Induced Membrane Technique for the Management of Segmental Femoral Defects: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Individual Participant Data

Bone marrow fluid enhances the osteogenic activity of induced membrane leading to spontaneous osteogenesis: experimental validation and application in tibiofibular fusion for support reconstruction of segmental tibial defects

BACKGROUND

Managing large bone defects remains a significant clinical problem. We enhanced the osteogenic activity of the induced membrane (IM) by incorporating bone marrow fluid, leading to spontaneous osteogenesis (SO). We aimed to explore the application of this method in tibiofibular fusion (TFF) for reconstructing segmental tibial defects.

METHODS

Forty-two rats with femoral defects were divided into seven groups (n = 6). Defects in groups A1-3 and B1-3 were filled with polymethylmethacrylate spacers while Group B4 was the control. Kirschner wires were used in Groups A1 and B1, plating was used in Groups A3 and B3-4, while the medullary canal was sealed in Groups A2 and B2. In Group A, osteogenic activity was measured using immunohistochemistry, W-B, and qRT-PCR. In Group B, the osteogenic results were measured using X-ray and gross examinations. Ten patients with 4-10 cm segmental defects of the middle and distal tibia underwent reconstruction using the IM technique, and IM and bone marrow fluid-induced SO for TFF, whose effects were assessed.

RESULTS

At five weeks, Group A1 showed higher levels of BMSCs and expression of BMP-2 and TGF-β1 than Groups A2 and A3 (p < 0.05). After 12 weeks, Group B1 had more new bone at the bone end than Group B3 (p = 0.009) whereas Groups B2 and B4 did not. All tibial defects and TFF healed. The TFF site and posterior tibia healed faster than the other sides and showed quicker clinical healing (p < 0.05). All patients could fully bear weight before tibial clinical healing, with an excellent-to-good functional rate of 80% (Paley's criterion) at the 13 - to 36-month follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Bone marrow fluid enhances the osteogenic activity of IMs leading to SO. TFF by SO progresses faster than tibial clinical healing, making the IM technique an effective stabilizer for faster and better functional recovery after reconstruction of segmental defects of the middle and distal tibia.

Surgical nonunion treatment of large-sized defects of femur and tibia based on the diamond concept

Aims

The aim of this study was to evaluate the radiological outcome of patients with large bone defects in the femur and tibia who were treated according to the guidelines of the diamond concept in our department (Centre for Orthopedics, Trauma Surgery, and Paraplegiology).

Methods

The following retrospective, descriptive analysis consists of patients treated in our department between January 2010 and December 2021. In total, 628 patients were registered, of whom 108 presented with a large-sized defect (≥ 5 cm). A total of 70 patients met the inclusion criteria. The primary endpoint was radiological consolidation of nonunions after one and two years via a modified Lane-Sandhu Score, including only radiological parameters.

Results

The mean defect size was 6.77 cm (SD 1.86), with the largest defect being 12.6 cm. Within two years after surgical treatment, 45 patients (64.3%) presented consolidation of the previous nonunion. After one year, six patients (8.6%) showed complete consolidation and 23 patients (32.9%) showed a considerable callus formation, whereas 41 patients (58.6%) showed a Lane-Sandhu score of 2 or below. Two years after surgery, 24 patients (34.3%) were categorized as Lane-Sandhu score 4, another 23 patients (32.9%) reached a score of 3, while 14 patients (20.0%) remained without final consolidation (score ≤ 2). A total of nine patients (12.9%) missed the two-year follow-up. The mean follow-up was 44.40 months (SD 32.00). The mean time period from nonunion surgery to consolidation was 16.42 months (SD 9.73).

Conclusion

Patients with presentation of a large-sized nonunion require a structured and sufficiently long follow-up to secure the consolidation of the former nonunion. Furthermore, a follow-up of at least two years is required in order to declare a nonunion as consolidated, given that a significant part of the nonunions declared as not consolidated at one year showed consolidation within the second year. Moreover, the proven "gold standard" of a two-step procedure, so called Masquelet technique, shows effectiveness.

