Transfusion in children: epidemiology and 10-year survival of transfusion recipients

Quantifying the impact of a novel virus on the economic value of pathogen reduction technology for platelets

BACKGROUND

Pathogen reduction technology (PRT) is an intervention designed to proactively reduce the amount of known and unknown pathogens in donated blood. As current screening for known pathogens is highly effective, some previous evaluations have found that the value of PRT largely hinges on a previously unknown pathogen, most likely a novel virus, emerging and entering the blood supply. In such situations, the risk of emergence can and should be modeled and presented transparently in the cost-effectiveness results for deliberation by decision-makers.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

We built a Markov cohort model assessing the economic value of introducing PRT for platelets in the United Kingdom. Input data were obtained from the existing PRT literature, national sources, or by conservative assumption. The primary objective of the study was to demonstrate methods for modeling and presenting the risk of emergence of a novel virus, using alternative time-to-emergence scenarios in the probabilistic sensitivity analysis.

RESULTS

As expected, PRT will be more cost-effective the sooner the novel virus emerges after the introduction of PRT. In the base-case cost scenario, the deterministic ICER was £270 K/QALY gained if the virus emerged immediately and rose to £3.3 M/QALY gained if the virus emerged after 25 years.

DISCUSSION

At current prices, PRT is unlikely to be cost-effective when judged against thresholds for medicines and treatments. Given significant additional willingness-to-pay for blood safety, PRT is only likely to be cost-effective if a novel virus that causes chronic infection with significant morbidity and mortality emerges very soon after the introduction of PRT.

Pediatric Hemovigilance and Adverse Transfusion Reactions

Some types of transfusion reactions occur more frequently in the pediatric than the adult population. Allergic reactions are the most common, followed by nonhemolytic transfusion reactions; male children seem most susceptible to such reactions. Platelets are often implicated and pulmonary reactions are understudied in children. Clinical sequelae in neonates, such as bronchopulmonary dysplasia/chronic lung disease and intraventricular hemorrhage, have received increasing attention in relation to transfusion. There is a need to better understand the pathophysiology of transfusion reactions in neonatal and pediatric populations so preventive strategies can be undertaken. There is also a need for robust hemovigilance systems.

Adverse transfusion reactions in transfused children

Transfusion in paediatrics requires specific guidelines, because child physiology and pathology differ significantly as compared to adults. Adverse transfusion reactions in transfused children also vary in type and frequency, but there is a better understanding of these reactions in adults than in children. However, for the most frequent adverse transfusion reactions, the overall prevalence is higher in children than in adults, with the exception of post-transfusion red blood cell alloimmunisation, which is lower, excluding patients with haemoglobinopathies. In several studies, allergic reactions were the most frequently reported adverse transfusion reaction in paediatrics, and the platelet concentrate the most frequently implicated blood product. Early diagnosis of certain adverse transfusion reactions such as haemosiderosis, is essential in order to initiate the best therapy and obtain a good clinical outcome. The prevention of adverse transfusion reactions in children is required, but needs further clinical studies in paediatrics. Lastly, changes in technology, policy and clinical practices will improve transfusion safety in children.

Blood Utilization and Transfusion Reactions in Pediatric Patients Transfused with Conventional or Pathogen Reduced Platelets

OBJECTIVES

To assess the safety and efficacy of a Food and Drug Administration-approved pathogen-reduced platelet (PLT) product in children, as ongoing questions regarding their use in this population remain.

STUDY DESIGN

We report findings from a quality assurance review of PLT utilization, associated red blood cell transfusion trends, and short-term safety of conventional vs pathogen-reduced PLTs over a 21-month period while transitioning from conventional to pathogen-reduced PLTs at a large, tertiary care hospital. We assessed utilization in neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) patients, infants 0-1 year not in the NICU, and children age 1-18 years (PED).

RESULTS

In the 48 hours after an index conventional or pathogen-reduced platelet transfusion, respectively, NICU patients received 1.0 ± 1.4 (n = 91 transfusions) compared with 1.2 ± 1.3 (n = 145) additional platelet doses (P = .29); infants 0-1 year not in the NICU received 2.8 ± 3.0 (n = 125) vs 2.6 ± 2.6 (n = 254) additional platelet doses (P = .57); and PEDs received 0.9 ± 1.6 (n = 644) vs 1.4 ± 2.2 (n = 673) additional doses (P < .001). Time to subsequent transfusion and red cell utilization were similar in every group (P > .05). The number and type of transfusion reactions did not significantly vary based on PLT type and no rashes were reported in NICU patients receiving phototherapy and pathogen-reduced PLTs.

CONCLUSIONS

Conventional and pathogen-reduced PLTs had similar utilization patterns in our pediatric populations. A small, but statistically significant, increase in transfusions was noted following pathogen-reduced PLT transfusion in PED patients, but not in other groups. Red cell utilization and transfusion reactions were similar for both products in all age groups.

Patient blood management, what does this actually mean for neonates and infants?

Patient blood management (PBM) refers to an evidence-based package of care that aims to improve patient outcomes by optimal use of transfusion therapy, including managing anaemia, preventing blood loss and improving anaemia tolerance in surgical and other patients who may need transfusion. In adults, PBM programmes are well established, yet the definition and implementation of PBM in neonates and children lags behind. Neonates and infants are frequently transfused, yet they are often under-represented in transfusion trials. Adult PBM programmes may not be directly applicable to these populations. We review the literature in neonatal (and applicable paediatric) transfusion medicine and propose specific neonatal PBM definitions and elements.