One-Third Tubular Plate Remains a Clinically Good Option in Danis-Weber Type B Distal Fibular Fracture Fixation

One-third tubular plates versus anatomical distal fibula plates in ankle fracture fixation: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Ankle fractures, especially fractures of the distal fibula, are very common. This review aims to compare the postoperative clinical and radiological outcomes between one-third tubular plating and anatomical distal fibula plating.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, and Scopus databases were searched from inception to 29 June 2024. Data was extracted and analyzed by RevMan Web. Differences in operative times, and clinical and radiological outcomes were evaluated by mean difference (MD) with a 95% confidence interval (95%CI). Risks of various complications and mortality were assessed by risk ratio (RR) with 95%CI. The quality of studies was assessed using the Good Research for Comparative Effectiveness (GRACE) checklist.

RESULTS

A total of 14 studies comprising a total of 2,802 patients were included, 1,792 in the one-third tubular plating group, and 1,010 in the anatomical distal fibula plating group. There were no significant differences in ≥ 12 months post-operative AOFAS results, range of motion from full extension to full flexion, time to fracture union, superficial or deep infections, delayed wound healing, hardware irritation, hardware removal rates, revision surgery rates, non-union, and implant failures. However, one-third tubular plating had a significantly shorter operative time in minutes (MD = -11.41, 95%CI [-20.95, -1.87]; p = 0.02), a significantly lower risk of overall wound complications (RR = 0.55, 95%CI [0.40, 0.74]; p-value = 0.0001). The average GRACE score of the 14 observational studies was 10.6 (range 8-11), suggesting good methodological quality of these studies.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review and meta-analysis showed that one-third tubular plating had a significantly shorter operative time in minutes and a significantly lower risk of overall wound complications than anatomical distal fibula plating. As such, these factors should be taken into consideration and evaluated when choosing between one-third tubular plating and anatomical distal fibula plating in the management of an ankle fracture.

The effect of screw configuration of tubular bone plate on the biomechanics of oblique lateral malleolar fractures

To investigate the biomechanical effects of varying physiological conditions and tubular plate screw configurations on the stability of lateral malleolar fractures. In this paper, different models were constructed for finite element analysis based on Computed Tomography (CT) data. The results showed that the biomechanical characteristics of the fixation method combining a tubular plate with 6 screws were optimal. The fixation methods showed significantly higher stability in dorsiflexion positions compared to neutral and plantarflexion positions. These findings provide valuable theoretical guidance for clinical selection of fixation methods for lateral malleolar fractures and rehabilitation training.

Biomechanical comparison of plate, intramedullary screw, and headless compression screw fixation in Danis-Weber type B lateral malleolar fractures

BACKGROUND

Weber type B transsyndesmotic fractures are the most common type of lateral malleolar fractures, a common ankle fracture type. Although several surgical techniques are available for fixation, no clinical consensus exists regarding the optimal fixation method.

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated the biomechanical differences in fixation stability among one-third tubular plates, 3.5-mm intramedullary screws, and 4.5-mm intramedullary headless compression screws for Weber type B lateral malleolar fractures using an in Vitro mechanical analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In total, 24 artificial fibula bone specimens were used. The specimens were subjected to Weber type B lateral malleolar fractures using a saw blade and randomly divided into three groups treated with different fixation methods, with eight specimens per group: (1) One-third tubular plate, (2) 3.5-mm intramedullary screw, and (3) 4.5-mm intramedullary headless compression screw. The specimens were subjected to bending and torsional mechanical testing using a materials testing system. The bending test was evaluated using 10-mm displacement force (Newtons) and bending stiffness (Newtons/millimeter) as the assessment parameters. For the torsional test, 20° rotation torque (Newtons/millimeter) and torsional stiffness (Newton∙millimeters/degree) were used as evaluation parameters. The experimental results were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. When significant differences were found, post hoc pairwise comparisons were conducted using the Dunn-Bonferroni approach.

