Effect of time-of-flight and point spread function modeling on detectability of myocardial defects in PET

Dual-Tracer Parathyroid Imaging Using Joint SPECT Reconstruction

Purpose

We assessed the lesion detection performance of the dual-tracer parathyroid SPECT imaging using the joint reconstruction method.

Materials and Methods

Thirty-six noise realizations were created from SPECT projections collected from an in-house neck phantom to emulate 99mTc-pertechnetate/99mTc-sestamibi parathyroid SPECT datasets. Difference images representing parathyroid lesions were reconstructed using the subtraction and the joint methods whose corresponding optimal iteration was defined as the iteration which maximized the channelized Hotelling observer signal-to-noise ratio (CHO-SNR). The joint method whose initial estimate was derived from the subtraction method at optimal iteration (the joint-AltInt method) was also assessed. In a study of 36 patients, a human-observer lesion-detection study was performed using difference images from the three methods at optimal iteration and the subtraction method with four iterations. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was calculated for each method.

Results

In the phantom study, both the joint-AltInt method and the joint method improved SNR compared to the subtraction method at their optimal iteration by 444% and 81%, respectively. In the patient study, the joint-AltInt method yielded the highest AUC of 0.73 as compared with 0.72, 0.71, and 0.64 from the joint method, the subtraction method at optimal iteration, and the subtraction method at four iterations. At a specificity of at least 0.70, the joint-AltInt method yielded significantly higher sensitivity than the other methods (0.60 vs 0.46, 042, and 0.42; p < 0.05).

Conclusions

The joint reconstruction method yielded higher lesion detectability than the conventional method and holds promise for dual-tracer parathyroid SPECT imaging.

Impact of reconstruction parameters on lesion detection and localization in joint ictal/inter-ictal SPECT reconstruction

PURPOSE

Previously, a joint ictal/inter-ictal SPECT reconstruction was proposed to reconstruct a differential image representing the change of brain SPECT image from an inter-ictal to an ictal study. The so-called joint method yielded better performance for epileptic foci localization than the conventional subtraction method. In this study, we evaluated the performance of different reconstruction settings of the joint reconstruction of ictal/inter-ictal SPECT data, which creates a differential image showing the difference between ictal and inter-ictal images, in lesion detection and localization in epilepsy imaging.

METHODS

Differential images reconstructed from phantom data using the joint and the subtraction methods were compared based on lesion detection performance (channelized Hotelling observer signal-to-noise ratio (SNR_CHO) averaged across four lesion-to-background contrast levels) at the optimal iteration. The joint-initial method which was the joint method that was initialized by the subtraction method at optimal iteration was also used to reconstruct differential images. These three methods with respective optimal iteration and the subtraction method with four iterations were applied to epileptic patient datasets. A human observer lesion localization study was performed based on localization receiver operating characteristic (LROC) analysis.

RESULTS

From the phantom study, at their respective optimal iteration, the joint method yielded an improvement in lesion detection performance over the subtraction method of 26%, which increased to 145% when using the joint-initial method. From the patient study, the joint-initial method yielded the highest area under the LROC curve as compared with those of the joint and the subtraction methods with optimal iteration and with 4 iterations (0.44 vs 0.41, 0.39 and 0.36, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In lesion detection and localization, the joint method at optimal iteration outperformed the subtraction method at optimal iteration and at iteration typically used in clinical practice. Furthermore, initialization by the subtraction method improved the performance of the joint method.

