissue interface, which has been found valuable for real-time monitoring of RF lesion formation.

SUMMARY

It is likely that using the combination of multiple metrics would be required to improve the quality and safety of RF lesions, but further investigation is still required.

Safety verification of a novel irrigation catheter with flexible tip of laser-cut kerfs and contact force sensor

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

The safety evaluation of TactiFlex, a novel contact-force sensing catheter with a flexible 4-mm tip irrigated through laser-cut kerfs, has been ongoing. This study aimed to verify the safety of this type of catheter.

METHODS

Study 1: Radiofrequency (RF) applications at a range of powers (30-50 W), contact forces (10-20 g), and durations (10-60 s) using perpendicular/parallel catheter orientation with half-normal (HNS) or normal saline irrigation were compared between TactiFlex (4-mm tip) and TactiCath (3.5-mm tip) with temperature-controlled mode in excised porcine hearts. Study 2: The relation between RF applications using TactiFlex and the incidence of steam-pops in the real clinical cases were examined.

RESULTS

Study-1: 576 RF lesions were examined. TactiFlex demonstrated a significantly lower risk of steam-pops (5[1.7%] vs. 59[20.5%], p < .0001). Compared to 3.5-mm-tip catheter (TactiCath), 4-mm-tip catheter (TactiFlex) produced smaller lesion volume at perpendicular (193[98-554]mm3 vs. 263[139-436]mm3 , p < .0001), but relatively similar lesion volume at parallel contact (243[105-443]mm3 vs. 278[180-440]mm3 , p = .06). HNS-irrigation tended to increase the lesion volume in both catheters and to increase the incidence of steam-pops with TactiCath, but not with TactiFlex. The cut-off value of %impedance-drop ( = absolute impedance-drop/initial impedance) of 20% predicted steam-pops with a sensitivity = 100% and specificity = 89.6% in TactiFlex. Study-2: 5496 RF applications in 84 patients (51AFs/8ATs/3AVNRTs/4AVRTs/17PVCs/4VTs) using TactiFlex were analyzed. Four steam-pops (0.07%) in three patients with pericardial effusion were observed (%impedance-drop = 24%/26%/29%/35%, respectively). The cut-off value of %impedance-drop = 20%, derived from ex-vivo study, showed sensitivity = 100% and specificity = 90.1% in detecting steam-pops.

CONCLUSION

TactiFlex reduced the risk of steam-pops than TactiCath. %impedance-drop ≤ 20% may be reasonable for safely use with a sufficient safety margin. For 4-mm-tip catheter, parallel-contact may be recommended for larger lesion creation.

Monitoring Spike Potential and Abrupt Impedance Rise with Concomitant Temperature/Contact Force Change for Timely Detection of the Occurrence of “Silent” or “Nonaudible” Steam Pop

Aim. Steam pop (SP) during radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) may cause cardiac perforation, which may require drainage and emergent thoracotomy or even lead to death. Data investigating the timely detection of the occurrence of “silent” or “nonaudible” SP events are limited. Methods and Results. A total of 516 consecutive atrial fibrillation (AF) patients who underwent index PVI were included in this retrospective observational study. The duration, power, impedance, temperature, and contact force (CF) of RFCA were continually monitored and recorded throughout the procedure. A total of 15 (2.9%) audible SP events occurred in 14 patients; 2 of the patients developed pericardial tamponade, 1 patient underwent drainage, and 1 patient underwent emergent thoracotomy. The time from RFCA initiation to the occurrence of audible SP was 19.4 ± 6.9 s. Abrupt temperature change occurred in 13 (86.7%) of the 15 SP events, of which 8 (53.3%) exhibited an abrupt temperature rise of 2.3 ± 1.0°C, 5 (33.3%) exhibited an abrupt temperature drop of 2.3 ± 1.3°C, and 2 (13.3%) exhibited no discernible temperature change. Conclusions. In conclusion, simultaneously recorded spike potentials and abrupt impedance rise with concomitant temperature and/or CF change could be a feasible method for the timely detection of the occurrence of audible, “silent,” or “nonaudible” SP events, particularly in regions where the risk of perforation may be of concern.

Optimal local impedance parameters for successful pulmonary vein isolation in patients with atrial fibrillation

INTRODUCTION

Local impedance (LI) parameters of IntellaNav STABLEPOINT for successful pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) of atrial fibrillation (AF) remain unclear. The purpose of this study was to seek LI data achieving successful PVI.