RESULTS

In the bending test, no statistical differences were observed between the three fixation methods, whether evaluated by 10-mm displacement force or bending stiffness. Nevertheless, for the 20° rotation torque assessment in the torsional test, both the one-third tubular plate (1360.31 ± 221.56 N·mm, median ± interquartile range) and the 4.5-mm intramedullary headless compression screw (1420.41 ± 281.95 N·mm) exhibited similar resistance, considerably outperforming the 3.5-mm intramedullary screw (605.80 ± 165.11 N·mm) in fracture fixation strength. In the torsional stiffness assessment, both the one-third tubular plate (67.67 ± 15.39 N·mm, median ± interquartile range) and the 4.5-mm intramedullary headless compression screw (62.44 ± 17.36 N·mm) exhibited equivalent resistance and were substantially superior to the 3.5-mm intramedullary screw (25.90 ± 5.1 N·mm) in their ability to fix fractures.

CONCLUSION

The 4.5-mm intramedullary headless compression screw provides strong mechanical stability and a lower risk of soft tissue complications in clinical practice. Therefore, this headless compression screw can be recommended as a fixation option for Weber type B lateral malleolar fractures.

Similar Clinical Outcome in Locking and Conventional Plate Osteosynthesis for the Treatment of AO 44-B2 Ankle Fractures

IntroductionBiomechanical studies have proved that locking plates have better primary stability besides versatility regarding fracture pattern while reducing bone contact and bridging the gap, whereas conventional nonlocking plates (plus lag screw) depend on bone-plate compression. The clinical benefit of locking plates over nonlocking plates remains unanswered, however. Therefore, this retrospective cohort study was set up to test the hypothesis that the use of locking plates for unstable ankle fractures will result in fewer re-displacements, superior bony healing, and functional and clinical outcomes better than observed in the nonlocking cohort.MethodsBimalleolar ankle fractures (AO 44-B2) without syndesmotic injury treated with either a locking or a nonlocking plate were included. Groups were compared for complications, bone healing, secondary dislocation, progressions of osteoarthritis, and clinical outcome using patient-reported outcome measures.ResultsData revealed no clinical outcome differences (Olerud-Molander Ankle Score: nonlocking 88.2 ± 14.4, locking 88.8 ± 12.3, P = .69, robust two 1-sided test for equality (RTOST): P = .03; American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Score: nonlocking 91.2 ± 12.9, locking 91.8 ± 11.3, P = .96, RTOST: P = .04). Nevertheless, a significant postoperative progression of osteoarthritis was detected in both groups (P = .04). This was independent of implant (P = .16). Although difference was not significant, locking plates were preferred in older (P = .78) and sicker patients (P = .63) and in cases with severer osteoarthritis (P = .16), and were associated with a higher complication rate (P = .42) and secondary dislocation (nonlocking 9.4%, locking 18.2%; P = .42). Re-displacement, however, was not a compelling reason for revision.ConclusionsThe present study shows statistically significant equality of both types of implants. Contrary to our expectation, locking plates seemed to be associated with a higher risk for re-displacement. Overall, the use of either locking or nonlocking plates for unstable AO 44-B2 fractures is safe and successful despite significant progression of osteoarthritis.Level of Evidence:III, Retrospective observational cohort study.

A novel classification of lateral malleolus morphological characteristics based on three-dimensional computed tomography reconstruction

BACKGROUND

The study was to establish a novel classification of the morphological characteristics of fibula anterior-inferior margin (FAIM), which was reported in few studies.

METHODS

The 501 images with three-dimensional computed tomography (3D CT) reconstruction were reviewed retrospectively. The width, height, thickness, long axis, short axis, and lateral malleolus angle were measured.

RESULTS

The FAIM was divided into Angular, Flat, and Arc. The Flat has no distinct fibular obscure tubercles (FOT). The short axis of Angular and Arc were more significant than the Flat (P < 0. 05). The height of left was larger than the right, but short axis was less than it (P < 0.05). The height and short axis of males were larger than the females (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

A novel classification (the Angular, Flat and Arc) of FAIM was identified based on lateral malleolus morphology, and it suggested that not all have obvious FOT.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level Ⅲ, retrospective study.

