RAD-sequencing reveals patterns of diversification and hybridization, and the accumulation of reproductive isolation in a clade of partially sympatric, tropical island trees

Improving species delimitation for effective conservation: a case study in the endemic maple-leaf oak (Quercus acerifolia)

Species delimitation is challenging in lineages that exhibit both high plasticity and introgression. This challenge can be compounded by collection biases, which may downweight specimens morphologically intermediate between traditional species. Additionally, mismatch between named species and observable phenotypes can compromise species conservation. We studied the species boundaries of Quercus acerifolia, a tree endemic to Arkansas, U.S. We performed morphometric analyses of leaves and acorns from 527 field and 138 herbarium samples of Q. acerifolia and its close relatives, Q. shumardii and Q. rubra. We employed two novel approaches: sampling ex situ collections to detect phenotypic plasticity caused by environmental variation and comparing random field samples with historical herbarium samples to identify collection biases that might undermine species delimitation. To provide genetic evidence, we also performed molecular analyses on genome-wide SNPs. Quercus acerifolia shows distinctive morphological, ecological, and genomic characteristics, rejecting the hypothesis that Q. acerifolia is a phenotypic variant of Q. shumardii. We found mismatches between traditional taxonomy and phenotypic clusters. We detected underrepresentation of morphological intermediates in herbarium collections, which may bias species discovery and recognition. Rare species conservation requires considering and addressing taxonomic problems related to phenotypic plasticity, mismatch between taxonomy and morphological clusters, and collection biases.

Genome-wide data reveal cryptic diversity and hybridization in a group of tree ferns

Discovery of cryptic diversity is essential to understanding both the process of speciation and the conservation of species. Determining species boundaries in fern lineages represents a major challenge due to lack of morphologically diagnostic characters and frequent hybridization. Genomic data has substantially enhanced our understanding of the speciation process, increased the resolution of species delimitation studies, and led to the discovery of cryptic diversity. Here, we employed restriction-site-associated DNA sequencing (RAD-seq) and integrated phylogenomic and population genomic analyses to investigate phylogenetic relationships and evolutionary history of 16 tree ferns with marginate scales (Cyatheaceae) from China and Vietnam. We conducted multiple species delimitation analyses using the multispecies coalescent (MSC) model and novel approaches based on genealogical divergence index (gdi) and isolation by distance (IBD). In addition, we inferred species trees using concatenation and several coalescent-based methods, and assessed hybridization patterns and rate of gene flow across the phylogeny. We obtained highly supported and generally congruent phylogenies inferred from concatenated and summary-coalescent methods, and the monophyly of all currently recognized species were strongly supported. Our results revealed substantial evidence of cryptic diversity in three widely distributed Gymnosphaera species, each of which was composite of two highly structure lineages that may correspond to cryptic species. We found that hybridization was fairly common between not only closely related species, but also distantly related species. Collectively, it appears that scaly tree ferns may contain cryptic diversity and hybridization has played an important role throughout the evolutionary history of this group.

The Syngameon Enigma

Despite their evolutionary relevance, multispecies networks or syngameons are rarely reported in the literature. Discovering how syngameons form and how they are maintained can give insight into processes such as adaptive radiations, island colonizations, and the creation of new hybrid lineages. Understanding these complex hybridization networks is even more pressing with anthropogenic climate change, as syngameons may have unique synergistic properties that will allow participating species to persist. The formation of a syngameon is not insurmountable, as several ways for a syngameon to form have been proposed, depending mostly on the magnitude and frequency of gene flow events, as well as the relatedness of its participants. Episodic hybridization with small amounts of introgression may keep syngameons stable and protect their participants from any detrimental effects of gene flow. As genomic sequencing becomes cheaper and more species are included in studies, the number of known syngameons is expected to increase. Syngameons must be considered in conservation efforts as the extinction of one participating species may have detrimental effects on the survival of all other species in the network.

Interspecific hybridization and island colonization history, not rarity, most strongly affect the genetic diversity in a clade of Mascarene-endemic trees