Clinical Observations of the Effectiveness of the Masquelet Induced Membrane Technique in the Treatment of Critical Long-Bone Defects of the Lower and Upper Extremities

Background and Objectives: Successful treatment of severe trauma and fractures of the long bones with successful healing and bone union is still a significant challenge for surgeons. Unfortunately, up to 10% of long-bone fractures develop bone healing disorders. The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of treating bone defects with different etiologies in the upper and lower extremities using the induced membrane technique. Materials and Methods: We prospectively evaluated the radiological and clinical outcomes of 45 patients with severe bone defects treated with the induced membrane technique during the period from May 2021 to October 2023. The time to bone defect regeneration, size of the bone defect, and the cost of treatment were evaluated. Functional outcomes were assessed using the Disabilities of the Arm Shoulder and Hand (DASH) scale, SF-36, and the Lower Limb Functional Index (LLFI). Results: The mean follow-up time was 31 months (12-35). There were 20 patients with upper extremity bone defects and 25 with lower extremity bone defects. The mean defect length was 7.9 cm for the upper extremity (3.5-18) and 5.3 cm for the lower extremity (3-11). The mean times to achieve bone union and remodeling were 6.0 months (3-12) and 9 months (3-13) for the upper and lower limbs, respectively. Clinical evaluation at the end of treatment (achieving bone union) showed statistically significant improvements in the DASH, SF-36, and LLFI scales for pre- and postoperative outcomes. There was no statistical significance in the SF-36 clinical scale scores after surgical treatment compared to reconstructive treatment of upper and lower extremity bone defects. Results: The presented reconstructive approach to the treatment of bone defects and healing disorders and extensive analysis demonstrate the effectiveness of the induced membrane technique in a short follow-up period, with a relatively high level of patient comfort and good clinical results in the treatment of severe bone defects with particularly infectious etiologies.

FixThePig: a custom 3D-printed femoral intramedullary nailing for preclinical research applications

Background

Critical-size bone defects (CSBDs) pose significant challenges in clinical orthopaedics and traumatology. Developing reliable preclinical models that accurately simulate human conditions is crucial for translational research. This study addresses the need for a reliable preclinical model by evaluating the design and efficacy of a custom-made 3D-printed intramedullary nail (IMN) specifically for CSBDs in minipigs. The study aims to answer the following questions: Can a custom-made 3D-printed IMN be designed for femoral osteosynthesis in minipigs? Does the use of the custom-made IMN result in consistent and reproducible surgical procedure, particularly in the creation and fixation of CSBDs? Can the custom-made IMN effectively treat and promote bone consolidation of CSBDs?

Hypothesis

The custom-made 3D-printed IMN can be designed to effectively create, fix and treat CSBDs in minipigs, resulting in consistent surgical outcomes.

Materials and Methods

The IMN was designed based on CT scans of minipig femurs, considering factors such as femoral curvature, length, and medullary canal diameters. It was 3D-printed in titanium and evaluated through both in vitro and in vivo testing. Female Aachen minipigs underwent bilateral femoral surgeries to create and fix CSBDs using the custom-made IMN. Post-operative follow-up included X-rays and CT scans every 2 weeks, with manual examination of explanted femurs to assess consolidation and mechanical stability after 3 months.

Results

The custom-made IMN effectively fitted the minipig femoral anatomy and facilitated reproducible surgical outcomes. Symmetric double osteotomies were successfully performed, and allografts showed minimal morphological discrepancies. However, proximal fixation faced challenges, leading to non-union in several cases, while most distal osteotomy sites achieved stable consolidation.

Discussion

The custom-made 3D-printed IMN demonstrated potential in modelling and treating CSBDs in minipigs. While the design effectively supported distal bone healing, issues with proximal fixation highlight the need for further refinements. Potential improvements include better screw placement, additional mechanical support, and adaptations such as a reduction clamp or a cephalic screw to enhance stability and distribute forces more effectively.

Hemi-Masquelet technique and nailing in a circumferential bone defect of 7 cm after open femoral shaft fracture. A case report

The treatment of Gustilo-Anderson type III open femoral fracture with large segmental bone defect remains a challenge for orthopedic trauma surgeons. The aims of management are first to prevent the risk of infection and then to reconstruct the bone loss with correct alignment and length. The induced membrane technique (or Masquelet technique) was initially described for tibia nonunion but became over the years an established procedure to treat any kind of large bone defect. The case of a 22-year old male who sustained an open femoral shaft fracture with a circumferential 7-cm bone defect after a car accident is presented. Given the critical size of the bone loss, we chose to manage this patient using a modified-Masquelet technique, in which we stabilized the fracture by an intramedullary femoral nail and filled only the lateral side of the defect with a cement spacer. He went on to have a full and successful union of his fracture 16-weeks after the second stage surgery. The final functional outcomes were excellent allowing the patient to resume all activities without restriction.