The Importance of Time-of-Flight Reconstruction and Point Spread Modeling in the Measurement of Myocardial Blood Flow Parameters

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Absolute quantitation of myocardial blood flow has been recognized as one of the most important advances in nuclear cardiology. The addition of absolute myocardial blood flow quantitation has had a significant impact on the determination of normalcy, artifact/defect differentiation, and the true extent of coronary artery disease in patients with known or suspected coronary disease. Time-of-flight reconstruction and point spread function modeling of the potential to greatly improve resolution and signal to background. This combined with absolute blood flow measurements could improve the reliability of regional blood flow estimates and overall image quality.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent publications have demonstrated that time-of-flight reconstruction can have an impact on the amount of spillover between the blood pool ROI and the myocardial regions. This may necessitate changes to kinetic models; however, these changes if implemented correctly may result in improved accuracy and reproducibility of blood flow estimates. This may also have the benefit of assessing blood flow in the microvasculature using newer F-18 labeled blood flow tracers. Time of flight and point spread function modeling represent significant improvements in the accuracy and quality of reconstructed myocardial perfusion PET images. This may also have significant implications for the reliability of blood flow estimates. To achieve these benefits, attention must be given to blood flow models to ensure that they have been correctly optimized for the scanner-specific time-of-flight reconstruction properties.

Procedural recommendations of cardiac PET/CT imaging: standardization in inflammatory-, infective-, infiltrative-, and innervation (4Is)-related cardiovascular diseases: a joint collaboration of the EACVI and the EANM

With this document, we provide a standard for PET/(diagnostic) CT imaging procedures in cardiovascular diseases that are inflammatory, infective, infiltrative, or associated with dysfunctional innervation (4Is). This standard should be applied in clinical practice and integrated in clinical (multicenter) trials for optimal procedural standardization. A major focus is put on procedures using [¹⁸F]FDG, but 4Is PET radiopharmaceuticals beyond [¹⁸F]FDG are also described in this document. Whilst these novel tracers are currently mainly applied in early clinical trials, some multicenter trials are underway and we foresee in the near future their use in clinical care and inclusion in the clinical guidelines. Finally, PET/MR applications in 4Is cardiovascular diseases are also briefly described. Diagnosis and management of 4Is-related cardiovascular diseases are generally complex and often require a multidisciplinary approach by a team of experts. The new standards described herein should be applied when using PET/CT and PET/MR, within a multimodality imaging framework both in clinical practice and in clinical trials for 4Is cardiovascular indications.

Behind Traditional Semi-quantitative Scores of Myocardial Perfusion Imaging: An Eye on Niche Parameters

The evaluation of stress-induced myocardial perfusion defects by non-invasive myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) modalities has a leading role in the identification of coronary artery disease, and has excellent diagnostic and prognostic value. Non-invasive MPI can be performed using conventional and novel gamma cameras or by PET/CT. New software has allowed novel parameters that may have a role in the identification of early marks of cardiac impairment to be evaluated. We aim to give an overview of niche parameters obtainable by single photon emission CT (SPECT) and PET/CT MPI that may help practitioners to detect initial signs of cardiac damage and identify new therapy targets. In particular, we summarise the role of left ventricular geometry indices for remodelling, phase analysis parameters to evaluate mechanical dyssynchrony, the concept of relative flow reserve in the evaluation of flow-limiting epicardial stenosis, vascular age and epicardial adipose tissue as early markers of atherosclerotic burden, and emerging parameters for the evaluation of myocardial innervation, such as the total defect score.

Comparative analysis of iterative reconstruction algorithms with resolution recovery and time of flight modeling for 18F-FDG cardiac PET: A multi-center phantom study

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the image quality in cardiac 18F-FDG PET using the time of flight (TOF) and/or point spread function (PSF) modeling in the iterative reconstruction (IR).

METHODS

Three scanners and an anthropomorphic cardiac phantom with an insert simulating a transmural defect (TD) were used. Two sets of scans (with/without TD) were acquired, and four reconstruction schemes were considered: (1) IR; (2) IR + PSF, (3) IR + TOF, and (4) IR + TOF + PSF. LV wall thickness (FWHM), contrast between LV wall and inner chamber (C IC), and TD contrast in LV wall (C TD) were evaluated.

