Deep Brain Stimulation Compared With Contingency Management for the Treatment of Cocaine Use Disorders: A Threshold and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

Restoring the firing activity of ventral tegmental area neurons by lateral hypothalamic deep brain stimulation following morphine administration in rats: LH DBS and the spiking activity of VTA neurons

We have previously shown that high-frequency deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the lateral hypothalamus (LH) compromises morphine-induced addiction-like behavior in rats. The exact mechanism underlying this effect is not known. Here, we investigated the assumption that DBS in the LH influences the firing activity of neurons in the ventral tegmental area (VTA). To that end, male Wistar rats received morphine (5 mg/kg; s.c.) for three days and underwent extracellular single unit recording under general anesthesia one day later. During the recording, the rats received an intraoperative injection of morphine (5 mg/kg; s.c.) plus DBS in the LH (130 Hz pulse frequency, 150 μA amplitude, and 100 μs pulse width). One group of animals also received preoperative DBS after each morphine injection before the recording. The spiking frequency of VTA neurons was measured at three successive phases: (1) baseline (5-15 min); (2) DBS-on (morphine + DBS for 30 min); and (3) After-DBS (over 30 min after termination of DBS). Results showed that morphine suppressed the firing activity of a large population of non-DA neurons, whereas it activated most DA neurons. Intraoperative DBS reversed morphine suppression of non-DA firing, but did not alter the excitatory effect of morphine on DA neurons firing. With repeated preoperative application of DBS, non-DA neurons returned to the morphine-induced suppressive state, but DA neurons released from the excitatory effect of morphine. It is concluded that the development of morphine reward is associated with a hypoactivity of VTA non-DA neurons and a hyperactivity of DA neurons, and that DBS modulation of the spiking activity may contribute to the blockade of morphine addiction-like behavior.

Can responsive deep brain stimulation be a cost-effective treatment for severe obesity?

OBJECTIVE

A first-in-human responsive deep brain stimulation (rDBS) trial (NCT03868670) for obesity is under way, which is based on promising preclinical evidence. Given the upfront costs of rDBS, it is prudent to examine the success threshold for cost-effectiveness compared with laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGB).

METHODS

Efficacy and safety data on LRYGB and safety data on rDBS were collected for established indications through a literature search. The success threshold was defined as minimum BMI reduction. Treatment costs were calculated via Medicare national reimbursement data.

RESULTS

LRYGB had a mean BMI reduction of 13.75 kg/m² . Based on adverse events, LRYGB was a less-preferred health state (overall adverse event utility of 0.96 [0.02]) than rDBS (0.98 [0.01]), but LRYGB ($14,366 [$6,410]) had a significantly lower treatment cost than rDBS ($29,951 [$4,490]; p < 0.0001). Therefore, for rDBS to be cost-effective compared with LRYGB, the multiple models yielded a success threshold range of 13.7 to 15.2 kg/m² .

CONCLUSIONS

This study established a preliminary efficacy success threshold for rDBS to be cost-effective for severe obesity, and results from randomized controlled trials are needed. This analysis allows for interpretation of the economic impact of advancing rDBS for obesity in light of ongoing trial results and suggests an attainable threshold is needed for cost-effectiveness.