The fibular intramedullary nail versus plate fixation for ankle fractures in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

OBJECTIVE

The effectiveness and safety of fibular intramedullary nail fixation (FINF) compared to plate fixation (PF) in treating ankle fractures among adults remains unclear. Therefore, we conducted a meta-analysis to assess the efficacy and safety of FINF versus PF, aiming to provide orthopedic surgeons with valuable insights when choosing between the two internal fixation methods for patient treatment.

METHODS

PubMed, EMBASE, and SCOPUS were systematically searched for articles comparing FINF and PF in ankle fractures among adults. Functional outcomes, complications, and bony union were compared between the implants.

RESULTS

A total of seven studies were included in the study, involving 586 patients. The results revealed no statistically significant differences in functional outcomes between two groups at 3, 6, and 12 months postoperatively. The outcomes favoring FINF comprised a lower infection rate (RR = 0.23, 95%CI, 0.11 to 0.47, P < 0.0001). Conversely, the PF group exhibited a superior performance in terms of hardware failure rate (RR = 2.05, 95%CI, 1.16 to 3.60, P = 0.01). A statistically significant difference was observed in the results of hardware failure rate in the subgroup of studies conducted in Europe (RR = 2.74, 95%CI, 1.45 to 5.18, P = 0.002). Comparable findings were also noted in a subgroup of older adults (RR = 4.25, 95%CI, 1.57 to 11.50, P = 0.004).

CONCLUSION

This systematic review suggests that FINF exhibits comparable effectiveness in the management of ankle fractures among adults, as compared to PF. Consequently, it is imperative to further delineate the surgical indications for both FINF and PF with precision to mitigate the risk of complications. Nevertheless, larger sample sizes and multi-center RCTs are imperative to corroborate this conclusion in the future.

Fractures of the peroneal malleolus: Current concepts

Ankle fractures represent up to 9% of all fractures, with an increased incidence in the elderly population. Among these fractures, isolated fractures of the lateral malleolus are the most common, representing 65-70% of all cases. The therapeutic decision-making primarily relies on the stability of the ankle ring, considering it stable if affected at one point and unstable if two or more points are affected. Surgical treatment focuses on restoring the length of the fibula, joint reconstruction, stabilizing the syndesmosis, and providing a stable fixation. It is crucial to rule out associated injuries that may influence therapeutic management. This article reviews the evaluation and management of lateral malleolus fractures, proposes a decision-making algorithm, and examines several fibular fixation options.

[Translated article] Fractures of the peroneal malleolus: Current concepts

Ankle fractures represent up to 9% of all fractures, with an increased incidence in the elderly population. Among these fractures, isolated fractures of the lateral malleolus are the most common, representing 65-70% of all cases. The therapeutic decision-making primarily relies on the stability of the ankle ring, considering it stable if affected at one point and unstable if two or more points are affected. Surgical treatment focuses on restoring the length of the fibula, joint reconstruction, stabilising the syndesmosis, and providing a stable fixation. It is crucial to rule out associated injuries that may influence therapeutic management. This article reviews the evaluation and management of lateral malleolus fractures, proposes a decision-making algorithm, and examines several fibular fixation options.

Cost analysis and clinical outcomes of anatomic pre-contoured locking versus conventional plates for distal fibula ankle fractures

PURPOSE

To analyze differences in union, complication rates and cost from surgical fixation of distal fibula fractures with fibular plating implants.

METHODS

In total, 380 adult patients from 2012 to 2015 treated with 12 fibular plates from 4 different manufacturers utilized by 9 surgeons were retrospectively reviewed. They were stratified into a conventional one-third tubular fibular plate group, pre-contoured anatomic locking plate group, or a heterogeneous group including 3.5-mm reconstruction, one-third tubular locking, composite, and limited compression plates. The outcomes included failure of fixation, deep infection requiring debridement, time to union, anatomic reduction, superficial infection, hardware removal, and post-traumatic arthritis. Plate and screw costs were calculated from hospital billing records.