METHODS

Consecutive AF patients who underwent catheter ablation with STABLEPOINT were prospectively enrolled in two centers. PVI was performed under a constant 35-or 40-watt power, 20-s duration, and >5-g contact force. The operators were blinded to the LI data. The characteristics of all ablation points with/without conduction gaps (Unsuccess or Success tags) after the first-attempt PVI were evaluated for the right/left PVs and anterior/posterior wall (RPV/LPV and AW/PW, respectively), and cutoff values of LI data were calculated for successful lesion formation.

RESULTS

A total of 5257 ablation points in 102 patients (65 [58-72] years old, 65.7% male) were evaluated. The LI drop values were higher in the Success tags than Unsuccess tags on the LPV-AW and RPV-AW/PW (p < .001), except for the LPV-PW (p = .105). The %LI drop values (LI drop/initial LI) were higher for the Success tags in all areas (15.8 [12.2%-19.6%] vs. 11.6 [9.7%-15.6%] in LPV-AW: p < .001, 15.0 [11.5%-19.3%] vs. 11.4 [8.7%-17.3%] in LPV-PW: p = .035, 15.3 [11.5%-19.4%] vs. 9.9 [8.1%-13.7%] in RPV-AW: p < .001, and 13.3 [10.1%-17.4%] vs. 8.1 [6.3%-9.5%] in RPV-PW, p < .001). The LI drop and %LI drop cutoff values were 20.0 ohms and 11.6%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

An insufficient LI drop with STABLEPOINT was associated with a gap formation during PVI, and the best cutoff values for the LI drop and %LI drop were 20.0 ohms and 11.6%, respectively.

Requirement of larger local impedance reduction for successful lesion formation at carinal area during pulmonary vein isolation

PURPOSE

Local impedance (LI) measurement from an ablation catheter is useful in predicting lesion size and acute success of pulmonary vein isolation (PVI). The LI variation can be described by absolute LI drop (ΔLID) or ΔLID/initial LI (%LID). We evaluated the utility of these parameters in predicting acute lesion durability during PVI using a novel catheter capable of measuring both LI and contact force (CF).

METHODS

PVI with a targeted CF, power, and duration was performed in 23 consecutive patients with paroxysmal atrial fibrillation. LI was blinded to operators during ablation. Parameters for each RF application were collected and compared for acute successful lesions and gaps.

RESULTS

A total of 1633 RF applications including 97 (5.9%) gap lesions were analyzed. Successful lesions were more frequently observed at non-carinal sites and those with higher contact force, FTI, initial LI, and larger variation of LI and generator impedance (GI). Multivariate analysis demonstrated that absolute GI drop (ΔGID) [OR 1.09 (1.04-1.15), p < 0.001], ΔLID [1.12 (1.09-1.16), p < 0.001], ΔGID/initial GI (%GID) [OR 1.04 (1.01-1.07), p = 0.01], and %LID [OR 1.15 (1.12-1.28), p < 0.001] were significantly associated with successful lesions, and carinal site [OR 0.15(0.09-0.24), p < 0.001] was significantly related to gaps. Both ΔLID and %LID equally predicted the acute durability of lesions during PVI. ΔLID ≥ 24Ω and %LID ≥ 15% at the carina, and ΔLID ≥ 21Ω and %LID ≥ 14% at non-carinal sites significantly predicted acute successful lesions with negative predictive values of 93-99%.

CONCLUSIONS

Both ΔLID and %LID were equally useful in predicting acute successful lesions during PVI. Larger cut-off values should be applied to carinal sites.

The correlation between local impedance drop and catheter contact in clinical pulmonary vein isolation use

INTRODUCTION

Local impedance (LI) drop during radiofrequency (RF) application is monitored to assess the lesion formation. Recently, a novel ablation catheter has been introduced to clinical setting, which is capable of monitoring LI and catheter contact parameters including contact force (CF) and contact angle (CA). This study aimed to clarify the correlation between LI drop and catheter contact parameters.