RESULTS

Tests of the reconstruction protocols showed a decrease in FWHM from IR (13 mm) to IR + PSF (11 mm); an increase in the C IC from IR (65%) to IR + PSF (71%) and from IR + TOF (72%) to IR + TOF + PSF (77%); and an increase in the C TD from IR + PSF (72%) to IR + TOF (75%) and to IR + TOF + PSF (77%). Tests of the scanner/software combinations showed a decrease in FWHM from Gemini_TF (13 mm) to Biograph_mCT (12 mm) and to Discovery_690 (11 mm); an increase in the C IC from Gemini_TF (65%) to Biograph_mCT (73%) and to Discovery_690 (75%); and an increase in the C TD from Gemini_TF/Biograph_mCT (72%) to Discovery_690 (77%).

CONCLUSION

The introduction of TOF and PSF increases image quality in cardiac 18F-FDG PET. The scanner/software combinations exhibit different performances, which should be taken into consideration when making cross comparisons.

Point-spread function reconstructed PET images of sub-centimeter lesions are not quantitative

Background

PET image reconstruction methods include modeling of resolution degrading phenomena, often referred to as point-spread function (PSF) reconstruction. The aim of this study was to develop a clinically relevant phantom and characterize the reproducibility and accuracy of high-resolution PSF reconstructed images of small lesions, which is a prerequisite for using PET in the prediction and evaluation of responses to treatment.

Sets of small homogeneous ¹⁸F-spheres (range 3–12 mm diameter, relevant for small lesions and lymph nodes) were suspended and covered by a ¹¹C-silicone, which provided a scattering medium and a varying sphere-to-background ratio. Repeated measurements were made on PET/CT scanners from two vendors using a wide range of reconstruction parameters. Recovery coefficients (RCs) were measured for clinically used volume-of-interest definitions.

Results

For non-PSF images, RCs were reproducible and fell monotonically as the sphere diameter decreased, which is the expected behavior. PSF images converged slower and had artifacts: RCs did not fall monotonically as sphere diameters decreased but had a maximum RC for sphere sizes around 8 mm, RCs could be greater than 1, and RCs were less reproducible. To some degree, post-reconstruction filters could suppress PSF artifacts.

Conclusions

High-resolution PSF images of small lesions showed artifacts that could lead to serious misinterpretations when used for monitoring treatment response. Thus, it could be safer to use non-PSF reconstruction for quantitative purposes unless PSF reconstruction parameters are optimized for the specific task.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s40658-016-0169-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Importance of Defect Detectability in Positron Emission Tomography Imaging of Abdominal Lesions

OBJECTIVES

This study was designed to assess defect detectability in positron emission tomography (PET) imaging of abdominal lesions.

METHODS

A National Electrical Manufactures Association International Electrotechnical Commission phantom was used. The simulated abdominal lesion was scanned for 10 min using dynamic list-mode acquisition method. Images, acquired with scan duration of 1-10 min, were reconstructed using VUE point HD and a 4.7 mm full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) Gaussian filter. Iteration-subset combinations of 2-16 and 2-32 were used. Visual and physical analyses were performed using the acquired images. To sequentially evaluate defect detectability in clinical settings, we examined two middle-aged male subjects. One had a liver cyst (approximately 10 mm in diameter) and the other suffered from pancreatic cancer with an inner defect region (approximately 9 mm in diameter).

RESULTS

In the phantom study, at least 6 and 3 min acquisition durations were required to visualize 10 and 13 mm defect spheres, respectively. On the other hand, spheres with diameters ≥17 mm could be detected even if the acquisition duration was only 1 min. The visual scores were significantly correlated with background (BG) variability. In clinical settings, the liver cyst could be slightly visualized with an acquisition duration of 6 min, although image quality was suboptimal. For pancreatic cancer, the acquisition duration of 3 min was insufficient to clearly describe the defect region.

CONCLUSION

The improvement of BG variability is the most important factor for enhancing lesion detection. Our clinical scan duration (3 min/bed) may not be suitable for the detection of small lesions or accurate tumor delineation since an acquisition duration of at least 6 min is required to visualize 10 mm lesions, regardless of reconstruction parameters. Improvements in defect detectability are important for radiation treatment planning and accurate PET-based diagnosis.