RESULTS

Pre-contoured locking plates were used in older, female patients with a greater number of comorbidities. Open injuries and OTA 44B fractures were more likely to be an indication for pre-contoured plates. There was no difference noted in time to union between the different plating groups. Risk factors for deep infection requiring debridement included a history of tobacco use, open fractures, and pre-contoured locking plates relative to the conventional plating group. The pre-contoured plating group was on average $586 more expensive compared to the conventional group.

CONCLUSION

Pre-contoured locking plates achieved similar radiographic outcomes compared to conventional plates with an increased risk of complications and higher cost. Surgeons should consider their choice of implant based on the patient's fracture pattern, underlying comorbidities, and risk for infection.

A comparison of outcomes of locking versus non-locking plate fixation for the distal fibula fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

A locking plate (LP) or non-locking plate (NLP) can be used for distal fibula fracture fixation. However, the advantages of LP over NLP in patients with distal fibula fractures are not clear. In terms of indications, the role of the two plates probably differs; however, to draw comparative conclusions, we conceptualized this systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that directly compared the two plates, wherein both groups' indications and baseline parameters were similar.

METHODS

An electronic literature search was performed using PubMed/Medline, Embase, Scopus, and Cochrane Library databases for studies comparing the LP versus NLP fixation for the lateral malleolus fracture. A total of 18 studies were included in qualitative and quantitative analysis. A subgroup analysis was performed for patients aged < 55 years and patients aged > 55 years. The statistical analysis was performed by Review Manager Software version 5.4.1.

RESULTS

A meta-analysis of 4243 fractures was performed across 18 studies. The rate of fracture union and overall complication rates did not differ between the two fixation groups with an OR of 0.71 (95% CI 0.26, 1.96, p = 0.51 and 1.11 (95% CI 0.84, 1.47, p = 0.47, respectively. There is no difference in the reoperation rate due to minor or major complications between the two groups. There was no difference in functional outcome (MD -0.85, with 95% CI -5.63, 3.93, p = 0.73), but NLP has a shorter surgical duration (MD 3.0, with 95% CI 0.26, 5.75, p = 0.03). A leave-one-out sensitivity analysis performed for overall complications affected the final outcome of the meta-analysis.

CONCLUSION

This meta-analysis demonstrates no clear benefit in selecting LP over NLP for the fixation of lateral malleolus fractures.

Finite element analysis and a pilot study of different fixation constructs for Danis-Weber A and B lateral malleolus fractures

BACKGROUND

Displaced lateral malleolus fractures are typically stabilised through open reduction and internal fixation. The biomechanically and clinically efficacy of locking plates and lag screws, particularly in Weber A and B distal fibular fractures remains a subject of contention. This study examines two locking plate designs for lateral malleolus fractures, evaluating their performance with and without interfragmentary screws using finite element models.

METHODS

Utilising CT images of a healthy adult male volunteer, a three-dimensional finite element model was constructed. The Fibula-specific Flank Multiaxial Locking Anatomic Plate (FMLP) and the Conventional Locking Plate (CLP) were subjected to stabilisation, both with and without an interfragmentary screw, mimicking the Danis-Weber A and B lateral malleolus oblique fracture fixation. Loads of 140 N and 70 N, equivalent to 20% of the body weight, were applied to simulate the single-leg and two-leg standing conditions in the axial direction. The von Mises stress (VMS) distributions and element displacements were subsequently analyzed.

RESULTS

In the Danis-Weber A fracture model group, the FMLP with an interfragmentary screw fixation exhibited the lowest peak VMS values: 51.9 MPa in the fibula, 89.0 MPa in the plate, and 61.3 MPa in the screws for simulating single-leg conditions. Under two-leg standing conditions, these peak VMS values decreased to 25.9 MPa in the fibula, 44.5 MPa in the plate, and 30.6 MPa in the screws, respectively. Furthermore, the overall structural peak displacements during single-leg standing for both Weber-A and B fractures with different implants ranged from 1.61 to 2.54 mm. While standing on two feet, the ranged was from 0.80 to 1.27 mm. An interfragmentary screw at the oblique fracture site resulted in reduced the peak value of VMS in the fibula, plate, screws, consequently decreased the overall structural displacement for FMLP and CLP fixation in lateral malleolus fractures.