The induced membrane technique for the management of infected segmental bone defects

Aims

The aim of the present study was to assess the outcomes of the induced membrane technique (IMT) for the management of infected segmental bone defects, and to analyze predictive factors associated with unfavourable outcomes.

Methods

Between May 2012 and December 2020, 203 patients with infected segmental bone defects treated with the IMT were enrolled. The digital medical records of these patients were retrospectively analyzed. Factors associated with unfavourable outcomes were identified through logistic regression analysis.

Results

Among the 203 enrolled patients, infection recurred in 27 patients (13.3%) after bone grafting. The union rate was 75.9% (154 patients) after second-stage surgery without additional procedures, and final union was achieved in 173 patients (85.2%) after second-stage surgery with or without additional procedures. The mean healing time was 9.3 months (3 to 37). Multivariate logistic regression analysis of 203 patients showed that the number (≥ two) of debridements (first stage) was an independent risk factor for infection recurrence and nonunion. Larger defect sizes were associated with higher odds of nonunion. After excluding 27 patients with infection recurrence, multivariate analysis of the remaining 176 patients suggested that intramedullary nail plus plate internal fixation, smoking, and an allograft-to-autograft ratio exceeding 1:3 adversely affected healing time.

Conclusion

The IMT is an effective method to achieve infection eradication and union in the management of infected segmental bone defects. Our study identified several risk factors associated with unfavourable outcomes. Some of these factors are modifiable, and the risk of adverse outcomes can be reduced by adopting targeted interventions or strategies. Surgeons can fully inform patients with non-modifiable risk factors preoperatively, and may even use other methods for bone defect reconstruction.

Use of F18 bioglass putty for induced membrane technique in segmental bone defect of the radius in rabbits

PURPOSE

To evaluate the inductive capacity of F18 bioglass putty on the induced membrane technique in a segmental bone defect of the rabbit's radius.

METHODS

Ten female Norfolk at 24 months of age were used. The animals were randomly separated based on postoperative time points: five rabbits at 21 and four at 42 days. A 1-cm segmental bone defect was created in both radii. The bone defects were filled with an F18 bioglass putty.

RESULTS

Immediate postoperative radiographic examination revealed the biomaterial occupying the segmental bone defect as a well-defined radiopaque structure with a density close to bone tissue. At 21 and 42 days after surgery, a reduction in radiopacity and volume of the biomaterial was observed, with particle dispersion in the bone defect region. Histologically, the induced membrane was verified in all animals, predominantly composed of fibrocollagenous tissue. In addition, chondroid and osteoid matrices undergoing regeneration, a densely vascularized tissue, and a foreign body type reaction composed of macrophages and multinucleated giant cells were seen.

CONCLUSIONS

the F18 bioglass putty caused a foreign body-type inflammatory response with the development of an induced membrane without expansion capacity to perform the second stage of the Masquelet technique.

Use of Autologous Bone Graft with Bioactive Glass as a Bone Substitute in the Treatment of Large-Sized Bone Defects of the Femur and Tibia

BACKGROUND

Managing bone defects in non-union surgery remains challenging, especially in cases of large defects exceeding 5 cm in size. Historically, amputation and compound osteosynthesis with a remaining PMMA spacer have been viable and commonly used options. The risk of non-union after fractures varies between 2% and 30% and is dependent on various factors. Autologous bone grafts from the iliac crest are still considered the gold standard but are limited in availability, prompting consideration of artificial grafts.

OBJECTIVES

The aims and objectives of the study are as follows: 1. To evaluate the radiological outcome of e.g., the consolidation and thus the stability of the bone (three out of four consolidated cortices/Lane-Sandhu-score of at least 3) by using S53P4-type bioactive glass (BaG) as a substitute material for large-sized bone defects in combination with autologous bone using the RIA technique. 2. To determine noticeable data-points as a base for future studies.

