Rebuttal from Marek Malik, Katerina Hnatkova, Heikki V. Huikuri, Federico Lombardi, Georg Schmidt and Markus Zabel

Speed of heart rate changes during postural provocations in children and adolescents

Heart rate is under constant autonomic influence but the development of the influence in children is not fully understood. Continuous electrocardiograms were obtained in 1045 healthy school-age children (550 females) during postural provocations with body position changes between supine, sitting, standing, supine, standing, sitting and supine (in this order), 10 min in each position with position changes within 20 s. Heart rate was measured in each position and speed of heart rate changes between positions were assessed by regressions of rates versus timing of individual cardiac cycles. Supine heart rate was gradually decreasing with age: 82.32 ± 9.92, 74.33 ± 9.79, 67.43 ± 9.45 beats per minute (bpm) in tertile age groups < 11, 11-15, > 15 years, respectively (p < 0.0001), with no significant sex difference. Averaged speed of heart rate changes differed little between sexes and age groups but was significantly faster during rate deceleration than acceleration (e.g., supine ↔ standing: 2.99 ± 1.02 vs. 2.57 ± 0.68 bpm/s, p < 0.0001). The study suggests that in children, vagal heart rate control does not noticeably change between ages of approximately 6-19 years. The gradual resting heart rate decrease during childhood and adolescence is likely caused by lowering of cardiac sympathetic influence from sympathetic overdrive in small children to adult-like sympatho-vagal balance in older adolescents.

Intra-Individual Relationship between Heart Rate Variability and the Underlying Heart Rate in Children and Adolescents

Background/Objective: The relationship between heart rate and heart rate variability (HRV) indices has been repeatedly studied in adults but limited data are available on the relationship in paediatric populations. Methods: Continuous 12-lead electrocardiograms were recorded in 1016 healthy children and adolescents (534 females) aged 4 to 19 years during postural manoeuvres with rapid changes between 10-min positions of supine → sitting → standing → supine → standing → sitting → supine. In each position, the averaged RR interval was measured together with four HRV indices, namely the SDNN, RMSSD, quasi-normalised high-frequency components (qnHF), and the proportions of low- and high-frequency components (LF/HF). In each subject, the slope of the linear regression between the repeated HRV measurements and the corresponding RR interval averages was calculated. Results: The intra-subject regression slopes, including their confidence intervals, were related to the age and sex of the subjects. The SDNN/RR, RMSSD/RR, and qnHF/RR slopes were significantly steeper (p < 0.001) and the (LF/HF)/RR slopes were significantly shallower (p < 0.001) in younger children compared to older children and adolescents. Conclusions: The study suggests that sympathetic and vagal influences on heart rate are present in both younger and older children. With advancing age, the sympatho-vagal balance gradually develops and allows the vagal control to suppress the sympathetic drive towards higher heart rates seen in younger age children.

The autonomic nervous system in atrial fibrillation-pathophysiology and non-invasive assessment

The autonomic nervous system plays a crucial role in atrial fibrillation pathophysiology. Parasympathetic hyperactivity result in a shortening of the action potential duration, a reduction of the conduction wavelength, and as such facilitates reentry in the presence of triggers. Further, autonomic remodeling of atrial myocytes in AF includes progressive sympathetic hyperinnervation by increased atrial sympathetic nerve density and sympathetic atrial nerve sprouting. Knowledge on the pathophysiological process in AF, including the contribution of the autonomic nervous system, may in the near future guide personalized AF management. This review focuses on the role of the autonomic nervous system in atrial fibrillation pathophysiology and non-invasive assessment of the autonomic nervous system.

Autonomic nervous system assessment using heart rate variability

The role of the autonomic nervous system in the onset of supraventricular and ventricular arrhythmias is well established. It can be analysed by the spontaneous behaviour of the heart rate with ambulatory ECG recordings, through heart rate variability measurements. Input of heart rate variability parameters into artificial intelligence models to make predictions regarding the detection or forecast of rhythm disorders is becoming routine and neuromodulation techniques are now increasingly used for their treatment. All this warrants a reappraisal of the use of heart rate variability for autonomic nervous system assessment.Measurements performed over long periods such as 24H-variance, total power, deceleration capacity, and turbulence are suitable for estimating the individual basal autonomic status. Spectral measurements performed over short periods provide information on the dynamics of systems that disrupt this basal balance and may be part of the triggers of arrhythmias, as well as premature atrial or ventricular beats. All heart rate variability measurements essentially reflect the modulations of the parasympathetic nervous system which are superimposed on the impulses of the adrenergic system. Although heart rate variability parameters have been shown to be useful for risk stratification in patients with myocardial infarction and patients with heart failure, they are not part of the criteria for prophylactic implantation of an intracardiac defibrillator, because of their high variability and the improved treatment of myocardial infarction. Graphical methods such as Poincaré plots allow quick screening of atrial fibrillation and are set to play an important role in the e-cardiology networks. Although mathematical and computational techniques allow manipulation of the ECG signal to extract information and permit their use in predictive models for individual cardiac risk stratification, their explicability remains difficult and making inferences about the activity of the ANS from these models must remain cautious.