METHODS AND RESULTS

This prospective study included 15 paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (AF) patients who underwent initial pulmonary vein isolation (PVI). First-pass encircling point-by-point PV ablation was performed by using a 4.5-mm irrigated ablation catheter, with monitoring LI, CF, and CA. RF energy was applied for 30 sec at each site with 30W. Stable ablation points were analyzed to examine the correlation between LI drop and catheter contact parameters. Among 903 ablation points, 499 stable ablation points (55.2%) were analyzed. CA showed good correlation with LI drop (ρ = 0.418, P<0.001). Maximum CF, minimum CF, average CF, and initial CF all showed weak correlation with LI drop (ρ = 0.201, P<0.001; ρ = 0.224, P<0.001; ρ = 0.258, P<0.001; and ρ = 0.212, P<0.001, respectively). Multivariate analysis demonstrated that CA was an independent factor of LI drop among the catheter contact parameters (β = 0.139, 95%CI = 0.111-0.167, P<0.001). The LI drop in the blocked segments was significantly higher than that in the electrical conduction gap segments (27.3 ± 9.8 Ω vs. 19.6 ± 6.4 Ω, P<0.001) CONCLUSION: In clinical PVI use, both CF and CA were correlated with LI drop. More parallel CA could induce higher LI drop, which may lead to effective lesion formation. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Local impedance for the optimization of radiofrequency lesion delivery: A review of bench and clinical data

INTRODUCTION

Radiofrequency catheter ablation is a cornerstone of treatment for many cardiac arrhythmias. Progression in three-dimensional mapping and contact-force sensing technologies have improved our capability to achieve success, but challenges still remain.

METHODS

In this article, we discuss the importance of overall circuit impedance in radiofrequency lesion formation. This is followed by a review of the literature regarding recently developed "local impedance" technology and its current and future potential applications and limitations, in the context of established surrogate markers currently used to infer effective ablation.

RESULTS

We discuss the role of local impedance in assessing myocardial substrate, as well as its role in clinical studies of ablation. We also discuss safety considerations, limitations and ongoing research.

CONCLUSION

Local impedance is a novel tool which has the potential to tailor ablation in a manner distinct from other established metrics.

Regional differences in the predictors of acute electrical reconnection following high-power pulmonary vein isolation for paroxysmal atrial fibrillation

BACKGROUND

Acute pulmonary vein reconnection (PVR) is associated with long procedure times and large radiofrequency (RF) energy delivery during pulmonary vein isolation (PVI). Although the efficacy of high-power PVI (HP-PVI) has been recently established, the determinants of acute PVR following HP-PVI remain unclear.

METHODS

We evaluated data on 62 patients with paroxysmal atrial fibrillation undergoing unipolar signal modification (USM)-guided HP-PVI. A 50-W RF wave was applied for 3-5 seconds after USM. In the segments adjacent to the esophagus (SAEs), the RF time was limited to 5 seconds. Each circle was subdivided into six regions (segments), and the possible predictors of acute PVR, including minimum contact force (CFmin), minimum force-time integral (FTImin), minimum ablation index (AImin), minimum impedance drop (Imp-min), and maximum inter-lesion distance (ILDmax), were assessed in each segment.

RESULTS

We investigated 1162 ablations in 744 segments (including 124 SAEs). Acute PVR was observed in 21 (17%) SAEs and 43 (7%) other segments (P = .001). The acute PVR segments were characterized by significantly lower CFmin, FTImin, AImin, and Imp-min values in the segments other than the SAEs and larger ILDmax values in the SAEs. Furthermore, lower Imp-min and larger ILDmax values independently predicted acute PVR in the segments other than the SAEs and SAEs (odds ratios 0.90 and 1.39 respectively). Acute PVR was not significantly associated with late atrial fibrillation recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

Avoiding PVR remains a challenge in HP-PVI cases, but it might be resolved by setting the optimal target impedance drop and lesion distance values.

The role of local impedance drop in the acute lesion efficacy during pulmonary vein isolation performed with a new contact force sensing catheter-A pilot study

Introduction

Our pilot study aimed to evaluate the role of local impedance drop in lesion formation during pulmonary vein isolation with a novel contact force sensing ablation catheter that records local impedance as well and to find a local impedance cut-off value that predicts successful lesion formation.

Materials and methods

After completing point-by-point radiofrequency pulmonary vein isolation, the success of the applications was evaluated by pacing along the ablation line at 10 mA, 2 ms pulse width. Lesions were considered successful if loss of local capture was achieved.