Many factors shape the genetic diversity of island-endemic trees, with important implications for conservation. Oceanic island-endemic lineages undergo an initial founding bottleneck during the colonization process and subsequently accumulate diversity following colonization. Moreover, many island endemics occur in small populations and are further threatened by anthropogenic factors that cause population declines, making them susceptible to losses in genetic diversity through genetic drift, inbreeding, and bottlenecks. However, life-history traits commonly found in trees, such as outcrossing mechanisms, long lifespans, and a propensity for interspecific hybridization, may help buffer against losses of genetic variation. To assess the relative importance of colonization history, rarity, and distribution in shaping genetic diversity of island-endemic trees, we conducted a comparative population genomic analysis of 13 species of Diospyros (Ebenaceae) endemic to the Mascarene Islands that differ in island colonization history, distribution, population size, and IUCN threat status. We genotyped 328 individuals across the islands using 2b-RADseq, compared genetic diversity both among and within species, and assessed patterns of genetic structure. Genetic diversity did not vary significantly by IUCN status, but we found that species that co-occur with others on the same intermediate-aged island (Mauritius) had much greater genetic diversity than those that occur solitarily on an island (Réunion and Rodrigues), likely because of greater interspecific hybridization among species with overlapping distributions and processes related to time since island colonization. Results presented here were used to determine priority localities for in situ and ex situ conservation efforts to maximize the genetic diversity of each Mascarene Diospyros species.

When tropical and subtropical congeners met: Multiple ancient hybridization events within Eriobotrya in the Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau, a tropical-subtropical transition area in China

Global climate changes during the Miocene may have created ample opportunities for hybridization between members of tropical and subtropical biomes at the boundary between these zones. Yet, very few studies have explored this possibility. The Yunnan-Guizhou Plateau (YGP) in Southwest China is a biodiversity hotspot for vascular plants, located in a transitional area between the floristic regions of tropical Southeast Asia and subtropical East Asia. The genus Eriobotrya (Rosaceae) comprises both tropical and subtropical taxa, with 12 species recorded in the YGP, making it a suitable basis for testing the hypothesis of between-biome hybridization. Therefore, we surveyed the evolutionary history of Eriobotrya by examining three chloroplast regions and five nuclear genes for 817 individuals (47 populations) of 23 Eriobotrya species (including 19 populations of 12 species in the YGP), plus genome re-sequencing of 33 representative samples. We concluded that: (1) phylogenetic positions for 16 species exhibited strong cytonuclear conflicts, most probably due to ancient hybridization; (2) the YGP is a hotspot for hybridization, with 11 species showing clear evidence of chloroplast capture; and (3) Eriobotrya probably originated in tropical Asia during the Eocene. From the Miocene onwards, the intensification of the Eastern Asia monsoon and global cooling may have shifted the tropical-subtropical boundary and caused secondary contact between species, thus providing ample opportunity for hybridization and diversification of Eriobotrya, especially in the YGP. Our study highlights the significant role that paleoclimate changes probably played in driving hybridization and generating rich species diversity in climate transition zones.

Admixture may be extensive among hyperdominant Amazon rainforest tree species

Admixture is a mechanism by which species of long-lived plants may acquire novel alleles. However, the potential role of admixture in the origin and maintenance of tropical plant diversity is unclear. We ask whether admixture occurs in an ecologically important clade of Eschweilera (Parvifolia clade, Lecythidaceae), which includes some of the most widespread and abundant tree species in Amazonian forests. Using target capture sequencing, we conducted a detailed phylogenomic investigation of 33 species in the Parvifolia clade and investigated specific hypotheses of admixture within a robust phylogenetic framework. We found strong evidence of admixture among three ecologically dominant species, E. coriacea, E. wachenheimii and E. parviflora, but a lack of evidence for admixture among other lineages. Accepted species were largely distinguishable from one another, as was geographic structure within species. We show that hybridization may play a role in the evolution of the most widespread and ecologically variable Amazonian tree species. While admixture occurs among some species of Eschweilera, it has not led to widespread erosion of most species' genetic or morphological identities. Therefore, current morphological based species circumscriptions appear to provide a useful characterization of the clade's lineage diversity.

Is speciation an unrelenting march to reproductive isolation?

Speciation is often portrayed as an "incomplete" or "incipient" process if two groups of organisms, technically distinguishable either by morphology or genetics, can exchange genes. The ultimate outcome of diversification, given this perspective, is complete reproductive isolation. But an increasing amount of evidence suggests that speciation is rarely complete and inter-fertility between different taxonomically accepted species is consistently maintained. In this issue of Molecular Ecology, Linan et al. (2021) provide results that bridge evolutionary processes from populations to phylogenies that indicate suites of closely related tree species in the Mascarene Islands actively exchange genes, evolving as a nested set of syngameons with a hierarchical pattern of interfertility. The deep insight into diversification provided by this study is particularly powerful because of the genomic scale of the data and the complete taxonomic sampling of an island clade evolving in situ. The prevalence of syngameon dynamics in a broad range of organisms indicates that we should adopt a fluid and comprehensive approach to defining evolutionary units for conservation and research. We should move beyond focusing on single endangered species in evolutionary and ecological isolation from other species but consider the entire network of potentially interfertile species and the potential for future adaptation and innovation, particularly in a human dominated world.