CONCLUSIONS

The current finite element analysis (FEA) demonstrates that FMLP exhibits superior mechanical characteristics in Danis-Weber A and B lateral malleolus fractures compared to CLP. The inclusion of an interfragmentary screw, combined with locking plate design, enhances stability for simple oblique distal fibular fractures. The FMLP presents itself as potential as an alternative for lateral malleolus fractures from a biomechanical perspective. Nevertheless, further verification of these results is imperative through subsequent clinical studies.

Postoperative Outcomes in Malleolar Fractures Fixed With a 3.5-mm Locking Compression Plate Hook Plate

Ankle fractures are among the most common types of fractures seen in the United States. Few studies have analyzed the use of a locking compression plate (LCP) hook plate in the fixation of malleolar fractures. The goal of this study was to analyze postoperative outcomes in malleolar fractures fixed with a 3.5-mm LCP hook plate. A cohort of 74 patients with ankle fractures treated operatively with hook plates between 2011 and 2021 by a single orthopedic surgeon was retrospectively reviewed. Time to union, duration of non-weight bearing, final range of motion, postoperative complications, demographics, and comorbidities were recorded. A total of 66 patients fulfilled our inclusion criteria. There were 5 isolated medial malleolar, 34 bimalleolar, and 27 trimalleolar fractures. There were 46 women and 20 men with a mean age of 60.9±18.9 years. Fourteen patients had diabetes, 27 had osteoporosis, and 4 were current or former tobacco users. All patients achieved union, with a mean time to union of 10.9±5.3 weeks. The mean time to weight bearing was 50.2±18.4 days. The mean length of follow-up was 8.1±5.6 months. At final follow-up, mean dorsiflexion was 9.9°±4.3° and mean plantarflexion was 14.1°±5.1°. Six patients experienced postoperative complications such as surgical site infections and posttraumatic osteoarthritis. This study demonstrates that the use of a 3.5-mm LCP hook plate in the operative fixation of malleolar fractures has a high rate of union while maintaining low rates of postoperative complications. [Orthopedics. 2023;46(6):340-344.].

Minifragment plating of the fibula in unstable ankle fractures

INTRODUCTION

Only 6.4-17% of the load is transmitted through the fibula when weight-bearing. Plate fixation of distal fibular fractures using minifragments (≤ 2.8 mm) could lead to similar reduction with less implant removal (IR) rates, compared to small-fragment plates (3.5 mm). We hypothesized that the use of minifragment plates is at least similar in unscheduled secondary surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study, all patients with surgically treated distal fibular fractures between October 2015 and March 2021 were included. Patients treated with plate fixation using minifragments and patients treated with small-fragment plates were compared regarding the following outcomes: secondary dislocation, malreduction, implant malposition, nonunion, surgical site infections (SSI) and IR.

RESULTS

Sixty-five patients (54.2%) received a minifragment implant (≤ 2.8 mm) and 55 patients (45.8%) received a small-fragment implant (3.5 mm). There were no patients needing secondary surgery in the minifragment group compared to 9 patients following fixation using small-fragment implants (3 with secondary dislocation, 5 with malreduction and 1 with malposition, p = 0.001). SSI rates were 3.1% for minifragment and 9.1% for small-fragment implants (p = 0.161). Implant removal was performed significantly less often following use of minifragment implants (17.8% and 53.2%, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

In this cohort, minifragment plate fixation for distal fibular fractures is an adequate fixation method offering stable fixation with significant lower need for implant removal and comparable complications to small-fragment plates, although an adequately powered randomized controlled study is needed for implementation in a clinical setting.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, III.