Results

Out of 645 applications, 561 were successful and 84 were unsuccessful. Compared to the unsuccessful ablation points, the successful applications were shorter (p = 0.0429) and had a larger local impedance drop (p<0.0001). There was no difference between successful and unsuccessful applications in terms of mean contact force (p = 0.8571), force-time integral (p = 0.0699) and contact force range (p = 0.0519). The optimal cut-point for the local impedance drop indicating successful lesion formation was 21.80 Ohms on the anterior wall [AUC = 0.80 (0.75–0.86), p<0.0001], and 18.30 Ohms on the posterior wall [AUC = 0.77 (0.72–0.83), p<0.0001]. A local impedance drop larger than 21.80 Ohms on the anterior wall and 18.30 Ohms on the posterior wall was associated with an increased probability of effective lesion creation [OR = 11.21, 95%CI 4.22–29.81, p<0.0001; and OR = 7.91, 95%CI 3.77–16.57, p<0.0001, respectively].

Conclusion

The measurement of the local impedance may predict optimal lesion formation. A local impedance drop > 21.80 Ohms on the anterior wall and > 18.30 Ohms on the posterior wall significantly increases the probability of creating a successful lesion.

Change in the local impedance and electrograms recorded by a micro-electrode tip catheter during initial atrial fibrillation ablation

BACKGROUND

A novel measurement of the local impedance (LI) and electrograms recorded from micro-electrodes on catheter tip has been developed. However, the data during pulmonary vein (PV) ablation is not sufficient. We aimed to investigate the utility of this measurement during initial atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation.

METHODS

We investigated 111 representative radiofrequency applications in 7 AF patients without a history of prior ablation (6 males, age 68 [65-72] years, 2 persistent AF). The ablation strategy was PV isolation for paroxysmal AF and single ring box isolation for persistent AF, using MiFi catheter. The correlation of the generator impedance (GI) drop and LI drop after radiofrequency applications and the predictive value of the initial LI elevation before radiofrequency applications for LI drop were analyzed. Also, the LI and GI drop were investigated according to the location of RF applications.

RESULTS

The LI drop was higher than GI drop (23.7 [16.4-35.7] and 9.0 [6.0-12.0]; P < .01). There were correlations between the initial LI elevation and LI drop (R 2 = 0.466, P < .01) and between the LI and GI drop (R 2 = 0.263, P < .01). The LI drops significantly differed according to the different anatomical localizations by the Kruskal-Wallis test, although the GI drops did not differ (P < .01 and P = .49, respectively).

CONCLUSION

LI drop was associated with initial LI elevation and was larger than GI drop. LI drop was different according to locations, although GI drop was not. These findings might indicate that LI drop would be a more sensitive marker for lesion formation than GI drop.

Superior vena cava isolation using a novel ablation catheter incorporating local impedance monitoring

BACKGROUND

A novel technology able to measure the local impedance (LI) during radiofrequency ablation has become available for clinical use. We investigated the change in the LI characteristics during superior vena cava isolations (SVCIs) using a novel catheter equipped with mini-electrodes.

METHODS

Twenty paroxysmal atrial fibrillation patients (68 ± 9 years; 14 males) underwent an SVCI by targeting breakthroughs. Subsequently, dormant conduction provoked by adenosine triphosphate (ATP) was evaluated.

RESULTS

Electrical SVCIs were successfully achieved in all with 7.2 ± 3.0 radiofrequency applications (RFA) without any complications. The procedure and fluoroscopic times were 13.1 ± 8.1 and 2.8 ± 2.3 min. No ablation was required at the anteroseptal SVC in 19 (95.0%) patients. The baseline LI and generator impedance (GI) were 125 ± 23 and 105 ± 14Ω. LI drops during RFA were significantly greater than GI drops (17 ± 12 vs. 4 ± 4Ω, p < 0.001). The correlation between the LI drops and GI drops was relatively high (R = 0.69, p < 0.001). LI drops were highest at the septal SVC and lowest at the lateral followed by antero-lateral SVC. The baseline electrogram amplitude between the mini-electrodes and tip-ring electrodes was 1.2 ± 1.4 and 0.8 ± 0.6 mV. The mini-electrode amplitude is more sharply attenuated with a greater magnitude than the tip-ring amplitude (p < 0.001). ATP-provoked dormant conduction was exposed in 10/17 (58.8%) patients and antero-lateral SVC gap locations in 7. Antero-lateral SVC LI drops were similar between patients with and without dormancy.

CONCLUSIONS

The LI drop magnitude during RFA significantly differed among the SVC segments. Antero-lateral SVC ATP-provoked dormant conduction was often exposed, and additional applications are recommended following the isolation for a robust SVCI.