METHODS

In our clinic, 13 patients received bioactive glass (BaG) as a substitute in non-union therapy to promote osteoconductive aspects. BaG is a synthetic material composed of sodium, silicate, calcium, and phosphate. The primary endpoint of our study was to evaluate the radiological consolidation of bone after one and two years. To assess bone stabilization, we used a modified Lane-Sandhu score, considering only radiological criteria. A bone was considered stabilized if it achieved a minimum score of 3. For full consolidation (all four cortices consolidated), a minimum score of 4 was required. Each bone defect exceeded 5 cm in length, with an average size of 6.69 ± 1.92 cm.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up period for patients without final bone consolidation was 34.25 months, with a standard deviation of 14.57 months, a median of 32.00 months and a range of 33 months. In contrast, patients with a fully consolidated non-union had an average follow-up of 20.11 ± 15.69 months and a range of 45 months. Overall, the mean time from non-union surgery to consolidation for patients who achieved final union was 14.91 ± 6.70 months. After one year, six patients (46.2%) achieved complete bone consolidation according to the Lane-Sandhu score. Three patients (23.1%) displayed evident callus formation with expected stability, while three patients (23.1%) did not develop any callus, and one patient only formed a minimal callus with no expected stability. After two years, 9 out of 13 patients (69.2%) had a score of 4. The remaining four patients (30.8%) without expected stability either did not heal within two years or required a revision during that time.

CONCLUSIONS

Bioactive glass (BaG) in combination with autologous bone (RIA) appears to be a suitable filler material for treating extensive non-unions of the femur and tibia. This approach seems to show non-inferiority to treatment with Tricalcium Phosphate (TCP). To ensure the success of this treatment, it is crucial to validate the procedure through a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a control group using TCP, which would provide higher statistical power and more reliable results.

Treatment of infected bone defects with the induced membrane technique

Aims

This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the induced membrane technique for treating infected bone defects, and to explore the factors that might affect patient outcomes.

Methods

A comprehensive search was performed in PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials databases between 1 January 2000 and 31 October 2021. Studies with a minimum sample size of five patients with infected bone defects treated with the induced membrane technique were included. Factors associated with nonunion, infection recurrence, and additional procedures were identified using logistic regression analysis on individual patient data.

Results

After the screening, 44 studies were included with 1,079 patients and 1,083 segments of infected bone defects treated with the induced membrane technique. The mean defect size was 6.8 cm (0.5 to 30). After the index second stage procedure, 85% (797/942) of segments achieved union, and 92% (999/1,083) of segments achieved final healing. The multivariate analysis with data from 296 patients suggested that older age was associated with higher nonunion risk. Patients with external fixation in the second stage had a significantly higher risk of developing nonunion, increasing the need for additional procedures. The autografts harvested from the femur reamer-irrigator-aspirator increased nonunion, infection recurrence, and additional procedure rates.

Conclusion

The induced membrane technique is an effective technique for treating infected bone defects. Internal fixation during the second stage might effectively promote bone healing and reduce additional procedures without increasing infection recurrence. Future studies should standardize individual patient data prospectively to facilitate research on the affected patient outcomes.

Incidence and Risk Factors for Extremity Osteoradionecrosis after Limb-Sparing Surgery and Adjuvant Radiotherapy

Osteoradionecrosis (ORN) is a major complication after radiotherapy. Most studies on ORN have focused on patients with mandibular lesions, with few studies including patients with extremity soft tissue sarcoma (STS). We included 198 patients with extremity STS who underwent limb-sparing surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy between 2004 and 2017. The incidence rate of extremity ORN was 3.5% (7/198), with most lesions (6/7) located in the lower extremities. The mean follow-up time was 62 months. Clinical presentations included chronic ulcers, soft tissue necrosis, sinus discharge, bone nonunion, and pathological fractures. Compared with the non-ORN group, the ORN group had a significantly higher total radiation dose (68 Gy vs. 64 Gy, p = 0.048) and greater use of intraoperative periosteal stripping (p = 0.008). Repeat surgeries and subsequent soft tissue reconstruction or limb amputation were performed as treatments. The risk and management of ORN in patients with extremity STS was ignored previously. Because the disease is complex and affects both clinicians and patients, careful surveillance should be undertaken.