Autonomic dysfunction and heart rate variability with Holter monitoring: a diagnostic look at autonomic regulation

Heart rate variability (HRV) refers to the beat-to-beat variation of the cardiac cycle. Since heart rate is modulated on a beat-to-beat basis by the combined influence of the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system at the sinus node level, HRV has been considered an indirect biomarker of cardiac autonomic control and widely exploited for the assessment of autonomic function in many pathological subjects. This focus article summarizes the main findings derived from HRV analysis applied to 24‑h Holter monitoring in both cardiac and non-cardiac diseases as well as in physiological conditions in the healthy population. Even if the prognostic role of HRV indices is well recognized and its use ever more widespread, its implementation in the diagnostic and prognostic processes in routine clinical practice remains limited. Several reasons for these limitations can be identified: first the lack of reliable reference values, and secondly, the low specificity of HRV indices in particular when considering the constant evolution of clinical practice and therapeutic approaches, making it difficult to refer to a specific and stable combination of clinical and HRV markers. Therefore, the clinical use of HRV should be further investigated. Finally, HRV represents a substantial tool for investigating the physiological conditions in healthy people that can have important implications in primary prevention and the understanding of gender differences, as well as in sport and occupational medicine.

Beat-to-beat blood pressure variability in patients with obstructive sleep apnea

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Cardiovascular comorbidities in obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) are difficult to treat, perhaps due to autonomic dysfunction. We assessed beat-to-beat blood pressure (BP) variability (BPV) in OSA while considering other markers derived from electrocardiogram and continuous BP signals.

METHODS

We studied 66 participants (33 participants with OSA: respiratory event index [mean ± SEM]: 21.1 ± 2.7 events/h; 12 females, aged 51.5 ± 2.4 years; body mass index: 32.8 ± 1.4 kg/m²; 33 healthy controls: 20 females; aged 45.3 ± 2.4 years; body mass index: 26.3 ± 0.7 kg/m²). We collected 5-minute resting noninvasive beat-to-beat BP and electrocardiogram values. From BP, we derived systolic, diastolic, and mean BP values, and calculated variability as standard deviations (systolic BPV, diastolic BPV, BPV). We also calculated diastole-to-systole time (time to peak). From the electrocardiogram, we derived QRS markers and calculated heart rate and heart rate variability. We performed a multivariate analysis of variance based on sex and group (OSA vs control), with Bonferroni-corrected post hoc comparisons (P ≤ .05) between groups. We calculated correlations of BPV with biological variables.

RESULTS

Multivariate analysis of variance showed effects of diastolic BPV and BPV in OSA; post hoc comparisons revealed high diastolic BPV and BPV only in female participants with OSA vs controls. QRS duration was higher in OSA, with post hoc comparisons showing the effect only in males. BPV correlated positively with heart rate variability in controls but not in participants with OSA. BPV correlated positively with time to peak in females with OSA and OSA combined, whereas there was no BPV-time-to-peak correlation in healthy participants.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings show sex-specific autonomic dysfunction reflected in beat-to-beat BP in OSA. The higher BPV may reflect poor baroreflex control or vascular damage in OSA, which are potential precursors to cardiovascular complications.

Autonomic Control of the Heart and Its Clinical Impact. A Personal Perspective

This essay covers several aspects of the autonomic control of the heart, all relevant to cardiovascular pathophysiology with a direct impact on clinical outcomes. Ischemic heart disease, heart failure, channelopathies, and life-threatening arrhythmias are in the picture. Beginning with an overview on some of the events that marked the oscillations in the medical interest for the autonomic nervous system, our text explores specific areas, including experimental and clinical work focused on understanding the different roles of tonic and reflex sympathetic and vagal activity. The role of the baroreceptors, not just for the direct control of circulation but also because of the clinical value of interpreting alterations (spontaneous or induced) in their function, is discussed. The importance of the autonomic nervous system for gaining insights on risk stratification and for providing specific antiarrhythmic protection is also considered. Examples are the interventions to decrease sympathetic activity and/or to increase vagal activity. The non-invasive analysis of the RR and QT intervals provides additional information. The three of us have collaborated in several studies and each of us contributes with very specific and independent areas of expertise. Here, we have focused on those areas to which we have directly contributed and hence speak with personal experience. This is not an attempt to provide a neutral and general overview on the autonomic nervous system; rather, it represents our effort to share and provide the readers with our own personal views matured after many years of research in this field.

Sex differences in heart rate responses to postural provocations

Sex differences are known in several facets of cardiac electrophysiology, mostly concerning myocardial repolarisation. In this study, heart rate and heart rate variability (HRV) responses to postural provocations were compared in 175 and 176 healthy females and males, respectively (aged 33.1 ± 9.1 years). Two different postural provocative tests with position changes supine→sitting→standing→supine and supine→standing→sitting→supine (15-min standing, 10-min other positions) were performed up to 4 times in each subject. Heart rate and heart rate variability spectral indices were measured in 5-min windows before positional changes. At supine position, females had averaged heart rate approximately 5 beats per minute (bpm) faster than males and this sex difference was practically constant during the postural changes. In both sexes, change supine→sitting and supine→standing increased heart rate by approximately 10 and 30 bpm, respectively, with no statistical differences between the sex groups. At supine baseline, females had normalised high frequency components (nHF) of HRV approximately 7% larger compared to males (p < 0.001). While the same difference in nHF was found at sitting, the change to standing position lead to significantly larger nHF reduction in females compared to males (mean changes 22.5 vs 17.2%, p < 0.001). This shows that despite similar heart rate increase, females respond to standing by more substantial shifts in cardiac sympatho-vagal modulations. This makes it plausible to speculate that the differences in autonomic reactions to stress contribute to the known sex-differences in psychosocial responses to stressful situations and to the known difference in susceptibility to ventricular fibrillation between females and males.