Morphology and phylogenetic position of three anaerobic ciliates from the classes Odontostomatea and Muranotrichea (Ciliophora)

Single cell transcriptomics reveals UAR codon reassignment in Palmarella salina (Metopida, Armophorea) and confirms Armophorida belongs to APM clade

Anaerobes have emerged in several major lineages of ciliates, but the number of independent transitions to anaerobiosis among ciliates is unknown. The APM clade (Armophorea, Muranotrichea, Parablepharismea) represents the largest clade of obligate anaerobes among ciliates and contains free-living marine and freshwater representatives as well as gut endobionts of animals. The evolution of APM group has only recently started getting attention, and our knowledge on its phylogeny and genetics is still limited to a fraction of taxa. While ciliates portray a wide array of alternatives to the standard genetic code across numerous classes, the APM ciliates were considered to be the largest group using exclusively standard nuclear genetic code. In this study, we present a pan-ciliate phylogenomic analysis with emphasis on the APM clade, bringing the first phylogenomic analysis of the family Tropidoatractidae (Armophorea) and confirming the position of Armophorida within Armophorea. We include five newly sequenced single cell transcriptomes from marine, freshwater, and endobiotic APM ciliates - Palmarella salina, Anteclevelandella constricta, Nyctotherus sp., Caenomorpha medusula, and Thigmothrix strigosa. We report the first discovery of an alternative nuclear genetic code among APM ciliates, used by Palmarella salina (Tropidoatractidae, Armophorea), but not by its close relative, Tropidoatractus sp., and provide a comparative analysis of stop codon identity and frequency indicating the precedency to the UAG codon loss/reassignment over the UAA codon reassignment in the specific ancestor of Palmarella. Comparative genomic and proteomic studies of this group may help explain the constraints that underlie UAR stop-to-sense reassignment, the most frequent type of alternative nuclear genetic code, not only in ciliates, but eukaryotes in general.